Tesla fails to end Florida lawsuit over fatal Model S crash
New York — Tesla failed to persuade a federal judge to end a lawsuit over the death of a woman struck after an Autopilot-equipped Model S ran off the road in Key Largo, Florida, paving the way for a possible trial next month.
U.S. District Judge Beth Bloom in Miami said the estate of Naibel Benavides Leon, and her former boyfriend Dillon Angulo, may pursue design defect and failure to warn claims against billionaire Elon Musk's automaker, and seek punitive damages.
A July 14 trial is scheduled. Lawyers for Tesla and the plaintiffs did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Tesla, based in Austin, Texas, has long faced questions about the safety of its self-driving technology.
It has said its features are meant for 'fully attentive' drivers holding the steering wheel, and the features do not make its vehicles autonomous.
The lawsuit concerned an April 25, 2019 incident where George McGee drove his 2019 Model S at about 62 miles an hour through an intersection into the victims' parked Chevrolet Tahoe, which they were standing beside on a shoulder.
McGee had reached down to pick up a cellphone he dropped on his car's floorboard, and allegedly received no alerts as he ran a stop sign and stop light before hitting the SUV, which struck the victims.
Benavides Leon was allegedly thrown 75 feet to her death, while Angulo suffered serious injuries.
In a 98-page decision, Bloom said the plaintiffs offered sufficient evidence that Autopilot defects were a 'substantial factor' in their injuries.
While McGee, who is not a defendant, conceded he was not driving safely, that didn't automatically make him solely responsible, 'particularly given McGee's testimony that he expected Autopilot to avoid the collision,' the judge wrote.
Bloom said the failure to warn claim survived in part because Autopilot's risks might be hard to extract from the owner's manual on Model S touchscreens.
The judge also dismissed manufacturing defect and negligent misrepresentation claims.
The case is Benavides v Tesla Inc., U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida, No. 21-21940.
(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel, Editing by William Maclean)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
14 minutes ago
- CBC
Trump terminates Canada trade talks ‘effective immediately'
U.S. President Donald Trump has announced the end of trade talks with Canada 'effectively immediately,' blaming Canada's digital services tax on technology companies, calling it a 'direct and blatant attack on our country.'
Globe and Mail
25 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
L3 Limo Party Bus Rental Company Expands Tampa Fleet for Record July 4th Weekend Travel
Transportation provider adds luxury party bus capacity as Tampa Bay area prepares for Boom by the Bay celebration L3 Limo, a party bus rental company serving the Tampa Bay area, has expanded its luxurious fleet ahead of Independence Day weekend as travel projections indicate record-breaking holiday demand, with more than 20 celebrations planned across the region. According to AAA, an estimated 72.2 million Americans will travel at least 50 miles from home during the holiday week, with 4.78 million traveling by bus, train, or cruise. Locally, multiple municipalities are preparing for large-scale festivities, including Boom by the Bay, which spans several downtown venues such as the Friends of the Tampa Riverwalk Boat Parade, Star Spangled Sparkman Wharf, and the Heights District Fourth of July Celebration at Armature Works. L3 Limo is positioning additional party bus and luxury vehicles to accommodate groups attending Independence Day events and celebrations across Tampa Bay, including sporting events, concerts, bachelorette parties, bachelor parties, birthdays, and weddings. From Clearwater's Coachman Park concerts to St. Petersburg's Red, White & Views festival and Temple Terrace's golf club fireworks, L3 Limo's party buses feature premium sound systems for passengers' favorite music, LED lighting, and onboard entertainment where guests can enjoy their favorite movies, ensuring guests celebrate comfortably as they travel between these Tampa Bay events. "Tampa Bay has become a top priority destination for July 4th weekend celebrations, and our professional reservations team is seeing unprecedented demand for tampa party bus rental services from Ybor City to Raymond James Stadium," said Mr. Seghrouchni, owner of L3 Limo. "Whether guests want to celebrate at Amalie Arena events, brewery tours, or a bar crawl through town, we provide quality transportation so the party starts the moment they step aboard." Industry data indicates that party bus prices often rise by 30–50% during peak holiday periods such as July 4th. Reflecting this demand, L3 Limo's reservation specialists report strong advance bookings from groups planning to travel between Tampa Bay's many Independence Day attractions, from Safety Harbor's patriotic parade and Tarpon Springs' picnic events to festivities at Sparkman Wharf and the Tampa Bay History Center area. July 4, 2025 Boom by the Bay 2025 will include the Heights District Fourth of July Celebration at Armature Works, the Star Spangled Sparkman Wharf festivities, and the Friends of the Tampa Riverwalk Boat Parade along the Hillsborough River. The Friends of the Tampa Riverwalk July 4th celebration features a boat parade with the theme "Salute to Service," honoring military and first responders with patriotic displays on the water. The event includes a water ski show, blessing of the fleet, and fireworks, with boats competing for most patriotic vessel. VIP tickets offer premium seating with drinks and food for spectators. This multi-venue format creates transportation challenges for attendees traveling between locations throughout the night, increasing demand for group transportation solutions like tampa party bus rentals. The special event weekend coincides with other major Tampa Bay area attractions near Raymond James Stadium and various sporting events throughout the fun-filled holiday period. L3 Limo serves the whole crew for any big event, with a fleet of tampa party buses accommodating groups of all sizes—from intimate birthday parties to large wedding parties. Its luxury vehicles feature premium sound systems, LED lighting, and onboard entertainment, with knowledgeable chauffeurs ensuring VIP treatment for every ride. Customers can request a free quote for tampa party bus services by filling out a contact form on the company's website or contacting L3 Limo directly via phone or email. About L3 Limo L3 Limo is a Tampa-based charter bus and party bus company serving Central Florida. The limo fleet provider offers quality transportation services for wedding packages, corporate events, birthday parties, celebrations and special occasions throughout Tampa Florida. More information is available at L3 Limo 5804 E Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd, Tampa, FL 33619 (813) 699-5777 Media Contact Company Name: L3 Limo Contact Person: Adell Seghrouchni Email: Send Email Phone: (813) 699-5777 Address: 5804 E Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd City: Tampa State: FL Country: United States Website:
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
‘Inherent risks to all parts of the river': Officials urge caution while floating the Bow and Elbow
This weekend kicks off the busiest time of year for aquatic rescues in Calgary, and officials want anyone floating the Bow or Elbow to be extra cautious. As July approaches, the Calgary Fire Department water rescue team is expecting a busy month ahead. Officials want anyone floating the Bow or Elbow to be extra cautious—wear a life jacket and don't drink or smoke cannabis. 'It's not top of mind for a lot of people, so that's why every year we want to remind people about the dangers,' said Carol Henke, public information officer for the Calgary Fire Department. Aquatic safety experts say the Bow and Elbow rivers, even during summer heat, can see flow and temperature variations very quickly. 'There's inherent risks to all parts of the river,' said Alex Kwan, community safety officer for the Calgary Fire Department. Kwan says the busiest stretch of the Bow River begins at the Shouldice boat launch and goes through to Harvie Passage in Inglewood, especially where there are bridge crossings. 'What we see is people get into trouble by getting pushed by the current against any of the bridge pillars,' said Kwan. The risks on the water are high. Since 2016, there have been 29 fatalities. Last July, there were four deaths on the water—higher than the average. Wearing a life jacket is not only life-saving—it's the law. Failure to wear one could result in a $500 fine. This weekend kicks off the busiest time of year for aquatic rescues in Calgary, and officials want anyone floating the Bow or Elbow to be extra cautious. This weekend kicks off the busiest time of year for aquatic rescues in Calgary, and officials want anyone floating the Bow or Elbow to be extra cautious. Calgary police say booze and cannabis should only be consumed where it's safe and legal on dry land. 'We don't want to see any tragedies. We've seen enough in the past,' said Acting Insp. Kurt Jacobs. There will be an increased presence of police and peace officers along the shoreline, not just for enforcement, but also for education. 'We want you to have fun on the waterways, but we want you to be safe and we want you to get home at the end of the day,' said Acting Sgt. Mark Smith. Emergency officials recommend having a plan. The rules on the water are the same as on the road. Alcohol or cannabis consumption is not allowed. If you are impaired, you can be charged—just as you would as an impaired driver behind the wheel. Police officers say not everyone might be aware of this.
