Murdered woman's body not found for three days after police call wrongly coded
Frances Anne Phelps - known as Faye - with her late husband Bill.
Photo:
Supplied
A murdered woman's body was not found for three days after the emergency call to police was given the wrong code.
Elliot Cameron was
jailed for life with a minimum non-parole period of 10 years
at the High Court at Christchurch last week for murdering 83-year-old Frances Anne Phelps - known as Faye - on 4 October last year.
On Monday, a suppression order was lifted
revealing he killed his brother in 1975
and was detained as a special patient after being found not guilty of murder by reason of insanity.
Police now say an initial call about the attack on Phelps, via 105 at 4:36pm on 4 October, stated Cameron had disclosed to a nurse at Hillmorton Hospital that he assaulted a woman with an axe on the corner of Mount Pleasant and Bellview Avenue.
"Given the limited information available at the time, the job was not coded as a serious or grievous assault, resulting in a unit not immediately being dispatched," the statement said.
Elliot Alfred James Cameron at sentencing in the High Court at Christchurch on 10 June 2025.
Photo:
Pool/ NZME / George Heard
Six hours later, at 10.43pm, another Hillmorton staff member called police and left a message saying Cameron since told them he made up the claim of assaulting someone.
"Police acknowledge that the job should have been coded as a serious or grievous assault, however we believe it would not have changed the outcome of this terrible tragedy."
They said they have since introduced training for emergency communications and dispatch staff.
The calls to police were revealed
at sentencing
. The court was told Phelps' lawnmower man found her dead lying on the steps beside the garage door on 7 October and called emergency services.
The court summary of facts said Phelps would have died very soon after the injuries were inflicted, if not immediately.
RNZ exclusively obtained emails from Cameron to his cousin Alan Cameron
sent over more than a decade
, detailing his concerns that he might kill again.
In his 60s, having spent most of his life as a mental health in-patient, had emailed his cousin Alan about why he needed to remain in hospital.
"The probability of me repeating the offence outside hospital is greater than the probability of me repeating the offence where I am and so disrupting society is less when I remain in hospital," he wrote.
"I am correctly placed in a mental hospital. I should remain where I am."
Following the revelations,
Chief Victims Advisor Ruth Money said
it was hard to see Phelps' death as "anything other than preventable".
The public deserves an inquiry into the forensic mental health system, Money said.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Gang members from New Zealand with Cook Islands heritage causing serious concerns
By Talaia Mika , Cook Islands News Cook Islands Police media and strategic advisor Trevor Pitt told Cook Islands News that the movement of known gang members is a regional problem that has found its way into the Cooks. Photo: Cook Islands Police The growing presence and influence of organised gang members from New Zealand with Cook Islands heritage is causing serious concern for local authorities, with police confirming that the Cook Islands is one of the destinations affected by transnational gang mobility across the Pacific. Cook Islands Police media and strategic advisor Trevor Pitt told Cook Islands News that the movement of known gang members is a regional problem that has found its way into the Cooks. "As for the gangs issue, yes I can confirm that the mobility of organised gangs is a concern to law enforcement, not just for the Cook Islands but throughout the Pacific Islands," Pitt said. "We are just one of the destinations impacted by the movement of known gang members." This comes at the back of the New Zealand Police Commissioner Richard Chambers visit to the Cook Islands on Wednesday to deepen its relationship with the Cook Islands Police Service and assist in whatever way they can. Cook Islands News understands that some individuals with connections to these gangs had been posting videos of their lifestyles on TikTok with local youth engaging with and reacting to this content online - a growing concern in terms of influence and aspiration. Pitt said the Cook Islands Police is part of a broader multi-agency network that includes Immigration, Customs, the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU), and Transnational Crime Units (TCUs) across the region, including New Zealand and Australia. He said collaboration and information sharing are critical in developing strategies to combat cross-border criminal activity. He added that while he could not speak for the other agencies, the police partnership with New Zealand Police and Australian authorities are vital, especially as more Cook Islanders with gang ties return home. "The increased mobility of known gang members to the Cook Islands is a growing concern, particularly as our own people are part of the organised criminal element," he said. While Immigration requirements are being followed, Pitt said Police cannot stop Cook Islanders from entering the country if they comply with border regulations. Pitt added that one of the greatest challenges lies with vulnerable youth, especially those sent from New Zealand or Australia due to family problems. "Our at-risk youth are an ongoing problem. That includes those young ones who, unfortunately, are often sent from NZ or Australia due to family issues," he said. "These teens would be at risk whether here or in NZ as organised gangs are known to target troubled youth that are caught up in broken homes and families." Despite existing leadership and youth development initiatives run by Police each year, Pitt acknowledged that the resources to support these young people are limited and the outcomes are not always consistent. "The Police can only do so much with the juveniles and our programmes are limited to the youth leadership and development courses, each year," he said. "While we certainly value the support and cooperation of NZ with these, impact upon troubled juveniles is mixed at best." The rising visibility of gang influence through social media, combined with the real-world presence of returning or visiting gang-linked individuals, has escalated concerns about the safety and well-being of Cook Islands youth. Pitt emphasised that strengthening tactical cooperation with international law enforcement is now a top priority for the Cook Islands Police in the face of these evolving threats. Chambers confirmed that New Zealand is open to supporting the Cook Islands in tackling the gang issue and addressing the potential spread of transnational crime. "We're very open to supporting the Cook Islands in any way that we can," Chambers told Cook Islands News during his visit to Rarotonga. -This article was first published by Cook Islands News .
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Napier CBD's only pharmacy raided for third time in 10 weeks
business crime 28 minutes ago Thieves have targeted central Napier's only pharmacy for a third time in 10 weeks. Life Pharmacy owner Peter Bailey spoke to Charlotte Cook.
Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
Govt Set To Surpass Both Law And Order Targets
Minister for Children Hon Paul Goldsmith Minister of Justice New quarterly data shows the Government is on track to deliver on both law and order targets ahead of schedule, Minister for Children Karen Chhour and Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith say. 'We're determined to protect communities, reduce victimisation, and to encourage young people not to continue down the path of serious crime and incarceration,' Mrs Chhour says. 'A year ago we set a target of reducing the number of children and young people with serious and persistent offending behaviour by 15 per cent by 2029. 'A 13 per cent reduction in the most recent quarter shows we are hot on the heels of achieving our goal. 'We've trialled bold new responses to this long-standing issue and have ensured agencies work in greater collaboration with each other. 'Proactive data-driven regional responses have also helped. It has truly been a team effort. 'Budget 2025 saw further investment in multiple complementary ways to address recidivism amongst young people, including future iterations of the military-style academies and the Youth Serious Offender declaration. 'We continue to want better for, and from, these young people. This is a strong start, but we're committed to sustained and meaningful success for our communities.' 'This success comes off the back of the Government tracking ahead of its violent crime reduction target,' Mr Goldsmith says. 'Our Government has wasted no time overhauling a culture of excuses left behind by the last administration. Victims are our priority, and we've returned them to the heart of the justice system. 'The latest New Zealand Crime and Victims Survey shows that for the year to February, there were 157,000 victims of violent crime. This is 28,000 fewer victims than the baseline set in October 2023. Specifically, there were 12,000 fewer victims in Auckland and 5,000 fewer in Canterbury. 'There is a lot more work to do, but these results are a good early sign we are heading in the right direction. 'We've provided police and the courts with extra tools to go after gangs, brought back a revised three strikes sentencing regime, restored real consequences for crime by limiting sentence discounts, and scrapped Section 27 reports. 'We do, however, expect the data to remain volatile, and there's still more work to do to continue driving these numbers down.'
