Husband rolling in money: Court hikes woman's compensation to Rs 1 crore
A sessions court here has enhanced the compensation granted to a woman from Rs 5 lakh to Rs 1 crore in a domestic violence case, ruling that her husband was 'rolling in money'.The court observed that the woman's husband, who runs an elevator company, and his family are 'crorepatis'.Besides the compensation, the court also increased the monthly maintenance granted to the woman and her daughter from Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1.5 lakh, holding that the 'physical and mental torture' faced by the complainant while living with her husband can 'scarcely be imagined'.advertisement
In her order passed last month, Additional Sessions Judge (Dindoshi Court) S J Ansari ruled that the initial compensation of Rs 5 lakh awarded by a magistrate was 'meagre' considering that the woman endured 'torture and humiliation' for 20 years.The victim, a 41-year-old housewife, had challenged a February 2020 compensation order passed by the magistrate under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act.She alleged a long history of physical, emotional, and economic abuse by her husband and in-laws since her marriage in December 1997.The sessions court noted that the woman was forced to seek legal help for maintenance as a last resort after suffering "beatings, severe assaults, taunts and even financial deprivation" in a marriage of almost 20 years.The 'physical and mental torture' endured by the woman while living with her husband can 'scarcely be imagined', the court said.advertisementThe sessions judge also noted that the magistrate had granted Rs 5 lakh to the aggrieved woman. According to the order, while the woman termed the amount too little, her husband contended that she was not entitled to any money as compensation.The man claimed that he was at the receiving end of his wife's 'behaviour' and his financial situation had now become 'precarious'. The husband said he pays the rent for the premises occupied by him and their twin sons, and he takes care of their educational and living expenses, which leaves him with nothing.The court, however, held that the complainant was subjected to domestic violence by her husband.It noted that the husband and his father had the financial capacity in 2012 to purchase land as well as a flat worth more than Rs 1 crore.The man could not prove that his financial condition was not good despite trying his level best, the court said.'On the other hand, he being in a position to purchase properties worth Rs 1 crore in 2012, and presently running an elevator company, will surely be rolling in money,' the court said.Citing the material on the record, the court said the man and his family are 'crorepatis'. Noting that he being 'extremely rich', the Rs 5 lakh compensation awarded to the complainant by the magistrate 'is too meagre an amount'.advertisement'The same requires a very substantial enhancement so as to actually compensate the complainant for the 20 years of torture, humiliation, economic abuse, taunts, etc., undergone by her at the hands of the respondent no. 1,' the court ruled.The court said the woman has to now also suffer being estranged from her two sons. The husband appears to have influenced the sons against their mother 'is also something which cannot be ignored', the judge said.After considering all aspects, the court raised the compensation as well as the maintenance granted to the woman and her daughter.Must Watch
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Piyush Jain case: Court dismisses accused application, hearing on July 4
1 2 Kanpur: Special chief judicial magistrate Kanpur Nagar Kumud Lata Tripathi on Friday dismissed the application of accused Piyush Jain and Sunil A Hirani in the much-publicised case in which the GST department had recovered approximately Rs 195 crore cash and gold bars weighing around 22 kgs. The DGGI Ahmedabad had raided perfume trader Piyush Jain's houses situated at Anandpuri Kanpur and Kannauj on December 21, 2021. The department had seized Rs 196 crore in cash and 23 kg gold from his possession. Piyush was ultimately arrested on December 27, 2021. He was bailed out after about eight months. The prosecution had made thirteen other persons accused apart from Piyush. All are currently on bail. Both accused had previously applied for the case diary and other documents as per provisions of the Cr PC which was strongly opposed by the prosecution. According to Ambrish Tandon, special prosecutor for DGGI Ahmedabad, the accused applicants pressed their demand on last date while he submitted that CD/DVD containing 479 to 11,455 pages of the charge sheet had already been provided to the counsel of Sunil A Hirani and the same had also been provided to Piyush Jain on October 20, 2023. Both had acknowledged receipt on the order sheet of the case file present in the court. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Hamburg: GEERS sucht 700 Testhörer für Hörgeräte ohne Zuzahlung GEERS Undo He stated that since copies of the documents had already been furnished by the court, it appears that this application had been filed only to delay proceedings. Therefore, the court should dismiss the application of Hirani and Piyush Jain. The court, which had reserved its order on the previous date, delivered the verdict and dismissed the accused applicants' plea. The magistrate in her order observed that since all documents had already been delivered by the prosecution to the accused, there was no reason to deliver them again. The application was viewed as a tactic to delay the trial and thus was dismissed. The next date was fixed as July 4 for hearing. Tandon informed that the prosecution would now present its evidence. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Eid wishes , messages , and quotes !
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
Lawyer bail plea rejected in 2.6cr cheating case
Mumbai: Observing that if this court exercises discretion in favour of applicant it will give a wrong message to society, a sessions court on Monday rejected the bail plea of advocate Vinaykumar Khatu, who is accused of defrauding a Delhi-based 74-year-old woman, a client, of Rs 2.57 crore by allegedly presenting her with forged orders purportedly issued by Bombay high court. "This court cannot ignore the antecedent of applicant. Admittedly, two offences were registered against applicant for misrepresenting himself as an IAS officer. If this court exercises discretion in favour of applicant, it will give a wrong message to society. The seriousness of allegations and antecedent of applicant prevent me from exercising discretion in favour of applicant," sessions judge VG Raghuwanshi said. The judge also said that if one decides to rely on WhatsApp chat then he cannot ignore that accused had stated about stay granted by honourable high court in his chat with the accountant and it is also clear that huge amounts were transferred to the accounts of his friends, associates and him after the date of fabricated orders. It was also held that offences relating to criminal breach of trust and forgery of valuable security were added against accused. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Nürtingen: GEERS sucht 700 Testhörer für Hörgeräte ohne Zuzahlung GEERS Undo "A judgment of civil court can be considered a valuable security…Court judgments often create or modify legal right and liabilities. Thus, the judgments fit within definition of valuable security," the judge said. The accused was a lawyer of the woman, Urmila Talyarkhan, who was involved in a property dispute relating to a land in Alibaug. After a lower court ruled against her, Talyarkhan appealed the decision to the district court. Her advocate failed to appear for the hearing, leading to the dismissal of the appeal on Mar 13, 2018. Residing in Delhi at the time, she remained unaware of this dismissal until 2022, as her advocate did not inform her. It was alleged that through a business acquaintance, Talyarkhan was introduced to Khatu. She retained Khatu for six matters, including the land dispute appeal, and a suit against her husband. Khatu allegedly charged an exorbitant fee of Rs 10 lakh per case. She allegedly transferred Rs 2 crore from her friend's account to those associated with the accused. Following Khatu's advice, she filed a second appeal in Bombay high court, with applications for condonation of a four-year delay and a stay order. Denying the allegations, the accused said that he was arrested on Oct 19, 2024. "Nothing needs to be seized from him. There is no possibility of tampering evidence," the lawyer submitted. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Eid wishes , messages , and quotes !
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
After 600cr highway overhaul, safety fix for Mistry accident site
Vasai: The accident site where former Tata Sons chairman Cyrus Mistry lost his life will now be marked as a 'go-slow and no-overtaking zone' -- measures being proposed only after the completion of a Rs600 crore white-topping project on the Mumbai-Ahmedabad National Highway (NH48). Ironically, this high-risk stretch -- known to locals as a "black spot" -- was already notorious for its hazardous design. It lies near Charoti flyover, where three highway lanes suddenly merge into a two-lane bridge over the Surya river in just 500 metres. Despite the obvious risk, no safety modifications were made during the highway overhaul. These observations have now been flagged by third-party safety auditor Geo Designs & Research, appointed by NHAI after public pressure mounted following multiple fatal accidents, including Mistry's. The safety audit only came after activist Mayur Thakur from Bhumiputra Sanghatna went on an indefinite hunger strike demanding urgent scrutiny of NH48. "We've submitted the audit report to the Palghar collector and are finalising cost estimates for implementing the corrective measures," said Suhash Chitnis, NHAI project director. He acknowledged that the audit was initiated by NHAI following demands from the activists. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Memperdagangkan CFD Emas dengan salah satu spread terendah? IC Markets Mendaftar Undo But the timing has sparked outrage. "Why was Rs 600 crore spent on the road without first fixing known design flaws?" questioned activist Harbans Singh Nanade. "What were the NHAI engineers doing while fatal crashes kept happening? Now, after public protests and preventable deaths, we're back to square one with fresh estimates and retroactive fixes." Thakur, who led the hunger strike, expressed disbelief: "NHAI always claimed the highway was safe. Now suddenly, two new black spots have been identified and by an external auditor, not NHAI itself. This just proves that the agency failed to act when it mattered most." The audit report recommends not only go-slow markings and no-overtaking signs, but also metal crash barriers, rumblers, and other measures to curb speeding -- steps that could have been integrated into the white-topping project from the beginning. Activists argue that had these recommendations been acted upon proactively, taxpayers' money could have been better spent, lives could have been saved, and public trust in infrastructure agencies might not have eroded so deeply. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Eid wishes , messages , and quotes !
