Tech giant SAP asks US Supreme Court to reconsider rival's antitrust win
Europe's largest software maker SAP has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review a decision that said the technology giant must face a lawsuit by U.S. data technology company Teradata accusing it of violating antitrust law. SAP in a petition made public on Tuesday said a decision by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in California that reinstated Teradata's lawsuit will threaten American tech innovation if it is left in place. Teradata accused SAP of violating antitrust law by "tying" sales of business-planning applications with the purchase of a key SAP database that can perform transactional and analytical functions. Teradata makes a rival analytics database.
In its filing at the high court, SAP said the integration of software products can often benefit consumers and "represent an effort to 'compete effectively,' rather than to stifle competition."
SAP declined to comment. Teradata did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
San Diego-based Teradata filed its lawsuit against SAP in federal court in California in 2018. The two companies once had a joint venture, but SAP terminated it after developing its own analytics database.
SAP won in the district court, but the 9th Circuit revived Teradata's case in December. The appeals court said there was material dispute between the companies that a jury could decide.
If the Supreme Court takes the case, the justices could rule on which legal standard judges should use to weigh antitrust tying claims.
Two key legal standards guide how judges resolve whether conduct restrains competition: the "per se rule," where alleged conduct is presumed illegal, and the "rule of reason," where judges balance between anticompetitive effects and a defendant's procompetitive justification.
The 9th Circuit, using a version of the "per se rule," applied too stringent a standard in evaluating Teradata's claims, SAP told the justices.
SAP said the appellate court's ruling clashed with how a Washington federal appeals court resolved a landmark antitrust case against Microsoft in the 1990s.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
38 minutes ago
- India Today
Rising cost of compliance
In December 2022, Muzaffarnagar-based entrepreneur Neeraj Kedia, managing director of zinc sulphate manufacturing firm Chakradhar Chemicals, received an unexpected notice from the Goods and Services Tax (GST) department, raising a tax demand of around Rs 95 lakh and interest of Rs 1.15 crore for the period from July 2017 to March 2018. It stated that the Input Tax Credit (ITC), which allows businesses to get reimbursement for the taxes they paid on their purchases, should not have been claimed by Kedia, as his supplier had not filed Form GSTR-3B, the monthly return to declare GST liabilities. The notice further alleged that Kedia had failed to file the form back in 2017. He was stunned. Like many small and mid-sized business owners, such a notice triggered not only a legal alarm but also operational disruption. Kedia responded swiftly, highlighting a key point: the Form GSTR-3B functionality wasn't even available on the GST portal at the time in question. The case was finally settled in September 2024. But addressing a show-cause notice years after is no easy task—it involves combing through old records, rechecking financial data and reconciling accounts. 'You have to jog your memory, track down data from years ago and build your case from scratch,' Kedia explains.
The Hindu
43 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Elon Musk's Starlink gets licence to start India services amid feud with Trump
Elon Musk's Starlink has received a licence from the telecom department for providing satellite internet services in India, a key milestone that will take it closer towards launching commercial operations in the country. Starlink is the third company after Eutelsat OneWeb and Jio Satellite Communications to get a licence from the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) to provide satellite internet services in the country. A fourth applicant, Amazon's Kuiper is still waiting for approvals. DoT sources confirmed on Friday (June 6, 2025) that Starlink has indeed received the licence and said the company will be granted trial spectrum in 15-20 days of applying for it. Starlink will now have to comply with the security norms such as providing access for lawful interception, before starting services. The licence came hours after a huge public spat between Mr. Musk and U.S. President Donald Trump. The falling-out between the world's richest man and the world's most powerful person began when Mr. Musk, who left his role as head of the Department of Government Efficiency a week ago, denounced Mr. Trump's sweeping tax-cut and spending bill. On Thursday (June 5, 2025), it erupted in the verbal duel after Mr. Trump criticised Mr. Musk in the Oval Office. Mr. Musk responded, saying, 'Trump would have lost' without his help, prompting the U.S. President to end U.S. contracts. The licence from DoT came nearly a month after the Starlink was issued a letter of intent (LoI) by the telecom department. The companies that have received the licence would, however, have to a wait a tad longer for commercial satcom spectrum as the Trai just recently sent its recommendations on pricing, and terms and conditions, to the government for its consideration. The players will be able to start their services after the allocation of radio wave frequencies. Typically, even before the commercial spectrum, the trial spectrum is required to test, and verify the systems and processes on security parameters to demonstrate that all norms and requirements, are being complied with. The status of the Starlink's final nod from the Indian space regulator, In-SPACe could not be immediately ascertained. Starlink is a satellite internet service developed by SpaceX — the American aerospace manufacturer and space transportation company founded in 2002 by the world's richest man Musk. It provides high-speed, low-latency broadband internet worldwide using satellite technology and is aptly described by some as broadband beamed from the skies. Unlike conventional satellite services that rely on distant geostationary satellites, Starlink utilises the world's largest low Earth orbit or LEO constellation (550 km above Earth). This constellation of LEO satellites (7,000 now but eventually set to grow to over 40,000) and its mesh delivers broadband internet capable of supporting streaming, online gaming, and video calls. Starlink, which had been vying for an Indian licence for some time now, recently signed pacts with Ambani's Reliance Jio and Mittal's Bharti Airtel, which together control more than 70% of the country's telecom market, to bring the U.S. satellite internet giant's services to India. The nod for the satcom offering — known for its resilience in harsh conditions and conflict zones — coincides with escalation of Donald Trump-Elon Musk feud in the U.S. Early last month, the government had issued stringent security norms mandating legal interception of satellite communication services and barred companies from linking connection of users in any form with any terminal or facility located outside the country's border as well as processing of their data overseas. The tighter security rules also mandate service providers to indigenise at least 20% of their ground segments of the satellite network within years of their establishment in the country. The satcom service licence holders will require security clearances for specific gateway and hub locations in India and compliance with monitoring, interception facilities and equipment requirements. India's rules mandate satcom firms to demonstrate system capabilities with respect to security aspects, including monitoring, to the Department of Telecom (DoT) or its authorised representatives before starting operations in India. It is pertinent to mention that telecom regulator TRAI last month recommended that satellite communication companies like Starlink pay 4% of their adjusted gross revenue (AGR) as spectrum charges to the government — a rate steeper than what these firms had been lobbying for. Operators offering satellite-based broadband internet services in urban areas would have to shell out an additional Rs 500 per subscribers annually, TRAI recommended. No additional levy would be applicable for services in rural areas. COAI, whose members include Reliance Jio and Airtel, recently approached the telecom department to raise concerns over TRAI recommendations on the satcom spectrum. The industry body argued that 'incorrect assumptions' have led to unjustifiably low spectrum charges for satellite services relative to terrestrial networks — a claim strongly rejected by Trai, which has ruled out any review of recommendations at this stage, based on industry body COAI's charges.
India.com
43 minutes ago
- India.com
F-47 sixth generation fighter jet of US likely to get its first buyer, not India, Pakistan, Israel, Ukraine, UK, France, Saudi Arabia, it is...
F-47 will be the first American-made 6th gen fighter jet. (File/Wiki) Amid Russia and China rapidly advancing their military technologies, especially the development of sixth-generation fighter jets, the United States has announced that it was building F-47– the country's first 6th-gen fighter jet. Sharing the news, US President Donald Trump described the F-47 as the 'most advanced and powerful jet' ever built. 'The F-47 will be the most advanced, most capable, most lethal aircraft ever built,' Trump said, while his Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth said the 6th-generation aircraft was a 'clear message' to US' allies and enemies. 'It sends a very clear message to our allies that we're here to stay—and to our enemies that we will continue to project power globally without any obstacles,' said Hegseth. F-47 – US' first 6th-generation fighter jet Developed and manufactured by American aerospace giant Boeing, the F-47 is the US' first officially-announced 6th-generation fighter jet designed to supplement and support its older platforms, such as the F-15, F-16, F-18, F-22, and F-35 fighters. Notably, China is already developing two two sixth-generation fighter jet prototypes, the J-36 and J-50, one of whom was showcased at the Zhuhai Airshow in late 2024. The Chinese 6th-gen fighter jets feature advanced stealth capabilities with a unique tailless airframes, and will be powered by three engines. Japan to be first buyer of F-47? Interestingly, Japan may become the first country to acquire the F-47 fighter jet from the US. According to a report by the Eurasian Times, Japan is considering to add the sixth-generation aircraft to its air force fleet. Additionally, several media reports have claimed the Donald Trump had personally offered F-47 jet to Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba during a phone call last month. However, Trump said the export variant of the F-47 which will be sold to US allies will be a 'toned down' version of the aircraft. 'Our allies are calling constantly. They want to buy them also. And we will be selling to certain allies—perhaps toned-down versions,' Trump said.
