
'Dodgy' parking machines cause heartache as motorists pay fines despite being innocent
Motorists would pay a 'dodgy' parking fine even if they hadn't done anything wrong - most would fork out just to 'get rid of the hassle', with 13% saying there's no point in appealing private company fines
Drivers say they would pay private parking charges even if they'd done nothing wrong. One in 20 would pay up even if they knew they hadn't broken the rules, according to the AA. Most would fork out just to 'get rid of the hassle', with 13% saying there's no point in appealing these private company fines.
The majority would appeal, but only a third say they'd be 'confident' of success. These latest findings show 'the delay in implementing the official government code is scandalous' says AA's head of roads policy who supply roadside assistance all over the nation. Campaigner Lynda Eagan, who operates a 'Private Parking Tickets - Help and Advice' Facebook group with 47,000 followers, told The Mirror she worries about the mental health impact of these fines.
She said: 'People are paying early to save themselves the aggravation of having to appeal, lose the appeal, pay even more and potentially go to court. What we really need to concentrate on is on the mental health of people. To get a PCN doesn't sound very much but for some people £60 is a lot of money, it's probably a grocery shop, especially for pensioners.
'It's a pain in your heart to know they are losing a night's sleep over it. Many of the vulnerable in the community are the ones getting tripped up by these parking machines. And it's all because of pure greed. It's the gravy train they know is going to be grinding to a halt when the Government impose regulations. " She explained the wait for regulations for private firms goes back to 2017, the act was passed in 2019 but the proposed code of practice was withdrawn in 2022 and "it's now sitting dusty on a shelf.'
Lynda predicts we are heading for 14 million PCNs this year, based on the number of requests that the DVLA get.
'They are generating PCNs for things they know are unfair. The graph is going up at about the same rate every year.' She says 'dodgy machines' are causing a lot of heartache, with sticky numbers and machines that encourage people to pay before they have put their full registration in. 'I only see the tip of the iceberg but I see lots of people who say they put their registration in but the machine has made a mistake.
"Those people are offered a £20 early cancellation fee by the companies that are chasing them even though those companies know there are repeated problems in their car parks.'
AA members were asked to imagine receiving a PCN for something they didn't commit, with one saying 'pay as no one seems to win in a contest with parking companies.'.
One in 50 respondents said they would ignore the PCN letter, with one explaining 'Ignore it as it's an invoice not a fine!'. While explaining their reason for paying and appealing one person said 'I'd rather pay it so that it doesn't escalate then contest it to get refunded'.
Meanwhile, one in 12 (8%) said they would approach Citizens Advice for help. In 2021-22 Citizens Advice helped 7,412 people with concerns regarding private parking operators, but that has now grown by 34% to 9,926 requests for help in 2024-25.
In their poll of more than 11,500 drivers, one in 20 (5%1) said they would pay up immediately if they received a PCN even if they knew they did not break the rules.
Of those that would pay, more than half (53%) said they would do so because 'it gets rid of the hassle'. More than one in 10 (13%) said they would pay the PCN because they felt they wouldn't get a fair hearing at appeal, while shockingly 11% said they'd pay due to fearing legal action. In contrast, 53% of drivers said they would appeal a PCN letter from a private parking company, but only a third said they felt 'confident' they would be successful.
After a legal challenge a code of practice for private companies was withdrawn. The private parking sector have since implemented their own code of practice, which The AA does not endorse.
'In fact, 5% of drivers have been hoodwinked into believing that this self-authored code is the official government backed document,' they said.
The AA is calling on the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) to act urgently and introduce the government backed scheme by the end of 2025.
Jack Cousens, head of roads policy for The AA, said: 'The delay in implementing the official government code is scandalous. Six years on, yet no part of the legislation has been introduced to protect and safeguard drivers from an aggressive industry. 'The fact that drivers are willing to pay up when they have done nothing wrong, nor have any confidence in the current appeals process, shows why urgent action is needed.
'We are hugely concerned that the government is standing idly by while drivers continue to receive threatening letters from a sector that works on the basis of guilty until proven innocent. Urgent action is needed, and introducing the rules by the end of the year will help wrestle back some of the balance in favour of the motorist.
'Until the measures within the Act are in place, drivers will continue to be attacked by these shark-like businesses.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Telegraph
30 minutes ago
- Telegraph
This £5k Brighton parking space is an auction bargain, but is it a good investment?
However, the point I want to draw your attention to is: the car parking space is leasehold, with approximately 63 years unexpired. As the sale is by an executor, I'm presuming the previous owner has died, but that this parking space was also at one stage likely tied to a flat in the building. As parking spaces don't carry the same rights of renewal as flats do, there's no statutory obligation for the freeholder to renew the lease – although, as the auctioneer replied: 'In practice, why wouldn't they?' Other people will see the same potential you do Billy Hart's Quay, Barton Road, Plymouth is a completely different find, and I have to be honest, if you're local or into boating, this is a gem of a lot. This is a quayside plot measuring 0.142 acres (6,186 sq ft) with direct vehicular and waterside access. The auctioneers have said it has development potential and, given the amount of residential development around and the picturesque setting, I wouldn't put it past some entrepreneurial bidder to come up with a novel scheme. Besides the residential angle, there's also a commercial opportunity for this quay that was constructed by American troops preparing for the D-Day landings. With hardstanding scrubland and access to Hooe Lake, and onward to Plymouth Sound, the English Channel and beyond, this presents several options for potential commercial operators, such as water sports hire, secure boat storage and motorhomes. The auction details also say there could be opportunity to acquire the adjacent slipway and foreshore by separate negotiation. The watch point on this: I think it's priced at a 'come buy me price'. The guide at £20,000-25,000 will really tempt people who are looking for lifestyle and commercial opportunities. But I think they'll be sorely disappointed in bagging a bargain – I reckon an 'armada' of buyers will be bidding for this, so I expect it to go way over guide. The importance of asking questions My third choice is this mid-terrace house located on St Johns Square, Stoke-on-Trent, guided at £23,000. The reason I selected this is because at first glance this looks like a pub. But then I went on Google maps and saw it was a closed barbers, with the upper floors boarded up and in a sorry state of repair. Understandably, I got confused and asked the auctioneers: 'So where is this house?' They replied: 'It is actually to the rear of the building.' Now, this is an important lesson in buying at auction – you always need to check the legals. As they are not yet available, the auctioneers don't have the title plan, but you can't always go off a photograph and think that's what you're buying. In a bid to find out more (I always say you have to be a detective when buying at auction), I tracked down the EPC (which expired in 2020), and I have learnt the property is a mid-terrace house with 54 sqm (581 sq ft), and it is rated a 'G'. This then comes with a big explanation mark and the accompanying text: 'You may not be able to let this property.' This is all useful information, should you be interested in this lot. However, the main reason I chose this property as a watch point was to highlight that it is being sold by the mortgagees (not in possession). This means the auctioneers will not be conducting viewings and, as yet, have not inspected the property. The emphasis on 'mortgages (not in possession)' is important because it means that the former owners of the property may still be living there. If you are bidding, you need to be aware of this. Also, the fact no viewings will be carried out makes this an incredibly risky buy, as you will not be able to find out what works need doing. The best-case scenario, in my opinion, would be to budget for a full back to brick renovation (and include a new roof) if you don't want to run out of funds. As auction lots go, this is one where you will be relying fully on the legal pack and your own due diligence to decide if the risk is worth the reward.


ITV News
4 hours ago
- ITV News
Uber announces self-driving cars in London from next year
Uber has announced it will begin operating self-driving taxis in London from spring 2026. The ride-hailing app company will operate services in partnership with artificial intelligence (AI) start-up Wayve. Uber launched in the capital in Summer 2012. This move has been enabled by the Government's decision to bring forward trials of self-driving commercial taxis and 'bus-like services' in England to next spring. They were previously expected to begin when the Automated Vehicles Act becomes law from the second half of 2027.


Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
UK drivers warned to fill tanks 'as full as possible' before Wednesday
Millions of petrol and diesel drivers have been urged to make sure their tank is as "full as possible" on Wednesday - but it's not for the reason you may have heard Motorists have been advised to keep their petrol and diesel tanks as "full as possible" this Wednesday, as temperatures are expected to reach up to 24C from Wednesday to Sunday, peaking at 27C on Friday. According to experts at 1dot, approximately 1-2 per cent of petrol and diesel fuel could evaporate in extreme heat. Specialists from All on the Wrist Auto and Diesel Repair warned: "Excessive heat can lead to increased evaporation of diesel fuel, potentially causing vapor lock and reduced engine efficiency." They added: "Additionally, engine oil may become less viscous in hot conditions, potentially compromising its protective properties." READ MORE: 'I'm a fashion writer and found an unlikely retailer selling glitzy festival-ready outfits' Hence, drivers are being encouraged to keep their fuel tanks as full as possible, reports Birmingham Live. However, amid the rising temperatures across the UK, online reports have falsely claimed that filling up during a heatwave could result in petrol tanks exploding. These fake posts, circulating on Facebook and Whatsapp, wrongly assert that five cars have exploded in the past week due to owners filling their tanks to the limit. The RAC has debunked these claims as nothing more than a social media hoax. In response to the rumours, RAC spokesperson Rod Dennis stated: "There is no truth in this." He reassured motorists by saying: "All fuel systems on passenger vehicles are designed to cope with any expansion of fuel, or vapour coming from the fuel. There is no risk of explosion from filling up a fuel tank fully and drivers should have no concerns in doing so. "We'd recommend people avoid the temptation to share misinformation like this via social media." Mr Dennis advised motorists to fill their tanks to the brim when possible, particularly before embarking on prolonged trips. However, as temperatures soar, he warned that it's crucial to adopt preventative measures against typical summertime issues.