The History of Sound review - I loved Paul Mescal in this imperfect gay drama
The History of Sound was one of the most eagerly anticipated films out of Cannes for its depiction of an historic gay love story between characters played by Paul Mescal and Josh O'Connor.
Director Oliver Hermanus delivers the romance in a poignant, beautifully-shot package – but it's smaller and slower than expected, even if it contains Mescal's finest onscreen work to date.
Mescal plays Kentucky farm boy Lionel, blessed with a gifted voice – and synaesthetic response to music – strong enough to send him to a Boston music conservatory on a scholarship in 1917.
There he meets Josh O'Connor's David, a genius-level composition student 'with a thousand songs in his head', after he plays a folk song from home that Lionel recognises.
It turns out collecting songs is David's passion, with the meeting between his confident and slightly louche manner and Lionel's shyness and sincerity a sweet moment.
That it turns sexual between the pair that evening is initially only hinted at, with moments such as them sharing the same glass before David invites Lionel into his bedroom – and it cuts to the next morning.
And so begins a surprisingly happy but casual relationship between the pair, given the period, interrupted only when David is drafted to serve in World War One.
With thousands of members from all over the world, our vibrant LGBTQ+ WhatsApp channel is a hub for all the latest news and important issues that face the LGBTQ+ community.
Simply click on this link, select 'Join Chat' and you're in! Don't forget to turn on notifications!
While embraces are later shown, The History of Sound is rather shy and prudish about sex, especially when given the emotionally vulnerable talents of its two lead actors. In some ways, yes, that matches it being a century ago – but it also somehow chafes against the nature of its passionate characters.
The angst and emotion of their connection – and how they figure it out when David later invites Lionel on a folk song collection trip in the forests of Maine – is reminiscent of Brokeback Mountain.
That's a big compliment to Mescal and O'Connor's natural chemistry, as well as the beautiful if ponderous way director Oliver Hermanus frames and shoots their relationship, even if this romance is not dealing with repression like Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal's film was.
But it leaves you wanting more with its sometimes plodding structure and repetitive moments in the wild together.
For a film called The History of Sound, I also didn't connect with the music as much as I expected. There's some lovely singing scenes, but far less of an abundance of folk music than anticipated given David's passion for it.
Mescal, who has a pleasant voice, is also given the task of living up to Lionel's much-hyped stunning vocal talent every time he opens his mouth to sing; it feels like the film skirts around it to avoid that issue of exposure where it can.
The History of Sound doesn't seem as concerned with music and its emotional impact as much as expected either, especially once David and Lionel's trip together is finished.
Lionel's blessed career then takes him across the world – never seemingly impeded by his poverty – as he pines after David following their trip, while pursuing the adventures David wanted him to have.
We follow him throughout the 1920s – the film is rigid in noting every date and location in a slightly unnecessary way – until Lionel decides to track down the man who has clearly become the love of his life. More Trending
The revelations of The History of Sound's final act are moving and more engaging than other sections of the often slow-moving film.
It fuels its poignant and reflective nature about the impact of a love still felt many decades later when Chris Cooper appears as an 80-something Lionel in a touching coda.
Mescal and O'Connor do prove the captivating onscreen couple that all their fans hope they'd be, it's just a pity that The History of Sound doesn't provide as sweeping a canvas for them to paint as anticipated.
The History of Sound premiered at Cannes Film Festival. It is yet to receive a UK release date.
Got a story?
If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the Metro.co.uk entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@metro.co.uk, calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you.
MORE: Alpha review – I'm sticking up for gruelling French body horror that inspired walkouts
MORE: The real story behind those '20-minute standing ovations' at Cannes Film Festival
MORE: The 'must-watch' film of 2025 just received a 19-minute standing ovation at Cannes
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
North Wales Chronicle
22 minutes ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Fan travels 4,000 miles to pay last respects to Mike Peters
David made the journey from the Middle East, where he currently lives, to attend the funeral in Mike's hometown of Dyserth. The service was held on Thursday, May 29 at the Parish Church of St Bridget and St Cwyfan. Although entry to the church was by invitation only, thousands of fans lined Waterfall Road, where a large screen had been set up outside to broadcast the service. The gathering became a moving celebration of Mike's life and legacy. David said: 'It was important to me because The Alarm and Mike have been such a significant part of my life. 'Seven years ago, I was diagnosed with stage four colon cancer, and Mike helped me through so much - especially during the lowest point in my life. He personally gave me hope. David travelled an incredible distance to pay his last respects to Mike. Mike had a big impact on David (Image: Suzanne Kendrick / Newsquest) "I was very lucky to have Mike in my life." Talking about how lovely it was to see the turn out for Mike, David said: "It is a gathering to celebrate Mike's life but for many people this is also a moment of closing. To be here and support the family, to support everything he represents and the effect that he has made on people's lives will live on for generations." Sisters Claire and Jo travelled from York and Derbyshire. Claire said: "My big sister Jo introduced me to The Alarm in 1988 and they really spoke to me. Throughout my life, they enabled me to keep positive and to keep strong and keep moving forward. I think, because he has held me up so much in my life it was important for me to come and pay my respects today." Sisters Claire and Jo (Image: Suzanne Kendrick / Newsquest) Steph from the Lincolnshire Coast said: "I have been an Alarm fan since the mid 80s but Mike, through Love Hope Strength, really convinced me that I could do things I thought I couldn't do and he never gave up on people even when we were giving up on ourselves. Steph wanted to come for closure and to pay her last respect to 'a legend' (Image: Suzanne Kendrick / Newsquest) "I just thought I needed to come and have the closure and pay my last respects to a legend." Rachel Knol travelled from the Netherlands. Her partner Andi Badge was Mike's Lighting Engineer for 15 Years. They have both been fans since the 80s. Rachel Knol, who travelled from the Netherlands, pictured with her partner Andi Badge (Image: Suzanne Kendrick / Newsquest) Rachel and Andi have been together for 10 years. Andi said: "He gave me a chance to travel the world. Over the years, The Alarm has been so important. All the friendships, all the memories, it feels like family." Chris Salt from Burts Taxis (Image: Suzanne Kendrick / Newsquest) Chris Salt from Burts Taxis spent the morning transporting fans from Prestatyn Train Station to Dyserth for the service. He finished his duties early; he is a huge Alarm fan and wanted to attend the funeral and celebrate Mike's life. He recalled seeing the band perform a young man. Mike's wife Jules and sons Dylan, 21, and Evan, 18, issued an open 'come a are you are' invitation to Mike's funeral. The talented and beloved musician died aged 66 from blood cancer on April 29. During the two-hour service, emotional tributes were paid to Mike as well as reflections, readings, and music. Opera singer Rhys Meirion, who is being treated for cancer and had undergone an operation just 10 days ago, delivered a beautiful rendition of the Welsh song Anfonaf Angel and friend and collaborator Billy Duffy played 'Fade In Fade Out Fade Away' along to Mike's vocals. Mike's wife Jules and sons Dylan, 21, and Evan, 18, were applauded by fans as they walked into the church. The crowd parted to allow the family to walk through. Jules clutched a single red rose and Evan carried his father's ashes.
Scottish Sun
3 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
I paid £70 for rare painting worth £8,000 at car boot sale – my three must-follow tips to find gems
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) ANTIQUES lover Sally-Ann Cathcart can often be seen hunting for treasures at car boot sales - but one find has left her quids in. The 50-year-old antiques dealer from North Shropshire paid just £70 for a pair of paintings - and she's now been told they could sell for £8,000 at auction. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 Sally-Ann Cathcart picked up these Percy Shakespeare paintings for £70 - but they've been valued at £8,000 Credit: Sally-Ann Cathcart 4 Another of Sally-Ann's finds is a vintage barometer from the 1700s Credit: Sally-Ann Cathcart 4 The antiques dealer also owns this photograph of a World War One soldier Credit: Sally-Ann Cathcart 4 The 50-year-old says she buys everything secondhand - including her clothes and homewares Credit: Sally-Ann Cathcart She was on one of her regular car boot sale trips in Bridgnorth when she spotted the paintings and immediately she knew she'd stumbled across something incredibly special. That's because the ultra-rare paintings were the work of one of the UK's most famous artists, Percy Shakespeare - and they were going for a bargain price. 'My eyes lit up when I saw them,' she told The Sun. 'I literally had that little heart flutter. I knew instantly what they were.' Sally-Ann said the man who sold her the paintings was a regular at car boot sales but 'clearly didn't know the value' of the art. The seller had got hold of the paintings while doing a house clearance for a lady. Unbelievably, they had been sat at the bottom of a trunk underneath a pile of old newspapers and magazines. The 1928 watercolour paintings show two children - a young boy and a girl - and Sally-Ann believes they may have been the children of the lady who owned the trunk. The paintings hadn't been in a frame or come with a plastic covering but Sally-Ann said they were in incredible condition as they had been kept inside the trunk for so long. She says she snapped them up immediately, and still has them 10 years on. Sally-Ann is a huge fan of Percy Shakespeare and is planning to keep hold of the paintings because she loves them so much. Antiques Roadshow guest is stunned by huge value of charity shop earrings bought for £5 But it was only recently that she decided to get them valued - and she was given a huge shock. An expert told her she could likely get £8,000 for the paintings if she took them to auction. 'I just have a second of thinking, 'have I heard you correctly?',' she said. 'I wanted to punch the air.' Other pieces of art from Percy Shakespeare that have gone to auction have sold for 10 times their estimated value, Sally-Ann says. If that came true for her, she could net herself a whopping £80,000 - although of course you never know what someone will pay at auction. The money might be tempting, but Sally-Ann says she plans to keep the paintings. 'I would only sell them if I absolutely really needed to because I just want to treasure them,' she says. The antiques dealer might be planning to keep hold of this rare find, but she's also made a small business out of buying and selling treasures from car boot sales and vintage fairs. Some of her clients include Cath Kidston, the National Trust and Pinewood Studios. 'Pinewood Studios is always fascinating because it could be like 'right we're doing a 1950s film and we need a petrol blue car'. 'Sometimes I'll be like, yeah, actually funnily enough, I've got one in the garage. Is this any good to you?' She's even sent an order to St James's Palace, where Princess Anne and Princess Beatrice live. Sally-Ann started out collecting antiques as a child when her grandma used to take her to Birmingham rag markets. 'I guess I've grown up with that old-fashioned rooting through, finding the best bargains,' she said. She bought her first antique - a 1920s art deco wallet - at around seven years old. 'I've always felt very comfortable in old places, old buildings,' she says. 'I love that whole old-fashioned mentality of let's make do and mend, which I think is perhaps coming back into fashion now. And then I've built a business out of it.' Now she'll often get requests from clients who ask her to search for specific items and she'll go on a hunt for them. Sally-Ann says she might for example be able to pick up a mirror for £5 and then sell it on for £120 to £150. Other memorable finds SALLY-ANN says she buys everything secondhand and her best finds end up staying with her. These are the ones she treasures the most… Vintage barometer The antiques dealer owns one of the oldest barometers produced by optician James Aitchison, who later went on to form optician chain Dollond & Aitchison in 1750. Sally-Ann says she picked up the antique for just £2 at a car boot sale last year. Photo album Another find is a photo album from the 1900s, which she snapped up for just £1. Sally-Ann says the photos inside show holidays and some sort of boating event. Photo of a World War One soldier Sally-Ann also picks out a photograph of a soldier from World War One. 'He looks about 16, and it's a beautiful French photograph of him,' she says. 'It hangs in my house and it has done for about 25 years.' Sally-Ann's top tips for finding valuable antiques The antiques dealer says she's developed an eye for something valuable over the years, but it's always worth going along to a car boot sale and seeing what you can find. 'The key things for car boots are take plenty of change, take comfortable shoes, take lots of bags, get there early,' she says. But her biggest tip is to remember your manners when talking to sellers. 'People will expect you to haggle at a car boot. So, if somebody says the item is £2, it is absolutely fine to say, 'would you take £1, please? 'And if they say, no, I wouldn't, no problem, you just decide whether you want to pay the £2 or not.' Sally-Ann says that around 70% of the time sellers will take the lower price, so you shouldn't be afraid to haggle but 'just do it with politeness and courtesy'. Sally-Ann says she's seen people throwing items back down onto the seller's table after not getting a lower price - and that's not the way to go. Another of her tips is that if we see something you like, you shouldn't wait around. 'Because if you leave it, I promise you, when you go back it will be gone,' she says. Sally-Ann says it's easy to start buying and selling antiques. 'You haven't got to invest thousands of pounds. You can take £20 or even £10 in cash this weekend, go to the car boot sale and just see what you can get.'
Scottish Sun
16 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Lionel Richie opens up about gruelling life on the road as he kicks off his first UK tour in a decade
THE LIONEL KING Lionel Richie opens up about gruelling life on the road as he kicks off his first UK tour in a decade Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) HE is one of the most enduring names in music and, at 75, is still gaining new fans. As he kicked off his first UK tour in a decade, it is clear things are different for Lionel Richie these days, with his beloved red wine switched for electrolyte-filled water to keep him on top form on the road. Sign up for the Entertainment newsletter Sign up 7 Lionel Richie is embarking on his first UK tour in a decade Credit: Getty 7 Lionel is good friends with King Charles and has invited him to a show Credit: PA 7 Lionel in 1979 performing with The Commodores Credit: Rex Features And as Bizarre's Jack joined him in his dressing room ahead of his first show in Belfast on Saturday night, Lionel issued an invitation for his mate King Charles to come and sing with him. He said: 'If The King wants to sing Easy like Sunday Morning with me, that's fantastic. It would be a hoot.' But despite his royal connections, Lionel admitted you might still find him in a British boozer. He said: 'I have my pub master Bernie. "He will take me to the latest and the greatest of the pubs.' And would he indulge in some of our great British pub snacks, like a bag of pork scratchings? 'Have I ever had some weird British food? Yes,' Lionel says with a laugh 'I had black pudding, I did not like it. "I was warming up on it for a moment and then they told me what it was and, psychologically, I just went off the rails. 'There will be no black pudding on tour for sure.' Charles always makes the same joke, says Lionel Ritchie as he opens up about friendship with King Opening up about going back on the road, Lionel explained: 'It's called play period. 'It's an excuse to leave the house and act silly all over again, otherwise life becomes boring. 'Going on tour is the best ever as my fans put on a show better than I can. "When I look out into the audience, I see all the afro wigs and moustaches . . . and that is just the girls. 'It is Lionel in the Seventies, Eighties, Nineties and Noughties — they put me all together in these various outfits. "It is amazing and fun to watch.' Now almost six decades into his career, Lionel travels with a small team including a physical therapist. Lionel said: 'You have to be in shape. "You might think that it's easy to walk on that stage but try two hours of that, plus running, plus singing. "You do that multiple times, well you better be in good condition. It is set up to wipe you out. 'PROTECT YOUR VOCALS' 'I have been doing it for so long now, it's like second nature. But don't take it for granted.' Another secret weapon in his touring armour is bringing along his own pillow on tour. He explained: 'I elevate the bed at an angle as that keeps the acid reflux at bay. "The most important part you are trying to protect is your vocals. 'Eating late is also a disaster because trying to sleep and digest food at the same time calls for a rough voice.' But while he has a team with him at all times, Lionel isn't dishing out a list of diva demands. Nor is he sitting in hair and make-up for hours. 7 Lionel Richie at the 7th Annual American Cinema Awards in 1990 Credit: Getty 7 Lionel in the 80s when he released single 'Hello' Credit: Getty He said: 'The one thing I can't do is a lot of hair and make- up. I don't know how people can do it.' 'I sweat a lot and on the first two songs, whatever make-up I had on, or whatever hair style I had, leaves immediately. "And I don't really need make-up by that point. 'I am on stage and enjoying it. "The last thing I would want is my mascara to be running. That is not a good look.' Even a pre-gig tipple is out of the question. Lionel laughed: 'Alcohol before a show? No, no, we don't do that. 'Back in The Commodores days you could do anything. You're bulletproof. 'But now, alcohol? No. Just get me out on stage with as much water and things to get the electrolytes going and that is it. 'I don't even know how we survived the Seventies and Eighties. It was fun though.' 7 Lionel and The Sun's Jack Hardwick Credit: Supplied Lionel added: 'Ten years ago I used to love red wine and I tried to let that be my potion to bring me down. "That phased out of my whole existence as purple teeth by the end of the tour was not going to be the way I wanted to go. 'I get a great bite to eat, lots of water and just wait for yourself to come down. 'Though I must admit, a good massage is needed. You need to just let your body come down. 'The worst thing to do is to try and jump into bed and think you are going to go to sleep. "You twitch for about four hours as your adrenaline is too high.' As we chatted in his dressing room, the rolling news channel on his TV showed King Charles, and conversation turned to His Majesty. Despite the invitation for a singalong, Lionel admitted: 'Listen, this guy is so busy. 'He is probably going to be the first royal to travel as much as you can imagine. 'I can see him moving around quite a bit but is he going to pop into the show and surprise me? You never know. 'Now Camilla, that would be possible. "She is a hoot in the kindest of respects. She is so funny and she has such a good sense of humour. "They both do. I love her sense of humour." We'd pay seriously good money to see that. 7 Lionel Richie performing at the Coronation Concert at Windsor Castle Credit: Getty Set list Overture Hello Running With The Night Easy - My Love Penny Lover Sela Stuck On You Sail On You Are Brick House Three Times A Lady Fancy Dancer Sweet Love Lady You Bring Me Up Truly Endless Love Destiny Dancing On The Ceiling Still Say You, Say Me We Are The World All Night Long Tour dates June 4 - Glasgow - OVO Hydro June 6 - London - The O2 June 8 Sheffield - Utillta Arena June 9 - Birmingham - Utillita Arena June 12 - Manchester - Co-Op Live June 13 - Manchester - Co-Op Live June 15 - London - The O2 Unlock even more award-winning articles as The Sun launches brand new membership programme - Sun Club.
