Red Deer overdose prevention site set to close after judge rules against extending injunction
The overdose prevention site in Red Deer will be closing at the end of the month, following a decision by a judge released Wednesday.
Justice C.A. Rickards of Court of King's Bench denied a request by Aaron Brown, a man with opioid use disorder, to keep the OPS open beyond March 31.
In January, a different judge granted an interim injunction to continue being open around the clock until the end of March. The government was planning to phase out the site and had already cut operating hours to 12 hours a day. Brown argued that the OPS closure would violate his Charter rights.
The judge said in his decision that while Brown had visited the site four times between October and January, he has continued to use drugs three times a day, and said he "cannot conclude that there is a real probability that Brown will suffer unavoidable irreparable harm if OPS closes."
His lawyer Avnish Nanda has filed an appeal of the judge's ruling that will be heard on April 16. The full hearing on the OPS closure is scheduled for June.
"We're hopeful that on appeal a court will fully examine what is at issue here, what's being requested and rule that it's reasonable to maintain the status quo for an additional 12 weeks," Nanda said Thursday.
"We weren't asking for an injunction for years. We were asking for an injunction for until June 26th of this year when the full hearing will be had."
The OPS has been operating in a trailer outside the Safe Harbour Society's homeless shelter in downtown Red Deer since 2018. Alberta Health Services took over operations from the non-profit group Turning Point in 2023.
Red Deer city council passed a motion in February 2024 asking the province to shut down the site after a full-day public hearing.
The majority of presenters told councillors they wanted the OPS to stay open.
Site closing
The Alberta government announced in September that it was cutting funding to the OPS and closing the site at the end of March.
Drug users will instead be getting access to a team of paramedics and nurses who will be in the immediate area to reverse overdoses and a new mobile addiction medicine clinic.
Recovery coaches are working inside the Safe Harbour Shelter to help people access services. The province is also funding more recovery beds.
Mental Health and Addiction Minister Dan Williams said he isn't waiting for the outcome of Brown's appeal.
"I will be stopping the drug consumption services in Red Deer starting next month," he said.
NDP MLA Janet Eremenko, the Opposition critic for mental health and addiction, said she was disappointed to hear the site will be closed as of April 1.
She said the OPS can be the first step to recovery by saving users from death if they ingest poisoned drugs.
"They could have kept it open for another 15 weeks until we could actually hear the real tooth in the argument for why the OPS should stay open," Eremenko said.
"So clearly the minister made that decision a long time ago that the OPS was going to close come hell or high water."
Lawyer Nanda says Brown is disappointed by Wednesday's decision.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Observer
7 days ago
- National Observer
Ottawa's wildfire aid to First Nations delayed and inadequate, NDP leaders say
As wildfires rage across Manitoba and Saskatchewan, displacing over 26,000 people — many from northern and First Nations communities — leaders say Ottawa's response has been both delayed and inadequate. The discussion reached a peak as NDP MP for Winnipeg Centre, Leah Gazan led an emergency debate on Tuesday in the House of Commons. Gazan accused the federal government of failing to protect Indigenous evacuees and violating their Charter and treaty rights. 'The federal government is obligated to uphold the dignity and well-being of First Nations that are affected by these wildfires,' she said. Gazan said First Nations leaders had told her evacuees — including children, Elders, and those with medical needs — were housed in crowded and poorly equipped facilities, creating risky and unstable situations. Families were split up and people were left without enough help in unfamiliar environments. Delays in evacuation efforts were especially severe in Mathias Colomb First Nation, where residents were flown out by helicopter, 'six people at a time when their airstrip was closed.' 'The helicopters are too slow and too small. We need the Canadian Armed Forces to step in now. Every hour we wait puts lives at risk,' said Gordie Bear, chief of Mathias Colomb Cree Nation in a press release on May 30. 'Our community is in immediate danger. We have over 2,300 people stranded with no road access and no way out by plane.' 'The federal government is obligated to uphold the dignity and well-being of First Nations that are affected by these wildfires,' said Leah Gazan, NDP MP for Winnipeg Centre. Minister of Emergency Management and Community Resilience, Eleanor Olszewski defended the response, calling it 'one of the fastest federal responses in recent memory.' Olszewski said the military was deployed immediately after the province asked for help. 'Our government acted swiftly when called upon,' Olszewski said. She said evacuations in remote areas took longer because 'when the landing strip could not accommodate larger planes, we had to source smaller ones, and so the evacuation was necessarily slower.' Gazan said that the current crisis is reflective of federal inaction during extreme weather events. She pointed to the 2011 floods in Lake St. Martin First Nation, when thousands were displaced for years and many could not return home for more than a decade. The long-term displacement led to mental health issues, family separation, and exploitation — especially among women and girls. She is concerned that the fire season arriving earlier, lasting longer and being harder to manage is 'the new normal.' She called for a national wildfire fighting force and a Youth Climate Court to help Canada respond to extreme weather and support climate resilience. Other MPs supported Gazan's concerns. Lori Idlout, NDP MP for Nunavut, said climate change is making disasters like these wildfires more frequent and severe, overwhelming local and provincial responders and raising concerns about housing, space and healthcare for those fleeing the fires. She said the debate is especially important for Nunavut, since many residents rely on Winnipeg for medical care and are now competing for resources with thousands of wildfire evacuees. 'My constituents must not fall through the cracks as Winnipeg sees a huge influx of people who require healthcare,' she said. Mandy Gull-Masty, Minister of Indigenous Services Canada, said during the debate the department gives advance payments so communities can act quickly during emergencies without waiting to be paid back. The Emergency Management Assistance Program covers eligible wildfire costs, including evacuation support and culturally sensitive services like mental health care, traditional food, language interpretation and child care. Gull-Masty also pointed to the FireSmart program, which supports fire training, fuel management and vegetation clearing projects in First Nations communities. 'Preparedness is key. These supports are about building strength before disaster strikes, so that communities can mitigate the impact to the greatest extent possible. It's not only to ensure that they have the ability to respond, but that they also have the capacity to recover and thrive,' she said. Wildfire activity remains high across Manitoba and Saskatchewan, with dry conditions and lightning sparking new blazes. Manitoba Wildfire Service reported more than 100 active fires as of June 3.
National Observer
7 days ago
- National Observer
NDP criticizes Ottawa's wildfire aid to First Nations
As wildfires rage across Manitoba and Saskatchewan, displacing over 26,000 people — many from northern and First Nations communities — leaders say Ottawa's response has been both delayed and inadequate. The discussion reached a peak as NDP MP for Winnipeg Centre, Leah Gazan led an emergency debate on Tuesday in the House of Commons. Gazan accused the federal government of failing to protect Indigenous evacuees and violating their Charter and treaty rights. 'The federal government is obligated to uphold the dignity and well-being of First Nations that are affected by these wildfires,' she said. Gazan said First Nations leaders had told her evacuees — including children, Elders, and those with medical needs — were housed in crowded and poorly equipped facilities, creating risky and unstable situations. Families were split up and people were left without enough help in unfamiliar environments. Delays in evacuation efforts were especially severe in Mathias Colomb First Nation, where residents were flown out by helicopter, 'six people at a time when their airstrip was closed.' 'The helicopters are too slow and too small. We need the Canadian Armed Forces to step in now. Every hour we wait puts lives at risk,' said Gordie Bear, chief of Mathias Colomb Cree Nation in a press release on May 30. 'Our community is in immediate danger. We have over 2,300 people stranded with no road access and no way out by plane.' 'The federal government is obligated to uphold the dignity and well-being of First Nations that are affected by these wildfires,' said Leah Gazan, NDP MP for Winnipeg Centre. Minister of Emergency Management and Community Resilience, Eleanor Olszewski defended the response, calling it 'one of the fastest federal responses in recent memory.' Olszewski said the military was deployed immediately after the province asked for help. 'Our government acted swiftly when called upon,' Olszewski said. She said evacuations in remote areas took longer because 'when the landing strip could not accommodate larger planes, we had to source smaller ones, and so the evacuation was necessarily slower.' Gazan said that the current crisis is reflective of federal inaction during extreme weather events. She pointed to the 2011 floods in Lake St. Martin First Nation, when thousands were displaced for years and many could not return home for more than a decade. The long-term displacement led to mental health issues, family separation, and exploitation — especially among women and girls. She is concerned that the fire season arriving earlier, lasting longer and being harder to manage is 'the new normal.' She called for a national wildfire fighting force and a Youth Climate Court to help Canada respond to extreme weather and support climate resilience. Other MPs supported Gazan's concerns. Lori Idlout, NDP MP for Nunavut, said climate change is making disasters like these wildfires more frequent and severe, overwhelming local and provincial responders and raising concerns about housing, space and healthcare for those fleeing the fires. She said the debate is especially important for Nunavut, since many residents rely on Winnipeg for medical care and are now competing for resources with thousands of wildfire evacuees. 'My constituents must not fall through the cracks as Winnipeg sees a huge influx of people who require healthcare,' she said. Mandy Gull-Masty, Minister of Indigenous Services Canada, said during the debate the department gives advance payments so communities can act quickly during emergencies without waiting to be paid back. The Emergency Management Assistance Program covers eligible wildfire costs, including evacuation support and culturally sensitive services like mental health care, traditional food, language interpretation and child care. Gull-Masty also pointed to the FireSmart program, which supports fire training, fuel management and vegetation clearing projects in First Nations communities. 'Preparedness is key. These supports are about building strength before disaster strikes, so that communities can mitigate the impact to the greatest extent possible. It's not only to ensure that they have the ability to respond, but that they also have the capacity to recover and thrive,' she said. Wildfire activity remains high across Manitoba and Saskatchewan, with dry conditions and lightning sparking new blazes. Manitoba Wildfire Service reported more than 100 active fires as of June 3.
Vancouver Sun
7 days ago
- Vancouver Sun
B.C. federal inmate's proposed class-action over COVID lockdowns certified by judge
A proposed class-action lawsuit filed against the federal government for confining prison inmates in their cells for 20 hours a day during the COVID-19 pandemic has been certified by a B.C. Supreme Court judge. Representative plaintiff Dean Christopher Roberts alleges medical isolation in the country's prisons beginning in March 2020 meant a large number of prisoners were subjected to 'inhumane rights restrictions,' a form of lockdown that amounted to solitary confinement, according to the judgment. The prisoners were 'confined to their cells for up to 22 hours a day and denied any meaningful human interaction for an extended period of time,' wrote Justice Michael Tammen. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. The lawsuit would include anyone imprisoned in a Correctional Services of Canada prison during a declared COVID-19 outbreak at the institution after March 11, 2020, it said. To be eligible, they will have had to have been confined to their cells for 20 or more hours a day and deprived of the opportunity to interact with others for less than two hours a day for 15 or more consecutive days, it said. The lawsuit alleges negligence and breaches of Charter-protected rights guaranteed by sections 7 and 12 of the Charter, which protect life, liberty and security of person, and ban cruel and unusual punishment. Other court decisions have recognized solitary confinement causes harm, that administrative segregation is a form of solitary confinement, that solitary confinement is the practice of confining an prisoner in a cell for 22 hours a day and failing to provide daily meaningful contact with other people, the judge said, citing the plaintiffs' arguments. The plaintiff cited a number of cases from Ontario and B.C. in 2020 and 2021 that relied on similar allegations of negligence and Charter breaches. The federal attorney general opposed certification, arguing administrative segregation for medical reasons is 'something entirely different' from solitary confinement, because it's 'both medically necessary and informed by medical advice,' according to Tammen's decision. Administrative segregation allows prisons to isolate an prisoner to ensure the safety of staff, visitors and inmates and to maintain security of the prisons and it is not a punishment or sanction, according to the Correctional Service website. It also said the proposed lawsuit is overly broad and lacks clarity, and Roberts is not a suitable representative plaintiff. But Tammen ruled the lawsuit could proceed. He said the federal government raised several points that could cause the lawsuit to fail at trial, including its argument that medical isolation is different from other forms of separate confinement. He said a trial judge may decide the prisons' response to the 'unprecedented and unexpected' pandemic and the type of isolation it implemented was medically necessary, and the lawsuit would fail. But he said that has to be decided at trial, 'not at this preliminary stage.' At the beginning of the COVID outbreak, Roberts was imprisoned at the Mission Institution, a medium-security prison. From April 2 to 7, 2020, the prison was in a lockdown and inmates were confined to cells around the clock. When Roberts returned from Mission hospital on April 11, 2020, where he was treated for five days for COVID, he said inmates were only let out of their cells for 20 minutes a day to shower, to use the phone and to have their cells cleaned, according to the decision. And even though Mission prison was declared COVID free by mid-May 2020, significant restrictions with limited time allowed out of cells continued until mid-July 2020, it said. Tammen said there is a 'considerable body of evidence about periods of medical isolation for non-symptomatic inmates at various institutions' over three years, with many saying they were confined to their cell for up to 23 hours a day with no meaningful social interaction and limited time for showering or phone calls. The federal government does not dispute this but said the prolonged periods of isolation were medically mandated. It said punitive damages aren't warranted but the judge said the notice of claim includes details that could support punitive damages because courts have condemned the practice of subjecting inmates to prolonged periods of separate confinement. None of the allegations have been proven in court. The inmates' first lawsuit was filed in 2020 and was amended several times until it was moved to the certification phase in October 2024. Roberts was sentenced to a life imprisonment after being convicted by a jury in 1995 for the 1994 strangling of his wife and one twin 14-month-old son, the smothering of the other twin, and for attempting to kill his adopted three-year-old, who was left asleep in the burning house before being rescued and surviving. He always maintained his innocence, claiming he was the victim of the then-new controversial RCMP investigative undercover sting technique called Mr. Big. In 2021, he was granted the right to ask for ministerial review of his case to seek updated DNA testing he said was needed to prove his innocence.
