
Percentage of Albertans Wanting to Secede Nearly Matches Quebec's: Poll
One in four Albertans would vote 'yes' in a referendum on leaving Canada, just 3 percentage points behind Quebecers' support for separation, a new poll suggests.
A quarter of Albertans would support separation from Canada, nearly matching the 28 percent of Quebec residents who would favour their province becoming its own country, according to a
Saskatchewan ranks third in support for a potential independence referendum, with 20 percent of residents saying they would vote 'yes.' British Columbia is fourth at 9 percent, while Manitoba follows with 8 percent.
Meanwhile, the Atlantic provinces and Ontario show lower support, with 7 percent and 6 percent, respectively.
Alberta also leads in support for joining the United States, with 22 percent of residents saying they would vote 'yes' in a referendum on the issue. Saskatchewan follows at 17 percent, and Manitoba at 13 percent.
In both Quebec and British Columbia, 11 percent of residents would support joining the United States, while support in Ontario and the Atlantic provinces is below 10 percent.
Related Stories
4/3/2025
4/3/2025
Nationally, 15 percent of Canadians support their respective province leaving the country, while 11 percent favour joining the United States. However, the 'vast majority' of Canadians would vote no on both issues, according to the poll.
If the Liberals win the federal election, support for an independence referendum would rise in all provinces, the poll suggests. Saskatchewan would see the largest increase, up 10 percentage points to 33 percent. British Columbia would follow with an 8-point rise to 17 percent, while Ontario would see a 7-point increase.
In Alberta and Quebec, a Liberal win would result in a five and two percentage point increase in support for independence, respectively
A Liberal victory would also result in a slight increase in support for joining the United States in all provinces except Quebec, where support would remain unchanged at 11 percent regardless of which party forms the next government.
By political affiliation, as expected, those supporting the separatist Bloc Québécois have the highest support for separation, with 58 percent saying they would vote 'yes' in an independence referendum. The Conservatives follow at 22 percent, with support rising to 39 percent if the Liberals win.
National Unity
Last week, Reform Party founder Preston Manning suggested in a
'Large numbers of Westerners simply will not stand for another four years of Liberal government, no matter who leads it,' Manning wrote on April 2, saying that one of the reasons for Western separation is Ottawa's 'failure' to address the concerns of Western Canadians.
On the campaign trail, both Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre and Liberal Leader Mark Carney have emphasized the importance of a united Canada in the face of U.S. trade tensions.
When asked about Manning's comments last week, Poilievre
'I am part of a government that governs for all of the country, and very much for the West,' Carney said on April 4, noting that he grew up in Edmonton.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has said she isn't advocating for separation, but is aware of efforts by some to hold referendums. She has said that if the next government does not address Alberta's concerns, which she
When asked at an unrelated April 7
'I'd be blind if I didn't see what is occurring in the media, on social media,' Smith said. 'I have to acknowledge that there's a lot of unhappiness on the part of Albertans in the way we've been treated by the Liberal government for the past 10 years.'
The province takes issue with many of Ottawa's policies, such as the Impact Assessment Act and the oil and gas emissions cap, arguing they overstep provincial jurisdiction and hinder the province
'
s oil and gas industry. Ottawa has maintained it has the authority to address issues of national concern such as climate change.
In one of her latest moves to assert provincial autonomy, Smith recently
Carney has said he's committed to making the energy sector more competitive, and that Canada needs more pipelines built 'so that we can displace imports of foreign oil.' He has said he'll keep the oil and gas emissions cap and the Impact Assessment Act, but that he would remove redundancies in regulatory reviews.
'We need to do things that had not been imagined or had not been thought possible at a speed we haven't seen before, and that's the nature of the time,' Carney said while visiting Edmonton on March 20, saying his government would build energy corridors to boost the sector.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Politico
33 minutes ago
- Politico
Notes for Trump
Presented by The Canadian Medical Association Send tips | Subscribe here | Email Canada Playbook | Follow Politico Canada Happy Monday. Thanks for reading Canada Playbook. Let's get into it. → JUSTIN TRUDEAU's prep note for a DONALD TRUMP call in February. → Three things we're watching this week: tariffs, streamers and the House. → Liberal MP SUKH DHALIWAL on the PM's NARENDRA MODI invite to the G7. THE FIRST THING SPENDING BOOST — Prime Minister MARK CARNEY is scheduled to make a defense and security announcement in Toronto at 10 a.m. He'll tour a military facility and speak with reporters at 1 p.m. — Sources tell The Globe and Mail's STEVE CHASE that Carney will unveil a plan that hits NATO's defense spending benchmark in the current fiscal year. Trade war TRUDEAU-TRUMP CALL — Ten days before Trump unleashed tariffs on Canadian-made goods in early March, Trudeau was on the horn with the U.S. president. A briefing note prepared for the PM in advance of the Feb. 22 call reveals his two major priorities: the war in Ukraine, which was two days away from its third anniversary, and those pesky, painful, looming tariffs. → Priority No. 1: 'Reiterate importance of engagement as part of G7 and the upcoming [leaders' video teleconference] and support for Ukraine and for the principle of a just and sustainable peace.' → Priority No. 2: 'Express disappointment with the President's decision to impose tariffs on Canada and reiterate the Government of Canada's obligation to defend the interests of Canadians.' — Good cop: The PM's briefers counseled him on saying nice things. 'In your first weeks in office, you have moved quickly on key issues, including economic security, energy dominance, and border security,' the note read, adding these were 'shared priorities.' And on Ukraine: 'I know the G7 appreciates your commitment to ending this war,' read a suggested talking point that also pressed the imperative of a sovereign Ukraine with a seat at the negotiating table. 'A bad peace will reverberate around the world,' read another line. — American firearms: The briefers tucked in a section on the increasing number of guns crossing the border into Canada. 'Canadian police have long warned that illegal U.S. firearms are driving gun-related crime in this country,' read the note. Trudeau and Trump both published readouts following the conversation. Neither mentioned firearms coming up in the conversation. — Trade 101: The memo advised Trudeau on how to cautiously rebut Trump's persistent claim that an American trade deficit with Canada is a 'subsidy.' The suggested talking points sound at times like an exasperated undergrad economics prof: 'The U.S. does not give anything for free by trading with Canada,' the memo said. 'It willingly purchases and obtains products it needs in return.' — Redacted entirely: A short section with advice on how to respond to Trump on defense spending. THREE THINGS WE'RE WATCHING COUNTER-TARIFF OR NAH — That is the question Prime Minister MARK CARNEY is mulling as he faces pressure to respond to Trump's latest hit to Canada's economy. Last week, the U.S. doubled tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminum to 50 percent. Business and labor leaders were quick to call for retaliation, alongside Ontario Premier DOUG FORD — who accused the PM of falling short in his response to Trump. — Patience wearing thin: This week, they're expecting answers. Canadian Steel Producers Association President CATHERINE COBDEN described her recent discussions with Cabinet ministers and senior officials on Parliament Hill as 'intense' and 'frank.' 'The CSPA expects to see concrete action taken as early as next week and we offer our full support to Canadian policymakers to ensure that action comes forward as soon as possible,' Cobden said in a statement Friday. Industry Minister MÉLANIE JOLY told The Globe and Mail a crackdown on the dumping of cheap foreign steel into Canada is coming, addressing concerns on that file from the Trump administration. — Turning up the heat: Ford has no plans to bring down the temperature himself, as Carney and Trump reportedly negotiate a cross-border deal. 'I have the utmost respect for the prime minister and his job. He's negotiating, but I have to protect the people of Ontario,' he told reporters in Toronto Friday. — On the horn: Ford says he speaks with Carney every day, and has been very clear with his message to the PM: 'The ideal situation is to get a deal, and if that deal does not happen in the next few days, then we have to slap another 25 percent tariff on top of the existing 25 percent tariff on our aluminum and steel,' Ford said. DAY IN COURT — Foreign streaming giants are pushing back against Ottawa's controversial Online Streaming Act. This week, they'll take their fight to the Federal Court of Appeal in Toronto. Regulations under the law have ordered foreign streaming companies to fund local news and other Canadian content through a portion of their Canadian revenue. — Major players: Amazon, Apple and Spotify have taken legal action to avoid coughing up a cut of their Canadian earnings. The Motion Picture Association – Canada, which represents studios such as Netflix, Disney, Paramount, Sony, NBCUniversal and Warner Bros., filed their own legal challenge. Their cases have been consolidated into one and will be heard by a judge starting today. WENDY NOSS, MPA — Canada's president, previously called the tax 'a discriminatory measure that goes far beyond what Parliament intended.' — Trade irritant: Republican and Democratic lawmakers in Washington have raised concerns over the law, insisting it discriminates against U.S. companies. Trump administration officials are monitoring the issue, including the Office of the United States Trade Representative — which has pegged the law as a trade barrier. BUILD, BABY, BUILD — The PM wants his signature 'One Canadian Economy' bill passed by the time the House is scheduled to adjourn for the summer on June 20. But if that doesn't happen, he's prepared to sit into July. 'We're in a crisis,' Carney said Friday. 'We will do everything to get it passed before the summer. And if parliament needs to sit longer, it should sit longer.' — Fine print: The PM is finding out that the House of Commons doesn't often move as quickly as a boardroom. Carney's government had to backpedal from a campaign promise of cross-Canada free trade by Canada Day. During a technical briefing for the bill, government officials said the goal is now to remove as many internal trade barriers 'as possible' by July 1. PLAYBOOK'S ONE-ON-ONE SURPRISE INVITE — B.C. Liberal MP SUKH DHALIWAL woke up in a state of shock Friday morning. News had just broken that Indian Prime Minister NARENDRA MODI would attend the upcoming G7 leaders' summit in Kananaskis. — Piece of the economic puzzle: Carney argued it made 'sense' having India at the table after consulting with other G7 partners. 'India is the fifth-largest economy in the world, effectively the most populous country in the world,' and central to global supply chains, Carney told reporters Friday. — Complete about-face: The Modi invite marked a remarkable shift in foreign policy for the Liberal government. Only eight months ago, the Trudeau government expelled India's high commissioner and five envoys after the RCMP revealed evidence linking members of India's government to multiple homicides on Canadian soil. The RCMP also uncovered apparent evidence of Indian interference into Canada's democratic processes. 'My constituents are telling me it's the wrong move to invite Prime Minister Modi,' Dhaliwal said to Playbook. 'Canada is the country of rule of law, the country of justice, the champion of human rights.' — Constituents first: Dhaliwal represents the riding of Surrey Newton, where Sikh Khalistani activist HARDEEP SINGH NIJJAR was gunned down in June 2023 outside a gurdwara. He was a constituent of Dhaliwal's. Trudeau told the House of Commons in September 2023 that Canada had 'credible allegations' that agents acting on behalf of the Indian government were involved in Nijjar's death. The Indian government rejected the allegations as 'absurd' and 'motivated,' and alleged Canada was a supporter of Khalistani 'terrorists.' Dhaliwal was the first MP to visit the gurdwara after the shooting and has remained engaged ever since. — Feeling the heat: The MP's phone has been 'ringing like crazy.' He has lost track of all the emails from constituents. 'People are telling me that they are not very happy. They're worried about their safety,' he said. 'It's ordinary people on the ground. People who don't have any links to anything. Just ordinary citizens, coming into my office telling me, 'this is not the right thing to do.'' — Message to the PM: Dhaliwal expects to share his constituents' concerns with Carney in the coming days. His ask: 'Make sure that India fully cooperates in the investigation so justice can be served for the victims and their family.' — Another thing: 'Make sure moving forward there will be, absolutely zero, interference from India into our affairs here in Canada,' he said. MORNING MUST-CLICKS — U.S. Ambassador to Canada PETE HOEKSTRA says the U.S. will not dictate what the Canadian government must spend on defense, CP's DYLAN ROBERTSON writes. — The Hill Times' ABBAS RANA reports that PMO staffers are no longer allowed in Liberal national caucus meetings. First quote from Liberal MP HEDY FRY: 'It's a good idea.' — 'PIERRE POILIEVRE's numbers as preferred prime minister have plummeted,' NIK NANOS tells CTV News. 'Him losing his seat, him not being in the House of Commons, him not having the same type of profile as during the election has really hurt him. It will be interesting to see if he recovers from this.' — Top of POLITICO this morning: How Trump broke the politics of Medicaid — Military deploys to support northern Ontario wildfire evacuations, Global News reports. — CTV's JUDY TRINH reports a father living in Canada faces indefinite separation from his son with Trump's travel ban. THE ROOMS THAT MATTER — Liberals will gather for a Laurier Club donor garden party this evening at the Canadian War Museum. Prime Minister MARK CARNEY will be there. A pile of ministers are expected to join him, including JOËL LIGHTBOUND, CHRYSTIA FREELAND, MARJORIE MICHEL, RECHIE VALDEZ, DOMINIC LEBLANC, PATTY HAJDU, JULIE DABRUSIN, STEVEN MACKINNON, JOANNE THOMPSON, STEPHANIE MCLEAN, ELEANOR OLSZEWSKI, RANDEEP SARAI, DAVID MCGUINTY and STEVEN GUILBEAULT. — Alberta Premier DANIELLE SMITH will deliver a keynote address at the Calgary Region Hydrogen Hub grand opening. The Global Energy Show also kicks off in Calgary today. — Monday and Tuesday are opposition days in the House of Commons. PROZONE For Pro subscribers, our latest policy newsletter by MIKE BLANCHFIELD, NICK TAYLOR-VAISEY and MICKEY DJURIC: 'Crisis' trade law needed by summer. In other news for Pro readers: — The stealth Senate dealmaker who could deliver Trump's tax cuts. — House appropriators unveil Homeland Security funding bill. PLAYBOOKERS Birthdays: HBD to Green MP ELIZABETH MAY, Ontario Green Party Leader MIKE SCHREINER, Canadian Identity Minister STEVEN GUILBEAULT, TVO anchor STEVE PAIKIN, ARIEL POLLOCK of the U.S. Embassy and former Liberal MP JEAN R. RIOUX. HBD + 1 to CINDY CATURAO, press sec to AI Minister EVAN SOLOMON. Noted: PM Carney published Canada's G7 priorities ahead of the upcoming leaders' summit: 'protecting our communities and the world', 'building energy security and accelerating the digital transition' and 'securing the partnerships of the future.' Spotted in that release: 'catalyzing' (with a 'z'). — The Procedure and House Affairs Committee picks its chair Tuesday. These MPs are on the committee: → Liberals: CHRIS BITTLE, ÉLISABETH BRIÈRE, GREG FERGUS, ARIELLE KAYABAGA and TIM LOUIS. → Conservatives: BLAINE CALKINS, MICHAEL COOPER, GRANT JACKSON and TAKO VAN POPTA. → Bloc Québécois: CHRISTINE NORMANDIN. Spotted: Liberal MP VINCE GASPARRO and Toronto city councilor BRAD BRADFORD, breaking bread at Bistro on Avenue with rest owner CINDY STERN. Movers and shakers: JESSICA FULLERTON starts this week as a senior policy adviser to Finance Minister FRANÇOIS-PHILIPPE CHAMPAGNE … BELLA OROZCO-MADISON is planning to leave the PMO comms shop for a new gig with a former boss: Industry Minister MÉLANIE JOLY … GUILLAUME BERTRAND is now director of communications for Health Minister MARJORIE MICHEL. JULIAN OVENS joined the board of directors at Kenz Global Resources … MICHAEL SOLBERG joined the board at Carbon Removal Canada. Got a document to share? A birthday coming up? Send it all our way. TRIVIA Friday's answer: On June 6, 1813, American and British forces clashed at the Battle of Stoney Creek during the War of 1812. Props to PATRICK DION, PETER STUDER, ANDREW BALFOUR, MARC SHAW, DAVE COURNOYER, BARB WRIGHT, PAUL PARK, GREG MACEACHERN, ELIZABETH BURN, BOOTS TAYLOR-VAISEY, GARY ALLEN, CHRIS RANDS, WILL BULMER, SAAHIL JAFFER, CULLY ROBINSON, MAUREEN MACGILLIVRAY, DARREN MAJOR, JOHN PEPPER, JOHN DILLON, JOHN ALHO, ALEXANDER LANDRY, RALPH LEVENSTEIN, CAMERON RYAN, ROBERT MCDOUGALL, MALCOLM MCKAY, BRETT SZMUL, MARC LEBLANC, SHAUGHN MCARTHUR and GREG LYNDON. Props +1 to BARB WRIGHT. Today's question: According to a motion that passed the House of Commons last week, how many MPs will sit on standing committees chaired by Liberals during this session of Parliament? Send your answer to canadaplaybook@ Canada Playbook would not happen without: Canada Editor Sue Allan, editor Willa Plank and POLITICO's Grace Maalouf.


Hamilton Spectator
11 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
U.S. ambassador says Canadians facing device searches, detainment ‘not a pattern'
OTTAWA - The American ambassador to Canada is pushing back on Ottawa's travel advice, saying his country doesn't search phones at the border and arguing some Americans travelling here are having a tough time. 'We welcome Canadians to come in and invest, to spend their hard-earned Canadian dollars at U.S. businesses,' U.S. Ambassador Pete Hoekstra told The Canadian Press in an interview Friday. 'If a Canadian has had a disappointing experience coming into the United States, I'm not denying that it happened, but I'm saying it's an isolated event and it is not a pattern.' In April, Ottawa updated its advice to Canadians travelling to the United States to warn them about the possibility they might be detained if denied entry. 'Expect scrutiny at ports of entry, including of electronic devices,' reads the new guidance. There have been reports of Canadians facing intensified scrutiny at the border, having phones searched and, in some cases, being detained. Hoekstra insisted concerns about device searches are not grounded in reality. 'Coming to the U.S., that's a decision for the Canadians to make. Searching devices and all of that is not a well-founded fear. We don't do that. America is a welcoming place,' he said. He said some Americans have expressed similar concerns about Canada. 'I've heard that from Americans coming into Canada as well, OK? Saying, 'You know, we've not received a warm reception when we've gotten to Canadian customs,'' he said. When asked if these reports from American travellers involve arbitrary phone searches and lengthy detainment, Hoekstra said there are consular cases of Americans complaining to the embassy about the Canada Border Services Agency. 'We've said, 'OK this may have been an isolated event. There may have been a Canadian border person who was having a bad day, and thought they'd take it out on, you know, somebody across the border,'' he said. In a statement, the CBSA said its officers follow a code of conduct and the federal ethics code that both require them to treat everyone equally, and the agency investigates any complaints of mistreatment. 'Employees are expected to conduct themselves in a way that upholds the values of integrity, respect and professionalism at all times,' wrote spokeswoman Karine Martel. 'Treating people with respect, dignity and fairness is fundamental to our border services officers' relationship with the public and a key part of this is serving all travellers in a non-discriminatory way.' Hoekstra said travel to the U.S. is up to individuals. 'If you decide that you're not going to come down or whatever, that's your decision and you're missing an opportunity. There are great things to see in America,' Hoekstra said. He also noted the case of CNN journalist Christiane Amanpour, who recently said she prepared to visit the U.S. last month as if she was 'going to North Korea' — with a 'burner phone' that didn't carry any personal information — only to experience a warm welcome. 'It's like, (let's) get past the rhetoric and let's look at the real experiences that people are having here,' Hoekstra said. Airlines have been cutting flights between Canada and the U.S. due to a slump in demand, and Flight Centre Travel Group Canada reported a nearly 40 per cent drop in flights between the two countries year-over-year in February. A survey in early May conducted by Leger Marketing for the Association for Canadian Studies found 52 per cent of respondents feel that 'it is no longer safe for all Canadians travelling to the United States,' with 29 per cent disagreeing and 19 per cent saying they were unsure. Roughly the same proportion said they personally feel unwelcome in the U.S. LGBTQ+ groups have opted against attending World Pride events in Washington and United Nations events in New York, citing scrutiny at the border as the Trump administration scales back protections for transgender and nonbinary people. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 7, 2025.
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
North missed £140bn of transport investment over last government, research finds
The North of England would have received an extra £140 billion in transport investment under the previous government if funding levels had been the same as in London, research has claimed. Independent analysis by think tank the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR) looked at Treasury figures between 2009/10 and 2022/23, during which time the Conservatives were in power. It reached the figure, which it said was enough to build seven Elizabeth Lines, by considering the amount of spending per person across the different English regions over that period. While England as a whole saw £592 spent per person each year, London received double that amount with £1,183 spent per person, the IPPR said. The entire North region saw £486 spent per person, with the North East and North West seeing £430 and £540 spent per person respectively. This amounted to £140 billion of missed investment for the North, more than the entire £83 billion estimate of capital spending on transport in the region since 1999/2000, according to the analysis. The region with the lowest amount of investment over the period was the East Midlands with just £355 spent per person. Among the most divisive transport investment projects for the previous government was the HS2 rail project, which was axed north of Birmingham in October 2023. Then-prime minister Rishi Sunak pledged to 'reinvest every single penny, £36 billion, in hundreds of new transport projects in the North and the Midlands', including improvements to road, rail and bus schemes. Earlier this week, Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced a £15.6 billion package for mayoral authorities to use on public transport projects across the North and Midlands ahead of the spending review. It is expected to include funding to extend the metros in Tyne and Wear, Greater Manchester and the West Midlands, along with a renewed tram network in South Yorkshire and a new mass transit system in West Yorkshire. Marcus Johns, senior research fellow at IPPR North, said: 'Today's figures are concrete proof that promises made to the North over the last decade were hollow. It was a decade of deceit. 'We are 124 years on from the end of Queen Victoria's reign, yet the North is still running on infrastructure built during her rein – while our transport chasm widens. 'This isn't London bashing – Londoners absolutely deserve investment. But £1,182 per person for London and £486 for northerners? The numbers don't lie – this isn't right. 'This Government have begun to restore fairness with their big bet on transport cash for city leaders. 'They should continue on this journey to close this investment gap in the upcoming spending review and decades ahead.' Former Treasury minister Lord Jim O'Neill said: 'Good governance requires the guts to take a long-term approach, not just quick fixes. So the Chancellor is right in her focus on the UK's long-standing supply-side weaknesses – namely our woeful productivity and weak private and public investment. 'Backing major infrastructure is the right call, and this spending review is the right time for the Chancellor to place a big bet on northern growth and begin to close this investment chasm. 'But it's going to take more than commitments alone – she'll need to set out a transparent framework for delivery.'