Lenovo wins appeal in UK fight with Ericsson over interim patent licence
LONDON, Feb 28 (Reuters) - Lenovo (0992.HK), opens new tab on Friday won an appeal in Britain in its attempt to get an interim licence to use Ericsson's (ERICb.ST), opens new tab patents, in the latest ruling in the companies' global licensing dispute over 5G wireless technology.
Lenovo sued Ericsson at London's High Court in 2023, one of several cases brought by Lenovo or Ericsson around the world which has seen the companies trade lawsuits in Brazil, Colombia and the United States.
The dispute centres on the fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms for a licence to use Lenovo and Ericsson's patents. Disputes over FRAND licensing have led to global legal battles in the telecom industry.
In London, Lenovo sought a declaration that a willing licensor would agree to a short-term licence pending the final determination of FRAND terms.
Its application was refused last year, but the Court of Appeal overturned that decision on Friday.
Judge Richard Arnold said in a written ruling that "a willing licensor in the position of Ericsson would enter into an interim licence with Lenovo", adding that he hoped Ericsson would now choose to do so.
Lenovo's Chief Legal Officer Laura Quatela said the ruling "not only confirms that Lenovo is a willing licensee but strengthens and reaffirms our commitment to advocating for transparency and fairness in global FRAND licensing".
Ericsson did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
8 minutes ago
- Reuters
Exclusive: Walmart to close Sam's Club fulfillment center in Texas, affecting hundreds of employees
NEW YORK, June 26 (Reuters) - Walmart (WMT.N), opens new tab said on Thursday it is closing a fulfillment center that services online orders for its warehouse club chain Sam's Club in Fort Worth, Texas, and sources familiar with the matter said the move could result in job losses. Walmart confirmed the closure to Reuters but said it could not estimate the number of possible job losses until employees make their decisions on relocation. "We're continuously evolving our fulfillment network to improve service for our customers and members as their needs change," the retailer said in a statement. "We are relocating operations ... to other facilities within our fulfillment network," it added. Volumes that were handled at the fulfillment center known as DFW4 will be relocated to a high-tech fulfillment center in Lancaster, Texas, and three other Dallas-area facilities, a spokesperson said. Walmart has significantly ramped up investments in its e-commerce operations to accelerate delivery times and better compete with (AMZN.O), opens new tab. In the first quarter, these efforts paid off as the retailer reported its first-ever profit from its online business. Sales at Sam's Club - Walmart's membership-based warehouse chain - surged 27% during the same period. The company also noted that more than 50% of its members now use digital transactions in some form with Sam's Club. The DFW4 facility's relocation will be completed by summer, the spokesperson said, adding that the retailer has roles for all affected people, if they choose to continue with Walmart. Sources familiar with the DFW4 facility, including one who applied for a position there in February, said the center employed hundreds of workers. The hourly pay for a freight handler position at the facility showed a wage range between $21.60 and $25.10 per hour, according to Walmart's career portal. The retailer said it would help employees obtain jobs at surrounding Walmart facilities, including stores. It said it will also offer a $7,500 transfer bonus and relocation benefits to those who choose to move to any of its Walmart high-tech fulfillment centers in the country.
Reuters
18 minutes ago
- Reuters
Senegal's revised budget sees slightly higher fiscal deficit
DAKAR, June 26 (Reuters) - Senegal's 2025 revised budget forecasts a fiscal deficit of 7.82% of gross domestic product, up from an initial projection of 7.08%, according to a draft document seen by Reuters on Thursday.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Spanish court suspends fines for two airlines over cabin bag fees
MADRID, June 26 (Reuters) - A Spanish court on Thursday ordered a temporary halt to a fine slapped by the government on two budget airlines, including Ryanair (RYA.I), opens new tab, for practices such as charging for larger cabin bags, which according to the consumer ministry violated customer rights. The airlines have appealed the decision, and the court said it was impossible to get to the bottom of the issue at the moment, and paying the fine while it is being challenged in court would financially strain the companies. The injunction order effectively maintains the airlines' policies until a final decision is reached, and represents a first victory for the airlines. Ryanair and Norwegian Air ( opens new tab logged the appeal after they were fined 109.6 million euros ($128.40 million) last year, saying they believe the fine has no basis. Madrid's administrative court ordered both airlines to issue bank guarantees worth 111.8 million euros, equivalent to the sanctions plus interest, while the suspension is in place, it said in a statement. Industry group ALA praised the court's decision and claimed that the fines have no basis. It argued the fines "limit customers' ability to choose, and distort (the European Union's) common market". It said airlines would continue their charging policy until a final ruling is issued. Other airlines were also fined by Spain's consumer rights ministry last year. ALA said it hoped the court ruling will be later applied to all airlines. The ministry imposed a combined sanction of 179 million euros to all the airlines, which also included IAG's (ICAG.L), opens new tab low-cost unit Vueling, easyJet (EZJ.L), opens new tab, and Volotea. It argued they violated customers' rights when charging for larger carry-on bags, picking seats or boarding pass print-outs and not allowing cash payments at check-in desks or to buy items on board. ($1 = 0.8536 euros)
