Misinformation being ‘whipped up' over immigration cases
Misinformation is being 'whipped up' over asylum and immigration cases in relation to international human rights law, the Government's top legal adviser has said.
Lord Richard Hermer KC warned there is a 'real job on misinformation' around Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), the right to private and family life, in how it is applied to immigration cases in the UK.
Giving evidence to Parliament's Joint Committee on Human Rights on Wednesday, the Attorney General said: 'There is clearly a lot of information, misinformation, that is being whipped up in the context of asylum and immigration in particular, Article 8.
'Many of you will have heard banded around the idea that the courts have allowed a foreign national offender to stay here because his child will miss chicken McNuggets.
'That is doing the rounds.
'What is not doing the rounds is that that case went to the Upper Tribunal, who categorically rejected that as an Article 8 argument.
'They rejected the claim.'
He added: ' Courts are always going to make mistakes.
'That's why we have appeal courts, and that's what's happened here.'
The senior lawyer however said it was 'entirely right' for the Home Secretary to conduct a review on the use of Article 8 in migration cases in the UK.
Yvette Cooper confirmed on Monday the review will be particularly focusing on cases where ministers have disagreed with the conclusions reached in the courts.
Several deportation attempts have been halted by how the ECHR clause has been interpreted in UK law.
Lord Hermer said there has been a 'rise' in the number of decisions reported at First Tier immigration tribunals on the basis of Article 8 that are 'capable of suggesting that it is not being applied properly or appropriately'.
He told the committee: 'I want to make clear in all my comments about decisions of any court that I am categorically not criticising judges.
'I think there is real merit in checking that Article 8 is being properly understood and applied, because, as I've said, you can have a very, very robust but fair process in asylum and immigration context that is entirely compatible with Article 8.'
He added there needs to be checks on the 'right calibration' of casework decisions and also that the Government is being robust in appealing against decisions.
'Completely understand that people are concerned, so are we,' he said.
'We are determined to ensure that the immigration asylum system is as robust, efficient and fair as it can be, and you can do an awful lot that is compatible.
'All of this I should stress will be within Article 8.'
Elsewhere, the Attorney General was quizzed by MPs and peers on how he ensures the Government receives impartial advice on questions of human rights law after a 'long career at the bar'.
It comes after Lord Hermer faced questions about how his previous work, including representing former Sinn Fein leader Gerry Adams, could result in possible conflicts of interest in his Government work.
But he replied: 'Well, I think the short answer is that's by doing the best I can.'
'It's absolutely essential that governments of whatever colour receive objective, legal advice.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
11 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Huge £17.5MILLION boost for England's ‘saddest town' where high street is dubbed ‘death row'
ENGLAND'S "saddest town", where the high street has been dubbed 'death row', has been given a huge financial boost to improve it's town centre. Barrow-in-Furness was once a thriving port town, but fell into disrepair after jobs in the steel industry dried up, with most shops now boarded up. 5 Barrow has been described as 'England's saddest town' Credit: David Nelson 5 Many shops and buildings have been boarded up Credit: David Nelson 5 The town is set for a £200m revamp Credit: David Nelson The Office for National Statistics has classified it as one of England's most deprived towns, and a YouTuber who explores the UK's roughest areas described it as "England's saddest town." Police battle rampant drug gangs, and many buildings have been vandalised with graffiti and broken windows. Barrow resident James Riche previously told The Sun: 'Covid hit the town centre hard. "I call it death row because so many of the shops are shut and boarded up. We avoid it." However, the Cumbrian town's look is about to change. Barrow is home to the BAE Systems factory, which builds the UK's key military submarines - including the Trident nuclear programme. And because of its "importance to National Defence" has been granted a whopping £200 million from the government, which will be used to give the town a facelift over the next 10 years. This is on top of the £17.5 million of cash that was given to the town back in October 2021. The council said: 'Extra funding made available through Team Barrow means significantly more money is now available and this has the potential to deliver a more transformational regeneration of the town centre. 'The additional funding from Team Barrow would be on top of the money already committed by Government for the current town centre regeneration works. Inside Barrow in furness' heroin gangs and derelict streets 'In recognition of the town's strategic importance to national defence and security, the Government has agreed to invest more than £200m in Barrow over the next 10 years. 'Team Barrow will use this money – and seek to secure additional private and public sector investment – to help transform the town, delivering improvements across health, education, transport, the economy and community.' Plans for the regeneration are currently being finalised, but could include a new and improved theatre and events space, better food and drink offerings and leisure and market facilities. Simon Case, chair of Team Barrow, said: 'We have bold and ambitious plans for Barrow and this includes transforming the town centre. 'While these are very early stages, with a significant amount of work now required to develop these plans, we are clear in our vision that this must deliver more than simply high street regeneration. 'The Government's investment in Barrow presents us with a once-in-a-generation opportunity to address the challenges which face the town. "This means that in addition to delivering a town centre that has a strong retail, leisure and cultural offering, we will also prioritise improvements in housing, health and education.' Bae Systems is set to drastically expand its workforce, due to a surge in demand, meaning that the population in Barrow is set to swell from 60,000 to 90,000 over the next decade. Some of the newly employed workers and their families will be housed in a new 800 home waterfront development, called Marine Village. Case has likened the regeneration of Barrow to the town of Bourneville, which was built specifically to house Cadbury's factory workers and their farmers. He said: "With the pressure that we've got on getting the Astute boats finished, then Dreadnought and then Aukus, we started to focus on this two years ago for almost Bournville-like reasons.' "The town is a strategic national asset, although it hasn't always been viewed that way. 'Pretty quickly, we realised we needed Team Barrow to create an environment that would deliver that happy, skilled workforce we need to support the defence nuclear enterprise. "Thanks to Mr Putin and Mr Xi, the business case makes itself!' 5 The UK's military submarines are made in the BAE systems factory in Barrow Credit: David Nelson
The Sun
11 minutes ago
- The Sun
Huge £17.5MILLION boost for England's ‘saddest town' where high street is dubbed ‘death row'
ENGLAND'S "saddest town", where the high street has been dubbed 'death row', has been given a huge financial boost to improve it's town centre. Barrow-in-Furness was once a thriving port town, but fell into disrepair after jobs in the steel industry dried up, with most shops now boarded up. 5 5 5 The Office for National Statistics has classified it as one of England 's most deprived towns, and a YouTuber who explores the UK's roughest areas described it as " England 's saddest town." Police battle rampant drug gangs, and many buildings have been vandalised with graffiti and broken windows. Barrow resident James Riche previously told The Sun: 'Covid hit the town centre hard. "I call it death row because so many of the shops are shut and boarded up. We avoid it." However, the Cumbrian town's look is about to change. Barrow is home to the BAE Systems factory, which builds the UK's key military submarines - including the Trident nuclear programme. And because of its "importance to National Defence" has been granted a whopping £200 million from the government, which will be used to give the town a facelift over the next 10 years. This is on top of the £17.5 million of cash that was given to the town back in October 2021. The council said: 'Extra funding made available through Team Barrow means significantly more money is now available and this has the potential to deliver a more transformational regeneration of the town centre. 'The additional funding from Team Barrow would be on top of the money already committed by Government for the current town centre regeneration works. 'In recognition of the town's strategic importance to national defence and security, the Government has agreed to invest more than £200m in Barrow over the next 10 years. 'Team Barrow will use this money – and seek to secure additional private and public sector investment – to help transform the town, delivering improvements across health, education, transport, the economy and community.' Plans for the regeneration are currently being finalised, but could include a new and improved theatre and events space, better food and drink offerings and leisure and market facilities. Simon Case, chair of Team Barrow, said: 'We have bold and ambitious plans for Barrow and this includes transforming the town centre. 'While these are very early stages, with a significant amount of work now required to develop these plans, we are clear in our vision that this must deliver more than simply high street regeneration. 'The Government's investment in Barrow presents us with a once-in-a-generation opportunity to address the challenges which face the town. "This means that in addition to delivering a town centre that has a strong retail, leisure and cultural offering, we will also prioritise improvements in housing, health and education.' Bae Systems is set to drastically expand its workforce, due to a surge in demand, meaning that the population in Barrow is set to swell from 60,000 to 90,000 over the next decade. Some of the newly employed workers and their families will be housed in a new 800 home waterfront development, called Marine Village. Case has likened the regeneration of Barrow to the town of Bourneville, which was built specifically to house Cadbury 's factory workers and their farmers. He said: "With the pressure that we've got on getting the Astute boats finished, then Dreadnought and then Aukus, we started to focus on this two years ago for almost Bournville-like reasons.' "The town is a strategic national asset, although it hasn't always been viewed that way. 'Pretty quickly, we realised we needed Team Barrow to create an environment that would deliver that happy, skilled workforce we need to support the defence nuclear enterprise. "Thanks to Mr Putin and Mr Xi, the business case makes itself!' 5 5
The Courier
19 minutes ago
- The Courier
EXCLUSIVE: Dundee snubbed by home secretary as immigration changes hit university
An invitation to see the impact of tighter immigration rules on Dundee University has been rejected by home secretary Yvette Cooper. Arbroath and Broughty Ferry MP Stephen Gethins had invited Ms Cooper to the city after the UK Government announced a series of proposed changes to immigration rules. This includes further restrictions on fee-paying international students – seen as critical to the survival of universities – that many fear will lead to a further reduction in recruiting. Dundee University's financial crisis was prompted by a sudden reduction in foreign students. The institution's coffers faced a multi-millon hit last year due to a significant fall in international recruitment. Mr Gethins says he wanted to bring the home secretary to the City of Discovery to see 'first hand' the damage of the UK Government's so-called hostile environment. But the invite was snubbed by Ms Cooper and migration minister Seema Malhotra. The Courier also requested an interview with UK Scottish Secretary Ian Murray on the topic, but this was declined. In a written response to SNP MP Stephen Gethins, the minister said: 'This government continues to welcome and value the contribution that is made to our society, our economy and our higher education institutions by those overseas students who want to come to the UK. 'Our country has some of the best universities in the world, and we want the best minds in every country to aspire to complete their educations here. 'However, immigration must be properly controlled and managed, so that the system is fair and works for the UK.' Mr Gethins says he is disappointed his offer was not accepted. He told The Courier: 'The challenges that Dundee University is facing are driven by Westminster policies such as Brexit and the hostile environment with the Scottish Government expected to pick up the pieces. 'I wanted the home secretary to come to Dundee and see first hand not just the damage of those policies but see first hand an international university that benefits us all through the excellence of its research and teaching. 'That is something we should all get behind.' Mr Gethins has also sought clarity on whether the Scottish Government's budget could be penalised as a result of the new levy being placed on international student income at universities in England and Wales. While ministers say the policy won't be forced on Scotland, where education is devolved, Mr Gethins fears the block grant for the Scottish Parliament could be reduced as a result.
