‘Drinking, urinating, littering': Most back larger alcohol ban area in Gisborne
Public consultation shows most submitters want locations in Gisborne city centre and Kaiti covered under an alcohol control bylaw.
Photo:
Gisborne Herald
With a "growing trend" of booze-fuelled incidents in the Gisborne suburb of Kaiti and in Gisborne's central city, a proposed alcohol ban extension is gaining public support.
Gisborne District Council has proposed an extension to the existing alcohol ban area to cover more of the city centre and create a new ban in the Kaiti area.
Submissions on the plan raised concerns around "congregating and drinking, urinating and littering" in public spaces covered under the proposed bans.
According to the hearings report on the topic, 77 percent supported extending the current alcohol ban in Gisborne City to include areas east of the Taruheru River and Gisborne Cenotaph, 18 percent disagreed and five percent gave no clear response.
Additionally, 80 percent supported a new alcohol ban area to include Kaiti Memorial Park, Kaiti Hub and the area outside Kaiti School, while 10 percent disagreed, and the remaining were either neutral or other.
The public consultation ran through April, with 39 submissions received, including one verbal submission from Te Whatu Ora Tairāwhiti Medical Officer of Health Dr Douglas Lush and compliance officer Cheanne Johnson.
During hearings on the alcohol control bylaw on Thursday, Lush and Johnson said Health NZ supported the proposed ban areas.
Almost half (44.9 percent) of drinkers in Tairāwhiti were considered hazardous compared with the national average of 27.1 percent, said Johnson, quoting a 2022 report.
"We know that Māori experience a higher rate of alcohol-related harm and hazardous drinking."
Lush said there would be ongoing concerns about how the bylaw would be enforced and the drinkers moving to other areas, but the proposed amendments would reduce public exposure to drinking and denormalise alcohol consumption, particularly with Kaiti Mall being close to Kaiti School.
According to the hearings report, almost all commenters who took a supportive position on the Kaiti ban emphasised "protecting children and families".
Additionally, two written submissions suggested the area needed to include both sides of Rutene Rd up to Craig Rd, as this area was used by children commuting to school.
During the hearings, councillor Colin Alder asked about potential unintended consequences of the ban, including how it could affect alfresco dining in the city or businesses like the Tatapouri fishing club, where - on busy occasions - patrons could drink outside, as long as they did not cross a designated line.
Strategic planning manager Charlotte Knight said the bylaw could get a little bit "hazy", but it did not include licensed premises or their footprints.
She said the police enforced the bylaw, which was a complaints-based response.
Intermediate policy adviser Makarand Rodge said police had advised that they would "exercise a lot of discretion".
The hearings report notes that an internal submission, written by a council staff member, described how a group of day-drinkers verbally abused council staff and contractors repeatedly, while they installed benches and picnic tables in Kelvin Park, Marina Park and Rose Gardens.
The group also interfered with their tools and worksites, and created "ongoing staff-safety concerns".
"Within two weeks of installation, the new furniture had been defaced with graffiti."
The cost to remediate the damage was "a recurring financial burden".
Overall, the hearing report said the reasons for supporting the city centre extension included reducing "unruly or abusive behaviour", and that intoxicated behaviour at the Gisborne Cenotaph or river "undermines the memorial's importance and public comfort".
Submitter Gael Alderton wrote that they were sick of seeing "congregating and drinking, urinating and littering" in the public spaces outside the museum, council building, cenotaph and along the river banks.
"[It's] unpleasant for residents and not good for visitors to the city. Puts normal folk off sitting down or having lunch in these areas."
However, submitters in opposition suggested it was better to address the source of the problem "by helping at-risk drinkers or homeless people".
Submitter Daniel Blair said the ban might target people "enjoying a glass of wine, while having a picnic near the river".
"Drunk and disorderly is another story, which covers the entire region already, and police respond accordingly," he wrote. "The more bans we have, the more freedoms we lose."
Police data suggested "a growing trend of alcohol-related incidents in these locations, highlighting the need to consider options to extend the current alcohol ban", according to the hearing report.
At an October council meeting, councillors decided to review the current Alcohol Control Bylaw 2015.
The amended proposals also included updating the maps in the bylaw for clarity, with which 82 percent agreed, three percent disagreed and 15 percent were neutral.
Depending on the panel discussion and suggestions, staff will prepare a report for the council for final approval at the next sustainable Tairāwhiti or council meeting.
Areas in the current bylaw that are not addressed in the amended proposals remain unchanged.
LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
14 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Landmark 'Dunedin Study' founder Dr Phil Silva dies, aged 84
Dr Phil Silva. Photo: Dunedin Multidisciplinary Health and Development Study The founder of a landmark study following more than a thousand babies born in the early 1970s has died. Dr Phil Silva, who started the Multidisciplinary Health and Development Study - commonly known as the 'Dunedin Study' - died on Thursday, aged 84. He began the study, which followed the lives of 1037 babies born at Queen Mary Maternity Hospital, Dunedin, in 1972. Current Dunedin Study director Professor Moana Theodore. Photo: Supplied Current Dunedin Study director Professor Moana Theodore said he was "an interesting academic", who previously worked as a former primary school teacher and psychologist. Teaching rural children in the 1960s underpinned his life's work, she added. "He always had a passion for teaching, and helping support children and their families." A masters degree and doctorate in research focused on children began under Otago University lecturer Dr Patricia Buckfield in the late 1960s, Theodore said. Buckfield had an interest in neonatology and gathered data on every baby born at Dunedin's Queen Mary obstetric hospital between 1967-73. This lead to the creation of the Dunedin Multidisciplinary Health and Development Unit, under Silva's direction. Theodore said Silva was an energetic mentor, who "took people along with him", and this bolstered the study's success, despite the odds of little funding. "In the very early days, that meant he was able to bring on board hundreds of volunteers, who would help the study. "He was incredibly driven, he had this huge energy and he faced almost impossible odds to set up the Dunedin Study in those early days, but he didn't let a lack of resource deter him. "Through this ability to create relationships and to bring people on board with this greater purpose of improving other people's lives, he was able to get hundreds of volunteers to collect data and that has been something that's made the Dunedin Study really special." The study's 90 percent participation rate - more than 50 years later - was "unparalleled in the world", she said. "A lot of that is to do with it's really a community study - it's proudly the Dunedin Study, it's not just the Dunedin Study - and that began with Phil." Silva mentored both the previous director - the late Professor Richie Poulton, who ran the study after Phil retired, beginning in 1999 or 2000 - as well as Theodore, she said. "He hired me originally as an interviewer at the age-26 assessment phase, when the study members were 26, back in 1998, and he always kept actively involved in supporting and providing advice to me as well. "He was so passionate about improving the lives of others and, starting in early life, he once argued publicly that New Zealanders, as a whole, could be seen to care more about their cars than they did about their children. They would check cars every six months to a year. "His research and his vision for improving lives resulted in things like more routine check-ups for children, particularly in pre-school, and this growing understanding of health in those early years, such as the high rates of glue ear, and the need to show compassion to our children and young people, particularly if they were seen to be going off the rails." The study made the cover of Time magazine in 1993 - a year before he was awarded an OBE for services to health and education. "The headline read, 'All you need is love'. That summed up how Phil really felt about children and young people." Silva left behind "an incredible legacy" said Theodore. "We continue to work to uphold [that] and we're seeing study members now at age 52, through this lifetime of service. "Dr Phil has left this legacy and a taonga [prize] for New Zealand, which leaves behind the best childhood foundation guarder in the world - and the most studied group of people anywhere in the world." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Navigating New Zealand's ableist health system with a disability
Photo: 123RF Julie Woods has navigated the world without sight since 1997 - but it is New Zealand's healthcare system that has most often left her in the dark. "For so long now, we've been getting our appointment letters in print, which - as a blind person - just seems so ridiculous," she said. "I received a letter from ACC in print and when I called them to say, 'This is not my preferred format - could you please email it to me?', they said, 'No, we can't do that'." Woods said there seemed to be a lack of awareness from healthcare workers, when it came to dealing with people who were blind - such as when an ophthalmologist handed her printed pre-operative instructions before cataract surgery, or when she was asked to fill out a printed meal form at the hospital, only for the catering team to later place the meal in front of her without saying a word. "It's the importance of saying who you are when you come into the room, [and] saying that you're leaving the room and when you come back," she said. "There are so many people that come into that hospital setting who, all of a sudden, start touching you or talking to you. You don't know who they are and you don't know whether they're talking to you." Julie Woods. Photo: julie woods Woods also called for medication to be labelled in braille. "When I go to the pharmacy and pick up my medication, it comes in a big bag," she said. "The way I can identify my medication is by the shape of the box or the size of the tube, or the feel of the tablet. "I can't tell what they're for. I just recognise them by the shape - and that's not ideal. "I had two tubes of ointment - one was for my vagina and one was for my face, and I couldn't tell which was which." At Access Matters Aotearoa's webinar on Wednesday - part of their Kōrero for Change series - Donald Beasley Institute junior research fellow Umi Asaka said experiences like Woods' were part of a wider problem within New Zealand's healthcare system. While Health Minister Simeon Brown announced that Cabinet had approved a suite of amendments to the Pae Ora (Healthy Futures) Act 2022 on Saturday , none of those were for people with disabilities. The medical model of disability was rooted in disablism and ableism, Asaka said. "It says that disabled people should have medical intervention to change our body and mind to become as close to non-disabled people's body and mind. "There are lots of different treatments within healthcare system that are - of course - needed, but there are also other treatments that are about making our bodies and mind fit into this ableist society." New Zealand's health system is even worse for Māori, who - at the end of May - had told the Waitangi Tribunal that the health system was failing them . Dr Huhana Hickey, a claimant in the Waitangi Tribunal's inquiry into the disestablishment of Te Aka Whai Ora - the Māori Health Authority - had been working with Te Aka Whai Ora to ensure there was a voice for Māori with disabilities, before it was disestablished. "Disabled people aren't faring well - but the most deprived demographic - and the last time Ministry of Health did this was in 2001, so it shows you they didn't want to show it again - was Māori disabled. "Then halfway down on that graph, it was Māori non-disabled, second most deprived. Dr Huhana Hickey. Photo: RNZ / Alexander Robertson Health New Zealand disability strategy head Rachel Noble said New Zealand's health system was "ableist by nature". "The individuals who work within Health New Zealand are, on the whole, very willing to create inclusive and accessible health services, but they're not sure how and there are many systems within the system that need to be addressed." Noble said Health New Zealand needed to "change the narrative". "That means reframing the way we think about disability in health to become inclusive and accessible for disabled people - to be responsive and relevant." She said Health New Zealand had committed to promoting the disability model of care, developing a tool that would allow people with disabilities to communicate their accessibility needs for healthcare appointments, and engaging with the community to inform service improvements. Noble added that there were also resources that Health New Zealand already had in place, which she had personally used, such as the "I am deaf" card. "I showed it to the receptionist, and straight away her body language changed, and she adapted how she communicated with me. She also took that card and passed it on to the next person, who passed it on to the next person," she said. "By the time I left that appointment, I didn't have the stress of having to justify or explain myself. I didn't have to teach people on the way. "They were all really able to accommodate me, which meant I left feeling like a human being - and I think that's the feeling that we want to create for everyone." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Dr Matire Harwood now a professor at Waipapa Taumata Rau
This week Dr Matire Harwood became a professor at Waipapa Taumata Rau, Auckland University's School of Medicine. She continues to combine academia with her mahi as a GP. When she was a young girl her grandfather told her she would become a doctor eventually she earned a Bachelor in Medicine, became a GP and earned her PHD in 2011. Dr Harwood says whanau encouragement was important as was the influence of a female school science teacher in Australia who wore stilettos and drove a hot rod.
