Report: Bobby Madley criticises VAR for removing emotion from football
Report: Referee Bobby Madley Says He 'Hates' VAR's Impact on Football
Referee Bobby Madley has delivered a scathing assessment of VAR, stating that he 'hates' the technology and the way it has changed the emotional dynamic of football. Speaking at the Cheltenham Science Festival during an event on technology in sport, Madley expressed frustration at how video assistant referees have affected the in-the-moment joy of goal celebrations.
Advertisement
'As a fan, hate it, hate it. Love the Championship, love League One – I'm still a fan,' said Madley.
'I love League One because you score a goal, you look at the referee, you look at the assistant, he hasn't put his flag up, it's a goal.
'It [VAR] takes that emotion away from it and football is a game where there could be one moment in the game, one goal, and that's it.
'To take that emotion away, to have to wait and wait, and what feels like an eternity, as a fan I'm not a huge fan of that experience.'
Madley currently officiates in the English Football League and acts as a fourth official in Premier League matches. While VAR is widely used in England's top flight, it has not been introduced to regular EFL fixtures.
IMAGO
Madley's career and return to English football
Madley's career has taken a complicated path. Between 2013 and 2018, he refereed 91 Premier League matches before being dismissed by Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) after sending a video that mocked a disabled person. Following that episode, he moved to Norway to officiate in the lower leagues.
Advertisement
In February 2020, he returned to English football as a National List referee. His return to the top flight has been limited, taking charge of one Premier League game in the 2022-23 season and another in 2023-24. He was not selected for any Premier League refereeing duties during the 2024-25 season.
Commercial pressures behind VAR's introduction
In his comments, Madley also pointed to the commercial forces driving VAR's implementation. He argued that the technology was introduced not because of fan or referee demand, but due to the financial interests of football's governing bodies and investors.
'There's so much money in football, it's business-driven. So any mistake is perceived to cost people money,' he said.
Advertisement
'And I don't think most football fans were clambering over each other to get video technology.
'The players weren't, the referees weren't, but the people who run football, they are multimillion-pound and billion-pound people, and they had issues with referees getting things wrong.'
This view brings into focus a larger debate within modern football: whether decisions driven by corporate stakeholders serve the spirit of the game or erode it.
Madley's words reflect growing scepticism within the football community about the direction the sport is heading. While VAR was designed to reduce refereeing errors, many argue it has created its own issues by slowing down the game and sapping moments of joy and spontaneity.
Advertisement
'I think we've got to the stage where people go, 'Sorry, we're ruining football with this now',' Madley added.
'But we knew the monster that had been created. As referees, we knew what was coming.'
His remarks will undoubtedly resonate with many fans, players and even officials who feel the soul of the sport is being sacrificed in the name of technical perfection.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
St. John Bosco wins Division I regional baseball title with a shutout
St. John Bosco High teammates celebrate with a dogpile on the field after winning the regional baseball title. (Steve Galluzzo / For The Times) On the day he turned 17, Jack Champlin gave himself his own best birthday present, one he got to share with his teammates. The junior right-hander needed 27 pitches to retire all seven batters he faced to wrap up St. John Bosch's 4-0 shutout of San Diego Patrick Henry in the Southern California Regional Division I championship game. Advertisement 'I'm going to dinner with my family and my girlfriend,' he said when asked what he would do to celebrate. 'I'm not sure where yet, but there are a lot of good places around here and we'll make a decision.' Champlin pitched in all eight playoff games for the Braves, picking up two wins and five saves, giving up no runs allowed in 11 2/3 innings. 'I don't really feel the pressure … as a closer you need to have confidence in your stuff and I'm just happy to be put in that position,' said Champlin, who fielded a grounder back to the mound and underhanded a toss to first base for the final out of the season. 'We knew our starter [Brayden Krakowski] had pitched earlier in the week and only had 14 outs remaining, so the gameplan was for me to come in after that or before if necessary. As it turned out I was able to finish each playoff game with the ball in my hand every single time.' Krakowksi allowed three hits and got all the support he needed in the first inning, as James Clark led off the bottom half with a triple and scored on a single by Noah Everly. Miles Clark added a two-out RBI single. In the next inning St. John Bosco doubled its lead when James Clark hit an RBI double and later scored on an infield single by Jaden Jackson. Advertisement St. John Bosco beat eighth-seeded San Diego St. Augustine 2-1 in the first round and No. 5 Villa Park 7-4 in the semifinals in a rematch of the Braves' 4-3 nine-inning triumph in the Southern Section Division 1 quarterfinals. Patrick Henry had lost 3-0 to Granite Hills in the San Diego Section Open Division final but after back-to-back victories over two of the best Southern Section teams in Santa Margarita and Crespi, the Patriots (23-11-2) came to Bellflower confident they could upset the No. 1-ranked team in California. It did not happen. Instead, the Braves notched their 19th consecutive win, 30th in 34 games and capped an historic campaign, which included a 3-2 walk-off victory over Santa Margarita to capture the program's first Southern Section crown May 30 after losing to Beckman 2-1 in eight innings in the Division 3 title game last season. 'We've proven ourselves,' Champlin said in the midst of a celebration on the same field where he and his returning teammates rallied to defeat Bakersfield Christian 5-4 and claim the Division III regional championship last June. Advertisement Champlin took the hill with one out in the top of the seventh inning in last year's regional final, got the final two outs, and was credited with the win when the Braves scored the game-ending run on a balk in the bottom of the inning. Saturday's achievement was even sweeter because it was accomplished at the highest level and was a testament to second-year coach Andy Rojo, who held the first-place plaque high and declared 'We won the West!' as his players surrounded him. 'It'll take a lot for any team to match what we've done winning by three titles in one year — the Trinity League championship, the Southern Section Division 1 championship and the regional Division I championship,' said Rojo, who got his squad to the top of the mountain despite losing 12 players to graduation — including pitcher Anthony Cosme (Cal Poly Pomona), center fielder Julian Villasenor (Washington State) and first baseman Zach Woodson (Pepperdine). 'Tomorrow will be two months since we lost a game (the Braves last suffered defeat on April 8 against Santa Margarita). I couldn't be more proud.' Sign up for the L.A. Times SoCal high school sports newsletter to get scores, stories and a behind-the-scenes look at what makes prep sports so popular. This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
The Timberwolves Want To Retain Their Free Agents in 2025
The Timberwolves Want To Retain Their Free Agents in 2025 originally appeared on Athlon Sports. Playing with a deep roster is the key to winning an NBA championship nowadays. That happened with the Boston Celtics in 2024, and the Oklahoma City Thunder look poised to do it in 2025. Advertisement The Minnesota Timberwolves lost to the Thunder in the Western Conference Finals. That loss was primarily due to their depth and elite defense. The Timberwolves are aiming for the NBA Finals, which will require them to have a deep team. Credit: Bruce Kluckhohn-Imagn Images The main storyline for the Timberwolves' offseason is retaining most of their core. Julius Randle was excellent in the second half of the season, playing as Anthony Edwards' co-star. He was superb, performing as arguably the best postseason player on the roster. Since he has a player option akin to bench star Naz Reid, the Timberwolves are trying to retain him. Nickeil Alexander-Walker is also a player they want to keep, as he will be an unrestricted free agent in the 2025 offseason. Advertisement Related: Austin Rivers Admits Anthony Edwards' Supporting Cast Needs Big Improvements Maintaining The Core Will Be Expensive For The Timberwolves The players who are secure in the Timberwolves' future are Anthony Edwards and Jaden McDaniels. They have the most potential on the roster, as they also fit the modern requirements for succeeding in the modern-day NBA. Alongside their two building blocks, the Timberwolves also need depth to compete against the Oklahoma City Thunder and Denver Nuggets. However, they will have to fork over a significant amount of money to maintain the core. Reid will likely be offered a deal over $30 million per year, while Randle is eligible for a four-year $181 million contract extension with the Timberwolves. For Alexander-Walker, he likely earns a contract between $14 and $24 million per year. Connelly Wants To Keep Everyone In Minnesota Despite the money issues they might face, team president Tim Connelly wants to retain their core group. This is a team that has led them to two consecutive Western Conference Finals, which makes it unsurprising that he wants to keep the core. "The goal is to keep everybody and what's neat is the players are all really happy here. The players are really happy here, they love the coaching staff, they love the teammates," Connelly said in an interview. "So, when the player wants to be here and the team wants to have them back, there's always room for optimism." Advertisement It will be an expensive decision because the Timberwolves will deal with the luxury tax. Thankfully, incoming owners Marc Lore and Alex Rodriguez are reportedly willing to pay the luxury tax. The 2025 offseason will be significant for the Timberwolves, as they might make some big decisions. Letting go of one of the three expiring contracts could be hard. Retaining the trio would be a successful offseason, especially if they get more players. Related: Alex Rodriguez Sends Strong Message Of Support For The Timberwolves This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 3, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Report: Liverpool weigh £30m sale as Brentford and others show interest
Ben Doak and Liverpool's £30m Opportunity: Smart Business or Short-Sighted Sale? Transfer Turbulence Around Young Talent Liverpool's summer activity has been relentless, with deals flowing in and out of the club in rapid succession. The latest transfer spotlight, however, is fixed on 19-year-old Ben Doak, a name that barely registered with the casual fan last summer but now finds himself a £30m-rated target for a trio of Premier League clubs. Advertisement Per the Hounslow Herald, Brentford are keen to add Doak to a growing collection of ex-Liverpool talent, having already secured the signatures of Caoimhin Kelleher, Sepp van den Berg and Fabio Carvalho over the past two summers. But they're not alone. Crystal Palace and Brighton have reportedly entered the fray, a development that significantly strengthens Liverpool's hand. Sale May Fund Big-Name Targets Liverpool's motivation is clear. While they've already welcomed Jeremie Frimpong from Bayer Leverkusen and bid farewell to Trent Alexander-Arnold and Kelleher, bigger targets are on the radar. Chief among them is Florian Wirtz. Liverpool to recoup funds to help fund Wirtz and more. With the club still engaged in talks over Milos Kerkez and potentially a striker, Doak's sale could serve a broader strategic purpose. His potential may be considerable, but in a summer of reshaping, even promising youth might be considered expendable to fund marquee arrivals. Market Value and Timing Work in Liverpool's Favour Doak's value, and the timing of this interest, place Liverpool in an advantageous position. Ipswich Town had tried in January, but the Reds didn't want to sell. The mood seems to have shifted, and rightly so. The competition between Brentford, Brighton and Crystal Palace all but guarantees a fee close to the full £30m. Photo IMAGO Given that Doak's 2024/25 campaign was hampered by injury after a strong loan stint at Middlesbrough, it's a bold valuation—but not unrealistic. There's enough performance data, promise and Premier League readiness to justify it, particularly in a summer when even mid-table clubs have serious money to spend. Development Versus Immediate Value Selling Doak would be another sign that Liverpool are prioritising short-term gains and proven quality over longer-term squad depth and player development. That may be a calculated risk worth taking, but it will only pay off if their reinvestments—particularly in the Wirtz deal—yield immediate returns. Advertisement It's a recurring theme under Fenway Sports Group: buy low, develop smart, and sell high. In this case, it might be more about selling smart and buying elite. Our View – Anfield Index Analysis There's no doubt Ben Doak has something about him. Pacey, direct, and fearless—he looks every inch a player suited to Arne Slot's dynamic football. His performances at Middlesbrough hinted at serious potential, and despite injury setbacks, most Liverpool fans would have liked to see him get a proper run in the first team before decisions are made. That said, £30m is no small change for a player who's still largely unproven at Premier League level. If that money helps secure someone like Florian Wirtz, a generational talent who could redefine Liverpool's attacking play, then it becomes more palatable. But it always stings to see homegrown or carefully scouted youth sold on just before they might explode. Advertisement Brentford, Brighton and Palace are all clubs with smart recruitment and solid coaching. If any of them land Doak, he'll probably thrive. The worry then is hindsight. If he becomes a star elsewhere, fans will question why we didn't show more patience. Still, given the bigger picture and financial pragmatism required to stay competitive in the modern game, this looks like a sale Liverpool can afford to make—but only if they get the rest of their summer business absolutely right.
