Alabama House passes bill overhauling Birmingham Water Works Board
Rep. Neil Rafferty, D-Birmingham, speaks during a debate over a bill changing the make-up of the Birmingham Water Works Board on May 1, 2025. The bill, sponsored by Rep. Jim Carns, R-Vestavia, passed the House over the objections of Jefferson County Democrats. (Brian Lyman/Alabama Reflector)
The Alabama House of Representatives passed a bill Thursday to reorganize the Birmingham Water Works Board (BWWB) over the objections of Jefferson County Democrats who called it state meddling in local affairs.
SB 330, sponsored by Sen. Dan Roberts, R-Mountain Brook, allows each of the following entities to appoint one member to the board of the utility: the City of Birmingham, Birmingham City Council, Jefferson County Commission, Blount County Commission, Shelby County Commission, the Lieutenant Governor, and the Governor. The governor's appointment is restricted to a resident of Jefferson County.
The legislation passed the Senate last week unanimously.
'I say it's a miracle because I've been here a lot of years,' he said. 'Never, ever have I ever seen a bill where Jefferson County was involved that passed out of the Senate 30-0.'
The legislation is broadly worded but effectively targets the BWWB, which supplies water to Jefferson County and surrounding areas has drawn criticism over rates and governance. Democrats in the Jefferson County delegation have long resisted efforts to reorganize the board, saying it would give officials outside Jefferson County power over a local resource. Critics have also noted the plans would give majority-white counties control of an asset in a county that is 67% Black.
Jefferson County Democrats spoke on the bill for over two hours Thursday morning.
'For over a century, the Birmingham Water Works Board has provided safe, clean and reliable water to hundreds of thousands of residents and businesses across our region,' Rep. Patrick Sellers, D-Pleasant Grove, said. 'Their work is not only essential, it's exceptional.'
While Carns said he would not take any amendments on the legislation, four members of the delegation tried. Sellers said the board should not be politicized by elected state officials being eligible for appointment. He offered an amendment that would prohibit any of the appointees from being a lawmaker.
The amendment failed 70-28.
Rep. Ontario Tillman, D-Bessemer, offered an amendment to return appointing authority for one seat on the board to Birmingham City Council instead of the Blount County Commission because there are fewer customers in Blount County than in Jefferson County.
'We are silencing the voices of Jefferson County when it comes to being able to control their own water, which is a very precious resource,' Tillman said. 'We are losing that because we allow an outside source that serves maybe 100 people in certain areas, maybe 8% outside of Jefferson County, to be able to control the water.'
The amendment failed 70-28.
Rep. Jim Hill, R-Odenville, offered an amendment to limit the lieutenant governor's appointment to a resident of St. Clair County, which is served by the BWWB. He said he'd only ever support the legislation if St. Clair County was represented.
'We are a customer. We don't like to be treated that way, as if we are not important,' Hill said. 'If you think we're big enough, if you think we're important enough, if you think we ought to have representation on a board that we contribute $3 million in revenue to a year then let us have a seat.'
The amendment failed 54-38. Hill abstained on the final vote.
Rep. Neil Rafferty, D-Birmingham, offered an amendment to restrict the board's appointees from having ownership or interest in any sewer system located in the county the authorizing municipality is located.
'So any potential complications with this bill have not been fully considered, particularly considering the Jefferson County sewer system,' Rafferty said.
The amendment failed 69-29.
Rafferty began protesting the legislation as the House adopted the Special Order Calendar. He said the bill is an assault on local governance.
'Each of us in this chamber would be rightfully concerned if outside representatives attempted to dictate how water systems operate in our districts without consulting us or even including us at the table, or, hell, even the room where this legislation was created,' he said.
Sellers said during debate that there are other issues with water supply and sewage in the state that are more important than restructuring the BWWB.
'Lowndes County, a significant portion of this majority black, low-income community, lacks proper sewer infrastructure, leading to raw sewage exposure in homes and public spaces,' he said. 'Why now? Why the Birmingham Water Works Board?'
Rep. Kelvin Datcher, D-Birmingham, called the bill undemocratic after it passed 66-27.
'What happened is undemocratic, and it absolutely destroys the opportunity for us to continue to work together as a region,' he said.
The bill goes to Gov. Kay Ivey's desk to be signed into law. A message seeking comment from her office was sent Thursday afternoon.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
32 minutes ago
- Axios
Colorado Gov. Polis wields power despite lame-duck status
Gov. Jared Polis is a lame duck — but he still holds a veto pen. Why it matters: The term-limited Democrat loomed large in the now-completed legislative term, evidenced by his record 11 vetoes, and his influence sets the stage for his final session in 2026. State of play: A deepening rift between Polis and his fellow Democrats emerged as a major theme from this year's session on issues ranging from artificial intelligence to labor issues. Polis signed 476 of 487 bills into law by last Friday, the deadline — 88% of the new laws included at least one Republican sponsor. He signed business-friendly legislation and rejected measures tightening regulations on technology companies, calling them "what's right for Colorado." Yes, but: The numbers mask the outward tension from the 2025 term that split Democrats. Polis managed to use his veto threat to scuttle numerous other bills to keep them off his desk. He vetoed three bipartisan measures and one to limit ambulance costs that passed with unanimous support. What they're saying:"This isn't the first year where we've had conflict. I think maybe the difference is how visible it might be," House Speaker Julie McCluskie said at a recent event hosted by the Colorado Sun. What we're watching: Asked if he feels like a lame duck, Polis demurred.
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Fetterman calls out 'anarchy' in LA, noting that Dems forfeit 'moral high ground' by failing to decry violence
Sen. John Fetterman, D-Pa., spoke out against the "anarchy and true chaos" in Los Angeles, declaring that Democrats forfeit "moral high ground" if they do not decry the violence. "I unapologetically stand for free speech, peaceful demonstrations, and immigration—but this is not that. This is anarchy and true chaos. My party loses the moral high ground when we refuse to condemn setting cars on fire, destroying buildings, and assaulting law enforcement," Fetterman declared in a post on X. Elon Musk replied to Fetterman's post with an American flag emoji. Marines Being Deployed To Los Angeles Amid Riots As California Moves To Sue Trump Over Response Ohio gubernatorial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy noted, "It's hard to preach hard truths to your own side. I respect this." Deputy White House chief of staff and Cabinet secretary Taylor Budowich responded to Fetterman in a post, writing: "This is a wake up call for many Democrats: there is no room for you in the party of @GavinNewsom and @KamalaHarris. Their self-obsessed pursuits of power are blind to you and your concerns. They defend chaos, reject biology, and are unbothered by the invasion of our nation." Read On The Fox News App Fetterman Disses Dems For Suddenly Embracing Musk Amid Trump Fallout Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., has spoken out against violence, declaring in a post on X, "Dr. King defeated racist government officials & ended segregation through disciplined non-violent resistance. Defeating Trumpism, oligarchy & authoritarianism requires that same level of discipline. Violent protests are counterproductive and play right into Trump's playbook." President Donald Trump has deployed National Guard troops in response to the unrest in LA. "We made a great decision in sending the National Guard to deal with the violent, instigated riots in California. If we had not done so, Los Angeles would have been completely obliterated," the president asserted on Monday in a Truth Social post. Fetterman Defies 'Punitive' Punishment For Breaking With Democratic Party During Bipartisan Discussion Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth noted in a tweet on Monday evening that U.S. Marines were being deployed to the city "to restore order."Original article source: Fetterman calls out 'anarchy' in LA, noting that Dems forfeit 'moral high ground' by failing to decry violence
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Democratic frustration reaches boiling point over David Hogg
Tensions are reaching a boiling point between David Hogg and Democratic National Committee (DNC) leadership as the organization moves to potentially redo Hogg's election as vice chair. Leaked audio revealed DNC Chair Ken Martin venting his frustration with Hogg, who has come under fire from some within the party for his efforts to oust certain incumbents while serving as a DNC vice chair. The leak occurred the day before DNC officials were set to vote virtually on whether to redo the vice-chair elections, a move that is technically unrelated to the controversy surrounding Hogg. And it has underscored the frustrations many in the party feel toward the 25-year-old gun control activist. 'David Hogg is one of the biggest distractions we've had and seen in our party,' said Democratic strategist Antjuan Seawright, who advised former DNC Chair Jaime Harrison and hopes Hogg loses his seat. 'I don't trust him and I don't think a lot of other people who are associated with the party should trust him.' Hogg is rattling members of the party as he's showed no signs of reversing course on getting involved in Democratic primaries as a sitting DNC officer despite Martin and members of the party making clear their opposition to it. That conflict came to a head last month when Martin expressed frustration with Hogg during a Zoom call with DNC officers, audio of which was leaked and subsequently reported by Politico over the weekend. 'I'm just quite frustrated to be in this position, because what you've done, whether you like it or not or know it or not, David, is I'm trying to — no one knows who the hell I am, right?' Martin said on the call, apparently addressing Hogg, according to audio published by the news outlet. 'I'm trying to get my sea legs underneath me and actually develop any amount of credibility so I can go out there and raise the money and do the job I need to, to put ourselves in a position to win,' he continued. 'And again, I don't think you intended this, but you essentially destroyed any chance I have to show the leadership that I need to, so it's really frustrating.' Martin also suggested he had considered stepping down as chair serveral months into his tenure. 'I'm not going anywhere,' he later said in a statement following the publication of the audio. 'I took this job to fight Republicans, not Democrats. As I said when I was elected, our fight is not within the Democratic Party, our fight is and has to be solely focused on Donald Trump and the disastrous Republican agenda. That's the work that I will continue to do every day.' A number of DNC officers have also expressed their support for Martin following the Politico report, with some criticizing Hogg over the controversy. 'We have a lot of work to do as a party, and Chair Martin is doing it,' said Stuart Appelbaum, a DNC associate chair, in a statement. 'I have total confidence in his leadership.' Meanwhile, Hogg has sought to distance himself from the leaked audio and its release in a post on the social platform X. In a separate post he suggested the call is a distraction that would only help Republicans. 'Republicans want us turning on each other so they can continue getting away with this. While Chair Martin and I have had our disagreements we are both in this to build the strongest party possible,' Hogg wrote. 'Our nation is in a moment of crisis and the people are looking for us to lead. This is a distraction that prevents us from doing that. Do not help the GOP.' A representative for Hogg did not respond to The Hill's request for comment. The situation has left Democrats feeling frustrated and furious, with some saying the controversy is creating a distraction just as party officials are grappling with how to respond to Trump's deployment of the military to California amid immigration-related protests. Meanwhile, the party is gearing up for the midterms, when it hopes to flip the House and possibly even the Senate. 'It shows that we're no different than [Republicans] and it shows that we haven't learned lessons from the past,' Seawright said. 'We've seen what happens when you are not unified. We've seen what happens when there's in-party fighting. We've seen what happens when selfish people try to poke their selfish heads up to make headlines instead of headway.' And while some members of the party agree with the idea that the party needs to make room for generational change or challenge ineffective members, they take issue with Hogg's decision to try to do so as an officer of the national party. 'By and large, even the most hardcore centrist, moderate Democrats in [a] roundabout way, agree with what he's doing. There are some Democrats that need to get primaried or at [least] challenged, right? That's fine,' said John Verdejo, a DNC member from North Carolina. 'Everyone agrees with him on paper, but now … you're a DNC vice chair.' One Democratic strategist who spoke on condition of anonymity said Hogg is 'over his skis.' 'We are relying on the experience of a gun violence prevention activist, now Democratic Party leader, three years out of college,' the strategist said. '[Hogg] does not have the shared experience of Ken and others on that call.' 'It's hard to not look at this and say this is someone who is clearly trying to build their profile,' the strategist added. Hogg explicitly noted that his group Leaders We Deserve would not target front-line members in competitive districts. Happening in tandem is the vote over whether the DNC should redo its vice chair elections after Oklahoma DNC member Kalyn Free contested the way the initial vice chair elections were conducted in February. The challenge over the DNC vice chair election was initiated before Hogg announced he would be wading into Democratic primaries. The virtual vote is taking place between Monday and Wednesday of this week; if DNC members decide to redo the vote, two separate virtual votes will be held for the spots currently held by Hogg and Pennsylvania state Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta. Some members are reconsidering how they might cast their vote in light of the leaked audio and the controversy that's ensued. Michael Kapp, a DNC member from California who sits on the DNC Credentials Committee, noted that he was one of the most vocal members of the committee to protect Hogg's and Kenyatta's seats and was against the resolution to consider redoing the vice chair election. 'Up until yesterday, I've been very consistent that I was going to vote no on the Credentials Committee report. I voted no on it in committee, I was planning on voting against it,' Kapp said. 'Now, I'm reconsidering that position, because I don't believe that we should have officers who are leaking private conversations between officers,' he added. The anonymous Democratic strategist warned that voting Hogg out of his post could elevate Hogg as a martyr of sorts. 'There is going to be a lot of backlash if he's forced out of his position,' the strategist said. 'You think he's making noise now? Holy cow, we're not going to hear the end of it.' Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
