Lampard Inquiry: Essex mental health trust boss 'sorry' over 'heartbreaking' failings to families
The chief executive of a mental health trust has admitted at an inquiry that listening to accounts from bereaved families was "extremely sobering and shocking", as he offered an apology.
Paul Scott, chief executive officer of Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust (EPUT), defended the organisation at the Lampard Inquiry on Thursday and said it should continue to deliver mental health services.
The Lampard Inquiry is examining the deaths of more than 2,000 people at NHS-run inpatient units in Essex between 2000 and 2023.
It includes those who died within three months of discharge, and those who died as inpatients receiving NHS-funded care in the independent sector.
At a hearing in London, he said: 'I'd like to offer an apology and condolences to all families who have lost loved ones under the care of Essex mental health.
'I have listened when I first joined, I've met many families, at the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) prosecution (which saw the trust fined £1.5 million), I was in the court for that and I've heard testimonies through this inquiry as well.
'They've been brave, powerful and heartbreaking.
'These have deeply affected me and motivated me to make a real difference and I'm sorry for their enduring pain.
'Since joining the organisation I have given everything I have to try and improve safety and I will continue to do so.'
Mr Scott became chief executive of EPUT in 2020 and described the HSE prosecution as 'extremely sobering and shocking to listen to very powerful testimonies of families in the courtroom, how they'd been failed, the impact it had on them'.
'The responsibility I felt to address that was very powerful with me,' he said.
'I still remember that every day, that day is probably one of the most profound days of my life.'
Mr Scott referred to an opening statement that a barrister for EPUT gave in September last year 'where we were very clear about accepting the failings of the past'.
He said: 'We admitted to failings around ligature points and other environmental risks; staff members' culture and conduct; sexual and physical abuse; absconding; discharge and assessment of patients; involvement of family and friends and staff engagement with investigations.'
EPUT was formed in 2017 following a merger of the former North Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust and the South Essex Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust.
Nicholas Griffin KC, counsel to the inquiry, asked Mr Scott if 'financial pressures have adversely impacted patient safety since the merger.'
Mr Scott said: 'Since I've joined there has been no financial constraints on our inpatient wards – the constraint is the supply of staff.
'I think prior to that there was very strict financial control, now whether you call that financial constraint or not…
'My view was we should have been investing more earlier.'
Thursday's hearing marked the conclusion of an "introductory" three-week session before the next public hearings of the inquiry in July, which will focus on 'those who died while under the care of EPUT's predecessor trusts'.
Some families have been left dissatisfied by the hearings so far, according to Hodge Jones & Allen solicitors, which is representing 126 families.
Priya Singh, from Hodge Jones & Allen Solicitors, said: "I think a lot of the evidence given today is not going to mirror our families' experiences which happened whilst their loved ones were alive and when they passed away, so I think they're going to struggle with the evidence they heard today."
Ralph Taylor's wife Carol died in 2023 after being admitted to the mental health unit at St Margaret's Hospital in Epping. Mr Taylor said: "I think there's a failure of culture, I really don't know what you do about it, but I don't think EPUT is the right organisation to do it because of the experience of families.
"They've failed to look after so many patients in the past, how can you be confident they'll do that in the future?
"I can't bring her back but if we can save at least one life by virtue of them changing how they treat people it's worth it."
During the inquiry opening in Chelmsford last year, the chairwoman of the inquiry, Baroness Kate Lampard CBE, said "we may never know" the true number of people who died.
But she warned it is expected to be "significantly in excess" of the 2,000 deaths previously reported.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Fury grows over the NHS staff who are turning away sick private school pupils
Wes Streeting was urged to 'act swiftly' yesterday after a child was denied vital treatment because he goes to a private school. Head teachers called on the Health Secretary to step in after the eight-year-old was unable to access occupational therapy for his hypermobility syndrome. The Independent Schools Council (ISC), which represents most private schools, said pupils should receive 'equal access' to NHS care regardless of whether they are fee-paying. The intervention comes after The Mail on Sunday revealed the family of the child, who asked to remain anonymous, believe a 'two-tier system' is now at play. They say the Government's attack on private school pupils, which prompted the new VAT on fees, has 'filtered' into the NHS. However, the Department of Health said yesterday any suggestion school choice was a factor was a 'miscommunication'. According to the boy's mother, he was referred to a paediatrician at Kingston Hospital in south-west London after she noticed he was 'struggling to hold the pen well enough to write properly', along with other mobility issues. At the hospital appointment she was asked to fill in a form which asked: 'Where does your child go to school?' She was hoping to get an appointment with Richmond children's occupational therapy service that would have been the 'most important stage' of his assessment. However, days later, she received a text message saying the child had been 'declined' the crucial next appointment with occupational therapists. She then discovered the specialist unit had written to her GP, seen by the Mail, saying: 'We are unable to see this child as we do not provide a service to school-age children who attend an independent schools [sic]. We are only commissioned to provide a service to the mainstream schools.' The boy's brother had been treated for the same condition without issue several years ago. Yesterday, a spokesman for the ISC said: 'Any child coping with ill health should receive equal access to NHS services. We would urge the Government to act swiftly to ensure no child is denied care they are entitled to.' A spokesman for parent group Education Not Taxation added: 'Parents pay for these services through their taxes, and their children have the same right to these services as other children. We urge the Government to end this discrimination and ensure equal access to these services.' Yesterday, a spokesman for Kingston and Richmond NHS Foundation Trust said the boy had not been denied treatment because of his school – a prep in Kew. They said occupational therapy services are provided to all children with an education, health and care plan (EHCP), regardless of their school. EHCPs entitle children with special needs or disabilities to state-funded support and care, and are issued by councils. However, they are rationed due to funding shortages. For those without an EHCP, some state schools provide an onsite NHS occupational therapy service. The spokesman added: 'We are sorry if the wording of our correspondence has caused upset and confusion; we will amend it.' It is understood anyone without an EHCP who attends a private school would not be able to use onsite services at state schools. But there remained questions last night as to why the child was not treated at source by the NHS and instead expected to seek care at a school site. It comes after the Mail revealed other similar cases. These included the mother of an autistic girl in Somerset saying her daughter was denied access to NHS mental health services, and was told: 'If you can afford the school fees, you should pay privately.' It is also understood a child in Norfolk was refused a standing frame by the NHS because he went to private school. And young cancer patients from private schools had to pay £115 an hour for tutoring in an Edinburgh hospital's wards, while it is provided free to state school pupils by the city council.
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
John Whaite says 'I feel like an ageing fool' as he struggles with diagnosis
Strictly Come Dancing star John Whaite took to social media with a candid update two years after revealing he had been diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder Former Strictly Come Dancing star John Whaite has candidly opened up on his health struggles in a new social media upload. The Bake Off star, 36, took to Instagram to reveal his thoughts on how his "superpower" can sometimes "make life confusing". John was diagnosed with ADHD in 2023 and said at the time he wished he had "known this sooner". According to the NHS, ADHD - which stands for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder - is "a condition where the brain works differently to most people". The health service explains symptoms of the diagnosis can leave people having trouble with things like concentrating and sitting still. Now, in an honest video shared to his social media page, John admitted of his condition: "Sometimes it makes life almost unbearable. I was promised I'd get older and wiser, but sometimes I feel like I'm just an ageing fool." He said in the clip: "Oh can we just talk about the reality of life with ADHD because you know a lot of the time we think we have a superpower and sometimes it can serve us very well. "It can serve us in so many ways where we can fixate on things and achieve things and create things and really do the best work or something imaginable but often that's such a pyrrhic victory because we bleed ourselves dry or we exhaust ourselves in doing it or we abandon plans or friends or family and the reality of ADHD is that it can make us believe that what we're doing in life sometimes is the exactly the righteous course of action for us." He went on: "It's the right path in spite of what people who love us might say. And then when it gets to the point where we are our interest fizzles away, the reality kicks in and we see the truth and we see the situation for what it is. "At that point we're left kind of thinking f***, I've given up so much for this. I've ignored people who love me for this. And this is really exhausting because usually the older you get the wise you get. And while that can still be true in a situation where you have ADHD I think the reality. "As you get older you don't necessarily get wiser, you just get older and when you get older and you keep making silly little mistakes people become less tolerant of those mistakes because you're meant to be older and wiser." He added that despite so much positivity surrounding the "superpower", there is also a flip side that can be "crippling and so dehumanising and annoying". John candidly confessed: "If I could chose to live life neurotypically at this point in my life, I would jump at the chance and I know that's not very pro ADHD it's not very kind of holding up the flag our community but sometimes it's just exhausting, it's horrific and sometimes I f****** hate it." John has regularly been open about his condition since his diagnosis. He has also spoke out about his mental health battle, previously suffering from bulimia and suicidal thoughts. He explained at how one point he was so low he decided to quit fame and move to Canada, where he volunteered on a farm in a bid to go back to basics and help him recover. Speaking on Steph's Packed Lunch in 2020, he said he also suffers from sexsomnia, a condition similar to night terrors and sleep walking, but instead he engages in sexual behaviour that he doesn't remember when he's awake. "You have night terrors, I have night pleasures, because I have sexsomnia," he said. "In the night, I'll be fast asleep... My boyfriend wakes up and I'll be fondling him. He's having the time of his life and I'm fast asleep." He has also admitted he was left feeling "suicidal" in the past following his Bake Off win. "I kind of felt like I'd failed. And I felt suicidal. I really really did think I was going to end it," John explained.
Scottish Sun
3 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Number of fat jab NHS prescriptions doubles in a year as 73% of Sun readers now think about using injections
Prescriptions for Mounjaro surged to 1.1million from just 3,300 a year earlier FAT JAB BRITAIN Number of fat jab NHS prescriptions doubles in a year as 73% of Sun readers now think about using injections Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) ENGLAND has become a fat jab nation as weight loss drug prescriptions double to almost three million in a year. Demand for drugs such as Ozempic and Mounjaro show no signs of slowing, with the NHS splashing out £269million on them in 2024-25. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 5 Weight loss drug prescriptions in England have doubled to almost three million in a year Credit: Getty 5 Prescriptions for Mounjaro surged to 1.1million from just 3,300 a year earlier Credit: Alamy It comes as a new Sun survey reveals 73 per cent of our readers are thinking of using them as they struggle to shift weight. Official figures show prescriptions for the big three — Ozempic, Mounjaro and Wegovy — rocketed from 1.4million in 2023-24 to 2.7million last year. The increase was driven by Mounjaro, regarded as the strongest jab, with prescriptions surging to 1.1million from just 3,300 a year earlier. Most were prescribed to people with type 2 diabetes, as the injections were designed to treat that condition, and have only recently been approved for weight loss alone. NHS figures suggest prescriptions in Wales also doubled last year, from approximately 34,000 to 70,000, and in Scotland from 40,000 to 50,000. The numbers are expected to rise again this year as the NHS introduces them through slimming clinics. More than a million people are also already buying the jabs privately. Dr Leyla Hannbeck, of the Independent Pharmacies Association, said: 'Never in my career have I seen a product with as much hype as these injections. 'The demand is absolutely huge and I expect it to keep increasing — the only way is up.' Clare Butler, 48, said the jabs also helped her mental health. Weight Loss Jabs - Pros vs Cons The mum, from Manchester, who has lost 4st 4lb, said: 'Mounjaro didn't only quieten the food noise, but it helped quieten the over-thinking, anxious thoughts that had consumed my life for so long.' She described it as, 'the best decision I've ever made for myself'. Research is revealing wide-ranging health benefits to the jabs, such as lowering risks of cancer, heart disease and dementia, yet warnings over weight loss drugs are also increasing. 5 Medics warn they must not be used in pregnancy, while trying to conceive or while breastfeeding, for fear they could lead to miscarriage or birth defects. They have also warned that rapid weight loss caused by the drugs could lead to bone loss and osteoporosis. Annual statistics from the NHS Business Services Authority show the total number of GLP-1 injections prescribed increased from 1,427,968 in the 2023-24 financial year to 2,734,499 in 2024-25. It was a 91 per cent spike — accounted for almost entirely by Mounjaro's growth. 5 Clare Butler lost 4st4lb on Mounjaro Credit: Clare Butler 5 Clare said the jabs not only helped her lose weight but improved her mental health Credit: Clare Butler The totals also included brands such as Saxenda, Ozempic and Wegovy. In the same period, the cost of prescribing rose from £137,808,297 to £269,276,366 — equal to 2.4 per cent of all NHS spending on pharmacy medicines, or £1 in every £42. The NHS said: 'We expect demand for weight loss drugs to continue to rise in the coming years.' The Department of Health added: 'We recognise the drugs' importance for treating type 2 diabetes and their exciting remit as new treatments for obesity.' Unlock even more award-winning articles as The Sun launches brand new membership programme - Sun Club.
