logo
Pahalgam to Rawalpindi via DC: Tale of a conflict

Pahalgam to Rawalpindi via DC: Tale of a conflict

Hindustan Times11-05-2025

India has shown that it will not accept terror attacks emanating from Pakistani soil and displayed serious political intent and military capacity to counter it. Pakistan has shown that it is not a pushover although the asymmetry in power was evident, and that it possesses military and diplomatic capabilities to stand its ground. China has shown that it will leave no stone unturned to use Pakistan to weaken India. And, America has shown that despite being a distracted power with the intent to do less in the rest of the world, it remains the decisive player in the international system to shape the course of war and peace.
That is the big picture that emerges out of the post-Pahalgam churn. But first here is a quick summary of how India and Pakistan got here based on the limited information in the public domain.
Pakistani-backed terrorists killed civilians based on their religion in Pahalgam. India decided that wasn't acceptable and prepared for a fortnight before mounting unprecedented strikes in both Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK) and Punjab against nine terror camps and bases. With Chinese equipment and support, Pakistan was possibly able to inflict some damage on Indian air capabilities, a fact that India hasn't yet publicly acknowledged. Pakistan then began an offensive against key Indian military bases across the western border, which India countered effectively and then responded by neutralising Lahore's air defence system.
Pakistan then mounted a drone-based offensive against urban centres and military bases in India which were intercepted; India responded with drone attacks of its own on military sites in Pakistan. Pakistan continued its offensive the next day, adding missile strikes on Indian air bases. India lost patience and hit three key Pakistani Air Force bases, including the one in Rawalpindi. This led to a renewed Pakistani offensive against Indian military installations and civilian centres and the likely mobilisation of ground troops. All this while, cross-border shelling at the Line of Control (LoC) kept intensifying with an increasing loss of lives. At this point, on Saturday evening, as the world moved from being exasperated to alarmed, Donald Trump announced that US 'mediation' had led to a ceasefire deal.
To be sure, this is a rough and incomplete story. The attacks and counter-attacks weren't neat and sequential but often simultaneous and multi-domain. In the next few days, all sides will attempt to cast themselves as the victor. And, over the next few weeks and months, we will know a lot more about what happened between the night of May 7 and May 10 in New Delhi, Rawalpindi and Washington DC, at the LoC and International Border, in the skies, and who gained what and lost what. But based on an admittedly incomplete sketch, here is a set of preliminary conclusions.
One, India has institutionalised a new template. Uri gave an indication, Balakot provided further proof, but Operation Sindoor has established for sure that New Delhi has no political tolerance for major terror attacks on Indian soil anymore. From quick cross-border surgical strikes in 2016 and an air strike in PoK in 2019, India moved to conduct strikes in a wider geography against a larger set of targets in Pakistan. This was an impressive logistical and military feat. On Saturday, India also decided that any future terror attack would be considered an act of war.
The principle of zero tolerance for terror, when translated into real policy, means that Pakistan will have to really think hard about whether it wants to incite a wider conflict with India when it sends its boys across the border to shatter the calm in Kashmir or beyond. While one can hope that better sense prevails in Rawalpindi, India will also have to prepare for the worst, boost its military capabilities, plug diplomatic weaknesses, enhance its internal security preparedness given the possibility of terror ground seeking revenge, and prepare its citizens for more frequent bouts of violence, losses and disorder.
Two, Pakistan has shown that while it may be weaker, it is no pushover. Yes, the Indian GDP is eleven times more than that of Pakistan. And yes, India's government wants to build the country unlike Pakistan's army which is happy to burn their own country for the sake of propping up terror proxies and to cement domestic legitimacy or make their chief look like a superhero. But it is important to recognise that the army's dominance, its control over the budget, its historical utility to major powers and therefore ability to extract weapon systems, its dense and intimate relationship with China and Turkey, and decades of anti-India nationalist propaganda and Islamist radicalisation have given the Pakistanis a set of tools.
This operates both at the level of mustering social support for prolonged conflict or escalation and at the level of having more military options. Drones have opened a new chapter of warfare. Pakistan showed an ability to strain India's air defences. The nuclear blackmail option persists even as India has now thrice successfully pushed the envelope on what's possible below the nuke threshold, effectively calling Pakistan's bluff. Pakistan's mobilisation of ground troops had created a possibility of a prolonged land-based war. And exporting terrorism remains a cheap option for a perennially irresponsible state. Make no mistake: India has overwhelming dominance in all domains, it would have won any war, and it has showed the ability to withstand Pakistan's asymmetric warfare for decades. But Pakistan's ability to cause destruction must not be discounted and was visible in this episode.
Three, China was absolutely central to Pakistan's ability to defend itself. All accounts suggest that Beijing provided diplomatic support at the UN, material support for operations and possibly intelligence support to Rawalpindi. For anyone in Delhi who still harbours dreams of detente or rapprochement with Beijing, if Galwan wasn't enough, the past five days should be a reminder that India's tensions with China are deep and have a strong Pakistan dimension. China controls parts of Kashmir. China wants parts of Ladakh. China has an active military presence and upgraded infrastructure at the border. Stability at the Line of Actual Control is fragile. And on top of that, China is behind Pakistan's nuclear and conventional military capabilities. China's relationship with Russia has meant that Moscow may no longer be as solid an Indian ally even on Pakistan as in the past. China is, clearly, happy to see India, on the cusp of ripe geopolitical opportunities, dragged back into a hyphenated morass with Pakistan. All of this means that Delhi will have to live with two active and fragile fronts and be prepared for challenges on either or both any time.
And, finally, the entire post-Pahalgam churn has shown the continued salience of America despite the rhetoric of disengagement and the reality of incompetence and limited personnel. Donald Trump doesn't want wars under his watch; go back to his inaugural speech where he said the one thing he would like to be is a 'peacemaker'. He is particularly obsessed with nuclear threats. And America's ability to wield both carrots and sticks with both India and Pakistan remains enormous. India may not have liked his tendency to claim credit and his use of the word 'mediation'. India may well have rejected Secretary of State Marco Rubio's claims that the ceasefire would be followed by dialogue between India and Pakistan at a neutral place. But it is clear that the US played a central role in facilitating conversations between the two sides and getting the firing to stop. The global cop is still the global cop. At the same time, there were also other players, particularly the UK, Saudi Arabia and UAE, that played a key role in weighing on Pakistan.
India can take satisfaction that it displayed serious political intent to battle terror, showed it had the capability to degrade terror infrastructure, remained unified and mature in its response, and kept the big picture of its developmental objectives in mind even at a highly emotive time as it decided to end this bout of confrontation. But it must also acknowledge that the task of imposing deterrence hasn't been met fully, and it must prepare for a more volatile security situation and a neighbourhood that may just have got more fragile.
Prashant Jha is a political commentator. The views expressed are personal

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Bid to revive J&K tourism: BJP leader plays cricket in Pahalgam; watch video
Bid to revive J&K tourism: BJP leader plays cricket in Pahalgam; watch video

Time of India

time36 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Bid to revive J&K tourism: BJP leader plays cricket in Pahalgam; watch video

Screengrab PTI NEW DELHI: Jammu & Kashmir BJP leader Ravinder Raina on Tuesday played cricket with Pahalgam locals in a bid to revive normalcy in the Valley, which witnessed a sharp decline in tourism after the April 22 terrorist attack at Baisaran meadow. In the clip, the BJP leader was seen bowling and batting with the local kids of the Valley. The efforts are being made from several quarters to revive tourism in Kashmir as travel agents from across the country will converge in Kashmir this weekend to boost tourism in the Valley. The Travel Agents Federation of India (TAFI), which is one of the country's biggest umbrella organisations for agents with over 1,600 members, will be holding its meeting in Srinagar and Pahalgam from June 13-16 to instil confidence among the fraternity. Srinagar hotels and flights commanded a big premium before the Pahalgam attack as Kashmir was seeing unprecedented tourist footfalls post Covid. But after the April 22 attack, tourists already there left Kashmir in droves and those who had plans to visit cancelled the same. J&K is currently focussed on ensuring a safe Amarnath Yatra as they hope that will send out a message that tourists can return to Kashmir. The yatra duration has been curtailed to 38 days, instead of 52 days in 2024, and will be on between July 3 and August 9, 2025. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Your Address of Pride – Signature Global SPR Signature Global Book Now Undo A total of 581 companies from various Central Armed Police Forces, along with personnel from the Jammu and Kashmir Police, will be deployed along the pilgrimage routes to ensure safety of the lakhs of pilgrims. The tourism industry in Kashmir has been badly hit since Pakistan-backed terrorists killed 26 civilians in Pahalgam on April 22. The attack sent a shockwave across the nation, prompting the government to take kinetic action against terror camps deep into Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (PoJK). The Indian forces, in a big action, destroyed the terror camps of Jaish and Lashkar located in Pakistan's Bahawalpur and Muridke.

Students living in U.S. being repeatedly mistreated but PM Modi is silent: Congress
Students living in U.S. being repeatedly mistreated but PM Modi is silent: Congress

The Hindu

time39 minutes ago

  • The Hindu

Students living in U.S. being repeatedly mistreated but PM Modi is silent: Congress

The Congress on Tuesday (June 10, 2025) slammed the government after a video emerged showing an Indian student being handcuffed and pinned to the floor at a U.S. airport, and demanded that Prime Minister Narendra Modi should immediately talk to President Donald Trump to appeal for intervention on the 'mistreatment' of Indians in America. Congress leaders shared the video and pictures of an Indian student handcuffed and pinned to the floor at U.S.'s Newark Airport before he was allegedly deported. The Consulate General of India in New York has said it is in touch with local authorities after the video surfaced online showing the young Indian man being handcuffed and allegedly being deported. 'We have come across social media posts claiming that an Indian national is facing difficulties at Newark Liberty International Airport. We are in touch with local authorities in this regard,' the Indian Consulate said in a post on X. U.S. crackdown on students | What are New Delhi's options | Worldview Congress general secretary in-charge communications Jairam Ramesh alleged that the Modi Government is continuously failing to protect the honour of India and Indians. 'For the first time in history, a foreign head of state has declared ceasefire between India and Pakistan in India's absence. US President Trump is continuously claiming to have ensured a ceasefire by pressuring India,' Mr. Ramesh said in his post in Hindi on X. 'For the past one year, Indian citizens and students living in America are being repeatedly mistreated but Prime Minister Modi is maintaining silence or it should be assumed that he is unable to muster the courage to speak,' Mr. Ramesh said. He is the Prime Minister of India, it is his most important responsibility to protect the honour and respect of India and Indians, Mr. Ramesh asserted. 'We demand that Prime Minister Modi should immediately talk to President Trump and appeal for intervention on the mistreatment and atrocities being committed against Indians in America,' he said. Congress' media and publicity department head Pawan Khera tagged a post on X carrying the video, which was posted online by an Indian-American social entrepreneur Kunal Jain. The video shows the Indian man pinned to the ground by Port Authority Police and being handcuffed. 'I witnessed a young Indian student being deported from Newark Airport last night — handcuffed, crying, treated like a criminal. He came chasing dreams, not causing harm. As an NRI, I felt helpless and heartbroken. This is a human tragedy,' Mr. Jain said in his post. Tagging Mr. Jain's post, Mr. Khera said, 'This is too painful, too humiliating and too distressing to watch. As a country, why should we tolerate this humiliation?' 'From the days where we showed the muscle to the U.S. during the Devyani Khobragade issue to now seeing our citizens being treated like animals, do we have no goodwill left in the world?' the Congress leader said.

Explained: China's monopoly on rare earth minerals spooking the world; what does it mean for India & what is it doing?
Explained: China's monopoly on rare earth minerals spooking the world; what does it mean for India & what is it doing?

Time of India

time39 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Explained: China's monopoly on rare earth minerals spooking the world; what does it mean for India & what is it doing?

China's firm grip on rare earths, essential components in the production of phones, automobiles and missiles, is giving a headache to countries world over, including India. (AI image) China's firm grip and worldwide monopoly on rare earth metals, essential components in the production of phones, automobiles and missiles, is giving a headache to countries world over, including India. Despite mounting pressure from countries including the US, EU and India, China remains steadfast in its stance regarding export limitations of these critical rare earths. Recent reports have highlighted increasing worries within the Indian automotive sector regarding the limited availability of rare earth magnets. These components are essential for electric vehicles and certain parts in conventional internal combustion engine vehicles. Furthermore, India's industrial sectors have expressed apprehension over China's decision to restrict rare earth exports, particularly germanium. This plays a vital role in the production of semiconductors, fibre optic cables and solar panels. Critical minerals and metals, including cobalt, copper, lithium, nickel and rare earth elements, are fundamental components in manufacturing environmentally friendly energy solutions, from wind power installations to battery-powered automobiles. What's China's hold on rare earths? China has established control over critical mineral deposits worldwide. Rare earth minerals comprise a collection of 17 metallic elements. While these elements are found across various countries, extracting them is expensive and environmentally damaging, resulting in substantial pollution. The International Energy Agency reports that whilst China produces 61 % of globally mined rare earths, it dominates 92% of worldwide production output. Following Premier Li Qiang's decree implementing export controls on rare earths, China has reportedly intensified these restrictions after US President Donald Trump levied 146% tariffs on Chinese exports. Recently Trump said that Chinese President Xi Jinping has allowed some rare earths to flow to the US. In a recent column in TOI, Tanmay Kumarr Baid & Pranay Kotasthane of Takshashila Institution argued that by restricting shipments, Beijing is lifting prices worldwide and incentivising countries to set up processing elsewhere. 'Once the capital is sunk into new refining in the rest of the world, even a later U‑turn by China cannot quickly claw these customers back,' they said. However, experts Ajit Ranade and Shardul Manurkar believe that China's rare-earth dominance is not a fragile or accidental monopoly, it is a product of deep, deliberate, and sustained strategy. 'Attempts to counter this dominance must acknowledge the scale of the challenge,' they say. Also Read | Move away from China: Shein & Reliance aim selling 'Made in India' clothes abroad; to list India-made clothes on US, UK websites How much does it impact India? The Indian automobile sector continues to face challenges as China maintains restrictions on critical rare earth magnet supplies, even though nine parts manufacturers received endorsements for their import requests from the Chinese embassy. The flow of supplies remains halted, pending approval from China's commerce ministry. These magnets play a crucial role in the production of electric vehicles and are essential for various automotive components, including gear mechanisms and drive trains. The Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers delivered a presentation to Indian government officials on May 28, urging immediate dialogue between India and China to expedite stalled approvals and simplify the complex procedures. The automotive industry body emphasised the need for bilateral discussions to address these regulatory challenges, according to a Bloomberg report. Saurabh Agarwal, Partner & Automotive Tax Leader, EY India says, 'The recent actions by China have significantly disrupted global supply chains, particularly through their increasing export control over critical commodities. This underscores the urgent need for India, and indeed any nation, to foster a self-sustaining economy. We must prioritize developing our own critical mineral resources and building an end-to-end domestic supply chain, especially as the world shifts towards greater self-reliance. ' 'Given the current trajectory of our growing economy, it's imperative that the government introduces a Production-Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme specifically for rare earth magnets and critical mineral recycling. This will be crucial in the mid-term for establishing a robust domestic supply chain,' he tells TOI. 'In the short run, we must leverage our diplomatic channels to engage with the Chinese government and resolve the immediate challenges around export control licenses. This is essential to prevent production stoppages in our industries,' he adds. Also Read | 'No longer any question..': Donald Trump says China's Xi Jinping has agreed to let rare earth minerals flow to US; sign of thawing tensions What India is doing India is currently negotiating with China regarding the procurement of permanent magnets made from rare earth minerals, whilst simultaneously exploring alternative supply channels for these vital components, according to commerce and industry minister Piyush Goyal. The minister confirmed that the administration maintains regular communication with domestic industry stakeholders to accelerate the development of indigenous sources. "There is a concern... our embassy is in dialogue with them (China)... commerce and industry ministry is also working," Goyal said, adding that the government had already begun work on developing alternate sources. The minister addressed concerns regarding China's halt on permanent magnet exports to India, acknowledging its impact on the automotive sector, white goods and other industries. He mentioned that whilst some companies have submitted applications, they anticipate favourable responses for permanent magnet approvals. Additionally, the government is collaborating with Indian Rare Earths Ltd to accelerate domestic resource development, Goyal stated. When questioned about potential production-linked incentive schemes for magnets, Goyal confirmed discussions with the automotive industry and expressed confidence in finding a solution. He noted that ongoing dialogues with innovators and startups indicate their willingness to support funding requirements and price adjustments necessary to stimulate sector growth and expansion. Also Read | Economy in dire straits, India's Indus Waters Treaty blow: Can Pakistan avoid the 'begging bowl'? Regarding alternative solutions, the minister highlighted potential technological developments within India. Goyal emphasised the collaborative efforts between government, industry, startups and innovators. He acknowledged possible short-term challenges but expressed confidence in achieving success over medium to long-term periods. Goyal recently said that the world must acknowledge the dangers of critical minerals and their supply chains being concentrated in a few geographies, as this concentration could impede economic progress of countries. He said that India has initiated measures, including support for startups conducting research and development, to discover innovative and alternative solutions, he noted. This will help reduce "our over dependence and over reliance on certain critical minerals," Goyal said. Critical minerals like copper, lithium, nickel, cobalt and rare earth elements play a vital role in advancing clean energy technologies. These critical minerals are fundamental components in the manufacturing of wind turbines, electricity networks, electric vehicles and batteries. As countries worldwide accelerate their shift towards clean energy, the requirement for these essential minerals continues to rise. The government's initiative for recycling critical minerals, including copper, lithium, nickel, cobalt and rare earth elements, is approaching its conclusive phase, according to a mines ministry official's statement. The National Critical Mineral Mission (NCMM) has received Rs 1,500 crore in the Union budget for recycling critical minerals, Dinesh Mahur, Joint Secretary in the Mines Ministry has said. The government's earlier approval of the National Critical Mineral Mission, with a budget of Rs 16,300-crore and a total allocation of Rs 34,300 crore distributed across seven years, aims to boost self-sufficiency and expedite India's shift towards green energy. The mission, which seeks to encourage exploration of critical minerals domestically and in offshore regions, anticipates a substantial contribution of Rs 18,000 crore from public sector enterprises. The primary aims of this initiative include enhancing exploration activities, lessening dependence on imports, securing mineral deposits abroad, advancing processing technologies for these crucial minerals and establishing recycling mechanisms. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store