‘Nuclear option' to close nursing homes must be used, says Taoiseach
The 'nuclear option' to close
nursing homes
for significant failings 'has to be on the table',
Taoiseach Micheál Martin
has said, describing it as a 'fundamental power' of the
Health Information and Quality Authority
(Hiqa), the monitoring body.
Mr Martin told the Dáil it was up to the
Health Service Executive
'to resolve the consequential crisis that occurs when a decision to close is made.
'But we shouldn't baulk from that decision because of that.'
He was responding to Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald and Labour leader Ivana Bacik, who highlighted what they said was a lack of power at Hiqa.
READ MORE
Wednesday's debate followed the publication of Hiqa's interim report on the Emeis Ireland nursing homes – Beneavin Manor in Dublin and The Residence in Portlaoise on Tuesday night. Both featured in the recent RTÉ Investigates programme.
Mr Martin said there were some 'very disturbing clear facts' in the report, citing the non-adherence to fire regulations.
'Now, to me, that's a red alarm,' he said, adding that when fundamental issues like the health and safety of residents are at stake, then closure is an option.
[
Taoiseach Micheál Martin's Cork office vandalised amid 'personal threats'
Opens in new window
]
Ms McDonald said it was clear Emeis did not fear Hiqa.
'Quite frankly, they didn't give a toss about regulations or inspections,' she said.
'Little wonder, because Hiqa's hands are tied behind its back. They don't have the legal power to impose fines. The corporate entities that own these nursing homes are out of their reach. And Hiqa badly needs new powers'.
She asked how it took an RTÉ programme to expose a scandal when the report showed there were 198 allegations of abuse at a single nursing home.
Opposition smells blood in the water over RPZ changes
Listen |
35:51
The Dublin Central TD said 20 years ago, 30 per cent of nursing homes were in private hands but that had since risen to 80 per cent.
During testy exchanges, Mr Martin said Hiqa's powers had been broadened since 2017 and stressed that 'if there is a series of noncompliance as seems to be the case in respect of the interim report of Hiqa', the option of closure 'should be on the table'.
Ms McDonald said the culture of abuse 'was obviously endemic, hard-wired into the operation of the homes, and went on for a very long time'.
Ms Bacik said trust in the model of private and for-profit nursing home care 'has been shattered' since the RTÉ programme and that 'faith in the system of inspections has also been greatly damaged', requiring Government action.
[
Ireland's EuroMillions winner bought their €250 million winning ticket in Munster
Opens in new window
]
The presentations of Hiqa's chief executive and inspectors at Wednesday morning's Oireachtas health committee had raised more questions than answers, she argued, claiming the chief inspector had been 'frankly evasive' when asked about reports of abuse in a third nursing home.
Mr Martin said the power to cancel nursing home registrations existed and that it had been used in eight cases last year. 'It can and has happened,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Draft occupied territories Bill not expected to cover banning trade in services, says Frances Black
Independent Senator Frances Black has said she expects draft Government legislation banning trade with illegally occupied Palestinian territories will not cover trade in services. The Government has indicated it will publish draft legislation before the end of this month, but has indicated its legal advice is against extending this to trade in services and instead focusing on trade in goods. Ms Black, who first published legislation seeking to curtail trade with the territories in 2018, also said she hopes to be called before the Committee on Foreign Affairs, where she will make the case for the legislation to cover services. Tánaiste Simon Harris, who will bring the legislation to Cabinet next week, has indicated an openness to considering amendments on trade in services if they are brought forward during the legislative process. READ MORE Mr Harris indicated earlier this week that the general scheme – an outline of the legislation – will go to Cabinet next week, which Taoiseach Micheál Martin reiterated at a meeting of his parliamentary party on Wednesday evening. On Tuesday, the Tánaiste said the Bill 'just needs a little bit of final work from a legal point of view' before going to Cabinet next week. Once that is published, it will be sent to the Oireachtas Foreign Affairs committee for pre-legislative scrutiny, a process which is expected to take around two to three weeks to complete. 'I don't think there'll be services in the general scheme, and that's where the debate will be in the Foreign Affairs committee, that's my expectation, that it won't be in,' Ms Black told The Irish Times on Wednesday. She said that her hope was that legal experts whose view is that the inclusion of services is legal will be asked before the committee to give evidence. [ Government wants to pass Bill banning trade with occupied Palestinian territories 'this summer' Opens in new window ] The inclusion of services could potentially mean tech and finance companies which conduct business in the occupied territories. Earlier this week, five separate international legal challenges were launched against Airbnb, the short-term lettings platform, which pro-Palestinian and human rights activists say is currently managing more than 300 holiday lettings in the West Bank. Elsewhere, Mr Harris told his parliamentary party meeting that the escalation in hostilities between Israel and Iran cannot distract from the situation in Gaza, where he said children are starving and humanitarian aid is not getting through. Mr Harris also told his TDs and Senators that the return of AIB to full private ownership is a 'milestone moment' and contrasted it with 2011 'when the entire banking sector was destroyed and the IMF were in town following reckless economic mismanagement'. Mr Martin told the Fianna Fáil meeting that the Government would consider proposals next week arising from the Dublin City Taskforce report, which would include funding for key initiatives including a special-purpose vehicle to partner with site owners to 'transform' the O'Connell Street area. He also welcomed the expansion of the rent pressure zones (RPZs) agreed by Cabinet last week and the granting of additional powers to the Land Development Agency, which got Government approval this week.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘This isn't about race or colour. This is about our community': Locals protest at sale of Citywest Hotel
Approximately 100 residents from the Saggart area staged a protest against the sale of the Citywest Hotel to the Government for permanent use as asylum seeker accommodation. It was the third night of protests outside the hotel which the Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has said will now be purchased by the State for €148 million. On Friday residents staged a convoy through the village passing Citywest. They escalated it to a peaceful protest outside the gates on Tuesday and Wednesday evening. The 764-bed hotel and conference centre has been leased by the State since 2020. It was initially used as a Covid-19 testing and vaccination centre before, in 2022, being converted to an accommodation and processing facility for asylum seekers and Ukrainian refugees. READ MORE Locals claim to have gathered more than 8,000 signatures going door-to-door in Saggart, Rathcoole and Citywest. 'Ninety per cent of the doors we called to signed that petition. It shows that 90 per cent of people in the areas around here do not want this,' said Amanda Higgins. Locals say Saggart has doubled in size since 2011 and the population went up by 46 per cent in the census between 2016 and 2022, but it does not have the facilities to cope with demand. The village has one pub, two restaurants and no hotel, a small Dunnes Stores and a small Centra. They fear they will lose access on the Citywest site to the gym and swimming pool, though the Government has stated that those facilities will remain open to the public. One woman said there is a large Indian community living locally which is supporting the protests on the basis that the permanent loss of the amenity will be detrimental to all residents. 'This isn't about race or colour. This is about our community. We are making a stand together,' she said. [ State to purchase Citywest hotel for €148m and use it as asylum seeker accommodation Opens in new window ] Mia Colgan said locals accepted its status as a Covid-19 centre, then as a centre for processing Ukrainian refugees and its current status as both an International Protection Accommodation Service (IPAS) centre and a place for Ukrainian refugees. But they would not accept the permanent loss of the hotel as a facility for the local community without any other hotel locally. 'We were told we were going to get this and going to get that. It has never transpired. They had a duty of care to the residents and they have not discharged it,' she said. 'Now they are saying five years down the road when they want to take the hotel out forever out of the public amenities, now we will discuss it with you. It's too little too late. 'We are asking for dignity for everybody and for the Government to do their job. The Government is not being transparent. It is riding roughshod over everybody.' She queried why the State was paying €148 million for Citywest when it was sold by Nama for €30 million in 2013.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Afghans among 197 children deported from Ireland so far this year
Afghanistan was one of the 'top' countries of origin for almost 200 children deported from Ireland between January and May this year. The Government deported 197 children during the first five months of 2024, according to figures released in response to a parliamentary question from Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon. Of these, 148 were aged 13 and under and 49 were teenagers between the ages of 14 and 17. Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan said that no unaccompanied child was deported, and that children and their mothers were not detained before deportation. The latest figures mark an increase from the 191 children deported in 2024, 27 in 2023, and three in 2022. Afghanistan was one of the 'top' countries of origin for children deported so far this year, along with Nigeria, Georgia, Brazil and South Africa, according to the Department of Justice. Afghan deportations were 'cases where there has been a lack of co-operation with the international protection process, such as when a person does not attend interviews or make representations that they and their family should be granted permission to remain in Ireland', the department said. In these cases, there was 'no alternative' but to make a deportation order. READ MORE Mr Gannon said children made up 14 per cent of those deported so far this year, despite only accounting for 7 per cent of all deportation orders issued since 2023. Children are being 'disproportionately targeted', he said. 'Most of these kids have been here for years. They're in our schools, in our communities, Ireland is the only home they know. They're facing the consequence of deportation, to countries they have no meaningful ties to, not because of anything they've done, but because the State didn't plan or staff the international protection system properly.' Ireland recorded the highest European increase in asylum-seeking child arrivals between 2023 and 2024, according to a new report from Save the Children. The number of migrant children to arrive in the State rose 81 per cent from 2,880 in 2023 to 5,225 in 2024. Slovenia, Malta, Poland and Greece also recorded significant increases in child arrivals. Last year, nearly a quarter of the 254,900 first-time asylum applications made in European countries came from children. Of these, more than a fifth came from Syria and 13 per cent were Afghan. Some 43,300 children who came to Europe in 2024 seeking asylum were unaccompanied, said Save the Children. The report warns children arriving at European borders face systematic abuse and detention as countries tighten migration controls in advance of the implementation of the EU Pact on Migration and Asylum next year. The pact, which promises to balance stronger border security with greater migrant protection, risks failing to safeguard children, particularly unaccompanied minors, the report warns. [ Five children among 35 people deported to Nigeria on chartered flight Opens in new window ] Testimonies from migrant children shine a light on these harrowing journeys, during which they must rely on smugglers and are exposed to violence and exploitation. A 15-year-old Syrian recalled how 'every second we thought we would die' when crossing from Turkey to Greece across the Aegean Sea on a boat crammed with people. 'Whenever the water splashed over the side, we thought that we were going to die. I was scared, every second.' Another Syrian 15-year-old migrant described how Serbian police slapped and beat boys who were held in prison for two weeks. 'We went a whole day without any food or water. We had to drink water from the toilet as we were shut in this tiny room, as wide as my arms and three metres long. We were five people in that same cell.' In 2024, Germany received the highest number of children applying for asylum for the first time (84,315), followed by France (40,845), Spain (29,740), Greece (18,000) and Italy (12,215), according to Eurostat. However, the overall number of first-time asylum applications across Europe fell by 13 per cent between 2023 and 2024. Greece witnessed a fourfold increase in the number of migrant children arriving across its borders, with 86 per cent aged under 15. Many of these children endure 'perilous journeys' from countries such as Syria, Afghanistan and Somalia before facing stays in 'restrictive, detention-like conditions in reception camps across the Aegean Islands and the Greek mainland', notes the report. Pushbacks and arbitrary detention remain in practice across the region, it adds. The Polish-Belarusian border, an increasingly common migratory route for unaccompanied children, remains a 'hotspot for serious human rights violations', with children on the Belarusian side subjected to 'physical and psychological abuse – beaten, attacked by dogs, stripped of clothing and shoes, and deprived of identity documents', said the report.
