Can homeowners association stop former NYPD officer from flying 'thin blue line' flag?
Live in a home governed by a condominium, co-op or homeowner's association? Have questions about what they can and cannot do? Ryan Poliakoff, an attorney and author based in Boca Raton, has answers.
Question: I am having a problem with my HOA about the 3 feet by 5 feet thin blue stripe American flag that flies over my garage. I am a retired NYPD officer, and the blue stripe represents the officers who lost their lives in the line of duty. I have been flying that flag for about 10 years and have never been told that it is an unacceptable flag.
I received an email on Friday from the HOA telling me that my flag must be removed because it is not authorized because they only allow the official flag of the United States, not larger than 4.5 feet by 6 feet, as well as the Florida, Army, POW, Marine Corps, Coast Guard or Air Force flag. Banners or any other flags are prohibited. I attached a photo of the flag that they are complaining about which is an American flag. Can you please tell me if they can make me remove that American flag and fly one only without the blue stripe? Thank you for any information you can provide. Signed, L.S.
Dear L.S.,
The HOA Act was amended to expand the types of flags that may not be restricted by HOAs.
An association may not prohibit a homeowner from displaying up to two flags, not larger than 4.5 feet by 6 feet, as follows: the US flag, the State of Florida flag, a flag representing the US Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, Space Force, or Coast Guard, a POW-MIA flag and, importantly, a 'first responder' flag.
A first responder flag is a flag that recognizes law enforcement officers, firefighters, paramedics or EMS technicians, correctional officers, 911 public safety communications, nurses, persons in a statewide urban search and rescue program, and federal law enforcement officers. Such flags may incorporate the design of any other flag permitted under this law to form a combined flag.
I think there's no real question that this law was intended to protect flags like yours.
To describe your flag to readers, imagine a regular American flag, but remove the red line from the right of the starfield and the white and red line below, and replace them with a navy blue stripe, a royal blue stripe, and another navy blue stripe. That is a flag that incorporates the design of the American flag and modifies it to recognize law enforcement. I do not think it can be restricted by your HOA.
I will mention though, for your interest, that your flag likely violates the US Flag Code. Now, that law is just advisory, and your flag is not illegal. But the Flag Code prohibits defacing an American flag, and taking a regular American flag and changing three of the stripes would violate the letter of that code.
It is more common to see thin blue line flags that are black and white other than the blue stripe; and the reason for this is because when the flag colors are changed that drastically, the flag is no longer a true American flag, and so the Flag Code no longer applies at all.
Again, the Code is entirely permissive, and you have a right to fly whatever type of American flag the law otherwise allows (and it is not something that would offend me, personally). I simply mention it for the interest of readers who may raise the question of whether yours or other thin blue line flags are 'legal' (they're all legal, because the Flag Code is not an enforceable law — but the black and white law enforcement flag is more common for the reasons described above).
Question: When a condominium has a rule stating that owners can rent only one time in a 12-month period, is there any precedent for what happens if the tenant dies only a few months into a lease? Can the condominium tell the owner that they cannot rent again until the end of the 12-month period? That seems extremely unfair to the owner. Signed, M.M.
Dear M.M.,
There is no guidance on this as far as I'm aware, and it's something that happens all the time in different contexts. For example, tenants can also just vacate leases early, and it would create the same situation (although perhaps with a bit less sympathy). I also see this a lot with leasing provisions that require owners to serve a leasing moratorium when they first purchase a unit — what happens if there is a tenant in that unit when it transfers? Do they have to kick the tenant out? And is that fair to the tenant who has been happily residing in the condominium, sometimes for many years?
There are no answers to these issues.
When I draft provisions like this, I will often incorporate language dealing with the leasing moratorium, specifically. But with respect to the situation you describe, I think that's just a case of being out of luck, and an example of restrictions like this not always being fair.
Ryan Poliakoff, a partner at Poliakoff Backer, LLP, is a Board Certified specialist in condominium and planned development law. This column is dedicated to the memory of Gary Poliakoff. Ryan Poliakoff and Gary Poliakoff are co-authors of "New Neighborhoods — The Consumer's Guide to Condominium, Co-Op and HOA Living." Email your questions to condocolumn@gmail.com. Please be sure to include your location.
This article originally appeared on Palm Beach Post: HOA challenges ex-NYPD cop for flying 'thin blue line' American flag
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
an hour ago
- Chicago Tribune
Native wisteria vines are a beautiful blue
What's a native vine that can cover a trellis or fence with June flowers the purply-blue color of a country sky just before dawn? Wisteria, that's what. Specifically, it's American wisteria (), which is native to the Southeastern states, including far southern Illinois. 'It's hardy to USDA Zone 5 and 6, which includes Chicago and its suburbs,' said Spencer Campbell, Plant Clinic manager at The Morton Arboretum in Lisle. It climbs a large steel trellis in the Arboretum's Grand Garden. Gardeners may be more familiar with other species that are now considered invasive in the United States, Chinese wisteria () and Japanese wisteria (). These Asian species spread very easily to natural areas, where their vigorous growth smothers native plants. 'We should not plant those vines,' Campbell said. 'But American wisteria is just as lovely, and it's a native plant that provides nectar and pollen to native insects.' American wisteria and the closely related Kentucky wisteria () are woody vines, with a main stem like a tree trunk, and are deciduous, meaning they lose their leaves in winter. They have glossy dark green leaves and produce large, drooping clusters of pealike, lightly fragrant flowers in late May or early June. The flowers of both native species are blue to purple, but white-flowering cultivated varieties have been introduced. Although American wisteria and Kentucky wisteria are less aggressive than the Asian species, they are still vigorous and can eventually grow 25 to 30 feet long if not controlled by pruning. The woody stems and branches will be heavy, so the vines need a very sturdy support. Wisteria climbs by sending out tendrils — slender curling stems — that curl around a support, the way a clematis vine does. 'The tendrils need to find something small enough that they can reach around it, so your trellis or fence should have wires or mesh or bars that are not too wide,' Campbell said. 'Wisteria can't climb a blank wall.' These plants need full sun for best flowering, so plant them in a spot that gets six to eight hours of sunlight a day. They prefer a moist, well-drained, slightly acidic soil, with mulch over their roots. Wisteria will need pruning every year, both to control its size and to encourage flowering. Just after the plant finishes blooming, prune excess growth back to 6 inches. These stems will continue growing and flower buds will form on them. In winter, cut them again so that each stem has two to three flower buds left. Planting American or Kentucky wisteria will be an investment of time and effort. 'You'll have to erect the right kind of support and you'll have to wait a few years before the vines are mature enough to flower,' Campbell said. If you have the patience to wait, you can be surrounded by the green shade of a splendid vine with blooms of wisteria blue.
Chicago Tribune
11 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Pope Leo XIV encourages peace and harmony at Chicago's Rate Field celebration
Pope Leo XIV spoke directly to the young people scattered throughout the audience at Rate Field Saturday afternoon, telling them that they are the 'promise of hope' and that the world looks to them to help spread a message of peace and harmony among all people. 'We have to look beyond our own, if you will, egotistical ways. We have to look for ways of coming together and promoting the message of hope,' Pope Leo XIV said in a video broadcast across the stadium. 'St. Augustine says to us that if we want the world to be a better place, we have to begin with ourselves. We have to begin with our own lives, our own hearts.' The recently elevated pontiff and South Side native shared a message of unity and hope to the thousands of faithful at a celebration of his election Saturday afternoon at Rate Field in the Bridgeport neighborhood. Around the stadium, the audience listened raptly to the approximately 10-minute video from the Chicago-born pope. Pope Leo XIV encouraged those in attendance and others watching online to build community and friendship in their daily lives and in their parishes, especially after the isolation during the COVID-19 pandemic. He said many people who suffer from depression or sadness 'can discover that the love of God is truly healing.' 'When I see each and every one of you, when I see how people gather together to celebrate their faith and discover myself how much hope there is in the world,' Leo said. Aside from a personal message from the pope, the event, which had a $5 ticket price, featured music, prayer and a 4 p.m. Mass. There was a performance of both the U.S. and Peruvian national anthems to honor Pope Leo XIV's ties to both countries, and speeches from various faith leaders, including the Rev. John Merkelis, a high school classmate of the pope's and president of Providence Catholic High School. The night before the conclave began, Merkelis said he emailed Leo and told him 'Whatever happens, I'll still like (you).' The pope responded that 'He's sleeping well because an American is not going to be a pope.' When Pope Leo XIV was ultimately selected, Merkelis said everyone in the Providence faculty lounge started cheering and crying. 'He's a prayerful man, and having said all that, he's a regular guy. He'll change your oil. He'll fix your carburetor. He'll play Wordle,' Merkelis said. 'He's just a down-to-earth guy who's very smart, very prayerful, and I believe he will bring those same qualities to all the issues he faces.' Merkelis said he's still having trouble wrapping his head around the fact that someone whom he's eaten pizza and had a beer with is now the pope, but that he's 'so excited' for the city and that his friend was 'destined to lead.' He said Pope Leo XIV comforted him when his father died decades ago, and that he's a 'sensitive man.' 'He plays Wordle with his brother, and I'm on a team of people that play Wordle. So we made this vow that every time we post on Wordle we're going to write 'pray for Leo,'' Merkelis recounted. 'I sent him the screenshot of all our responses, and just a few days ago he emailed back and said thanks for the prayers.' Sister Dianne Bergant, a former teacher of Pope Leo XIV's at the Catholic Theological Union, where he earned his master's in divinity, said he was a good student, which she can prove because she didn't throw out her grade lists. The crowd laughed when she said his success must speak to the quality of the city's education. 'Everyone is involved. Everyone belongs to church. Everyone is a missionary in a very real sense, and that's the theology on which he grew,' she said. Robert Prevost, a missionary who became the first American to helm the Catholic Church, was born in 1955 at Mercy Hospital in the Bronzeville neighborhood, and grew up in south suburban Dolton with his parents and two brothers. He attended school and served as an altar boy at St. Mary of the Assumption parish on the Far South Side, where one classmate remembered him as the 'pride and joy of every priest and nun.' He's also a longtime White Sox fan. The pope donned a White Sox baseball cap as he met newly wedded couples in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican on Wednesday, and his brief appearance during the television broadcast of Game 1 of the 2005 World Series resurfaced and went viral. 'Pope Leo defines and represents the fabric and the heartbeat of the city of Chicago,' said Brooks Boyer, the White Sox's senior vice president, who also invited him back to Rate Field to throw a ceremonial first pitch. People flooded into the stadium hours before the program began. Many wore White Sox memorabilia, and several 'Da Pope' shirts were seen. Mike Donatelli, 67, had the best of both worlds — a White Sox jersey with 'Pope Leo' on the back. Donatelli now lives in the Loop, but he said he grew up on the South Side and he thinks it's incredible that someone who was basically a neighbor is now the leader of the Catholic Church. 'Same type of education system, we're the same age,' Donatelli said. 'One of my best friends from the Air Force Academy went to grade school with him … and said he was a great guy.' Donatelli said he's particularly drawn to the pope's humility and sense of humor. He thought it was clever when the pope joked that 'we can't invite Sinner' during a meeting with the tennis star Jannik Sinner. Donatelli, the former head of the Delta Air Line Pilots Association, also respects the pope's nod to workers in the selection of his name. 'He's already mentioned that we're all humans,' Donatelli said. 'We all have the same interests, especially for families. We just want to do the right thing and get ahead.' Miguel Vargas, 60, said he's also inspired that the new pope is from the Chicago area. He believes Chicagoans will follow the pope's lead and become ambassadors of what it means to be a good Catholic — united and peaceful. 'Since we are seeing a lot of things going on right now, we have to pray more and more,' Vargas said. 'We're here to pray for (Leo) and for the whole church.' Vargas, a Hoffman Estates resident, said he was born in Mexico and moved to the U.S. when he was 17. He said he's 'embraced the American Dream' ever since. 'The American Dream for me is not the money, but the faith,' he said.
Buzz Feed
12 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
38 Photos That Scream "American Public Schools"
Welcome to America, where you can't even escape the capitalist hellscape that is the United States at school! Cool, I'll make sure to only get sick during certain times of the school day. My middle school was like this, but much worse — the health office was closed, like, every other hour. One time I was about to throw up in chorus so I went to the nurse's office and it was just closed. "About to vomit" was not under "emergencies," so I just had to go BACK TO CLASS and hope I didn't puke on everyone. I'm unsure how effective this quote is at promoting success, but I know it doesn't promote accessibility. Having a massive bag check line every morning seems way more safe and convenient than, I don't know, actual gun safety laws. I mean, clearly, safety is a big priority at schools. You gotta love how schools won't let women wear tank tops because it's "distracting," but they'll pull a stunt like this. How the heck is this school getting away with making parents BUY their kids' artwork? Especially when, most of the time, the parents are buying all the supplies needed to make said artwork and schoolwork. Or the teachers are, and you can bet that the school isn't collecting money from parents to give to teachers. No, they're using money for stuff like this. definitely not using funds on teachers. Just in case it's not clear, teachers are not the enemy in this post. Where are our taxes going if not the basic essentials??? Seriously, where are our tax dollars going?!?! Don't you love the way the government supports learning? At American schools, we apparently take away bathroom doors. This school bathroom literally doesn't even have stall doors. I swear schools have a vendetta against bathrooms. Like, what is this??? Would they really rather you pee your pants in class? This school literally FINES students who "take too long" in the bathroom. What if I have to poop??? I literally shudder when I think about the food our cafeteria served. How are nachos lunch???? I actually think this "meal" might be alive. At least schools require milk with lunch, which gets you the calcium needed for the day! Is this really necessary??? Is it? Why the heck are class schedules organized this way? My school also had three or four minutes between class periods, and it still infuriates me. I literally didn't use my locker because there wasn't time to go between classes, so I'd carry all my books and binders around all day. And that whole "go to the bathroom on your own time" thing? How are we supposed to make it to class AND go to the bathroom in three or four minutes, especially when the teacher says, "the bell doesn't dismiss you; I do"?Can you tell I have pent-up rage about high school? Your taxes pay for public school but not lunch, apparently, and some schools are fine seeing kids go without. The standards at some schools are ridiculous. My favorite is "You won't get away with this in college." Reader — you will, in fact, get away with it in college. Now we have the fun new challenge of being accused of using AI in our essays. I just want to see if there's a booger in my nose!!!! Are you supposed to take a shit next to Frank from third-period English???? Forget about crossing streams. This is a whole new level. The fact that this isn't even the worst school bathroom on the list is horrifying. Babe, wake up, new "frivolous errand" just dropped: ESSENTIAL BODILY FUNCTIONS. At the end of the day, is it really SO AWFUL that some kids leave class and walk the halls instead of actually going to the bathroom? Is it really worth making everyone suffer to prevent this? It's not just students (some of whom are literally 18 and adults) who are being treated like kids; it's parents, too. You gotta love the way schools have incorporated technology into their curriculum. It's definitely foolproof and way better than traditional paper homework. And the equipment is never broken! I swear, we could've gotten a whole other lesson in the time it took my teacher to boot up the Smart Board every class. Privacy issues at school? Unthinkable! And finally, at least follow your own rules, Wikipedia haters! What was the most infuriating part of your public school? Let us know in the comments!
