Brits' favourite shopping app Temu 'makes a fortune from wrecking our planet'
Experts claim Chinese firm Temu is causing a toxic carbon footprint by flying in cheap products to the UK in under a week - as well as adding to our throwaway culture
Experts have issued a warning over the huge environmental cost of cut-price goods sold by one of the world 's fastest growing websites. Temu (pronounced tee-moo) is an online marketplace and app - dubbed Amazon on steroids - that stocks millions of products at rock-bottom prices and claims it can help you 'shop like a billionaire'.
It connects shoppers with third party sellers mainly based in China. But experts say it is creating a toxic carbon footprint by flying in cheap clothes, toys, make-up and other goods from its warehouses in China. Environmental scientist and founder of One Home, Angela Terry, said: "Flying is the worst way we can transport goods. If you do need to buy new products it is important to use sustainable firms that are as local as possible. Firms like Temu are making a fortune from wrecking our planet."
A Mirror investigation has found how items can be at your door in less than a week. I ordered 10 items for £25.34, including two dresses, a lipstick, five pairs of socks and a dust pan and brush with no delivery fee. You can also buy a banana slicer and a lavatory roll holder that looks like a Polaroid camera.
But each 5,500-mile flight from China to London pumps out 175 tonnes of carbon emissions - the same as driving a car more than 560,000 miles.
Dr Patsy Perry from the Manchester Fashion Institute at Manchester Metropolitan University said: 'We have seen a greater shift to air freight in fashion as speed is so important for retailers to be competitive in meeting consumer expectations for fast delivery of on-trend items. Flights are much more carbon-intensive than shipping, but that also contributes a lot to our carbon footprint overall.'
She added: 'If we buy cheap fast fashion items from such websites but then decide they are then not suitable, it is also unlikely they will be returned due to the cost. Once disposed of the environmental damage of that freight journey was unnecessary, as well adding to our increasing problem of textile waste.
'Cheaply-made plastic household goods may not last long so are more likely to be disposed of, encouraging a throwaway culture and adding to our plastic waste crisis.'
Last year Temu was the most popular mobile shopping app in the UK, amassing more than 16 million downloads that year. Chinese rival SHEIN - the ultra fast-fashion firm - was second at around eight million downloads.
A relentless social media advertising blitz has helped Temu amass this vast customer base by selling T-shirts for just 68p on Black Friday. Many items can be up to 80 per cent cheaper than comparable goods on Amazon. Last year we imported £65bn worth of goods from China, with clothing making up nearly £3.5bn.
Founded in 2022, Temu is owned by conglomerate PDD Holding and keeps shoppers hooked on its app with games as well as a constant cycle of flash sales. There are now more than twice as many UK consumers regularly using Temu's app than there are using those of Amazon or eBay, according to data from market intelligence firm Sensor Tower.
Consumer group Which? Said: 'Temu has exploded in popularity thanks to its prices but also its marketing strategy, which focuses on encouraging users to promote the app and its products. It has created a huge buzz by combining referrals, social media and a gamified way of shopping. Users can also share their referral links or codes on social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram and TikTok.'
This appears to have made its way to reviews of the platform itself. When Which? checked reviews of Temu on Trustpilot in September 2023, a large number of those giving it five stars shared referral codes that allowed them to earn credits.
Another advantage Temu has is that, as an ecommerce firm delivering to the West, it's exempt from export duties in China. Products, which are also incredibly cheap, nearly always escapes UK import duty, which only applies to orders worth £135 or more.
China-founded fast-fashion retailer Shein operates a similar business model by shipping low-value, individually packaged consignments directly to customers' homes. The firm is currently lobbying Chancellor Rachel Reeves to float on the stock market this year.
Online shopping giant Temu has also come under fire after a controversial advert showing cats being roughly handled during grooming sparked outrage among animal experts and celebrities.
The now-deleted Instagram clip showed cats being vigorously brushed with a rubber grooming mitt, with one feline clearly flinching as the tool was aggressively dragged through its fur at speed. In another scene, a tabby cat appeared visibly uncomfortable as clumps of fur were piled on its head for comedic effect.
Katie Gwilt, who runs the Kat Lady holistic grooming business, slammed the video and said: 'This advert is completely inappropriate. It could encourage people to be rough with their pets, causing them unnecessary stress and discomfort.'
Last year Alicia Kearns, chairwoman of the foreign affairs committee, said there was a risk some items were made with Uighur slave labour. Temu said the claims were 'unfounded.'
US lawmakers have warned 'there is an extremely high risk that Temu's supply chains are contaminated with forced labour' in a Congressional report published in June 2023. Since 2017, Chinese authorities in Xinjiang have detained an estimated one million Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims in 're-education camps', and it's believed hundreds of thousands of ex-detainees are living in forced labour camps.
Temu told the US Congress that it conducts no audits and reports no compliance system but says it has a zero-tolerance policy for the use of forced, indentured or penal labour.
A spokesperson for Temu told the Daily Mirror: "Good value doesn't have to mean poor, throwaway quality. We help UK shoppers save money by removing the middlemen—without cutting corners on quality. Our model lowers costs without lowering standards.
"We're moving more fulfilment closer to customers, with a target for 80% of European sales to be shipped from within the region. That means faster delivery and fewer emissions from long-haul transport."
In relation to the cat grooming, a spokesperson for Temu said: "We take all feedback seriously, and the ad has been taken down so we can review it internally."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
7 hours ago
- The Independent
Walmart and Amazon looking at creating their own cryptocoins as digital currencies popularity rises
Walmart and Amazon are looking to create stablecoins, a type of cryptocurrency, people familiar with the company's plans have said. Higher-ups at the company are hopeful the high volumes of cash and card transactions will save them billions in fees, according to reporting from The Wall Street Journal. The coins could limit the fees and immediately transfer money to retailers. Stablecoins are used to store cash or purchase other cryptocurrency tokens. The coins are backed by Treasuries and have a one-to-one exchange ratio with dollars or government currencies. Still, for the payment method to be implemented, lawmakers would need to pass the Genius Act, a piece of legislation that aims to establish a regulatory framework for stablecoins. The legislation would need to be approved by both the House and Senate. One trade group has been lobbying members of Congress to push for the legislation's passage. The regulatory framework for stablecoin, the Merchants Payments Coalition, said in talks it would allow merchants to utilize alternative payment methods that could significantly lower expenses. The news sent Visa and Mastercard stocks down about six percent on Friday. Visa was the worst performer on the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the S&P 500 close to noon. Still, it's not clear if competition between the coin makers and banks would be beneficial. Walmart is lobbying to include an amendment that would introduce more competition in the credit-card sector. Airlines and other companies like Expedia Group are also working to implement the payment system, sources told the outlet. It's not clear how the country's biggest banks would respond to the move from the two largest retail vendors. Cryptocurrencies are becoming more popular, with approximately six percent of the population owning one type of digital coin. A person familiar with the ongoing Amazon discussions said the company's plans are in the early stages, but there are talks of potentially using outside stablecoins. In a note this week, TD Cowen analyst Jaret Seiberg said the 'push to instant payments is inevitable and represents a risk' to Visa and Mastercard, according to the newspaper.
Economist
10 hours ago
- Economist
Can you pass the toughest tests in the world?
Civil-service exams in China and India are notoriously difficult. But they shape their countries' societies Max Weber, sensible German intellectual that he was, considered bureaucracy the best way to organise large societies. And societies don't come any larger than China and India, where the decisions of bureaucrats shape the lives of more than a quarter of the world's people. Even as the countries' private sectors have grown in recent decades, jobs in their civil services remain deeply coveted. Government jobs in India, especially in the federal services that run the country, remain a ticket to prosperity, prestige and better marriage prospects. In China, where the economy has slowed, securing a top-tier state job (known locally as 'landing ashore') is back in fashion—quite literally. Young people sometimes don 'cadre-style' attire—windbreakers in muted colours and high-waisted suit trousers—in order to emulate officials. But perhaps the biggest similarity between the two bureaucracies is the brutality of their selection processes, which hinge on a gruelling set of examinations. To give you a taste of the difficulty, The Economist has chosen some questions from the first part of recent exams. Have a go: Such questions are only a small part of a much larger process. In India those who pass the first exam in May or June must sit a second later in the year. This features nine papers taken over 27 hours. In China the written test takes place on one day in late November or early December. Candidates do a multiple-choice exam and then write a series of essays testing their understanding of policy, as well as their writing skills. Both countries hold in-person interviews as a final filter. Only a fraction survive the ordeal. Last year 1.1m people applied to join the top tier of India's civil service, but around 1,000 (0.2% of those who actually sat the first exam) were offered a spot. In China a record 3.41m people registered and passed the initial screening for the national civil-service exam last year—well over twice the number who did so in 2014. Just over 39,700 (1.5% of those who sat the exam) secured a job. In both countries the exams are considered the fairest way to filter candidates. Indeed, in India they were introduced by British colonial masters after Indians complained about the previous patronage-based system. In China, the guokao, as the exam is called, is modelled on the keju, which was instituted in 587 and was lauded for being relatively corruption-free and meritocratic. Candidates' ability to leapfrog social classes was so cherished that, say some academics, the riots that followed the exam's abolition in 1905 contributed to the toppling of the Qing dynasty, China's last imperial rulers, a few years later. The civil-service exam in China has shaped the country's evolution. The keju was the 'anchor of Chinese autocracy', according to Yasheng Huang, who has written a book about it. Mind-bogglingly difficult, it required total intellectual commitment, sometimes from the age of five, leaving the most talented and ambitious members of society no time to foment new ideas. Gui Youguang, a 16th-century writer, passed the exam's final stage aged 59, after decades of failed attempts, and died shortly after. The guokao, which can only be taken by those aged 35 or under, remains an important tool for the state. After China embarked on market reforms in the 1970s, the bureaucracy took on a more important role in a complex, open society. As a result, the guokao was tweaked to examine candidates' knowledge of laws and regulations. Over time the questions became more practical, testing common sense and numeracy. But in recent years the exam has also become a test of party loyalty, with ever more questions dedicated to Xi Jinping Thought. Chinese essay questions 'Dedicate yourself to your field, constantly 'refine' and 'repair', and silently contribute to a warm and steadfast order of life for the people, while progressing steadily.' Based on your understanding of this sentence, draw on real-life examples and experiences, choose your own angle and title, and write an essay. Write a report on the achievements, shortcomings and suggestions for improvement regarding the implementation of the Intangible Cultural Heritage Law. Conduct an in-depth analysis of the three dimensions of administrative law enforcement—'power' (力), 'reason' (理) and 'interest' (利). Draw on real-life examples and experiences, choose your own angle and title, and write an essay. India's civil service, in contrast, has remained relatively apolitical. After independence in 1947, leaders chose to retain the 'steel frame' of the Imperial Civil Service, but changed the role of the bureaucrats it hired from upholding colonial rule to ensuring development. By 1979 competition to enter the service was so fierce that a second set of exams was introduced to test candidates' breadth of knowledge. In 2012 a paper on ethics was added. India's civil service is associated with prestige—but also corruption. In a recent high-profile example, a young civil servant in the eastern state of Odisha was accused of accepting a bribe of 1m rupees ($11,683) from a businessman. Indian essay questions Is conscience a more reliable guide when compared to laws, rules and regulations in the context of ethical decision-making? Discuss. Child cuddling is now being replaced by mobile phones. Discuss its impact on the socialization of children. Thinking is like a game, it does not begin unless there is an opposite team. Discuss. Success in both exams requires immense toil. Many examinees do not work in the year, even years, leading up to the test; those holding down jobs end up studying early in the morning or late at night. Thousands seek the help of coaching centres; the best ones offer full-time training and board. Shikha Singh, for example, moved from a small town in central India to Delhi just to prepare for the exam surrounded by fellow aspirants. She has failed the test three times, but ramped up her efforts with each attempt. Ahead of her recent fourth try, Ms Singh put in ten-hour days, but worries that still might not be enough to cover the wide variety of subjects. In south-eastern China, Ms Zhong, a prospective civil servant from Jiangxi province, has put in similar shifts since quitting her job in 2023 and moving back in with her parents. Her concern is that preparation alone may not be enough in an exam that tests 'innate ability'. Even if they succeed, will their effort be worth it? Those who pass the exams reap instant and long-term benefits, such as housing and a pension (and often a job) for life. Once in their roles they are treated like royalty, with an army of staff to do their bidding and a special chair marked with a white towel. Research from India suggests some correlation between exam performance and effectiveness as a civil servant. But in both countries critics believe the exams filter candidates according to the wrong criteria. By screening for rote-learning and test-taking, they neglect to assess actual public-policy skills such as management, teamwork and communication. This contributes to the poor performance of the bureaucracy. On a measure of government effectiveness calculated by the World Bank, China and India rank in the 74th and 68th percentiles globally. In both countries efforts are under way to recruit people in other ways. China is experimenting with hiring some candidates for fixed terms according to their experience, rather than their exam performance. Similarly India has introduced a 'lateral-entry' scheme to allow private-sector specialists to join the public workforce. But these remain nascent initiatives. Exams will remain the backbone of public-sector recruitment. If the merits of this selection process are debatable, the costs—both human and economic—are more easily quantified. Aspirants who fail to meet the mark tend to try again. A cycle of application and rejection has an effect on morale: exam failure often pushes candidates to suicide in both countries. Ms Singh, the Indian candidate, feels she has lost social status because of her failed attempts. Her Chinese counterpart, Ms Zhong, is also weighed down by anxiety. 'Only a few people pass the exam,' she says. 'I wonder what those who fail do.' It is an important question. Years of youth spent in study, instead of work, are an economic loss. The exams force college graduates to delay employment, reducing their long-term consumption. And the subjects so feverishly swotted up late at night are not necessarily of use once the exams are over. Knowing big cats' biological intricacies or the details of Xi Jinping Thought might help candidates earn a civil servant's towel-covered chair—but perhaps not a place in the private sector.
Reuters
10 hours ago
- Reuters
Inter Milan set to early repay bond as plans new debt deal
MILAN, June 13 (Reuters) - Champions League finalist Inter Milan is set to repay early a 415 million euro ($479.57 million) high-yield bond this month as the Italian soccer club prepares to secure funds from a new debt deal, it said in a statement on Friday. Inter Milan paid a 6.75% coupon to place a five-year bond in 2022 to refinance Italy's top-flight soccer club's debt. The debt facility was issued by the Serie A club's media company, which manages the broadcast and sponsorship business of Inter Milan. The company plans to redeem the bond on June 26, subject to securing funds from a debt financing transaction by the business day before the redemption date, it said in a statement. Companies typically repay debt early to secure better financial conditions. Controlled by U.S. investment fund Oaktree (OAK_pa.N), opens new tab, Inter Milan was reportedly tapping private debt investors to refinance the debt facility. Oaktree took over the club last year after a missed 395 million euro payment from the then majority shareholder, Chinese conglomerate Suning ( opens new tab. ($1 = 0.8654 euros) (This story has been refiled to fix typos in paragraphs 1 and 5)
