First Nations people rally for housing as class action suit heard in Winnipeg
About 100 people rallied downtown as a class action lawsuit that accuses the federal government of failing to address the housing crisis on First Nations was front and centre in a Winnipeg courtroom Wednesday.
'Some of the houses are deplorable, they're not livable, and a lot of our people, they have no choice but to live there,' said St. Theresa Point First Nation Chief Raymond Flett outside the Anishininew Okimawin building on Broadway.
St. Theresa Point First Nation in Manitoba and Sandy Lake First Nation in northwest Ontario filed the suit in 2023. More than 100 First Nations have signed on. The case is being heard this week in federal court. The suit seeks $5 billion in damages.
ALEX LAMBERT / FREE PRESS
Rally participant Chloe Kakepetum (left) hugs Myrna Mawakeesic, who says she developed Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease because of the constant flooding her house gets every spring in Sandy Lake, Ont. The rally, in support of a lawsuit against the federal government, was at Anishininew Okimawin on Broadway.
Flett said Ottawa has failed to provide adequate housing on First Nations.
'A house, even though it's not that old, but the material used to build that house is cheap material — they don't last,' said Flett. 'Most of the houses only have two or three bedrooms… that is not right for us, a lot of families they have four adults, five children living in a house.'
He said its hard for residents to maintain houses in small communities because of the lack of resources.
'You have a broken door and want to fix it? We can't just go to the store and buy it,' Flett said. 'You have to fly it in, and that's extra, a lot of extra money that we don't have.'
Former St. Theresa Point chief Elvin Flett, and Toronto-based firm McCarthy Tétrault LLP filed a statement of claim in June 2023 that alleged Canada 'deliberately underfunded housing on reserves,' while simultaneously isolating First Nations by imposing restrictions on their ability to provide housing for themselves.
'They're the ones that put us in there in the first place, they have to honour that,' said Raymond Flett.
The chief wants to see an equal partnership with the Canadian government to improve housing and development. Flett said he is hopeful it will happen.
The statement of claim said of the 646 houses in St. Theresa Point, 25 per cent should be condemned due to severe decay and rotting. It also said more than half of the houses in Sandy Lake require major repairs.
One woman from Sandy Lake said she developed chronic obstructive pulmonary disease because of the poor condition her house is in. She said she has had trouble breathing for years because her house floods every spring.
'We want our kids to have better housing than what we have right now,' said Myrna Mawakeesic, 57, who was also part of the rally.
During Elections
Get campaign news, insight, analysis and commentary delivered to your inbox during Canada's 2025 election.
Another rallygoer said she wanted to help make a difference.
'Monkey see monkey do, when you see someone fighting for something that they like, then you'll get inspired by something you like,' said 18-year-old Kariya Kakepetum, who is also from Sandy Lake. 'What I love is my community.'
Canada argued in its 2024 statement of defence the country 'does not owe any legal obligations or duties to build and maintain houses on-reserve. The claim should be dismissed.'
St. Theresa Point, 465 kilometres northeast of Winnipeg, is one of four First Nations that make up the Island Lake region in northeastern Manitoba. The community of 5,200 people is accessible by plane or ice road for six weeks out of the year.
fpcity@freepress.mb.ca
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
11 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Ontario leaves out American banks from U.S.-dollar bond issuance in a first since 2011
For the first time in more than a decade, Ontario has issued a U.S.-dollar bond without the assistance of any U.S.-based banks. The province sold US$2-billion worth of 10-year bonds last week with the help of British banking giant Barclays PLC, according to Bloomberg data. Three Canadian banks also helped manage the latest provincial debt issue: BMO Capital Markets, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce and Bank of Nova Scotia. American banks have participated in every Ontario government U.S.-dollar bond sale since 2011, the data show. As recently as January of this year, the province sold US$3-billion worth of five-year bonds with the help of Bank of America Corp. Ontario Premier Doug Ford had previously committed to banning U.S. companies from government contracts in response to the continental trade war launched earlier this year by U.S. President Donald Trump. However, Ontario finance ministry spokesperson Scott Blodgett said there is currently no prohibition on U.S. banks participating in Ontario bond issues. In fact, Mr. Blodgett said, Bank of America remains a long-standing member of the banking syndicate that regularly assists with the sale of Ontario's domestic market bonds. 'U.S. banks were not 'dropped' from our bond sale,' he said in an e-mailed response to questions. 'Inclusion in any Ontario bond deal is a competitive process with financial partners around the globe vying for international mandates. As bond funds struggle as uncertainty grips the market, here are four for investors to consider 'Several factors, including dealer availability, indicative pricing, consistent quality coverage, and participation on recent transactions is considered. Rotation is also considered with respect to participation on past deals as well as future deals.' Last week's deal generated 'record interest for an Ontario 10-year USD deal,' Mr. Blodgett added. In early March, Mr. Ford pledged to ban U.S. companies from all Ontario procurement contracts until the Trump administration removes tariffs from Canadian goods. The policy has subsequently faced criticism for exempting American companies with at least 250 employees in Canada. For example, Bank of America, which boasts more than 1,000 Canadian employees working out of offices in Toronto, Montreal, Calgary and Vancouver, would qualify for such an exemption. Alberta also avoided using a U.S. bank for a recent bond deal. In March, the province sold €1.25-billion ($1.95-billion) worth of 10-year bonds with the help of Barclays, RBC Capital Markets and TD Securities, according to public data and provincial records. Alberta regularly taps Bank of America for its euro-denominated bond sales, though Marisa Breeze, spokesperson for provincial Finance Minister Nate Horner, said the change was not intentional. Opinion: Here's what really is going on in the bond market - and why I'm still very bullish 'There is no blanket ban on U.S.-based financial institutions,' Ms. Breeze said. 'The province is continuously monitoring and assesses the performance of the service providers employed for its funding activities and adjusts its borrowing syndicate based on that performance.' Meanwhile, at least one other province has continued openly using U.S. banks for its U.S.-dollar bond sales. Bank of America and Citigroup Inc. were both part of the syndicate behind a US$2.5-billion bond issued by British Columbia last week. That syndicate also included BMO Capital Markets, National Bank of Canada and TD Securities. 'The province's inclusion of U.S. banks aligns with market practice among other Canadian issuers,' B.C. finance ministry spokesperson Shantel Esplen said in an e-mail. 'B.C.'s approach is the same as the government of Ontario, who continues to follow a policy which does not rule out inclusion of U.S. banks.' Both the Canada Pension Plan and the federal government have also recently allowed U.S. banks to participate in their debt sales, Ms. Esplen said.
Calgary Herald
18 minutes ago
- Calgary Herald
John Ivison: Carney's new defence plan takes seriously the darker world we're now living in
Article content Justin Trudeau went to Washington for last year's NATO summit and unveiled what he called a 'credible, verifiable path' to spending two per cent of Canada's GDP on defence … by 2032. Article content The lack of urgency and ambition was reflected in the then prime minister's belief that two per cent is a 'nominal target' that makes for easy headlines but doesn't make Canadians more safe. Article content Article content Article content His disdain for military spending was apparent in a Washington Post story from 2023, when he reportedly told the Americans that Canada would never hit two per cent. Article content Article content If credibility is a leader's currency, Trudeau left the U.S. capital bankrupt in the eyes of many of Canada's allies. Mike Johnson, the House speaker, said Canada was riding on America's coattails and called it 'shameful.' Article content Mark Carney, who is heading for this year's NATO summit in The Hague later this month, clearly did not want a repeat of the Washington debacle, especially as NATO secretary-general Mark Rutte is proposing a new target of 3.5 per cent of economic output on military spending and another 1.5 per cent on 'defence-related expenditure.' Article content On Monday, Carney announced that Canada will hit the two per cent target this fiscal year, five years ahead of the schedule he set during the general election. Article content Article content Canada will spend an additional $9.3 billion this year in a defence package that is primarily focused on improving operational readiness. Article content Article content 'Canadian leadership will be defined not just by the strength of our values but also by the value of our strength,' Carney said, using another JFK-style antimetabole ('Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.'). Article content Last year, Trudeau expressed frustration that his government got no credit for doubling defence spending over his decade in power. 'We have stepped up massively,' he said. Article content Carney acknowledged the increase in spending over the past 10 years, but also pointed out Canada's defence deficiencies: aging infrastructure and equipment; just one submarine being seaworthy at any given time; and, only half the marine fleet and land vehicles being operational, leaving the military more reliant on the U.S. than ever.
Montreal Gazette
27 minutes ago
- Montreal Gazette
Letters: Why is Trump the felon allowed into Canada for G7 summit?
It seems impossible to observe next week's G7 summit in Kananaskis, Alta., without thinking of the mistreatment some Canadians and others have received at the hands of U.S. authorities. Consider the recent case of the Canadian woman jailed in Georgia in part for driving without a driver's licence though she held a valid Ontario licence. Or Trump's bellicose slanders against Latin Americans the U.S. deported to foreign lands in atrocious conditions without due process. Will Canadians receive U.S. President Donald Trump at the G7 with open arms or with elbows up? And why is Trump, a convicted felon, being allowed entry into Canada, which he is openly seeking to undermine? It is time to send a petition, signed by thousands, to the U.S. ambassador. It may well be that protests will occur in Alberta, but for those unable to make it, there must be other ways Canadians can express their discontent over the bully's arrival. Carl Hager, Gatineau CAQ ignores global realities Bill 84 smacks of de souche supremacy with Immigration Minister Jean-François Roberge's boast that Quebec's the new integration law relegates multiculturalism to the 'limbo of history.' The CAQ government seems determined to legislate against two immutable realities — that English is the lingua franca of the world and that multiculturalism is the way of the world. Instead of reckoning with these realities, Quebec is retreating into an ethnocentric enclave rather than facing a future framed by ever more global connectivity. It's as though Quebec has surrendered to its own self-absorption at the expense of a more expansive trajectory for la belle province. George McArthur, Montreal Garneau set lofty example Thank you to Peter F. Trent for a beautiful tribute to an exceptionally wonderful man. Marc Garneau was truly everything that is wonderful in a human being and exemplified all that is best in a Canadian. His passing leaves those who had the good fortune to meet him with much sadness, but also with the hope that others will be inspired to follow his path, particularly with his ease in French and English. One does not need one parent from each background, as he had. We need a proper education system with wonderful teachers throughout Canada who ensure everyone is perfectly fluent in French and English. Learning languages is easier at an early age — and at any age, is good for the mind and makes life more interesting and enjoyable. A truly bilingual Canada is a wonderful base for the many cultures that add to our mosaic. Where there is a will, there is a way, and it is more important than ever when we want to present a strong, united Canada forever. Sandra Sterling, Snowdon Submitting a letter to the editor Letters should be sent by email to letters@ We prioritize letters that respond to, or are inspired by, articles published by The Gazette. If you are responding to a specific article, let us know which one. Letters should be sent uniquely to us. The shorter they are — ideally, fewer than 200 words — the greater the chance of publication. Timing, clarity, factual accuracy and tone are all important, as is whether the writer has something new to add to the conversation. We reserve the right to edit and condense all letters. Care is taken to preserve the core of the writer's argument. Our policy is not to publish anonymous letters, those with pseudonyms or 'open letters' addressed to third parties. Letters are published with the author's full name and city or neighbourhood/borough of residence. Include a phone number and address to help verify identity; these will not be published. We will not indicate to you whether your letter will be published. If it has not been published within 10 days or so, it is not likely to be.
