Probe of crash of Mexican tall ship into Brooklyn Bridge centres on engine
The NTSB intended to talk with the tug boat pilot, harbour pilot, ship captain and other crew members. PHOTO: AFP
Probe of crash of Mexican tall ship into Brooklyn Bridge centres on engine
NEW YORK - The investigation into why a Mexican Navy training ship struck the Brooklyn Bridge on May 17, shearing the top of its masts, will look into a possible engine failure and the role of a tug boat that assisted it in backing out of its pier, officials said on May 19.
The ship's engine was the key focus for the National Transportation Safety Board, said Mr Brian Young, who is leading the agency's investigation.
"We will look at the status of the engine, we will look for any failures, we will look for engine inspections and we'll talk to the crew on what may have possibly happened with the engine," Mr Young said at a preliminary NTSB briefing.
He said investigators would also look for any electronic control data.
The accident occurred when the majestic white training vessel Cuauhtémoc was departing from Lower Manhattan's Pier 17 on the East River shortly after sunset on May 17.
The ship's planned route was south-ward, away from the Brooklyn Bridge and toward New York Harbour and her next destination in Iceland.
As it backed out of the pier, the ship was accompanied by a tug boat operated by McAllister Towing.
As it cleared the dock, the ship pivoted but continued to move swiftly in reverse in the direction of the bridge.
Minutes later, its three 44.8m masts hit the underside of the iconic 142-year-old bridge, causing them to partially collapse.
The strike knocked dozens of white-uniformed naval cadets off the ship's crossbeams, where they were standing ceremoniously for her exit from the harbor. They could be seen dangling from their harnesses high above the ship's deck.
Two people aboard the ship - a cadet and a sailor - were killed, and around 20 were injured, two of them critically.
Associate Professor Salvatore Mercogliano, a maritime historian at Campbell University, said it appeared that an engine malfunction caused the accident.
"Without the engine failure, the ship would have maybe drifted into the bridge, but it wouldn't have hit it at speed," Assoc Prof Mercogliano said.
"The engine failure drove the ship into the bridge. And it's not exactly clear what role the tug could have done to prevent that from happening."
Videos posted online showed the tug first pushing the bow of the ship, then separating from it as the vessel moved closer to the bridge.
It then appeared to rush toward the stern as if it intended to stop the ship from striking the bridge.
After the masts collapsed, the ship kept sailing under the bridge until it was stopped at an embankment on the Brooklyn side of the river, videos showed.
NTSB board member Michael Graham said the board had not yet conducted any interviews and intended to talk with the tug boat pilot, harbour pilot, ship captain and other crew members.
"We will be looking into three main areas... the crew and the operation of the crew, the vessel and the condition of the vessel, and finally, the environment, and that includes the weather, the wind, the current, the tide and the operating environment," Mr Graham said.
Investigators are asking the public for additional video of the incident and have yet to determine if the Mexican naval vessel had a data recorder. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
4 hours ago
- Straits Times
‘Many of the bodies were burned': Eyewitnesses recount horror at Air India crash site
Debris at the site of a plane crash near Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport in Ahmedabad, Gujarat, western India, on June 12. PHOTO: EPA-EFE 'Many of the bodies were burned': Eyewitnesses recount horror at Air India crash site AHMEDABAD - Thick black plumes of acrid smoke towered high above India's Ahmedabad airport on June 12 after a London-bound passenger jet with 242 people aboard crashed shortly after takeoff. The plane came down in a residential area between a hospital and the city's Ghoda Camp neighbourhood. It crashed into a medical college hostel during lunch hour Ahmedabad, the main city of India's Gujarat state, is home to around eight million people and the busy airport is surrounded by densely packed residential areas. An AFP journalist saw people recovering bodies and firefighters trying to douse the smouldering wreckage after the Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner crashed. A photograph published by India's Central Industrial Security Force, a national security agency, showed the tail of the plane jutting from a building. The AFP journalist saw a section of the plane lying on the ground and a building ablaze, with thick black smoke billowing into the air. 'One half of the plane crashed into the residential building where doctors lived with their families,' said Dr Krishna, a doctor who did not give his full name. 'The nose and front wheel landed on the canteen building where students were having lunch,' he said. Dr Krishna said he saw 'about 15 to 20 burnt bodies', while he and his colleagues rescued around 15 students. 'When we reached the spot, there were several bodies lying around and firefighters were dousing the flames,' resident Poonam Patni told AFP. 'Many of the bodies were burned,' she said. The AFP journalist saw medics using a cart to load bodies into an ambulance, while a charred metal bed frame stood surrounded by burnt wreckage. Mdm Ramila, the mother of a student at the medical college, told news agency ANI her son had gone to the hostel for his lunch break when the plane crashed. 'My son is safe, and I have spoken to him. He jumped from the second floor, so he suffered some injuries,' she said. Rescue teams supported by the military had found over 200 bodies so far, with at least one survivor found, according to city police commissioner G.S. Malik. AFP, REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Business Times
8 hours ago
- Business Times
India battles container ship fire with ‘hazardous' cargo
[NEW DELHI] India's coast guard said it was battling to extinguish fires raging on a container ship carrying 'hazardous' cargo off the southern coast to prevent a 'potential ecological disaster'. The 268-metre Singapore-flagged container vessel MV Wan Hai 503, carrying 22 crew members – four of whom are missing – caught fire about 78 nautical miles off India's Beypore port on Jun 9. Photographs released by the coast guard soon after the blaze broke out showed heavy containers scattered about the vessel, as if hurled up by a powerful explosion. Since then, fire has engulfed the ship. 'The vessel is carrying 2,128 tonnes of fuel and hundreds of containers, including hazardous cargo, posing a serious risk to the marine environment and regional shipping routes,' the coast guard said in a statement late on Wednesday (Jun 11). It did not provide more details on the contents of the cargo, but said that 'the situation remains critical'. Eighteen crew members were rescued by the Indian coast guard and navy. Four crew – one from Indonesia, two from Taiwan and one from Myanmar – were listed as missing. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up The coast guard said it had 'winched five salvage team members' and a diver onto the burning ship. 'With the fire yet to be fully extinguished, efforts to establish a towline and pull the vessel away from the coast are underway to prevent a potential ecological disaster', it said. 'Intensive firefighting efforts... have significantly reduced visible flames', it added. 'However, the fire remains active in the inner decks and near fuel tanks.' Seven vessels, including five coast guard vessels as well as airplanes and a helicopter, were engaged in trying to put out the fire. The MV Wan Hai 503 container ship is the second to run into trouble off India's southern coast within weeks. A Liberian-flagged container ship, also with hazardous cargo, sank off the coast of Kerala late last month. The Indian navy rescued all 24 crew members. AFP
Straits Times
a day ago
- Straits Times
Overfishing threatens a third of global fish stocks, FAO says
Shrinking fish stocks destabilise marine ecosystems, while challenging people's ability to nourish themselves and earn a living, especially in coastal communities. PHOTO: AFP More than a third of global fish stocks are being depleted at a pace that is driving down populations, marking a trend that has been getting worse in recent years, according to a study by the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO). The Rome-based United Nations agency found that 35.5 per cent of marine stocks are subject to overfishing, based on the most recent catch data, which uses an improved methodology to assess stocks in 2021. The findings, unveiled on June 11 at the UN Oceans Conference in Nice, make clear that continuing current levels of fishing would have dire consequences, FAO said. 'The proportion of overfished stocks continues to increase at a rate of approximately 1 per cent per year in recent times, which is a significant concern,' the study's authors wrote. 'This underscores the urgent need to strengthen effective management across all fisheries.' The 500-page document, described as the 'most comprehensive, evidence-based, and community-built assessment' of the status of global fish stocks, spotlights unsustainable human activity at sea, with species such as sharks and rays at risk. The oceans conference, which ends on June 13 , also addresses how rising sea levels further threaten biodiversity. Shrinking fish stocks destabilise marine ecosystems, while challenging people's ability to nourish themselves and earn a living, especially in coastal communities. A 2022 FAO report found that 600 million people rely – at least partially – on fisheries and aquaculture, for their livelihoods. Improved marine management systems and data are helping to make fishing more sustainable in some places. Areas with strong systems, such as the North-east Pacific and the South-west Pacific, had sustainability rates of 92.7 per cent and 85.5 per cent, respectively, FAO found. In contrast, only 35.1 per cent of fishing done in the Mediterranean and the Black Sea can be considered sustainable, according to the report. Funding is also key to replenishing stocks, the authors wrote. The UN Sustainable Development Goal 14 of 'conserving and sustainably using the oceans, sea and marine resources' is one of the least-funded. Under its fourth target, overfishing should have stopped five years ago, according to the UN. BLOOMBERG Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
