‘Totally unacceptable': Ceasefire talks set back as US, Israel reject Hamas demand for permanent truce
GAZA CITY, June 1 — Hamas announced yesterday that it had replied to a US-backed Gaza ceasefire proposal, but Washington's main negotiator criticised the response as 'totally unacceptable'.
The Palestinian militant group said its response was positive while emphasising the need for a permanent ceasefire — long a sticking point for Israel.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu echoed US envoy Steve Witkoff's assessment that the response was 'unacceptable', accusing Hamas of clinging 'to its rejectionism'.
Israel on Friday warned Hamas to either accept the deal and free the hostages held in Gaza 'or be annihilated'.
In a statement yesterday, Hamas said it had 'submitted its response... to the mediating parties'.
'As part of this agreement, 10 living prisoners of the occupation held by the resistance will be released, in addition to the return of 18 bodies, in exchange for an agreed-upon number of Palestinian prisoners,' it added.
A source within the group's political bureau said it had offered 'a positive response to Witkoff, but with emphasis on guaranteeing a permanent ceasefire and full Israeli withdrawal' from the Gaza Strip.
Witkoff said Hamas's response was 'totally unacceptable and only takes us backward', urging the group to 'accept the framework proposal we put forward'.
'That is the only way we can close a 60-day ceasefire deal in the coming days in which half of the living hostages and half of those who are deceased will come home to their families and in which we can have... substantive negotiations in good-faith to try to reach a permanent ceasefire,' he added in a post on X.
Hamas alleges negotiation 'bias'
A member of Hamas's political bureau, Bassem Naim, later told AFP the group 'responded positively and responsibly' to Witkoff's proposal.
He alleged there was a 'complete bias' in the negotiating process in favour of Israel, accusing it of disagreeing with 'provisions we had agreed upon' earlier with the US envoy.
Hamas has long maintained that any deal should lay out a pathway to a permanent end to the war.
Israel has balked at that prospect, insisting on the need to destroy the group to prevent a repeat of the October 2023 attack that sparked the war.
It recently stepped up its campaign in Gaza in a bid to defeat Hamas.
'While Israel has agreed to the updated Witkoff framework for the release of our hostages, Hamas continues to cling to its rejectionism,' Netanyahu's office said in a statement, adding the group's reply was 'unacceptable and sets the process back'.
'Israel will continue its efforts to bring our hostages home and to defeat Hamas.'
A breakthrough in negotiations has been elusive ever since a previous ceasefire fell apart on March 18 with the resumption of Israeli operations.
US President Donald Trump had said on Friday that the parties were 'very close to an agreement'.
Two sources close to the negotiations said Witkoff's proposal involved a 60-day truce, potentially extendable to 70 days.
It would include the release of five living hostages and nine bodies in exchange for a number of Palestinian prisoners during the first week, followed by a second exchange the following week, the sources said.
Gaza 'hungriest place on Earth'
Of the 251 hostages taken during Hamas's October 7, 2023 attack, 57 remain in Gaza, including 34 the Israeli military says are dead.
'After 603 days of war, we wish to remind everyone that war is a means, not an end in itself,' the main group representing the hostages' families said in a statement.
Israeli society was 'united around one consensus', bringing home all the remaining hostages 'even at the cost of ending the war', the Hostages and Missing Families Forum added.
Israel has come under increasing international criticism over the dire humanitarian situation in the Palestinian territory, where the United Nations warned in May that the entire population was at risk of famine.
A spokesman for the UN humanitarian agency has called the territory 'the hungriest place on Earth'.
Aid is only trickling into Gaza after the partial lifting by Israel of a more than two-month total blockade, and the UN has recently reported looting of its trucks and warehouses.
The World Food Programme has called on Israel 'to get far greater volumes of food assistance into Gaza faster', saying desperation was 'contributing to rising insecurity'.
The health ministry in Hamas-run Gaza said yesterday that at least 4,117 people have been killed in the territory since Israel resumed its offensive on March 18, taking the war's overall toll to 54,381, mostly civilians.
Hamas's attack on Israel resulted in the deaths of 1,218 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official figures. — AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
5 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
US sanctions Chinese, HK firms for aiding Iran's missile programme
The US noted that Iran continued to heavily rely on China for operations in the Middle East, particularly its oil and nuclear industries. (Reuters pic) WASHINGTON : The US on Wednesday unveiled fresh sanctions against six people and 12 firms – including several based in China and Hong Kong – for their support of Iran's ballistic missile programme. The action follows sanctions on a series of entities and individuals linked to Iran's oil industry and nuclear programme the Trump administration imposed in recent weeks. Wednesday's sanctions are aimed at organisations involved in 'efforts to help the Iranian regime domestically source the manufacturing of critical materials needed for Tehran's ballistic missile programme,' according to the US treasury department. 'The US cannot allow Iran to develop intercontinental ballistic missiles,' US treasury secretary Scott Bessent said in a statement. Tehran's attempts to produce missiles and components domestically 'represents an unacceptable threat to the US and the stability of the region,' he added. Those sanctioned include three Chinese nationals – Qin Jinhua, Qin Dehui, and Wang Chao – who work for a China-based firm which has exported carbon fiber precursor materials to a sanctioned Iranian firm, and another Hong Kong-based company. 'Iran remains heavily reliant on China to conduct its malign activities in the Middle East,' US state department spokesperson Tammy Bruce said in a statement. 'This is another example of how the CCP (Chinese Communist Party) and China-based companies provide key economic and technical support to Iran and its proxies,' she added. Wednesday's sanctions come a day after the US announced fresh sanctions on Iranian oil sales to China, as President Donald Trump's administration continues its 'maximum pressure' campaign against Tehran while backing ongoing nuclear talks. The sanctions follow similar designations in recent weeks, at the same time as Washington and Tehran have stepped up nuclear talks. The two sides held their fourth round of indirect talks over the weekend, which mark their highest-level contact since the US in 2018 pulled out of the 2015 nuclear deal.
Free Malaysia Today
5 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Iran says no sanctions relief in US nuclear proposal
Iranian speaker of the parliament Mohammad-Bagher Ghalibaf accused the US of seeking a 'unilateral' agreement that Tehran would not accept. (EPA Images pic) TEHRAN : Iran's parliament speaker said on Sunday that the latest US proposal for a nuclear deal does not include the lifting of sanctions, state media reported as negotiations appeared to have hit a roadblock. The two foes have held five rounds of Omani-mediated talks since April, seeking to replace a landmark agreement between Tehran and world powers that set restrictions on Iran's nuclear activities in return for sanctions relief, before US President Donald Trump abandoned the accord in 2018 during his first term. In a video aired on Iranian state TV, parliament speaker Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf said that 'the US plan does not even mention the lifting of sanctions'. He called it a sign of dishonesty, accusing the Americans of seeking to impose a 'unilateral' agreement that Tehran would not accept. 'The delusional US president should know better and change his approach if he is really looking for a deal,' Ghalibaf said. On May 31, after the fifth round of talks, Iran said it had received 'elements' of a US proposal, with officials later taking issue with 'ambiguities' in the draft text. The US and its Western allies have long accused the Islamic republic of seeking to acquire nuclear weapons, a charge Iran has consistently denied, insisting that its atomic programme was solely for peaceful purposes. Key issues in the negotiations have been the removal of biting economic sanctions and uranium enrichment. Tehran says it has the right to enrich uranium under the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, while the Trump administration has called any Iranian enrichment a 'red line'. Trump, who has revived his 'maximum pressure' campaign of sanctions on Iran since taking office in January, has repeatedly said it will not be allowed any uranium enrichment under a potential deal. On Tuesday, Iran's top negotiator, foreign minister Abbas Araghchi, said the country 'will not ask anyone for permission to continue enriching uranium'. According to the UN nuclear watchdog, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), Iran is the only non-nuclear-weapon state in the world that enriches uranium up to 60% – close to the 90% threshold needed for a nuclear warhead. Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei on Wednesday rejected the latest US proposal and said enrichment was 'key' to Iran's nuclear programme. The IAEA Board of Governors is scheduled to meet in Vienna starting Monday and discuss Iran's nuclear activities. On Sunday the Atomic Energy Organization of Iran warned it could reduce its level of cooperation with the UN nuclear watchdog if it adopts a resolution against it. 'Certainly, the IAEA should not expect the Islamic Republic of Iran to continue its broad and friendly cooperation,' the Iranian agency's spokesman Behrouz Kamalvandi told state TV. Araghchi on Friday accused European powers of 'opting for malign action against Iran at the IAEA Board of Governors', warning on X that 'Iran will react strongly against any violation of its rights'. A quarterly report from the IAEA issued last week cited a 'general lack of cooperation' from Iran and raised concerns over undeclared nuclear material. Tehran has rejected the report as politically motivated and based on 'forged documents' it said had been provided by its arch foe Israel.
Free Malaysia Today
5 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Iran says to target US bases if conflict breaks out
An Iranian military truck carries an S-300 missile system during the annual Army Day celebration in Tehran. (EPA Images pic) TEHRAN : Iran threatened Wednesday to target US military bases in the region if conflict breaks out, while President Donald Trump said he was 'less confident' about reaching a nuclear deal. Amid escalating tensions, a US official said staff levels at the embassy in Iraq were being reduced over security concerns, while the UK maritime trade operations, run by the British navy, advised ships to transit the Gulf with caution. Tehran and Washington have held five rounds of talks since April to thrash out a new nuclear deal to replace the 2015 accord that Trump abandoned during his first term in 2018. Since returning to office in January, Trump has revived his 'maximum pressure' campaign on Tehran, backing nuclear diplomacy but warning of military action if it fails. 'All its bases are within our reach, we have access to them, and without hesitation we will target all of them in the host countries,' Iran's defence minister Aziz Nasirzadeh said in response to US threats of military action if the talks fail. 'God willing, things won't reach that point, and the talks will succeed,' the minister said, adding that the US side 'will suffer more losses' if it came to conflict. The US has multiple bases in the Middle East, with the largest located in Qatar. Iran and the US have recently been locked in a diplomatic standoff over Iran's uranium enrichment, with Tehran defending it as a 'non-negotiable' right and Washington calling it as a 'red line'. Trump had previously expressed optimism about the talks, saying during a Gulf tour last month Washington was 'getting close' to securing a deal. But in an interview published Wednesday, Trump said he was 'less confident' the US and Iran could reach a deal, in response to a question on whether he believed he could stop Tehran from enriching uranium. Iran currently enriches uranium to 60%, far above the 3.67% limit set in the 2015 deal and close though still short of the 90% needed for a nuclear warhead. Western countries, including the US and its ally Israel, have long accused Iran of seeking to acquire atomic weapons, while Tehran insists its nuclear programme is for peaceful purposes. Last week, Iran's supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said enrichment is 'key' to Iran's nuclear programme and that Washington 'cannot have a say' on the issue. During the interview with the New York Post's podcast 'Pod Force One', which was recorded on Monday, Trump said he was losing hope a deal could be reached. 'I don't know. I did think so, and I'm getting more and more – less confident about it. They seem to be delaying and I think that's a shame. I am less confident now than I would have been a couple of months ago,' he said. 'Something happened to them but I am much less confident of a deal being made… Maybe they don't wanna make a deal, what can I say? And maybe they do. There is nothing final.' Trump maintained that Washington would not allow Tehran to obtain nuclear weapons, saying 'it would be nicer to do it without warfare, without people dying'. On May 31, after the fifth round of talks, Iran said it had received 'elements' of a US proposal for a nuclear deal, with Araghchi later saying the text contained 'ambiguities'. Iran has said it will present a counter-proposal to the latest draft from Washington, which it had criticised for failing to offer relief from sanctions – a key demand for Tehran, which has been reeling under their weight for years. On Monday, the United Nations nuclear watchdog began a Board of Governors meeting in Vienna that will last until Friday to discuss Iran's atomic activities and other issues. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) meeting followed a report issued by it criticising 'less than satisfactory' cooperation from Tehran, particularly in explaining past cases of nuclear material found at undeclared sites. Iran has criticised the IAEA report as unbalanced, saying it relied on 'forged documents' provided by its arch-foe Israel. In January 2020, Iran fired missiles at bases in Iraq housing American troops in retaliation for the US strike that killed top Iranian general Qassem Soleimani days before at Baghdad airport. Dozens of US soldiers suffered traumatic brain injuries.
