DA legal challenge to Employment Equity sparks political divide
The DA's case against employment equity amendments has intensified labour and political divisions across the country.
Amendments in the Employment Equity Act came into effect on 1 January 2025. Picture: iStock
Against the background of the DA challenging the Employment Equity (EE) Act, aimed at forcing companies to comply with the latest legislative changes, geared at redressing apartheid imbalances at workplace, the EE debate has fuelled political polarisation in the country's labour movement.
The DA has argued that new employment quotas would 'cut hundreds of thousands of South Africans out of employment – unfair and unconstitutional' – a stance supported by the National Employers' Association of South Africa (Neasa), Solidarity and other unions on the right.
This as President Cyril Ramaphosa and the country's largest labour federations Cosatu and Saftu, have seen EE as 'necessary and significant in redressing the past'.
Employment Equity a 'necessary and significant in redressing the past'
Writing in his weekly newsletter, Ramaphosa said South Africa's labour laws were 'part of our effort to overcome the structural inequality of apartheid'.
He said the latest report of the EE commission, showed 'how far we still have to go in ending the race-based disparities that exist in our economy'.
ALSO READ: Affirmative-action measures must 'not go too far', argues DA in court
'Despite Africans constituting the majority of the economically active population, the majority of top management positions in the private sector are still held by white males.'
Cosatu national spokesperson Matthew Parks said targets are 'a necessity, given how many sectors and employers in the private sector have chosen to ignore the call to embrace a nonracial society.
'There has been minimal progress in the banking, insurance, mining and retail sectors,' he said.
Minimal progress in banking, insurance, mining and retail
'The DA case was lodged in 2023 as they were preparing to campaign for the 2024 elections.
'It's a tragedy that they sought to exploit and fuel fears of white, coloured and Indian workers – claiming their jobs were at risk.'
ALSO READ: Workers' rights: Union members tend to become spectators while leaders take decisions
Saftu national spokesperson Newton Masuku said the EE Act was 'significant to address discriminatory practices of the past'.
'The recent amendment to the Act was due to most companies not complying – setting targets and not meeting them.'
Masuku said EE was 'not a racial law' – an argument dismissed by Neasa.
Neasa disagrees that EE 'not a racial law'
'Since the dawn of the Employment Equity Act in 1998, the law has succeeded – not in achieving its stated aims – but rather in creating a marginal group of elites,' said Neasa spokesperson Chanté Dean.
Dean added that this system of 'pseudo empowerment and veneer-thin transformation' is seeking to extend its tentacles even further.
ALSO READ: Employment Equity Bill has 'shortcomings'
'What is truly cumbersome, is government's absolute ignorance to the effects of their destructive and business-debilitating policies and laws,' she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
an hour ago
- The South African
Youth Day: Long weekend loading for South Africa
South Africans are mere hours away from another long weekend – and a short week next week. Those who like to diarise public holidays well in advance will no doubt be well aware that the next official day off work is Monday, 16 June when Youth Day will be celebrated. Youth Day is the day on which South Africans honour the youth that were ambushed by the apartheid regime police in Soweto on 16 June 1976. On the day over 500 youths were killed. On the morning of 16 June 1976, thousands of black students went on a protest rally from their schools to Orlando Stadium. They were protesting against an official order which made Afrikaans compulsory in black township schools throughout the country. The use of local languages was prohibited in these schools whilst the constitution supported that Afrikaans and English be made the official languages of the country. The rally was meant to be a peaceful protest with the intentions to plea with government not to make Afrikaans compulsory in schools. However, things got out of control when the police were called in to disperse the crowds and riots broke out. Although the protests of 16 June 1976 resulted in a number of casualties, the youth of 1976 played a role in fighting and overcoming the inequality and oppression caused by apartheid. Following the advent of democracy in 1994, the new democratic government declared 16 June as National Youth Day and June as Youth Month. Although South Africans will enjoy fewer public holidays in 2025, there will be more long weekends this year than in 2024. Mzansi had 14 public holidays in 2024, but there will only be 13 days this year – and only 12 will be actual days off work. Of course, the fewer days off, the better for business in the country. Working South Africans will not get a day off to celebrate National Women's Day in 2025 because the public holiday falls on Saturday, 9 August. The Public Holidays Act (Act No 36 of 1994) determines that whenever any public holiday falls on a Sunday , the Monday following it will also be a public holiday. However, for public holidays that fall on a Saturday , it's just a 'normal' weekend day. The exciting news is that there are FIVE long weekends in 2025. The first was thanks to Human Rights Day on Friday, 21 March which gave South Africans 21-23 March off. The second was the Easter weekend with a four-day 18-21 April break to enjoy your chocolate. The third was thanks to Freedom Day falling on Sunday, 27 April, meaning Monday, 28 April was a holiday – and another three-day weekend. Monday, 16 June (Youth Day) will mean another three-day long weekend in mid-year, while the fifth and final long weekend in another four-day one with Christmas and the Day of Goodwill (Boxing Day) falling on a Thursday and Friday, respectively. Diarise the following public holidays in 2025 and plan your vacations accordingly! Wednesday, 1 January: New Year's Day Friday, 21 March: Human Rights Day Friday, 18 April: Good FridayMonday, 21 April: Family Day Sunday, 27 April: Freedom Day
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Time for the Youth to Rediscover Their Militancy and Voices
Edwin Naidu | Published 3 hours ago Edwin Naidu South Africa observes June 16 on Monday, the day when youth revolted against Afrikaans as a compulsory school subject. Three decades into democracy, Afrikaans is entrenched as one of the country's official languages, almost five decades after the fight against it. Ironically, Afrikaners remain in control of the economy, education, and media, with a significant presence in most learning institutions and the country's major media houses, including Media24 and MultiChoice (currently being sold to a French company). Through fake news about a genocide which does not exist, Afrikaners also enjoy the remaining ear that snipers missed off US President Donald Trump. So far, 49 people deemed failed car guards and their ilk on social media platforms have been given asylum based on a phoney war against Afrikaners. The war is in the racist minds, propagated by the likes of AfriForum, which seems emboldened after the ANC's 2024 knock at the polls, resulting in a Government of National Unity. So much for Jacob Zuma's once boastful quip that the ANC would rule until Jesus comes. Of course, there's a greater chance of the ANC being out of power before Jesus comes in the next election than the NPA's ineffective Shamilla Batohi bringing in the Guptas to account for the millions they obtained under Zuma. However, the man from Nkandla appears to have amnesia about state capture. Under the presidencies of Mandela, Mbeki, Mothlante, Zuma, and now Cyril Ramaphosa, subsequent governments have adopted a pro-poor stance while enriching themselves, the party and friends. A new black middle class has emerged under democracy, along with a black elite, some of whom are now close to the ruling party. A story circulates that the ANC, bereft of leadership and lacking ideas, wants Patrice Motsepe to bankroll the party back into power. Whether or not it's true, it's another sign of a party in decline. Since the Mandela euphoria over democracy, everything hinges on whether the country is keeping its promise of a better life for all. Another burning question is whether political greed is failing the youth? Ditto: women? Ditto: Heritage: Ditto: the Constitution? The conduct of politicians hardly inspires confidence. While South Africans remain mired in poverty, politicians in the GNU used R200 million of taxpayer money on expensive overseas travels. High-flier Deputy President Paul Mashatile alone spent more than R2 million on his travels. One wonders if he is making up for lost time, having joined the gravy train late. The government established Sector Education and Training Authorities to equip young people with the skills needed to address chronic unemployment. Unfortunately, there is no narrative about the success of SETAs. Under the former Minister, Dr Blade Nzimande, SETAs were filled with boards comprising comrades from the Struggle, whose disastrous impact has hindered skills training but enriched many through unscrupulous means, without facing the consequences. Half of the country's 21 SETAs previously received adverse audits from the Auditor-General when Nzimande was in charge. Most alarming, however, is that the SETAs were meant to transform the fortunes of the country's youth. Instead, it enriched those running SETAs and their associates. His successor, Dr Nobuhle Nkabane, a former deputy under Gwede Mantashe, angered political rivals when she appointed the son of her former boss as a SETA Chair before protests forced her to withdraw the decision. She claimed an advisory board helped her make the choice, but in an age of transparency, she showed none, resulting in the president putting pressure on the gum-chewing Minister to do the right thing. Politics is about serving the citizens of South Africa, not the party and friends. Politicians must put the people first. However, Nkabane undermines citizens by having a non-existent advisory board where a real board of experts could have helped ensure that South Africa's youth finally benefit from the skills revolution. Former higher education ministers had advisors whose counsel they trusted. Nkabane must secure the help of many learned people available. Otherwise, the comrades will lead her astray. Nkabane has highlighted the pressing issue of youth unemployment, insisting that SETAS must respond to the rapid pace of industry change. However, suppose she needed reminding of the dire need to transform the fortunes of youth. In that case, it will not come from youth pensioners such as Julius Malema, Fikile Mbalula, or the recently put to pasture Floyd Shivambu. The answer lies in the voices of young people who are fed up with political rhetoric, not just the noise from the trio of former youth league officials. According to the latest Quarterly Labour Force Survey (QLFS) released by Statistics South Africa (Stats SA) for Q1 2025, young people aged 15 to 34, around 10,3 million individuals, face the highest barriers to entering the workforce. Over the past ten years, youth unemployment has remained persistently high. June 16 is seen as a day when the youth of 1976 stood courageously against apartheid. Their bravery pushed South Africa's journey towards democracy, and their legacy continues to inspire generations. Does it? There's apathy. There are also pointless slogans that do not bring about significant change. Youth Month's theme is ' Skills for the Changing World – Empowering Youth for Meaningful Economic Participation. ' However, Statistics SA's reflection that nothing much has changed for youth over the past decade concerning employment is telling. Like the youth of 1976, the generation of 2025 must reclaim the future with a youth reset, not await handouts from the fading liberators who only care about the party, themselves, and their friends. Youth must find their voice, not politicians, telling them what is good for them, while enabling the party or their friends to get rich or die trying to help South Africa's forgotten youth. * Edwin Naidu is a communications professional and the founder of Higher Education Media Services. ** The views expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of IOL, Independent Media or The African.
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
MKP, EFF Unity: Is It Time for Another Cup of Tea?
MKP President Jacob Zuma and EFF CIC Julius Malema enjoying a cup of tea at a meeting held in Nkandla on February 5, 2021. Instead of challenging the dominance of the GNU, the EFF and the MK have become entangled in a web of personal and political rivalry, mistrust, and internal strife, says the writer. Image: EFF/Twitter Kim Heller The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) dare not betray their revolutionary mission as the ANC has done. The EFF and MK, together with smaller black progressive parties, could well be the last hope for economic liberation and historical justice in South Africa. The ANC government, once the dream catcher for black South Africans, has failed to end the dark nightmare of structural racism, inequality and economic exclusion. The majority of South Africa's people are desperate. The dream of liberation and justice cannot be deferred yet again, lest it is lost forever. The ever-uncertain gambit of politics saw the ANC lose its majority in the 2024 elections. It was a well-deserved loss, for the ruling party has failed and forsaken the masses. In The Art of War, Sun Tzu writes about the need to seize the moment and teaches that amid chaos lies opportunities. EFF and MK have yet to seize the moment. If they do not do so, the cries of ordinary people seeking salvation from their daily battles against joblessness, landlessness, and poverty will remain unanswered, and the country could tumble furiously towards total collapse. The electoral defeat was no wake-up call for the ANC. In its political slumber, it has been desperate to market the GNU as a win for democracy rather than as an unprecedented loss for the ANC and economic liberation. Progressive black parties need to find a common cause and expose the fatal fault lines of the GNU, its uneasy mesh of irreconcilable ideological contradictions and backward agenda. But instead of challenging the dominance of the GNU, the EFF and the MK have become entangled in a web of personal and political rivalry, mistrust, and internal strife. This damages prospects for tactical and strategic unity. There is nothing revolutionary in personal and political upmanship. Both the EFF and the MK are astute enough to know that liberation is not a competitive sport, the exclusive trademark of political leaders, or the province of any political party. In his book, One Azania, One Nation, Black consciousness scholar Neville Alexander emphasises how joint tactical campaigns and collaboration do not constitute ideological surrender, fusion, or compromise. The EFF demonstrated this in their compact with the DA in Gauteng in 2015. It utilised this tactical relationship to advance pro-black, pro-poor budgets and outcomes, as well as insourcing and service delivery to underserviced areas. It is not too late for tactical engagement and programmes between the EFF, MK and other progressive forces. The PAC may be tempted to reevaluate whether its easy acquiescence with right-wing partners within the GNU is not irrevocably tarnishing the impeccable legacy of Robert Sobukwe or damaging its future revolutionary wingspan. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ The willingness of progressive forces to work in unison at this moment, irrespective of longer-term strategic differences, will determine a new matrix of political power in South Africa for years to come. It will also impact on their fates and fortunes. The EFF is still a work in progress. The EFF's electoral blow, which saw the party dip to just 9.5% of the national vote has prompted introspection. The departure of Deputy President, Floyd Shivambu cannot continue to overshadow or cloud the EFF's focus on organisational recalibration. Hackneyed parliamentary objections and walkouts are obscuring the solid and steady work executed by the party in Parliaments and legislatures across the country. This includes EFF's potent challenge of the paralysing VAT increases and the party's legal challenge to the fuel increase which represent material wins for ordinary South Africans. Similarly, the recent insourcing of public service workers in Tshwane is a meaningful victory. It is on the crest of its ability to deliver a better life for ordinary people that the EFF will recover from its electoral and leadership losses. The fortunes of the MK are difficult to predict. The Zuma factor was completely underestimated. Great expectations for the MK party after its strong birth cry and outstanding electoral performance have tempered due to a lack of organisational cohesion and a disruptive gamble of musical chairs. The party needs to stabilise and showcase its leadership pedigree and mettle in Parliament and solidify its vision for the future if it wants to be a party of gravitas rather than grievance. The ambiguity of its dual ANC-MK membership provision creates confusion and uncertainty and may scare off progressive alliances and voters. Time is running out. Political leaders must never forget that the revolution belongs to the people and that political parties and leaders are merely servants. Petty party-political rivalries must never be placed ahead of the grand mission for economic justice and transformation. A new era of politics is upon us. Whether the progressive forces can seize this moment and boldly influence the future trajectory of power relations in South Africa is in their hands. To join hands on critical tactical projects which will strengthen democracy, raise the voice for the voiceless in Parliament and benefit the people of South Africa is the very least we should expect of progressive politicians. Both the EFF and the MK have been game-changers and kingmakers in South African politics. They must now lead the charge in reviving hope and radical focus, disrupting neoliberal hegemony and stopping the master plan of the DA to entrench its structural power over the plains of South Africa. For now, a tactical pact is necessary to help address the unfinished business of Black liberation. When the love of the people trumps personal or political hatred or dispute, everyone wins. * Kim Heller is a political analyst and author of No White Lies: Black Politics and White Power in South Africa. ** The views expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of IOL, Independent Media or The African.
