Out or not out? David Bedingham survives the handle-the-ball appeal in WTC final
South Africa batter David Bedingham found himself at the centre of a rare and controversial moment during the World Test Championship final against Australia, surviving an appeal for handling the ball - now classified as obstructing the field.The incident took place when Australia's Beau Webster bowled a length delivery that Bedingham defended with a faint inside edge. The ball deflected off his pads and dropped close to his feet. As it hovered near the pitch, wicketkeeper Alex Carey rushed forward, attempting to take a catch.advertisementIn an instinctive reaction, Bedingham bent down and scooped the ball away from his body with his hand before it hit the ground. Carey immediately appealed, convinced the batter had interfered with a possible dismissal.
AUS vs SA Live Score, WTC Final 2025 Day 2Umpires Richard Illingworth and Chris Gaffaney discussed the appeal before ruling Bedingham not out. Their decision was based on MCC Law 37.3.1, which states that a batter is out obstructing the field if they willfully prevent a fielder from making a play - including a catch - using the hand or body. Since 2017, "handling the ball" is no longer a standalone dismissal and is instead considered under this law.While Bedingham clearly made contact with the ball using his hand, the umpires determined there was no deliberate intent to obstruct Carey. As a result, the appeal was dismissed.advertisementThe moment drew comparisons to Michael Vaughan's dismissal against India in 2001 - one of the few instances of a batter being given out for handling the ball in Test cricket. However, Vaughan's case fell under the older version of the law, which did not require proof of intent.In Bedingham's case, the emphasis was on whether he had willfully interfered. With no clear obstruction found, the South African batter was allowed to continue.If the delivery is not a no ball, the striker is out Obstructing the Field if wilful obstruction or distraction by either batter prevents the striker from being out caught.Also relevant are Laws 20.1, which pertain to when a ball becomes dead:20.1 Ball is dead20.1.1 The ball becomes dead when20.1.1.1 it is finally settled in the hands of the wicket-keeper or of the bowler.20.1.1.2 a boundary is scored. See Law 19.7 (Runs scored from boundaries).20.1.1.3 a batter is dismissed. The ball will be deemed to be dead from the instant of the incident causing the dismissal.20.1.1.4 whether played or not it becomes trapped between the bat and person of a batter or between items of his/her clothing or equipment.20.1.1.5 whether played or not it lodges in the clothing or equipment of a batter or the clothing of an umpire.20.1.1.6 under either of Laws 24.4 (Player returning without permission) or 28.2 (Fielding the ball) there is an offence resulting in an award of Penalty runs. The ball shall not count as one of the over.20.1.1.7 there is contravention of Law 28.3 (Protective helmets belonging to the fielding side).20.1.1.8 the match is concluded in any of the ways stated in Law 12.9 (Conclusion of match).20.1.2 The ball shall be considered to be dead when it is clear to the bowler's end umpire that the fielding side and both batters at the wicket have ceased to regard it as in playadvertisementVideo footage showed the ball briefly trapped between Bedingham's thighs before rolling onto his pad flap. As Carey closed in, Bedingham grabbed the ball and threw it down - an instinctive move that raised eyebrows.Australia's players, including Usman Khawaja, sought a review, while Carey and the rest of the team exchanged wry smiles, aware of the delicate nature of the call. After discussion, umpire Illingworth signalled a dead ball, allowing Bedingham to continue his innings.Many questioned whether the ball had truly come to rest, arguing that it was not dead and that Bedingham's action could have warranted dismissal. The umpires' decision to let play continue reflected the fine balance between applying the letter of the law and respecting the spirit of the game.advertisementThe incident inevitably drew comparisons to a similar Carey-involved controversy from the 2023 Ashes - the stumping of Jonny Bairstow at Lord's - which went Australia's way but sparked intense debate.With Bedingham not out, South Africa stand at 121 for 5, trailing by 91 runs. You May Also Like
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Virat Kohli predicted Aiden Markram's future 7 years ago. Old tweet resurfaces after South Africa opener hits WTC ton
Virat Kohli is a man of many talents. Predicting the future isn't one of them. Or is it? Fans started to double-check after Kohli's seven-year-old tweet on Aiden Markram resurfaced after the South African batter played one of the best knocks of his career to bring the Proteas inches closer to their maiden World Test Championship title and the first ICC trophy in nearly 30 years. The last time South Africa won an ICC tournament was back in 1998, lifting the inaugural Champions Trophy in Bangladesh. They still need 72 runs to beat Australia but with eight wickets in hand, including that of a rock-solid Markram, batting on 102, it looks ever so likely that South Africa will bring an end to their long wait for an ICC trophy. Kohli's admiration for South African batters is nothing new. Legendary South African cricketer AB de Villiers is one of his best friends on and off the field. Of course, it helped that they played together for RCB for more than a decade, forming one of the most beautiful cross-border bonds that cricket has seen but it's no coincidence that Kohli's favourite captain is another South African, Faf du Plessis. During the all-captains meeting before the start of the 2019 ODI World Cup, Kohli was asked to pick one cricketer from any participating team in that World Cup that he would pick to play for his side, and he had no hesitation in naming du Plessis. It was therefore no surprise when RCB bought him in the auction and also named him captain after Kohli decided to step down in 2021. Markram is the latest addition to Kohli's fondness for South African batters. Markram, who made his Test and ODI debut in 2017, drew Kohli's attention a year later. He had already hit three Test centuries, but it was his 84-run knock in the second innings of the Test match at Cape Town against Australia that really caught Kohli's eye. "Aiden Markram is a delight to watch!" wrote Kohli on X (then Twitter). Seven years and three months later, the same tweet went viral when Markram put South Africa on the brink of the WTC title. In pursuit of 282, which currently stands as the second highest successful fourth innings chase in a Test at Lord's, an unbroken third-wicket stand of 143 took the Proteas to the close on 213 for two, requiring a further 69 to be crowned champions. Australia had earlier looked to hold the upper hand after Mitchell Starc's gritty half-century extended their overnight lead, while the seamer later took the two South African wickets to fall. But Markram, who will resume on 102, and Bavuma, dropped on two by Steve Smith, played brilliantly to raise South African hopes of a first ICC trophy since 1998. Markram survived a heart-in-mouth moment on 23, nicking a Cummins delivery between the keeper and first slip. Since then, the South African opener grew in confidence. Makram hit 11 fours in his fluent knock, scoring a strike rate of 102 off 159 balls. He got to his century with a flick off his pads that raced away to the boundary right at the fag end of Day 3. Did Kohli predict something like this for Aiden Markram? He certainly could not have but as they say, class is permanent and Kohli, like most other greats of the game, identified that very early.
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
MCC changes boundary catch rule, ‘bunny hops' to be deemed as illegal in massive move
In a huge decision, the MCC has decided to update its law regarding boundary catches and to make the 'bunny hop' illegal. The new rule will become operational later this month, and such spectacular catches in the future will be deemed as illegal. The updated law will also be integrated into the ICC's playing conditions this month and also into the MCC's laws in October 2026. The new law states that if a fielder who is airborne, can touch the ball once beyond the boundary, will also need to come back inside the field for the catch to be called fair. The 'bunny hop' catch which Michael Neser pulled off, where he palmed the ball up as a contact while airborne outside the boundary, but also landed outside, will no longer be considered legal anymore. Neser's catch took place in BBL 2023, where he caught the ball with both hands, but his momentum took him over the ropes. He tossed the ball up, initially while airborne, landing outside the ropes, and then jumped again, palming the ball back into the fielder with both feet in the air. Then he hopped back into the playing field to complete the catch. The batter was ruled out, and was left utterly annoyed. Meanwhile, Neser also revealed that he was inspired by fellow teammate Matt Renshaw's effort to catch Matthew Wade in 2020. According to the existing Law 19.5.2, the fielder's last contact with the ground before they first touch the ball must be within the boundary (this part of the law will remain in the new update). The fielder cannot touch the ball and the ground outside the boundary at the same time. If he or she completes those criteria and also the catch, then it is legal. Meanwhile, earlier this year, the MCC also reportedly sent a note to ICC, where it described Neser's catch as 'bunny hopped', and also called for a rule change as some attempts were unfair. The MCC has also stated, 'MCC has devised a new wording where the 'bunny hop' wholly beyond the boundary is removed, but these catches where the fielder pushes the ball up from inside the boundary, steps outside and then dives back in to catch the ball, are permitted.' 'Our solution has been to limit any fielder who has gone outside the boundary to touching the ball while airborne only once, and then, having done so, to be wholly grounded within the boundary for the rest of the duration of that delivery.' The law will take effect from October 2026, when the next round of changes by ICC come into effect. The updated law will be applied to the ICC playing conditions in the new WTC cycle, which starts on June 17, and it will take effect from October 2026, when the new round of changes begin.
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Aiden Markram's 'Sauce' 100 in WTC final vs Australia dubbed 'one of the finest tons': '2025 the year of the underdog'
South Africa's right-handed opening batter, Aiden Markram, decided to stand up for the team in the World Test Championship (WTC) final against Australia at the Lord's Cricket Ground. Chasing 282, the Proteas were in desperate need of a good solid start, and Markram decided to step up as he smashed his 8th Test ton off 156 balls with the help of 11 boundaries. Markram remained unbeaten at stumps on Day 3, and he, along with Temba Bavuma, will now look to finish the job on Saturday. At stumps on Day 3, South Africa's score read 213/2, with Markram and skipper Temba Bavuma unbeaten on 102 and 65, respectively. The Proteas need just 69 runs more to win their maiden WTC title. On the first two days of the WTC final, a total of 28 wickets fell and hence not many gave South Africa a chance after Australia set a target of more than 280 runs. However, Markram and Bavuma had different plans as they took down the famed Australian attack, which included Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, Pat Cummins, and Nathan Lyon. Also Read: Aiden Markram rises to the challenge, smashes 8th Test ton Markram's innings is now being lauded by several former cricketers on social media. Michael Vaughan and Dale Steyn took to X (formerly Twitter) to showcase their appreciation for the right-hander's clutch knock in London. "S A U C E 100!!!!!!!!!" wrote Steyn. On the other hand, Vaughan said, 'What a special innings by Aidan Markram .. At the most important time against a World class attack he has produced one of the finest tons in a final .. This is a huge moment for a S.A Cricket .. 2025 is certainly the year of the under dog .. maybe that will continue for the Ashes.' 2025 has already seen several firsts when it comes to sporting events. Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) won their first-ever Champions League title while English club Crystal Palace won their first trophy in 120 years as the club won the FA Cup by beating Manchester City. When it comes to cricket, Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB) ended their 18-year-long trophy drought as the franchise won the Indian Premier League (IPL) for the first time by beating RCB in the final. Now all eyes are on the Rainbow Nation South Africa on whether they can cross the final hurdle on Day 4 to win the WTC against a formidable Australian lineup. It must be mentioned that South Africa lost the T20 World Cup final last year against India. The side then lost the semi-finals of the ICC Champions Trophy 2025 against New Zealand.
