Chris Minns blasts inquiry into Dural caravan plot as a 'giant conspiracy' as senior staffers are hit with arrest threat
NSW Premier Chris Minns has fiercely rebuffed calls for three of his senior staffers to appear before a parliamentary inquiry into the Dural caravan plot.
Independent Upper House MP and inquiry chair, Rod Roberts, will on Tuesday sign summonses urging Mr Minns' chief of staff James Cullen and his two deputies – Sarah Michael and Edward Ovadia - to give evidence, the Daily Telegraph reports.
Should they refuse, the Upper House could instruct its president, Ben Franklin, to request that a Supreme Court judge issue arrest warrants.
But the premier made it clear he and his staffers would not cooperate, dismissing the inquiry as nothing more than a partisan attack.
'This is a giant conspiracy being pushed by the Opposition, Greens, and Independents,' Minns told 2GB radio on Tuesday.
'It's a conspiracy based on the false claim that we knew everything from the beginning and used it to push through laws to counter antisemitism.'
In February, NSW introduced tougher hate speech laws following a series of antisemitic incidents across Sydney.
One of the main triggers was a reported terror plot involving antisemitic threats and a caravan in Dural, a claim that was later revealed to be a hoax.
Roberts said the inquiry would examine whether parliament was 'morally bullied' into passing the laws without knowing the full facts.
The showdown follows refusals by both Minns and NSW Police Minister Yasmin Catley to appear before the inquiry.
However, under parliamentary rules, Upper House inquiries cannot compel Lower House members such as Minns and Catley, to testify.
Minns said Opposition and crossbench MPs had had opportunities to question him about the caravan plot during Question Time and biannual Upper House estimates.
The premier said that claims he knew about the circumstances of the Dural caravan being a hoax from the very beginning were not true. He also denied claims that the incident was used to push through the anti-vilification laws passed earlier this year.
'My sense is that Mr Roberts made this outlandish conspiracy claim early on, and is trying to find some back fill evidence to justify it, and there is none there,' he said.
Daily Mail Australia has contacted Roberts for comment.
NSW Opposition Leader Mark Speakman told this publication that the inquiry was simply trying to get to the bottom of what happened.
'This isn't about targeting staff but getting to the truth,' he said in a statement.
'If the Premier and Police Minister won't front up, the committee has a duty to ask those who might know the facts, as the former opposition have done when we were in government.
'Staffers aren't the decision makers, but they might hold key evidence. The Jewish community deserves answers and NSW deserves a government that's honest and accountable.'
Liberterian MP John Ruddick, who is a member of the inquiry, told Daily Mail Australia that the cross party group was holding the government accountable.
'The modus operandi of governments is to whip up fear and then rush in more laws to curb freedom so they appear to have done something,' he said.
'This needed to be reviewed by the parliament because if we just swept this under the carpet they'll do it again.
'There must be accountability and the inquiry is doing just that.'
In 2023, the NSW Upper House invoked the Parliamentary Evidence Act in an attempt to compel the brothers of then Premier Dominic Perrottet to give evidence to an inquiry regarding the Hills Shire Council, a move then backed by the Labor Party.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
32 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Horrifying moment masked gunmen storm a kebab shop and open fire leaving an innocent woman in a coma - as cops reveal why underworld figure was likely targeted
An underworld figure shot in broad daylight inside a Sydney kebab shop had avoided four previous attempts on his life and had allegedly ripped off other a rival gang in a tobacco heist. Two masked and hooded gunmen, dressed head to toe in black, sprinted into the Turkish diner in Auburn in Sydney 's west just after 1pm on Monday. Samimjan Azari, 26, was hit in the arm and shoulder, an unidentified male was shot in the face and an innocent female shop employee suffered two gunshot wounds to the torso. The would-be assassins unleashed a volley of eight handgun shots as their victims tried to flee out the back, while another man attempted to fend them off with a chair. It was revealed on Tuesday evening that police are considering whether Azari was the target of the attack, Nine News has reported. Azari has survived four attempt on his life and he was allegedly behind a heist at Condell Park in January. He allegedly sent two men to steal illegal tobacco valued at roughly $4.5million but it became a violent kidnapping. Three men were allegedly threatened with weapons, tied up, bashed and one of the men had his toe 'partially severed' in the attack which lasted up to half an hour. Officers are believed to have seized the cigarettes. Police are now considering whether this incident is why Azari is wanted dead. The dramatic moment a gangland hit squad burst into a kebab shop and opened fire was captured in disturbing new CCTV footage, as shop staff break their silence about the terrifying attack. The CCTV video captured the moment the victims scrambled to hide as the gunmen stormed into the M Brothers kebab shop and bore down on them. The video cut out when a ricochet bullet fragment took out the power supply to the cafe, before it was reconnected as emergency service workers tended to the victims. Footage also showed the aftermath, with NSW Ambulance paramedics treating the injured at the scene. The victims remained in Westmead Hospital on Monday night. Diner owner Mohammed Rahimi revealed on Tuesday how he fought to save the life of staff cook Gul Yildiz, 47, as she lay bleeding from her wounds. 'There was a lot of blood,' he told Daily Mail Australia. 'I was basically putting pressure [on them].' He said he did not recognise the men who were shot in the hit, saying he sees a lot of customers each day. But he said the gunmen knew their targets and told staff to get on the ground. 'After second gunshot, the power cut off, so there shop was dark,' he added. 'One of the staff, as soon as she hear a gunshot, she fell down. She was there behind the counter with another staff, and basically [the gunman] told [us] to get down. The innocent victim caught in the crossfire is known in the community as a 'very good lady', locals told Daily Mail Australia. She is currently in a coma at Westmead Hospital with her daughter by her side. The gunmen tried to enter an office at the back of the shop as they fled before escaping in a black BMW with cloned registration plates, Acting NSW Police Commissioner Peter Thurtell said. 'It is beyond comprehension that three people were shot in a crowded Sydney street in broad daylight, and the resources of the NSW police have already been deployed,' Commander Thurtell said. Police recently warned that Azari was at the 'epicentre' of gangland tensions in the city. Officers are investigating whether the two gunmen were hired on the Airtasker online platform, according to The Daily Telegraph. This is the same method that was used in a separate attempted murder of a figure from the Alameddine criminal clan within the past month. During a press conference on Monday, police minister Yasmin Catley said the gunmen will be held accountable as she shared her anger at an innocent woman getting caught up in the gangland shooting. 'All she did was go to work and she has been caught up in this shocking event,' she said. 'It's one thing for criminals to be shooting each other but when innocent people get caught up in this, it is absolutely abhorrent and we will not tolerate it.' 'It's completely unacceptable that this sort of behaviour should happen in Sydney. 'We will do everything we can to bring these gunmen to justice. It's as simple as that. We will make sure that we go and go until we bring these people to justice.' Witnesses said two men with their faces covered entered the South Parade kebab shop and fired eight bullets. At the time of the shooting, the area was bustling with people on their lunch break and heading to the nearby Auburn train station. The shooting comes less than three weeks after Police Minister Catley announced the formation of Taskforce Falcon — a new strike force targeting a recent spate of underworld shootings. Police sources are reported to have said a split between the Alameddines and the KVT gang members, who were once the former's enforcers, is the reason behind the latest run of violence in the city. Last month, police warned a court there would be 'bloodshed on the sheets' if Azari was granted bail after he was charged with possessing an unauthorised gun allegedly found inside a ute. He had been the target of a previous daylight shooting incident on May 25 at Granville, which killed Dawood Zakaria, when a gunman opened fire at their vehicle at a set of traffic lights. Azari's first attempt on his life took place at Brighton-Le-Sands back in February, but he escaped without serious injury.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Defence highlights a lack of motive in 'flawed prosecution' as the epic trial of Erin Patterson draws to its gripping final hours
The prosecution case against Erin Patterson has been branded 'flawed' during a final onslaught by her defence. As the trial within the Latrobe Valley Law Courts entered its eighth week, Patterson's barrister Colin Mandy, SC finally had his chance to attack the prosecution case that aims to put her behind bars for decades. Patterson, 50, has pleaded not guilty to the murders of Don and Gail Patterson, and Gail's sister, Heather Wilkinson. They died after consuming death cap mushrooms served in beef Wellingtons during lunch at her Leongatha home on July 29, 2023. Only Pastor Ian Wilkinson survived the lunch, in what Crown prosecutor Dr Nanette Rogers, SC on Monday suggested was a big mistake. Finally on his feet before the jury to offer Patterson's defence, Mr Mandy kicked-off his closing address by tearing apart the prosecutor's case. 'I want to start by addressing you on some overarching themes which we'll return to throughout this address and the first of those is a flawed approach by the prosecution in the way that they have analysed the evidence,' Mr Mandy began. 'The prosecutor has just made an argument to you. That's not evidence. The prosecution has referred, we say, selectively to the evidence, choosing the bits they like to suit their theory, in a very deliberate way, and then arguing to you that you should accept those bits that they like, while they don't draw your attention to the bits that they don't like.' Mr Mandy accused the prosecution of 'cherry picking' evidence that fit its narrative while ignoring other 'crucial' evidence. 'Their approach is this: working from the assumption that Erin Patterson is guilty of these crimes, pick and choose the evidence that fits that theory, and then tie it all together in an attempt to present a coherent narrative and ignore the things that don't fit,' Mr Mandy said. 'So they have constructed that case theory by, as I say, picking and choosing evidence while ignoring the context. Cherry-picking convenient fragments, while discarding inconvenient truths.' Earlier, Dr Rogers had described Patterson as a person who just could not resist the urge to tell anyone who listened lies. 'In the lead up to the lunch and in the periods after the lunch, Erin Patterson told so many lies it's hard to keep track of them. She has told lies upon lies because she knew the truth would implicate her,' Dr Rogers told the jury in the morning. While Dr Rogers took the jury on Monday through what she described as 'four calculated deceptions' Patterson embarked upon, she outlined a 'fifth deception' on Tuesday. 'The deception she has tried to play on you, the jury, with her untruthful evidence,' Dr Rogers said. 'When she knew her lies had been uncovered, she came up with a carefully constructed narrative to fit with the evidence - almost. 'There are some inconsistencies that she just cannot account for so, she ignores them, says she can't remember those conversations, or says other people are just wrong, even her own children.' In closing her address, Dr Rogers argued that Patterson deliberately poisoned her guests, pointing to her inconsistent statements and alleged lies. She claimed Patterson's actions, such as dumping a dehydrator and wiping her phone, were calculated to hide incriminating evidence and stressed that motive was not required to prove murder. While Mr Mandy agreed the prosecution indeed did not need to prove Patterson had motive to murder her guests, he suggested it did need to prove she had 'murderous intent'. 'That's an element of the offence of murder: intention and they have to prove that Erin - that's what Erin Patterson meant to do,' Mr Mandy said, 'So they don't have to prove there was a motive, that's not an element. We're all agreed about that. But obviously enough proof of a motive, or the fact of a motive, can be very important to intention.' Mr Mandy said his client had no reason to murder her lunch guests. 'So our submission to you that to prove the intention to kill or cause really serious injury to four good people who were important in Erin's life, the prosecution has to be able to demonstrate a motive or provide evidence of one,' he said. 'And if they don't, then you might think they fall short of being able to prove intention as a matter of logic and common sense. Without a motive, you're left guessing about the most important element of the offence in this trial and that's intention.' Mr Mandy said not only did his client have no motive to kill her guests, but had an 'anti-motive'. 'Erin Patterson, for instance, putting Simon's name on the title to Mount Waverley on the title to Gibson Street in Leongatha, long after they had separated. Still voluntarily treating their assets as joint assets,' he said. 'Then there is all the other evidence about the Patterson relationship, closeness between Erin and Don. 'Don tutoring (his grandson). Don hanging out with (his grandson) and doing science experiments not long before the lunch. 'Don and Gail coming around to the house on 24 June and having lunch with them and how well she, that is Erin and Don got on, with the special connection that they shared that Simon Patterson told you about.' Mr Mandy said Patterson was devoted to her children and would never harm the people who meant so much to them. 'Erin Patterson had a motive to keep these people in her world so that they could keep supporting her and her children, especially her children, and there is absolutely no doubt that Don and Gail had a great relationship with (their grandchildren), no doubt about that,' he said. 'Absolutely no doubt that Erin was devoted to her children. Why would she take wonderful, active, loving grandparents away from her own children?' Mr Mandy refuted the prosecution claims his client had meticulously planned the alleged crime. 'An intelligent person, carefully planning a murder would know that if you poison four people at a lunch at your house, and you poison them so badly, carefully administering a fatal dose of poison designed to kill them all at the same time, the meal that you cooked will be under suspicion,' he said. 'There's absolutely no way of avoiding that. It is inevitable that the focus will be on the cook very, very quickly.' Mr Mandy suggested Patterson had gone out of her way to be fingered for the crime if that were her true intention. 'And that prosecution theory, in our submission to you, doesn't make any sense,' he said. 'Erin Patterson was never, ever thinking that way, because she never intended this to happen and if she had been thinking that way and planning this from April, here are some things that she would never do: buy the dehydrator in her own name, with her own details, using her own credit card from the local store; take photographs of the dehydrator; take photographs of mushrooms in the dehydrator, share those photographs online, publish them with people in a Facebook chat group, and then wait for so long after the meal before getting rid of the dehydrator.' 'But Erin Patterson did the opposite of all those things because she didn't plan it; she never planned to kill anyone, and when they did get very, very sick she panicked, because that's when she realised that it might have been the meal and the spotlight would be on her. 'And that's a very powerful reason why you can't, in our submission, find this element of intention.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Accused killer cop Beau Lamarre-Condon hit with fresh charge more than a year after he allegedly shot dead Jesse Baird and Luke Davies
The former policeman accused of murdering a television presenter and his Qantas flight attendant partner has been hit with a fresh criminal charge. Beau Lamarre-Condon allegedly shot dead Jesse Baird, 26, and Luke Davies, 29, at Paddington in Sydney 's eastern suburbs in February 2024. He was originally charged with two counts of murder, later amended to indicate they were alleged to be related to domestic violence. Lamarre-Condon was then charged with aggravated break and enter with intent to commit an indictable offence, listed as 'stalking Jesse Baird'. In relation to that offence, police allege Lamarre-Condon broke into Mr Baird's Paddington house in August 2023, six months before he and Mr Davies were killed. On June 4, police laid a new second charge of aggravated break and enter with intent to commit a serious indictable offence against the 29-year-old. Lamarre-Condon was due to face Downing Centre Local Court on Tuesday in relation to the three existing and one new charge. Daily Mail Australia revealed earlier this month that Lamarre-Condon had offered to provide information about a woman he claims helped dispose of the bodies. '[He] wants to do the right thing for the families and is happy to assist investigators with information about who else played a part in the incident,' a source claimed. 'So far both the DPP and the officer in charge have failed to reply to the offer made by Lamarre-Condon's legal team for assistance.' Police allege that Lamarre-Condon bundled Mr Davies and Mr Baird's bodies into surfboard bags before dumping them at a farm in the Southern Tablelands. The source claimed a woman, who Lamarre-Condon knew through her partner, had told investigators she had waited at the fence line of the Bungonia property where the bodies were first dumped for 15 to 20 minutes. Phone records indicated Lamarre-Condon and the woman, previously described by police as 'an innocent agent', were at the farm for almost two hours, the source claimed. 'Police also located two sets of white overalls at the scene where bodies were located which indicates it was a two-person job,' the source said. A NSW Police spokeswoman said: 'As this matter is before the court, we are unable to comment.' A spokeswoman for the DPP said the same thing. Lamarre-Condon has spent almost 16 months in prison since the shootings, which were allegedly the result of a months-long campaign of 'predatory behaviour' targeting Mr Baird. The onetime celebrity chaser reportedly briefly dated Mr Baird before the TV presenter began a relationship with Mr Davies. Suspicions of foul play were raised after possessions belonging to the dead men were found in a skip bin in the southern Sydney suburb of Cronulla, leading police to Mr Baird's blood-smeared terrace. The case returned to Downing Centre Local Court last month after confidential discussions between prosecutors and the alleged killer's Legal Aid lawyer Alex Curnick. Both sides agreed 'things are progressing,' magistrate Megan Greenwood was told. A forensic psychiatrist's report was also tendered after Lamarre-Condon was assessed in previous weeks. Lamarre-Condon joined the force in 2019 and previously ran a celebrity blog, posing in photos with dozens of A-listers including Taylor Swift, Selena Gomez, Katy Perry, Miley Cyrus and Harry Styles. Baird worked on TV programs Studio Ten and Totally Wild while Davies, his new boyfriend, was a respected Qantas flight attendant. Lamarre-Condon, who was sacked by the NSW Police Force in March 2024, has not entered pleas to any of the charges.
