New Lynn terror attack: Graphic CCTV footage to be shown to closed court
The first phase of the inquest begins next week and will focus on the day of the terror attack.
Coroner Marcus Elliott will hear from survivors, witnesses, police officers, Corrections staff, doctors and others during the 10-day hearing.
The first phase is partly driven by questions from survivors about the attack. In particular, survivors wanted to know why police who were surveilling Samsudeen were not inside the supermarket at the time of the incident and whether this would have prevented the stabbings.
The police have applied to suppress some sensitive evidence, including CCTV footage from inside the supermarket during the violence. Members of the public will be excluded from the hearing when the footage is played.
The police submission said the footage was graphic, could compromise the safety of police officers, and breached the privacy of witnesses in the supermarket during a traumatic event.
The second phase of the inquest will cover the four-month period in which Samsudeen was living in the community before the attack. He was under constant police supervision and living in an Auckland mosque at the time, which media are legally unable to identify.
The third phase will look at the attacker's time in prison, much of which was spent in segregation and on remand. Samsudeen was in and out of jail over a period of four years on a range of offences related to the possession of objectionable material.
The second and third phases will have a special focus on how the attacker came to be radicalised into violent extremism.
The terror attack has already been the subject of five investigations, beginning with a co-ordinated review by the Independent Police Conduct Authority (IPCA), Corrections and the NZ Security Intelligence Service (SIS).
Corrections and police carried out their own reviews, as did the IPCA, which found that the two police officers were justified in shooting Samsudeen. Mike Heron KC carried out a review of the attacker's immigration files.
The case has influenced changes to New Zealand's immigration and counter-terrorism laws.
Samsudeen, a member of the Tamil ethnic minority group from Sri Lanka, was granted refugee status in New Zealand in 2013 after claiming his family had been tortured for their political views.
His refugee status was revoked in 2019 when it was found that it was fraudulently obtained, but complexities in New Zealand law meant he could not be deported.
The Government has now drafted a law change to allow refugees' residence visas to be cancelled if they posed a risk to national security.
Despite the risk that Samsudeen posed, he could not be charged under anti-terror laws because planning an attack was not an offence under the legislation. The law has now been amended.
Isaac Davison is an Auckland-based reporter who covers Auckland Issues. He joined the Herald in 2008 and has previously covered the environment, politics, social issues and healthcare.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Ranjna Patel leads Asian recipients of King's Birthday Honours
Dame Ranjna Patel Photo: Supplied More than a dozen Asian New Zealanders have been recognised in this year's King's Birthday Honours List for their services to the country. Business and community leader Ranjna Patel heads the list after being appointed a Dame Companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to ethnic communities, health and family violence prevention. She co-founded Tāmaki Health in 1977, which has grown to become New Zealand's largest privately owned primary healthcare group, now serving more than 330,000 patients. Patel became the first person of Indian origin to be inducted into the New Zealand Business Hall of Fame in 2024 and the first woman to receive the Kiwibank Innovator of the Year award in 2021. In 2014, she co-founded Gandhi Nivas, an innovative early intervention service supporting men at risk of committing family harm, which to date has helped more than 6000 families in Auckland. "[It is] very humbling to be honoured at this incredibly high level," Patel said. "For someone who is community-minded ... [and] has had the privilege of working with high needs and vulnerable communities especially in health, and with some very talented individuals to create a very large medical and social service, as well as provide pastoral care to many, has been a big honour. "It's all about the people: He tāngata, he tāngata, he tāngata." A strong proponent of well-being in New Zealand's ethnic communities, Patel rated social cohesion as a very important factor in enabling it. "Many steps are being taken to be inclusive of the many different ethnic groups in New Zealand, and I can see the diversity of thought on the 'how' we solve problems and issues are now being accepted," she said. "Having a voice at the table is important, but having a voice heard will see better [social] cohesion." Clockwise from top left: Yuanyong Yang, Ai Ling Tan and Panchanatham Narayanan Photo: Supplied Dr Ai Ling Tan has been named a Companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to gynaecology - in both public health and clinical practice, nationally and in the Pacific. Tan has been recognised as having had an impact on raising awareness of gynaecological cancers and promoting early detection and prevention strategies. She was a founding trustee for the New Zealand Gynaecological Cancer Foundation from 2003 and medical advisor from 2017 to 2023. She is a mentor for low- to middle-income countries for the International Gynaecological Cancer Society and trained the first Pacific-based gynaecological oncologist in Fiji. "As a gynaecological oncologist, I see the urgent need for earlier diagnosis, timely access to specialist care and better wraparound support for women with gynaecological cancers," Tan said. "Equity gaps - particularly for Māori, Pacific and rural women - remain a serious concern. "[The recognition] strengthens my resolve to keep advocating for equitable, timely care for women with gynaecological cancers, both here in Aotearoa and across the Pacific." Clockwise from top left: Sunit Prakash, Santosh Prasad Bhandari and Lalita Vanmali Kasanji Photo: Supplied Panchanatham Narayanan, president of New Zealand Federation of Multicultural Councils, has been named an Officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to New Zealand's multicultural communities. Already a Queen's Service Medal recipient in 2010, Narayanan has been credited for providing vision and leadership for Huarahi Hou, an internationally recognised community-based approach for cultural integration and inclusion of immigrants anchored in the bicultural foundations of New Zealand. "I accept [this honour] as a guardian. This belongs to the many vibrant multicultural communities across Aotearoa, whose contributions enrich our nation every day," Narayanan said. "[This award] is a reflection of their resilience, diversity and selfless volunteering spirit. I remain committed to Huarahi Hou (Pathways to Te Tiriti-based Multicultural Aotearoa New Zealand) serving and uplifting all our communities with gratitude and humility." Five individuals from New Zealand's Asian communities were appointed Members of the New Zealand Order of Merit on the honours' list. Lisa Li received the honour for her contribution to the development of New Zealand's tourism industry for more than two decades. Li established the New Zealand branch of China Travel Service (Hong Kong) in 2000, which has now grown into one of the premier China specialists for inbound Chinese tourists to New Zealand. Calling for the government to recognise tourism as a key economic driver, Li stressed the need to continuing investment in infrastructure. "At the same time, industry players must work together to enhance the quality of visitor experience and ensure we deliver strong value for money," Li said. Lisa Li (left) and Khoa Truong Nguyen Photo: Supplied The husband-wife duo of Lalita Vanmali Kasanji and Sunit Prakash were recognised for services to the Indian community as well as their contributions to New Zealand's IT sector. They co-founded the New Zealand Centre for Digital Connections with India in 2023 to accelerate and incubate digital and technology collaboration between the two countries. "We performed a stakeholder analysis and saw no one operated wholistically in the space comprising New Zealand, India and all things digital. We took that space," Prakash said. He also collaborated with Kasanji and published research on the story and contribution of Indian IT professionals to New Zealand, in which the authors "identified predicators to success and created catalyst programs for visibility, growth and success". Meanwhile, Santosh Prasad Bhandari and Khoa Truong Nguyen were each named a Member of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to the Nepalese and Vietnamese communities, respectively. In accepting the honour, Prasad emphasized the need to adopt targeted and collaborative strategies for improving the well-being of ethnic communities in the country. "For instance, the Nepalese community has long advocated for 29 May to be recognized as Everest Day in the official calendar," Prasad said. "Acknowledging such culturally significant requests would enhance a sense of belonging for the Nepalese community without imposing financial burdens on taxpayers." Nguyen arrived in New Zealand as a refugee in 1990 and has contributed significantly to positive trade relationships between New Zealand and Vietnam. "When my parents and I first arrived in New Zealand, we had nothing," he said. "Looking back on those early years, I can honestly say that, despite the challenges, we were incredibly fortunate. "We received support from the government, charity organisations and most memorably from everyday New Zealanders who welcomed us with open hearts. "That said, I believe there's always more that can be done to support refugees, especially during those critical early years of resettlement. "Continued efforts to improve access to affordable housing, language education, job and economic support, and strong anti-discrimination policies can make a profound difference. "When these foundations are in place, refugees are better equipped to build safe, stable, and fulfilling lives, and, in turn, contribute to a more connected and compassionate Aotearoa." Clockwise from left: Narayanan Kutty Pulloothpadath, Parminder Kaur and Narendra Bhana Photo: Supplied Another five individuals were awarded the King's Service Medal for their services to various ethnic communities of New Zealand. Narendra Bhana, Parminder Kaur and Narayanan Kutty Pulloothpadath received it for services to the Indian and multicultural communities, while Sohim Hay was awarded the medal for services to New Zealand's Cambodian community. Yuanyong Yang was recognised for services to bonsai arts and the Chinese community. Bhana, former president of New Zealand Indian Central Association, looks forward to fostering political and community engagement along with strengthening inter-ethnic dialogues. "Encouraging greater political participation within the Indian community by supporting leadership development programs and providing pathways for individuals to engage with local and national politics would further integrate the community into New Zealand's political landscape," Bhana said. "These efforts would ensure that the voices of ethnic communities are heard in decision-making processes that affect their lives." Kaur, chairperson of the social organisation Indian NZ Association of Christchurch, who also runs the Women's Helping Hand Trust, dedicated the award to the people her initiatives have helped over the years. "This honour is not just mine, it belongs to every volunteer, every woman who found her voice and every child who felt seen and included through our programmes," Kaur said. "This recognition strengthens my commitment to continue working towards a more inclusive, united Aotearoa, where diversity is celebrated and every individual has a chance to thrive." Pulloothpadath, who has advocated for ethnic communities in Taranaki for 25 years and is a former president of the New Plymouth Indian community, shared similar sentiments. Yang wanted to support grassroots groups, investment in cross-cultural education and real pathways for ethnic voices to lead - not just participate. "For the Chinese community especially, we have so much to offer, but sometimes we are still treated as outsiders," Yang said. "That needs to change." Yang urged New Zealand to embrace bonsai art. "Bonsai is more than a plant in a pot - it's a way of thinking, a quiet art that teaches patience and respect for nature," Yang said. "To promote bonsai in New Zealand, I'd love to see it in schools, in libraries and even at festivals where people can get hands-on and learn the stories behind the trees. "We need to connect it to local culture, too, so it's not just an imported art but something people here can feel a part of."
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
King's Birthday honours - 'This belongs to the Samoan community'
Former National MP Anae Arthur Anae and Repeka Lelaulu president of P.A.C.I.F.I.C.A Inc 20 November 2024 Photo: RNZ Pacific/Coco Lance Former National MP Anae Lupematasila Lima Arthur John Anae has received a King's Service Medal in the King's birthday honours. Anae Arthur Anae has been honoured for services to the Samoan community. "On behalf of our community, I'm thrilled for it, because this isn't me. This is not mine," Anae said. "This belongs to the Samoan community who stood behind and joined the battle to get justice that belonged to us, and the recognition belongs to all of us, because we've all had to hold hands and and fight this for a long time." Read more: Anae has been part of the push for the Samoa Citizenship Bill , which restores a pathway for citizenship for a group of Samoans who had their right to it removed. He led the Mau o Samoa I le Sitiseni committee from 1997, keeping awareness of the issue alive and supporting the activism of transitional Samoans, which culminated in 24,500 Select Committee submissions on the Bill before its passing. Anae was a list MP from 1996 to 2002, initiating several Pacific initiatives during this time. He was a Manukau city councillor from 2004 to 2010 and an Auckland councillor from 2010 to 2016, chairing the Economic Forum for both councils. Anae Arthur Anae - far right corner - with his parents and siblings. Photo: Supplied Besides politics Anae is an elder of the Pacific Islanders Presbyterian Church and has chaired its development committee. Hailing from the villages of Falelatai, Apia, Siumu, and Safotulafai in Samoa, Anae reflects on his parents' journey and their challenges after moving to Aotearoa from Samoa. He said he dedicates the King's Service Medal to his parents, who moved to New Zealand in 1951 when he was five years old. "All our parents, not just my parents.... came out here in the 50s for one reason, to give their children an education, an opportunity. "We tend to overlook, these days, the people who paved the way for us, and our parents had to sacrifice themselves on factory floors to give their children opportunities for tomorrow, and those opportunities are what we're reaping today. "I was asked the question the other day, well, who's going to run the mantle after you're gone? I said, there's an army of young Pacific people behind me, highly educated, and they won't be drawn back by the fa'a'aloalo [respect] which has always held us back. "Palangis (Pakeha) have always said - treated us - our fa'a'aloalo and respect is a sign of weakness. They've got a hell of a lot to learn." The advocating doesn't end here for Anae, who is currently working on getting one million signatures for a petition on a visa-free travel for Pacific countries. "I'm still battling on two things, and that is the recognition of the woman married to these people or the men as well. "I still believe in my heart that New Zealand owes these people 50 percent of their pension if they stay in Samoa, where they want to stay, and have the freedom to travel backwards and forward as they want. And these are two issues that I will continue to fight with them because I believe in it and they're things that are right and should be done." Asked about future generation looking at awards like this, he said: "My only advice for all our people is, whatever we do in life, you do it with a clean heart. "You don't look at any rewards or anything that might come - they never come. "Your thinking is based on what you're trying to achieve for people, from your heart, that's what you do; win or lose, you do it."
RNZ News
16 hours ago
- RNZ News
Backyard battles take fighting off street, participant says
Hamilton man Cameron Harcourt (left), with an opponent at the King of the Street event on 24 May. Photo: Supplied A participant in a controversial street fighting competition is defending it, saying amateur tournaments remove violence from the streets. An unregulated tournament promoted by New Zealand mixed martial arts fighter Dan Hooker was held in a suburban Auckland backyard on Saturday 24 May , with 32 combatants competing for a $50,000 prize. Hooker said the only major injury was to a fighter's arm and signalled plans to host further events , despite criticism. New Zealand Boxing Coaches Association president Billy Meehan described the event as "thuggery, not sport", but Hamilton fighter Cameron Harcourt, who travelled up for the event, said the backlash was unfair. "We're going to fight anyway," he said. "There's fights on the streets. "The same way Streetbeefs in America started to get the fights off the streets. If you had beef, you apply for this and you jump in, and it gives us a place to do it in a controlled environment. "The thuggery is taken out and we've turned it into a sport." Streetbeefs is an unregulated American backyard fighting club and You Tube channel, hosting different combat codes. The founders said it was established as a response to more "dangerous forms of street and gun violence". Cameron Harcourt (right) says the Auckland backyard fighting event took violence off the street and put it in a controlled environment. Photo: Supplied Police are investigating one fighter from the Saturday event, who was seen wearing an electronic monitoring bracelet in social media footage of his fight. Harcourt said he wanted to prove that the fights were a fair playing field, and not all about "tattoos and gang affiliations". "Nothing changes what someone is - we're all humans. Doesn't matter about your colour, your size, your age, your background, we're all people and we all bleed. "I think it is a good sport and I love fighting for that." Up to nine different gangs were reportedly represented at the tournament. Fighters had to sign a waiver before taking part, stipulating that involvement was at their discretion. He said, unlike team sports like rugby, he enjoyed how he was the only person accountable, if the fight did not go his way. "You're stuck in a ring with contact and you just feel alive, and it's just sick," he said. "It's also art. "You can create your combos and perform them. It's just a wicked sport." Although billed as an amateur event, it is understood a professional fighter won the tournament. Harcourt hoped to contest a planned tournament in Christchurch later this year. The Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) suggests participants of amateur street fighting events will be covered under the scheme, as it did not require details of how injuries occur. An agency spokesperson said the scheme operated on a no-fault basis. "All New Zealanders pay levies in different ways. The money we collect goes into one of our five accounts. "We use each account to cover specific types of injuries. For example, if someone is injured playing sports, the money used to support their recovery is dependent on their individual circumstances." Last year, the cost of active ACC claims for sport and recreation injuries exceeded $1 billion, while accidental injuries in the home and community, which covered injuries from assaults and also concussion, cost more than $2.3 billion. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
