Plans for £8m Ripon Cathedral annexe withdrawn
Plans for a new £8m annexe at Ripon Cathedral have been withdrawn after they failed to gain council backing.The proposals for the two-storey structure to be built on part of the public open space known as Minster Gardens were due to be debated by councillors later this month.But the cathedral chapter said it had been decided to withdraw the application after the plans were not supported by Ripon City Council at a meeting in December.In a statement, the cathedral chapter said the debate surrounding the annexe scheme had been "challenging and difficult for everyone, but especially for cathedral staff and supporters".
'Eloquent arguments'
The proposals for the building, which would have contained a song school, cafe and toilets, had divided opinion within Ripon and the surrounding area.Original plans for work on the site had included the felling of 11 trees to make way for the annexe's construction.But under revised plans to be considered within weeks by North Yorkshire councillors, 12 trees would have been removed, a heritage beech tree would have been saved and 23 trees would have been planted in mitigation.In its statement, the cathedral chapter said its members "were saddened" the council did not support the proposed annexe in its December meeting "despite the many eloquent arguments placed before them and the amendments that had been made to retain the beech tree".According to the Local Democracy Reporting Service, the statement said the application had been withdrawn to "allow the further development and amendment of our plans to be discussed constructively and positively, balancing the many complex constraints and opportunities"."We now look to work constructively with North Yorkshire Council and Ripon City Council on how the essential needs of the cathedral can be met and will be asking them to share their vision for how the Cathedral Quarter will be developed," it added.
'Meaningful discussions'
A spokesperson for the Save Our Trees campaign, whose members had fought the scheme, said the withdrawal of the plans was "a vindication for campaigners who have tirelessly fought for the past two years to protect the local park against a large development and developer".Meanwhile, Ripon Civic Society, which has an advisory role on local planning applications, said the move by the cathedral chapter would allow "meaningful discussions" to be held with planners, the council, Historic England and local residents."The society has never denied the cathedral's needs, and looks forward to finding a way of meeting them that heals the present divide," it added.Announcing the withdrawal, the cathedral chapter said it wanted to clarify that all costs for developing the annexe proposals had been covered by fundraising from supporters.Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North or tell us a story you think we should be covering here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
18 hours ago
- BBC News
Whitby East Pier ladder replacements prompt objections
Concerns have been raised over the replacement of wooden ladders with a steel alternative on a pier in Yorkshire Council has asked for its retrospective application for the replacement of five ladders on the Grade II listed East Pier at Henrietta Street to be approved at a 29ft 6in (9m) long ladders, which provide pedestrian access to the pier, are made of galvanised steel rather than timber and locals have raised concerns about the visual impact on the site, which was built in the early 18th Town Council has objected to the proposal, stating that councillors wanted to see a "like-for-like replacement instead". It said the replacements would "impact on the character and appearance of the area" and raised concerns "about the choice of materials used".According to a report prepared for the Scarborough and Whitby planning committee, the previous timber ladders were "replacements for earlier ones, likely replaced numerous times over the centuries as a result of the maritime environment" and they were not considered "original".Three of the ladders are located on the western side and two are on the eastern side of the pier. According to the Local Democracy Reporting Service, the report added: "They are permanently fixed and installed in the same location with the same measurements as the previous timber ladders […] and are fixed to the existing recesses in the pier wall."The authority's principal building conservation officer said the plans had not resulted in the loss of "features of architectural interest" and "no harm would result to the overall heritage significance of the East Pier".A planning officer added that the colour and appearance of the new ladders would dull down relatively quickly and the metal ladders would then "blend more comfortably with the stonework".The planning committee will meet on 12 June to decide on the application. Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Switching Basildon night lights back on set to cost £480k
Switching street lights back on all night could cost a town £480,000 over four years, a council has Council is expected to give the green light to spend the money at a meeting on February 2014, Essex County Council switched street lighting off across the county between the hours of midnight and 05:00. The times were later revised to 01:00 to 05: councillor Aidan McGurran said he would be "delighted" if it happened but the final decision lay with the county council. Basildon Council turned the lights back on in 2019 for a four-year period - but that ended in 2023. It was hoped they would return by the autumn. Mr McGurran said: "I feel very pleased this is happening, I'm delighted, we would have liked to have done it earlier, when we got back into administration a year ago, but our finances didn't allow it."Residents bring it up all the time, it's the biggest issue after bins, as people just don't feel safe."Council papers stated the year cost for the lights would be about £120,000, with a risk that sum could rise due to increasing energy costs, but as LED lights were upgraded in 2020/21, they could cost less to run, said the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS)."Reinstating night-time lighting could help to improve the look and feel of the borough and reduce the perception of crime," the council said. It hoped the outcome would mean that "residents feel safe and secure in their homes, towns and open spaces". "Reinstating night time lighting will contribute towards this objective," it added. Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Cornish slurry lagoon plans raise smell and access concerns
Concerns have been raised over plans for a slurry lagoon in Cornwall.A Cornwall Council planning committee is set to review the application from Richard Best - which is seeking permission for an earth-banked slurry lagoon at a farm site in Hatt, near lagoon would provide up to five months of storage and lie approximately 280m (918.6ft) to the south west of the nearest neighbouring residential property, according to the Local Democracy Reporting plans have been objected to by Botus Fleming Parish Council, which had concerns about the smell, potential contamination of a water course and highways impact. Slurry is a mixture of water and animal manure, which is spread on the land as a natural fertiliser.A council planning report said the scheme would not result in any significant adverse impacts to the living conditions currently enjoyed by neighbours and had been earmarked for approval. 'Headaches and cough' In its objection, Botus Fleming Parish Council said it was not clear how the slurry would be transported to the land is just off the A388, but concerns about large tankers driving down narrow rural roads locally used by walkers, horse riders and other motorists were raised by the added residents currently suffered from the stench of slurry across the wider farming site."They suffer headaches and coughs from the air pollution that is generated around their homes, their eyes sting and they have good reasons to fear the long-term consequences for their health," the council said. An odour impact assessment had been submitted and the council's public protection team had raised no objections from a Cornwall Wildlife Trust has also been consulted as the site is near the Villaton Wood County Wildlife Site, with the charity making recommendations to ensure wildlife is protected during Environment Agency (EA) had no objection to the plans, which it said would ensure the farm operated with sufficient storage for slurry."Nonetheless, the proposal must operate in accordance with the relevant regulations," the agency added.
