Sean 'Diddy' Combs juror dismissed despite defense's concern about race
By Luc Cohen
NEW YORK (Reuters) -A Black juror was dismissed from Sean "Diddy" Combs' sex trafficking trial on Monday, despite defense objections that the dismissal would reduce the racial diversity of the panel determining the hip-hop mogul's fate.
U.S. District Judge Arun Subramanian said the juror's inconsistent answers to questions about where he lived raised questions about his honesty and could taint a verdict.
Subramanian said he took defense concerns about race seriously -- Combs is Black -- but could not take into account that the Black male juror would be replaced by a white male, who had been an alternate juror.
"The court should not, indeed cannot, allow race to enter into its consideration," Subramanian said outside the jury's presence, as the sixth week of Combs' trial got underway in Manhattan federal court.
The jury is anonymous, which is common for high-profile trials where jurors could face threats or harassment if their identities were known.
Subramanian said the jury was "diverse."
Combs has pleaded not guilty to racketeering and sex trafficking charges. Prosecutors say he coerced women over two decades to take part in drug-fueled sexual performances with male sex workers, sometimes known as "Freak Offs." The defense says the sexual activity described by prosecutors was consensual.
Lawyers for Combs, 55, have argued that their client was unfairly targeted because of his race. In a Sunday night court filing, defense lawyers wrote that the juror in question was one of two Black men on the jury.
"The fairness of the trial depends in part on having jurors with backgrounds similar to Mr. Combs share their perspectives on the evidence with other jurors from diverse backgrounds during deliberations," Combs' lawyers wrote.
Prosecutors said in a Monday court filing that it was "baseless" for the defense to suggest that they had a racial motivation to seek the juror's dismissal.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
2 hours ago
Diddy trial day 28 recap: Judge dismisses a juror over a 'lack of candor'
For the first time since the sex trafficking trial of Sean "Diddy" Combs began six weeks ago, the jury that will decide the fate of the rap mogul gained a new member on Monday. The judge overseeing the case dismissed a juror -- and replaced him with an alternate -- after prosecutors raised concerns about his answers during jury selection and whether he could be trusted. The decision to drop the juror means that a Black, middle-aged man has now been replaced by an older, white man. Combs' attorneys have objected to the change, saying it was a "veiled" attempt by the prosecution to alter the racial makeup of the panel. U.S. District Judge Arun Subramanian dismissed those concerns, saying it is "inappropriate to consider race" in deciding whether the juror's responses to questions about where he lived were appropriate. "The record raised serious concerns as to the juror's candor and whether he shaded answers to get on and stay on the jury," Subramanian said Monday. "There's nothing the juror could say at this point to put the genie back in the bottle." At issue was whether Juror No. 6 had been honest about where he lived. During jury selection, he had said he lived in the Bronx but later suggested he moved to New Jersey, making him ineligible for a Manhattan federal jury. The juror was replaced with an alternate juror -- a 57-year-old architect from New York City's northern suburb of Westchester -- making the jury overall older and whiter. The change to the jury comes as prosecutors are calling their final witnesses this week. Next up will be the defense and, from there, the jury will get the case. Prosecutors argue that Combs used his wealth, influence and power to coerce women into sex before using violence and threats to keep them silent to protect his reputation. Combs has pleaded not guilty to the charges, and his lawyers argue that any of the women who participated in his drug-fueled sex parties were voluntary participants who consented to having sex with male prostitutes while Combs directed, watched and masturbated. Combs could face the rest of his life in prison if convicted on all counts. On Tuesday, prosecutors plan to call Combs' former assistant, Brendan Paul, who has been granted immunity so he could testify without fear of being prosecuted himself. Paul was arrested on drug charges last year, around the time Combs' mansions were raided by federal agents. Charges against him were dismissed after Paul agreed to participate in a diversion program. Jury sees freak-off videos To conclude the 28th day of the trial, members of the jury donned headphones Monday to watch excerpts of videos showing the orgies Combs allegedly hosted, described by multiple witnesses as "freak-offs," "hotel nights" or "wild king nights." Prosecutors had previously shown the jury still images from the sex parties, but Monday's testimony marked the first time they saw the video evidence. Prosecutors allege that Combs kept the recordings and used them as leverage over his alleged victims to enforce their silence. One video was longer than 39 minutes, though the jury saw only a portion of that. The videos were pulled from a laptop turned over by Combs' ex-girlfriend and star witness, Cassie Ventura. The exhibits were entered into evidence under seal, so they were not accessible to the press or public to view. News organizations had fought for the right of the press or the public to have some ability to see the recordings in order to help the general public understand the nature of what the jury was watching. The judge has refused those efforts. Prosecutors try to fill in the gaps The names of Combs' former chief of staff, Kristina Khorram, and security guard Damian Butler were mentioned by other witnesses as key individuals who allegedly assisted Combs. But prosecutors have not called either of them to the stand. Instead, prosecutors on Monday used so-called "summary" witnesses -- a federal agent and government paralegal -- to offer to the jury additional evidence related to the allegations against Combs. Though prosecutors allege that Combs relied on others to orchestrate his criminal enterprise, no one besides Combs has been charged with any crimes. In one group of messages shown to the jury on Monday, Khorram and Combs' travel arranger Jessica Ruiz discussed a flight for Jane -- one of Combs' former girlfriends who testified he forced him to participate in sex parties -- and an escort named Paul. Prosecutors hope the evidence could bolster the sex-trafficking allegations against Combs. Khorram's attorneys did not respond to a request for comment from ABC News, but they have denied wrongdoing in past statements related to civil lawsuits in which she was mentioned. Combs' former assistant, known by the pseudonym "Mia," told the jury that Combs' bodyguard, Damian Butler, known as D-Roc, called her and texted her repeatedly in the days and weeks after Cassie Ventura's explosive civil lawsuit became public. According to the testimony, Butler was urging her to talk to Combs. Butler is not testifying, but a summary witness read into the record some of the call and text logs from his phone. They appear to show him in close communication with Combs while he is breezily chatting with Mia. Mia testified that the outreach from Butler and Combs "terrified" her. The messages showed how Mia brushed off Butler's repeated offers to "send my sister a gift." Federal prosecutors allege Combs's prominent record label and music business doubled as a criminal enterprise with the assistance of his bodyguards, who pressured witnesses like Mia "to stay silent and not report what they experienced or knew." Prosecutors try to show a criminal enterprise Through summary witnesses, jurors also saw additional business records that prosecutors argue show how Combs used his business to fund his personal life and alleged crimes. Credit card statements showed Sean Combs used his American Express for Ventura and a male escort to fly separately to New York in December 2009. The jury was shown a bank statement from one of Combs' businesses -- Bad Boy Entertainment Worldwide -- that paid $369,279 to cover the costs of the trip, along with other expenses. The bank statement could help support prosecutors' claim that Combs used his business to engage in sex trafficking by flying escorts across state lines. Earlier this month, prosecutors called Derek Ferugson, the former chief financial officer of Combs' Enterprises, who testified that Combs' business and personal expenses were often intertwined. Defense previews their case With prosecutors expected to rest their case as early as Wednesday, defense attorneys began to preview on Monday the case they will bring to the jury. Combs' lawyers signaled it has as many as three witnesses lined up to testify beginning Friday. Among the first defense witnesses is going to be Vashta Dunlap, who was a vice president at Bad Boy. Defense lawyers signaled they may call additional witnesses and did not address whether Combs would take the stand in his own defense.
New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
Minnesota state Sen. Ann Rest —who escaped accused assassin Vance Boelter's crosshairs — speaks out on ‘scary' ordeal
One of the Minnesota pols who escaped suspected assassin Vance Boelter's crosshairs told The Post on Monday that her close call was terrifying. 'It's scary,'' Democratic state Sen. Ann Rest said — shortly after it was revealed that Boelter had allegedly shot and wounded another Minnesota senator and his wife before parking near her home early Saturday. Boelter, 57, was apparently scared off from Rest's home by a cop who had pulled up to her property as part of a wellness check, which police were conducting on local politicians after the earlier shooting. 3 Minnesota state Sen. Ann Rest is speaking out as its revealed she narrowly escaped a close call with accused assassin Vance Boelter. Minnesota Senate Media Services 3 Boelter was apparently scared off from Rest's home by police conducting wellness checks. via REUTERS 3 Police say Boelter used this Beretta handgun to carry out the shootings. District Court of Minnesota Boelter is accused of later fatally gunning down state Rep. Melissa Hortman and her husband. 'I have been made aware that the shooting suspect was parked near my home early Saturday morning. I am so grateful for the heroic work of the New Hope Police Department and its officers,' Rest said. Follow the latest on the arrest of suspected Minnesota assassin Vance Boelter: 'Their quick action saved my life. I am also thankful for the work of state and local law enforcement to apprehend the suspect before he could take any more lives.' A relative of Rest told The Post the lucky lawmaker is 'pretty sad' about the targeted shooting. 'She's been [in politics] for I think 42 years and for something like this to happen is just tragic,' the kin said outside Rest's home Monday. 'I know she feels horrible for her colleagues.' 'She's had better days,' she added. 'You lose colleagues like that, that's terrifying.'
Hamilton Spectator
4 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Man formerly on death row can't serve 2 life terms at the same time, Tennessee Supreme Court rules
MEMPHIS, Tenn., (AP) — A Tennessee judge did not have the authority to give Pervis Payne, who was formerly on death row, concurrent sentences of life in prison after ruling that he was intellectually disabled and could not be executed for two 1987 killings, the state Supreme Court said Monday. The court's ruling said a Memphis judge lacked the jurisdiction to give Payne two life sentences to run at the same time rather than one after the other. The concurrent sentences allowed Payne to be eligible for parole in 2026 — 30 years earlier than if the sentences were consecutive. The Supreme Court did not issue the consecutive life sentences for Payne in its ruling. Instead, it returned the matter to the trial court in Memphis for further proceedings. Payne had been on death row for the killings of a woman and her 2-year-old daughter. In January 2022, Judge Paula Skahan sentenced Payne to concurrent sentences of life with the possibility of parole after ruling in November 2021 that his death sentences must be vacated because he was intellectually disabled. The case has drawn national attention from anti-death-penalty activists and included the involvement of the Innocence Project, which argues for the use of DNA testing in cases claiming wrongful conviction. DNA tests failed to exonerate Payne. Skahan's ruling that Payne should be removed from death row was based on a Tennessee law passed earlier in 2021 that made prohibiting the execution of intellectually disabled people retroactive to past cases. Before the 2021 law, Tennessee had no mechanism for people to reopen a case to press an intellectual disability claim. Executions of intellectually disabled people were ruled unconstitutional in 2002, when the U.S. Supreme Court found they violate the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishment. Payne, 58, was convicted of first-degree murder for the killings of Charisse Christopher and her 2-year-old daughter, Lacie Jo, who were repeatedly stabbed in their Millington apartment and left in a pool of blood. Christopher's son, Nicholas, who was 3 at the time, also was stabbed but survived. Payne, who is Black, has always maintained his innocence. He told police he was at Christopher's apartment building to meet his girlfriend when he heard the mother, who was white, screaming and tried to help. He said he panicked when he saw a white police officer and ran away. During his murder trial, prosecutors said Payne was high on cocaine and looking for sex when he killed Christopher and her daughter in a 'drug-induced frenzy.' Prosecutors said the evidence overwhelmingly pointed to Payne as the killer. However, evidence presented by two experts showed Payne was intellectually disabled, while Payne's supporters said he had taken significant steps in his rehabilitation while serving three decades in prison. It was not immediately clear Monday when Payne would be eligible for parole under the Supreme Court's decision. A hearing must be set to address the new ruling. Payne's lawyer, Kelley Henry, has pushed for Payne's full exoneration. 'Pervis Payne remains incarcerated for a crime he did not commit,' she said in an email Monday. 'We will continue to fight for his freedom and to bring him home to his family.' Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
