REVIEW: ‘Dept. Q' — Netflix's cold-case thriller is fun but flawed

Arab News

a day ago

DUBAI: Netflix's latest police-procedural is set in Scotland, but based on the novels of Danish writer Jussi Adler-Olsen.
For the latest updates, follow us on Instagram @arabnews.lifestyle
At its heart is detective Carl Morck (Matthew Goode). Morck is one of those cops; you know, great at his job but terrible with people, emotionally stunted, arrogant, divorced, et cetera. Morck and his partner — and best (only?) friend — James Hardy (Jamie Sives) are shot and wounded in a seemingly routine visit to a crime scene, leaving Hardy paralyzed and the junior officer who arrived first at the scene dead. Morck returns to work to discover that his boss has assigned him to head up a new department (established at the behest of her superiors) looking into cold cases — a good excuse to get the troublesome Morck out of the main office and into a dingy basement room where he can't easily bother anyone.
He's assigned some assistance: Akram (Alexej Manvelov) — a Syrian refugee who's ostensibly an IT boffin, but, it quickly becomes clear, is also a very handy detective with some serious combat skills; Rose (Leah Byrne), an eager and capable cadet struggling with her mental health after a fatal accident at work; and, eventually, Hardy.
Their first case is the disappearance and presumed death of prosecutor Merritt Lingard four years previously. The last person to see her alive was her brother William, but he's unable to communicate having suffered brain damage as a teen. The case's many tangents lead off into conspiracies, organized crime and more. The truth of it, though, is considerably more prosaic.
The good news: 'Dept. Q' — as you'd expect with Netflix money behind it — looks great, with a gritty, noir-ish feel. There's a genuine chemistry between the members of the titular department, and it has an absorbing mix of dark humor and sometimes-horrifying violence. Sives, Manvelov, and Byrne, in particular, are compelling draws. Goode offers a largely convincing portrayal of a not-very-nice man attempting to become slightly nicer. It's enjoyable and easy to binge.
But one suspects that 'enjoyable and easy to binge' wasn't the limit of the showrunners' ambitions, and 'Dept. Q' certainly shows the potential to be more than that. It's let down, however, by some horribly clunky storylines, not least the relationship between Morck and his assigned therapist Rachel (a wasted Kelly Macdonald), which appears to have been lifted from a discarded rom-com pitch. And many will likely find that the ultimate solution to the case stretches credulity well beyond their limits.
Still, it's clearly set up for a second season (and possibly many more), and there's enough promise here to believe that 'Dept. Q' will find its feet and become a must-see — rather than a maybe-see — show.