ICMSA: New EU deforestation law ‘makes mockery' of simplification
The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association (ICMSA) has said that the EU Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) 'makes a mockery' out of the EU's efforts to simplify regulations for farms and businesses.
The aim of the EU Deforestation Regulation, according to the European Commission, is to ensure that goods in the EU market do not contribute to deforestation and forest degradation, both within the EU and globally.
The new regulation means that companies will only be allowed to sell products in the EU if the supplier provides a 'due diligence' statement confirming that the product does not come from deforested land or has led to forest degradation.
The regulation was set to come into effect at the end of 2024. However, this was deferred until the end of 2025, and mid-2026 for smaller businesses.
Despite that deferral, the ICMSA has claimed that the commission will 'have zero credibility with farmers on their much-hyped simplification process…if they proceed with the EU Deforestation Regulation as currently structured'.
The chairperson of ICMSA's Livestock Committee, Michael O'Connell, remarked that the requirements of the EDUR are 'illogical, dizzyingly complex, make no sense, and place an unacceptable burden on farmers'.
'It is surely not too much to ask the commission to decide one way or the other what they are trying to do. The new level of administration and form-filling involved in the deforestation regulation makes a mockery of the so-called simplification process,' he said.
The vast majority of farmland in Ireland has been declared on the [basic payment] system all the way back to 1994, so there's over 30 years of records along with an inspection regime that means the Department [of Agriculture, Food and the Marine] has excellent data on every parcel of land and its usage.
'What the EU Deforestation Regulation will involve is effectively to ignore all this data and implement a new regime where farmers will have to declare annually where their cattle are grazing or their feed is coming? What about the information that we've been giving them for the last 30 years? Why can't they use that?' O' Connell commented.
'We're being asked to start from scratch again and comply with yet another additional administration system; a whole new regulatory regime that will almost certainly cause serious problems when introduced and which ultimately will not achieve its objective,' he added.
The ICMSA is calling for the EU to allow the department to utilise this data and use it to pre-approve or reject farmers under the EUDR for 2026.
'They have the data and it is simply a case of verifying it. There should be absolutely no requirement on pre-approved farmers to submit documentation or otherwise and the produce from their farms should be marketed as normal,' O' Connell said.
He added: 'ICMSA cannot understand the logic of the EU Commission of introducing a ridiculously complex system on top of the system that's already giving them the data they need to make the decisions.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
3 hours ago
- RTÉ News
€90m in counterfeit food, drink seized in EU last year
Over €90 million in counterfeit food and drink products were seized across the European Union last year, according to the EU's Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO). Counterfeit products are often associated with luxury goods but food products are the second most seized category of products at the EU's external borders. Over 3,600 EU food and drink products are protected by geographical indications (GIs), which protect the names of products that originate from specific regions and possess qualities or characteristics due to that geographical environment. For example, Irish whiskey is a protected product name, meaning whiskey produced outside Ireland cannot legally be labelled as Irish whiskey. Other protected Irish brands include Achill Island Sea Salt, Sneem Black Pudding, Irish Grass Fed Beef, and the Waterford Blaa. EUIPO said that wines and spirits face one of the highest counterfeiting rates compared to other products, with annual losses in sales of €2.28 billion and nearly 5,700 jobs in the EU across all categories. For Irish products, €40 million in sales are lost each year in this sector. Last year's €90 million worth of seizures of counterfeit food and drink products were coordinated by Europol and Interpol, and amounted to 22,000 tonnes of food and around 850,000 litres of (mostly alcoholic) drinks. EUIPO said the operation resulted in 11 criminal networks being dismantled and 278 people reported to judicial authorities in connection with the counterfeits. According to the report, France, Italy and Germany lead in both production and consumption of geographically protected products, with France alone accounting for nearly 32% of EU GI product sales. Wine constitutes 54% of the total EU GI consumption, which makes it particularly vulnerable to counterfeiting. Other products heavily impacted by counterfeiting include olive oil, beer, meat, cheese, and dairy products. The EU agency said that when counterfeiting of drinks, particularly alcoholic drinks, organised crime groups employ sophisticated methods to deceive consumers. Counterfeiters frequently reuse original bottles or print fake labels to place on empty bottles, making it harder for consumers and authorities to distinguish between legitimate and fraudulent products. Apart from the economic loss, in its report, the EU Intellectual Property Office points to health concerns over counterfeit food and drink products, with some of the seized items containing dangerous substances, including methanol, mercury, fipronil, and toxic pesticides. China and Turkey are listed as being among the most frequently reported countries of origin for counterfeit food and drinks in the EU. Along with the report entitled 'What's on your table?', the EUIPO is highlighting ways for consumers to avoid fake products, including buying from official retailers and verifying product labelling. EUIPO Executive Director João Negrão said that counterfeit food and drink products are a "major public health concern". "Our campaign aims to equip consumers with the knowledge to protect themselves while supporting legitimate businesses that uphold EU quality standards. This is a battle we must fight together: authorities, producers and consumers alike," he added.
RTÉ News
3 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Harris urges exemption for key sectors from retaliatory tariffs
Tánaiste Simon Harris has urged the EU's trade commissioner to exempt sectors key to the Irish economy, such as aviation, medical, agrifood and the equine industry, from any retaliatory tariffs the EU could impose on a range of US products should the current trade negotiations fail. In a letter to Maroš Šefčovič, seen by RTÉ News, the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade also urged the trade commissioner, previously the EU's Brexit negotiator, to ensure that Europe's potential retaliation against US President Donald Trump's threat of sweeping tariffs does not adversely impact Northern Ireland. The letter essentially sets out the Government's position as the deadline for a potential escalation of the trade war between President Trump and the European Union looms. Talks between EU and US trade officials have been intensifying in recent days in an effort to avert wholesale US tariffs on European goods, which in turn would trigger a significant retaliatory response by the EU. On 2 April, President Trump announced 20% "reciprocal" tariffs on nearly all European goods, as well as sweeping duties on scores of other countries. After turbulence on the bond markets Mr Trump paused the 20% tariffs for 90 days (until 9 July). Negotiations between the European Commission, led by Mr Šefčovič, and the Trump administration, led by Trade Secretary Jamieson Greer and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, then got under way. Last month, Mr Trump threatened to hit the EU with 50% tariffs, complaining that negotiations were "going nowhere". That threat was lifted following a phone call with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. US and EU teams negotiating a potential trade deal that would lift the threat of mutual tariffs have intensified their work in recent days. Despite that the EU has been readying a list of hundreds of US product lines worth some €95 billion which could be hit by retaliatory tariffs should those negotiations fail. The list, which was published on 8 May, was followed by a four week consultation period between the European Commission and member states. Mr Harris's letter to Mr Šefčovič essentially codifies Ireland's concerns about the damage the list could do to key sectors of the Irish economy. He wrote: "I have heard concerns both about the immediate impact of the proposed rebalancing measures on imports, but also about the potential for them to result in further retaliatory action by the US. "I believe this is a reasonable and well-founded concern which we must also take account of in formulating our approach. It is particularly acute in the agri-food and drinks sector." The Tánaiste highlights the risk to Ireland's "leading" role in the global aviation sector, given that it is home to Ryanair, "Europe's largest airline, as well as the world's leading aircraft leasing sector." The Government believes that the leasing sector would be damaged given its reliance on US spare parts. "Given the limited capacity of EU manufacturers to meet demand in the sector, I believe that rules of origin for goods with a very long service life, such as whole aircraft and helicopters, need to be very carefully considered in the eventual approach to applying tariffs. "Specifically, I would ask that used aircraft are excluded from import tariffs," he wrote. The Tánaiste also highlighted the risk to Ireland's medtech industry, which relies heavily on an integrated supply chain with the United States. He wrote: "I have consulted with stakeholders and have concerns about the potential impact of the proposed list, which includes a large number of tariff lines (around 800) which could potentially impact on essential medical devices for European patients. "I would ask that you engage in detail with the medtech sector to ensure that our rebalancing measures are targeted in a way that does not undermine this important sector and the lifesaving technologies they supply to consumers across the EU." He said that while it may be "theoretically possible" for companies to switch suppliers, in practice this was not an immediate option in the short term due to the regulatory and certification requirements. Mr Harris also raised "an issue of serious concern in Ireland," namely the potential for the EU to retaliate by imposing tariffs on animal feed "for which Irish farmers have a very high reliance on imports from the US." He wrote: "Increasing costs on these vital inputs will not only put further pressure on a stressed sector but risks feeding through in increased prices for consumers (in one area, beet pulp, Ireland accounts for the entirety of EU imports)." The Tánaiste also raised concerns about the inclusion of pure breeding horses on the EU's list of countermeasures. He wrote: "The equine sector provides significant employment in rural areas, with the US by the far the largest export market for Irish thoroughbreds outside the UK. "This trade depends on horses moving in both directions. I would ask that these items be removed from the list - doing so will have a very limited impact on the overall value of the list and would reduce disproportionate impact on Ireland." The Tánaiste concluded by warning about the risk of EU retaliatory measures to Northern Ireland, given its hybrid trade status post-Brexit. "I would also like to highlight the need to minimise unintended consequences on Northern Ireland of the current situation to the extent possible," he wrote. "Considering your deep experience from EU-UK negotiations, and your continuing responsibilities in that relationship, I know you will appreciate that this is a politically sensitive topic and will need careful management." The Government is understood to be relieved that neither pharmaceuticals nor dairy products appear on the list of EU countermeasures. Officials have stressed that while aircraft, spirits, including whiskey, and medical devices are included, the EU's retaliatory measures would be implemented immediately and may not be implemented at all if a deal is reached. While officials have said EU and US teams are making progress, it is understood the final say on whether a trade agreement can avert an escalating trade war will go to President Trump.
Agriland
13 hours ago
- Agriland
NI beef and lamb export markets ‘more critical than ever'
Beef and lamb exports are of major significance to Northern Ireland's overall economy. according to Livestock and Meat Commission (LMC) chief executive, Colin Smith. And he considers the scale of this enterprise even more significant. The LMC representative pointed out that Northern Ireland – with a population of approximately two million people – produces enough food to feed five times that number, underscoring the vital importance of export markets to the region's agri-food economy. Smith said: 'At the core of this output is the production of Farm Quality Assured beef and lamb. 'Identifying and securing high-value markets for red meat is more critical than ever, especially in light of significant political and economic developments over the past three years.' 'These include a change of UK government and the negotiation of key trade agreements with major global players such as the US, EU, Australia, New Zealand, and India. 'The evolving international trade landscape, combined with fluctuating global tariffs, presents increasing complexity for red meat exporters.' According to Smith, the navigation of these challenges will be essential to ensuring long-term profitability and sustainability for Northern Ireland's red meat sector. He fully recognises the need for Northern Ireland's beef and lamb sectors to be fully cognisant of all these factors. But there is also a political dimension to all of this, which could be of an even more fundamentally significant. Reflecting on the evolving political landscape, Smith commented on the impact of recent UK government decisions. 'The new Labour government has now been in office for a year. And during that time, it appears to have prioritised food security over food self-sufficiency. 'This shift in focus has raised concerns within the farming community.' Smith claimed that support for Labour among farmers 'is clearly waning', which he said was down to 'the government's recent handling of agricultural issues'. 'Inheritance tax reforms are just one example and many within the sector feel farming has been sacrificed at the expense of other interests – particularly in trade negotiations such as those with the US,' he said. Beef and lamb export markets In the view of the LMC CEO, these developments underscore growing tensions between policy direction and the needs of UK agriculture at a time when global competitiveness is more vital than ever. The aforementioned agreements follow on from free trade deals with Australia and New Zealand arrived at by the previous Conservative governments. When fully operational, these arrangements could provide beef export quotas of 170,000t and 60,000t annually for the respective countries. Smith said: 'But that's not the end of the story. The EU continues to progress a trade deal with the Mercosur block which could see almost 100,000t of beef from South American countries coming into Europe on an annual basis. 'This may not impact directly on the UK beef market. But it could have a very significant indirect effect.' So the question then arises: what happens to the significant tonnages of UK beef that are currently exported to the EU in the wake of the Mercosur deal's full implementation? 'The prospect of significantly reduced beef export trading levels from the UK to Europe is a very real one in these circumstances,' said Smith. But even in the here and now the commission's chief executive is concerned about imported beef making its way on to UK supermarket shelves. He explained: 'UK supermarkets are the most significant purchasers of farm quality beef and lamb produced in Northern Ireland. 'It is crucially important that this commitment to Northern Ireland's red meat sector is maintained into the future.'
