BC Court of Appeal Dismisses Health-Care Workers' COVID Vaccine Mandate Challenge
The B.C. Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal of the province's COVID vaccine mandate for health-care workers.
In a May 6 hearing, the court dismissed the appeal on the grounds it was moot, or no longer relevant.
Allison Pejovic, a constitutional lawyer representing the health-care workers, said she was disappointed by the decision, telling The Epoch Times the legal team had expected to argue the case over a number of days.
Pejovic said several Canadian courts have dismissed challenges of pandemic orders on the basis of mootness while, she argued, 'the violation of Charter rights and freedoms has been unprecedented during COVID.'
She said the case was an 'ideal opportunity' for an appellate court to consider 'whether the right of liberty protects a fundamental personal medical decision' of taking a COVID-19 vaccine under threat of termination of employment.
The case was brought by 11 health-care workers and dismissed by the B.C. Supreme Court in 2024, ruling that the mandates did not infringe on workers' rights or charter freedoms.
Related Stories
7/26/2024
5/15/2024
The court said the health orders 'were reasonable in light of the information available' to the provincial health officer at the time.
The appeal court dismissed the case after the Crown brought a motion arguing mootness, Pejovic said.
She said the case would have looked at evidence that 'nearly 100 percent of British Columbians were immune to COVID' during the time COVID-19 mandates continued to be enforced for health-care workers.
Pejovic argued the case would have been an opportunity for the court to decide whether it's lawful under the Charter to restrict rights and freedoms of people who didn't take the COVID vaccine 'when they have proven that they have natural immunity to COVID.'
B.C. Provincial Health Officer Bonnie Henry issued an
The mandate was one of several that resulted in about 1,800 health-care workers losing their jobs, according to the
When the B.C. Supreme Court heard the lawsuit in November 2023, the province still had a vaccine mandate. The health workers argued that COVID-19 no longer presented 'an immediate or significant threat to public health.'
They also said Henry's order was 'ineffective' and 'unreasonable' on the grounds that, because of preventative measures already in place, unvaccinated health-care professionals did not pose a greater risk of passing on the virus to patients.
The Epoch Times contacted Henry's office but did not hear back by publication time.
In her 2023 vaccine order, Henry said she was concerned that any 'slippage in the level of vaccination' among health-care workers could result in 'significant illness' among them, undermining the health-care system's capacity.
Henry said it was 'essential' to maintain high vaccination levels among hospital and community care workers as the 'best means available by which to mitigate the risk to the health of patients, residents, clients and workers and to ensure the preparedness and resiliency of the health-care system,' both at the time and in the event of a resurgence of COVID-19.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
25 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Americans Told To Stay Indoors In 6 States
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Air quality alerts have been issued across six states on Friday, as smoke from Canadian wildfires continues to impact parts of the U.S. Health authorities warn that worsening air quality presents a health hazard, especially for vulnerable populations such as children, seniors, and individuals with existing medical conditions. The National Weather Service (NWS) published alerts for parts of Minnesota, Illinois, Indiana, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Nebraska. The alerts warn that elevated levels of particulate pollution are anticipated due to smoke from the blazes. They also advise residents in affected areas, particularly those in sensitive groups, to avoid prolonged or strenuous outdoor activities. A wildfire burns in Lewiston, Idaho, last week. A wildfire burns in Lewiston, Idaho, last week. August Frank/Lewiston Tribune/AP This is a breaking story. More to follow.
Hamilton Spectator
3 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Niagara Falls MPP backs cross-party push to extend OHIP for prostate cancer testing
Momentum continues to grow for Wayne Gates' push to extend OHIP coverage for prostate cancer screening. On Thursday, the New Democrat supported independent MPP Bobbi Ann Brady's motion to extend Ontario Health Insurance Plan coverage for PSA testing — a cause Gates has championed at Queen's Park for the past six years. 'This isn't about politics — it's about saving lives,' said Gates. 'Every year, thousands of men are diagnosed too late because cost is a barrier to early testing. We can fix that. I'm proud to support MPP Brady's motion and I hope every member in the legislature does the same.' Brady, the province's lone independent MPP, representing nearby Haldimand-Norfolk, said she has previously stood and called on the government to support Gates' effort. 'Seeing no movement on this initiative and inspired by the longtime calls for this important change from my colleague Wayne Gates … I have renewed the call with the motion asking the Ford government to cover the cost of PSA tests through OHIP when referred by a health-care provider.' Independent MPP Bobbi Ann Brady. The call to action comes just ahead of Father's Day — a time Gates said is 'perfect' for raising awareness of men's health. He said prostate cancer is the most commonly diagnosed cancer among Canadian men. PSA testing now is not covered by OHIP unless there are symptoms evident, often making it too late for early intervention, said Gates. The motion wants OHIP to cover the cost of tests for patients referred by a health-care provider, saving them the roughly $40 charged by private labs in Ontario. Although earlier readings of Gates' bill won all-party support, the government defeated the bill last year. Canadian Cancer Society's Dr. Stuart Edmonds. A cancer diagnosis costs Canadians an average of $33,000 in their lifetime — on top of that, there are other out-of-pocket expenses like PSA testing, said Dr. Stuart Edmonds, executive vice-president of mission research and advocacy at the Canadian Cancer Society. He said prostate cancer strikes one in eight Canadian men. 'We believe that early detection of prostate cancer shouldn't come with a price tag. The question shouldn't be, 'Can you afford the test?' It should be, 'Do you need it?'' Gates said the latest motion will be debated at a later date, adding it's significant to have Brady — a woman — at the forefront of the effort. 'I think it's really important because it affects the entire family — it may be men that get prostate cancer, but it affects their spouses, the kids. It's good news for us as we try to put more pressure on the government to do this.' He said there's also growing support from firefighter groups across Ontario. 'Firefighters are more likely to get prostate cancer than the general public by 1.41 per cent, so this is now one that the provincial association and the local firefighters are now raising the awareness of trying to get it covered.' Gates said continued awareness is also important. 'Early detection is the key. We think it's a very important motion. I'm glad that it's supported by the Liberals. I'm glad that it's supported by the Greens. I'm glad it's supported by Bobbi Ann. Let's make this the year we get it done — together.' Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Marc Garneau died after 'short but very difficult battle' with cancer, former staffer says
Marc Garneau died this week after being diagnosed with two types of cancer earlier this year, his former staffer says. The first Canadian to travel to space and former cabinet minister died on Wednesday. He was 76. Marc Roy, Garneau's former chief of staff, told CBC's Power & Politicsthat the former minister had been diagnosed with lymphoma and leukemia earlier this year. "He fought a short but very difficult battle with two very rare types of cancer," Roy told host David Cochrane. "Although his diagnosis was only a couple of months ago, he was well until four or five weeks ago. So it went very, very quickly … it's a very, very tough loss." Roy said Garneau only shared his diagnosis with a small circle that agreed to respect his wish for privacy. "[It was] something he wanted to keep with his family so he could concentrate on his time with his family and not distract his family by the attention it could have gotten," Roy said. WATCH | It's a tragic loss,' says former chief of staff: Beyond his legacy as an astronaut, Garneau held a number of federal cabinet positions since 2015, including in transport and foreign affairs. Roy said Garneau was "tremendous" to work for as he reflected on his time in politics. "It's a huge loss to government. I think that his years in Ottawa are filled with many contributions to improving safety and expanding policy. I think he will be remembered for that for decades to come," Roy said. The House of Commons held another moment of silence for Garneau on Thursday and MPs took time to pay tribute to their former colleague. "He reminded us that Canadians can dream big, that we could aim for the stars quite literally," Government House leader Steve MacKinnon said. "He became a powerful symbol of the achievement and the accomplishment of this great country of ours." Like MacKinnon, other MPs reflected on how Garneau inspired Canadians. "Mr. Garneau, the future will always be inspired by your life, which was so inspiring for all Canadians," Conservative MP Gérard Deltell said in French. WATCH | Garneau's 'extraordinary ride': Bloc Québécois MP Rhéal Fortin said Garneau paved the way for other Canadians to journey to space, including Chris Hadfield and Julie Payette. "He showed us the way to the stars," Fortin said in French. Fighting back tears, Green Party Leader Elizabeth May said it was hard to say goodbye to "someone who was unfailingly kind [and] unfailingly respectful." "We've lost a very great human being, and to his entire family: my deepest condolences and sympathy — and know that in that space where he looks down at planet Earth now, I think it's a place called heaven."
