What Whale Bubbles Can Teach Us About Alien Communication
A new study analyzes 12 events in which whales may have tried to communicate with humans.
Researchers have decided that a potentially good way to prepare for future contact with extraterrestrial beings is by studying…whale bubbles.
No, it's not a joke—researchers from the SETI Institute, the University of California, Davis (UC Davis), and several partner institutions recently published a paper describing humpback whales blowing bubble rings during friendly interactions with humans. While this might not seem like a shocking action, the behavior provides insight into non-human intelligence, with important implications for our ongoing search for alien life.
'Because of current limitations on technology, an important assumption of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence is that extraterrestrial intelligence and life will be interested in making contact and so target human receivers,' Laurance Doyle, SETI Institute scientist and co-author of the study published last month in the journal Marine Mammal Science, said in an institute statement. 'This important assumption is certainly supported by the independent evolution of curious behavior in humpback whales.'
While researchers had previously documented humpback whales creating bubble nets to capture prey and using bubbles to vie for female whales, the study examines the cetaceans blowing bubble rings during amicable interactions with humans. Doyle and his colleagues studied 12 bubble ring events involving 11 whales and 39 rings, behaviors that may represent playfulness or an attempt at communication. Jodi Frediani, a co-lead author of the study and marine wildlife photographer affiliated with UC Davis, explained that humpback whales frequently interact with boats and even swimmers in a curious, friendly way.
'Humpback whales live in complex societies, are acoustically diverse, use bubble tools and assist other species being harassed by predators,' added Fred Sharpe, also a co-lead author of the study from UC Davis. 'Now, akin to a candidate signal [from extraterrestrial life], we show they are blowing bubble rings in our direction in an apparent attempt to playfully interact, observe our response, and/or engage in some form of communication.'
Chances are that, should we ever establish contact with extraterrestrials, their form of communication won't be what we expect. By analyzing intelligent nonhuman communication systems—such as whales blowing bubbles while engaging with boats and people—scientists can broaden their understanding of unfamiliar forms of communication and refine what we should look for in our search for life beyond Earth. The goal is to be better prepared if or when contact occurs. Simply put, whale bubbles can be an analog for an alien language.
Their approach is the latest in a host of efforts to simulate extraterrestrial scenarios and hypothesize how we might ultimately come into contact with an alien species.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
an hour ago
- Washington Post
EPA says power plant carbon emissions aren't dangerous. We asked 30 scientists: Here's what they say
WASHINGTON — The Trump administration's Environmental Protection Agency on Wednesday proposed a new ruling that heat-trapping carbon gas 'emissions from fossil fuel-fired power plants do not contribute significantly to dangerous air pollution.'' The Associated Press asked 30 different scientists, experts in climate, health and economics, about the scientific reality behind this proposal. Nineteen of them responded, all saying that the proposal was scientifically wrong and many of them called it disinformation. Here's what eight of them said.
CBS News
an hour ago
- CBS News
How UT Dallas researchers are helping spinal injury patients reclaim their lives
With a tablet propped up in front of him and a joystick-like device in hand, Marshall Bell looks like he's playing a video game. But it's actually physical therapy — powered by innovative, Texas-developed technology that's changing his life. "I can officially shampoo my hair with my injured arm," said Bell, 35, of Arlington, with a smile. "It might take a while, but I am just ecstatic to be able to get it to touch my —" he said, moving his hand to his head to demonstrate. Life changed by hit-and-run Marshall Bell, 35 CBS News Texas In 2016, Bell was hit by a car while walking along a Fort Worth street. The driver didn't stop. Bell was left with a partially severed spine and a devastating prognosis. "His name was Dr. Gundy," said Bell. "He pulled my father into the room and told him, 'You need to make arrangements for your son. He might not be able to do anything on his own ever again.'" At the time, Bell could only move his index finger. But he was determined to recover. Over time, he regained the ability to walk—but he wanted more. UT Dallas leads breakthrough Bell joined a groundbreaking study led by researchers at the University of Texas at Dallas. The study centers on a tiny, implantable device that stimulates the vagus nerve during physical therapy. "That's the device," said Robert Rennaker, Ph.D., a retired Marine turned neuroscience professor and inventor. "It's just a little circuit board inside some glass." Tiny device, big results The device is implanted through a small incision in the neck and zip-tied to a nerve. It doesn't require batteries, is MRI-safe, and is charged externally with a device that resembles headphones. "I can't feel it at all," said Bell. "In the test trials, I thought I had the placebo. Then they pressed it, and I felt the shock. I was like, 'Oh, all right, it's there!'" Rewarding the brain's effort During therapy, the device stimulates the vagus nerve to reward successful movements. "I always tell people, I like to golf. I hit the ball well, and I'm like, yeah!" said Rennaker. "We're doing that, but we're doing it artificially." "It's not exciting to relearn how to pick up a cup or put in an earring," said Jane Wigginton, M.D., chief medical officer at the Texas Biomedical Device Center at UT Dallas. "So we give them that same little zap to the vagus nerve that releases those same chemicals. It lays down that pathway so it gets easier and easier." Hope for long-term injuries Wigginton said the study has shown unprecedented recovery rates for spinal cord injuries, regardless of how much time has passed. She cited examples like Hal, who is now able to point and type 40 years after his injury, and Amanda, who can now put on earrings by herself. "In my mind, it's like a miracle," said Wigginton. Years of research pay off The research builds on more than a decade of neuroscience and bioengineering work at UT Dallas. Previous studies showed that vagus nerve stimulation during therapy could rewire the brain after a stroke. Now, the same approach is helping spinal cord injury patients make progress once thought impossible. "I can officially dress myself completely," said Bell. "And I can fully open mason jars now! It's the little things." Texas at the forefront The Communities Foundation of Texas funded the initial production of the implantable devices. Researchers are continuing to fundraise and conduct clinical trials as they pursue full FDA approval, which they hope to achieve in the next three to four years. "It's going to make North Texas the center of the universe in this sort of research," said Wigginton. "It absolutely will. It's that big." The goal, researchers say, is to help patients reclaim their lives. "I would say that is dead on what this is doing," said Bell.
Forbes
an hour ago
- Forbes
Taming Wild Fires Before They Spiral - Part 1: Solutions
PACIFIC PALISADES, CALIFORNIA - JANUARY 30: In an aerial view, neighborhoods lie in ruins after the ... More Palisades Fire on January 30, 2025 in Pacific Palisades, California. (Photo by Qian Weizhong/VCG via Getty Images) Its heartbreaking. Losing your home, your neighborhood, your memories, your relationships. A series of 14 destructive wildfires affected the Los Angeles metropolitan area in California in January 2025. The ensuing devastation killed at least 30 people, forced more than 200,000 to evacuate, destroyed more than 18,000 homes and structures, and burned over 57,000 acres of land in total. The costs and time to rebuild are staggering - in the $100Bs and ~ 10 years. The deaths and damage to property from these fires made them likely among the most destructive fires in California's history How do we tame these fires these before they spiral out of control? a startup out of TechStars L.A. accelerator, uses publicly available social media content with a proprietary data science and AI platform to predict and understand customer trends and sentiments. (Disclosure: I am an advisor to They had previously used their platform to analyze consumer sentiments on the rapidly progressing revolution of autonomous (driverless) cars. For this article, they analyzed ~300K social media posts during the January-February 2025 period to reveal thoughts and recommendations from the public for managing future wild fires. These are listed below: The first insight is the most effective and subject of Part 1 of this article (the sensing and AI solution). Part 2 will report user experience of this capability (Florida Forest Service and San Bernardino County, California Fire Protection District). Fire Neural Network (FNN) is a venture backed company that germinated out of research in 2021 at the University of Florida. It was co-founded by Dr. Istvan Kereszy and Caroline Comeau. Wildfires can be caused by natural (electrical transmission failures and lightning) as well as human (arson, vehicle accident, etc.) events. In many parts of the United States, lightning is a dominant cause of natural wildfires (over 50% of such fires according to ESRI). Lightning creates a continuing current with durations ranging from tens to hundreds of milliseconds and exhibit amplitudes from several tens to a few hundreds of amperes. The core intellectual property that FNN has commercialized is the High Risk Lightning Detector (Figure 1) which detects these current profiles over a 20 mile radius and within 40 seconds of the strike. Figure 1: FNN's Terrestrial Solar Powered High-Risk-Lightning Detector Has a Detection Radius of 20 ... More m and Can Identify Lightning Strikes Within 40 Seconds FNN deploys a network of such detectors in wildfire prone areas for commercial and government customers in the United States as well as internationally. Real-time data from these sensor networks is combined with GIS (Geographical Information Systems) to integrate location specific weather and vegetation data into a trained AI (Artificial Intelligence) engine to assess wildfire risk due to lightning strikes (Figure 2). Time and accuracy are of the essence here - early detection (within 40 seconds) and notifications help get fire-fighting resources to the right locations to eliminate wildfires before they spin out of control. Figure 2: FNN Uses Real-TIme Sensor Data and Location Specific Weather and Vegetation Information ... More Within an AI Engine to Issue Lightning Alerts to Fire-Fighting Agencies Within 40 Seconds Foreflight is FNN's tablet-based wildfire alert application issued to fire fighting agencies along with high risk locations. This enables quick verification and containment of the highest risk wildfire sites before they spread and spiral out of control (Figure 3): Figure 3: Florida Forest Service Pilots Use FNN's High-Risk-Lightning Map in ForeFlight to Detect, ... More Locate, Verify and Contain Wildfire Hotspots The State of Florida has one of the highest rates of lightning in the United States. This, combined with the amount of foliage and weather conditions makes lightning-related wildfires essentially an all-year phenomenon, with peak activity in spring (February-June) when the weather is dry. Fighting wildfires through use of technology is a state government priority. The non-profit XPRIZE Foundation (established in 1994) which has hosted competitions to address global challenges announced the XPRIZE Wildfire in 2021, a 4-year, $11 million competition is meant to incentivize the innovation of autonomous and time sensitive wildfire management technologies. FNN is one of the finalists in this competition through the GatorX team which includes the University of Florida, NVIDIA, SATLANTIS (satellite imaging), SwissDrones, Phenix Systems and Archer (Drones), N5 and SWIR Vision (Sensors) to identify, locate, assess and eliminate wildfire germinations autonomously, without compromising human safety. The HiPerGator, a NVIDIA equipped AI computing platform established by NVIDIA co-founder Chris Malachowsky (a University of Florida alumnus) plays a critical role in absorbing the terabytes of video, climate, vegetation, communication, location and sensor data, and providing actionable information to drone-based, fire verification and mitigation platforms. SwissDrones, based in Zurich, was founded in 2013 by ex-pilots and aviation experts to develop and sell drones to oil, gas, and utility companies to inspect pipelines and infrastructure in remote areas, as well as to civil authorities for search and rescue missions. The drones are VTOL (Vertical Takeoff and Landing), twin rotor autonomous helicopters powered with aviation turbine engines, and have a take-off weight of ~200 lb (fuel + payload), speeds of ~30 mph and mission range of ~50 miles (Figure 4). This enables BVLOS (Beyond Visual Line of Sight) operation to cover broad geographic regions for day and nightime operation. The drones are equipped with precision navigation and GPS sensors, and incorporate multiple payloads (as required by the customer and their application) including infrared and mid-wave (3-5 um wavelength) thermal cameras, and LiDAR imaging for 3D awareness and mapping. As a partner on the GatorX team, the role of the SwissDrone platform is to fly to the location indicated by the FNN ForeFlight application and confirm whether the fire threat is real. If it is, the information triggers firefighting action by specialized aerial drones and ground-based fire fighting teams. Figure 4: SwissDrone Autonomous Helicopter on a Search and Rescue Mission Phenix Solutions, founded in 2011 by ex-pilots and aviation professionals is based in Oregon and 'delivers game changing aircraft worldwide in order to save lives and maximize demand on command'. The company specializes in design and manufacture of heavy lift (above 3,000 lbs payload) Remotely Piloted Aircraft (RPA) for various civil, defense, firefighting, search/rescue, disaster management and construction applications. It is a member of the GatorX program with FNN and others. Once prompted by inspection drones like SwissDrones of the verification and location of wildfires, the Phenix drone deploys and commences mitigation actions (Figure 5). Figure 5: Phenix Ultra 2XL is Designed as a Fire Fighting Solution to Provide Initial Suppression ... More and Contain Wildfires Equipped with Rolls Royce engines, its VTOL drone-helicopters can carry and dispense 3000 lb containers of liquid firefighting solutions at targeted locations to extinguish fires before they spiral out of control. Their vehicles are FAA certified and used in firefighting and other hazardous applications to prevent loss of human life, and respond quickly to threats before they escalate. In current operation, a human pilot plans and controls the flight path. The eventual goal is to use AI and sensor data to achieve full autonomy. The causes of wildfire can be due to human (intentional or unintentional) causes. But as the 2025 Los Angeles fires show, the impact is devastating. Using advanced sensors, imaging, AI and autonomy to locate, verify and suppress fires at their origination is critical and can return huge benefits. The operational process flow is complex but achievable. Part 2 of this article will report user experience of this capability (Florida Forest Service and San Bernardino County, California Fire Protection District).
