I tried supermarket washing up liquid – a 69p own-brand bottle is better than Fairy and would save you £16 a year
Lynsey Hope, Consumer reporter
Published: Invalid Date,
DOING the washing up often seems like a never-ending chore - no sooner has one lot dried, then another pile of dirty dishes is stacked up on the side.
But it can be made quicker and easier with a good washing up liquid.
9
The best formulas will leave your pots, pans, plates, cutlery and glassware gleaming, now matter how greasy your leftovers.
Fairy has long been the most popular in many households. But as the cost of living crisis continues, is there a cheaper alternative that will do as good a job?
LYNSEY HOPE investigates:
Lynsey says: "The bottle claims it washes up to two times more dirty dishes than other brands, even in cold water. It's a small bottle so time to check whether it is good value.
"It smelt zingy and fresh when I opened the bottle and even a tiny amount, produced masses of bubbles which lasted a long time and got the dishes sparkly clean in no time.
"Cutlery came out clean, glasses were streak free and it did a good job of cutting through tough food left overs and burnt on grease.
"You didn't have to use as much as other brands but I was sceptical about the claim it would clean twice as much. The bottle seemed to run out faster than others, so I knocked a mark off when it came to value for money."
Performance: 5/5
Value: 4/5
Overall score: 9/10
Tesco Anti Bac Washing Up Liquid Eucalyptus (500ml)
85p, £1.70 per litre
Lynsey says: "I was surprised by how thick this liquid is. It worked well, cutting through grease with ease.
"To boot, it had a lovely smell and produced lots of sudsy bubbles, which didn't clog up the sink when I drained the bowl. It cleaned very effectively.
"Not the cheapest own brand but still a huge saving on Fairy - around £1.42 per litre of liquid, so a saving not to be sniffed at. I was impressed."
Performance: 5/5
Value: 4/5
Overall score: 9/10
Aldi Magnum Washing Up Liquid (500ml)
69p, £1.38 per litre
Lynsey says: "Very bubbly but I didn't find this as effective as some of the other liquids. I had to use a lot more elbow grease to get dirty dishes sparkly and clean.
"There were lots of bubbles but they dissipated quickly and there was still residue left on some of the grubbier pots and pans.
"It is amazing value so if you want a cheap alternative to Fairy, this is ok, but be prepared to use a bit more elbow grease and take a bit more time over the job in hand."
Performance: 3/5
Value: 3/5
Overall score: 6/10
Mum buys eight potted basils from different supermarkets to see which lasted the longest - the winner leaves her stunned
Morrisons Original Washing Up Liquid (450ml)
62p, £1.38 per litre
Lynsey says: "I found the Morrisons liquid to have quite a strong smell and it produced lots of foam.
"The biggest issue here was the cap on the bottle, which seemed to leak, so I lost some of the liquid before I even started washing up.
"It also had quite a strong smell and whilst it produced lots of foam, the bubbles disappeared quickly and the plates weren't left as sparkling as when I used other brands. Some cutlery and glasses were left a bit streaky, too."
Performance: 2/5
Value: 2/5
Overall score: 4/10
Sainsbury's Original Washing Up Liquid (500ml)
69p, £1.38 per litre
Lynsey says: " Sainsbury's Original did a great job at tackling tough grease and I managed to clean more dirty dishes than other own brands before having to change and use fresh water and an extra squirt of liquid.
"It didn't produce tons of bubbles but it still did a good job of cutting through grease and tough, burnt-on leftovers.
"It's a brilliant price, matching Aldi and Lidl in terms of value. The bottle is recyclable for added eco points."
Performance: 4/5
Value: 4/5
Total score: 8/10
Essential Waitrose Washing Up Liquid Citrus (500ml)
75p, £1.50 per litre
Lynsey says: "Loved the fresh smell of this Waitrose washing up liquid. It didn't dry out my hands but was powerful, cutting through grease easily with only a small squirt every time.
"The bottle seemed to last for ages so whilst it's not the cheapest own brand, it's half the price of Fairy per litre and I thought it was excellent value.
"It didn't produce tons of bubbles, but it performed well on dirty plates and everything was sparkly and clean afterwards. Something about it seemed high quality."
Performance: 5/5
Value: 4/5
Total score: 9/10
Lidl W5 Washing Up Liquid Pomegranate (500ml)
69p, £1.38 per litre
Lynsey says: "This pomegranate liquid smells like a bag of sweets when you open it. But the liquid was thick and it cleaned dirty dishes in just a couple of easy wipes.
"It created a good amount of bubbles in the bowl and the lasted well. After an hour, only this Lidl cleaner and Fairy still had a significant amount of bubbles left.
"It didn't dry out the skin on my hands the bottle is recyclable. Buy a bottle of this instead of Fairy every week for a year and you'd save yourself over £16 in a year. Small savings add up."
Performance: 5/5
Value: 5/5
Total score: 10/10
Asda Original Washing Up Liquid (1 litre)
£1.30 per litre
Lynsey says: "A brilliant wallet-friendly option that promises it 'cuts through grease instantly'. And it did actually, doing a good job of removing severe grease and dried on food.
"A small squirt was enough to clean a sink full of dirty dishes with minimal scrubbing required. The solution didn't disperse too well in the water and whilst the bubbles were plentiful, they did clog up the sink a little.
"Glasses looked restaurant worthy after drying. Just be wary if you have sensitive skin, as it left my hands feeling quite dry."
Performance: 4/5
Value: 3/5
Total score: 7/10
Its not the first time a cheaper product has beaten big brand names.
This was also the case when Lynsey test Magnum supermarket dupes.
It follows her jam doughnut test which revealed a much cheaper competitor to Krispy Kreme.
How to compare prices to get the best deal
JUST because something is on offer, or is part of a sale, it doesn't mean it's always a good deal.
There are plenty of comparison websites out there that'll check prices for you - so don't be left paying more than you have to.
Most of them work by comparing the prices across hundreds of retailers.
Here are some that we recommend:
Google Shopping is a tool that lets users search for and compare prices for products across the web. Simply type in keywords, or a product number, to bring up search results.
Price Spy logs the history of how much something costs from over 3,000 different retailers, including Argos, Amazon, eBay and the supermarkets. Once you select an individual product you can quickly compare which stores have the best price and which have it in stock.
Idealo is another website that lets you compare prices between retailers. All shoppers need to do is search for the item they need and the website will rank them from the cheapest to the most expensive one.
CamelCamelCamel only works on goods being sold on Amazon. To use it, type in the URL of the product you want to check the price of.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
20 minutes ago
- BBC News
Woodeaton Manor School to move despite £1.6m spend on improvements
A school for pupils with special educational needs that a council has spent £1.6m improving is still operating on a "dilapidated" site and will eventually need to Manor School, near Oxford, was rated inadequate and found to be "chaotic" by Ofsted inspectors who visited in October 2023 and its governing body later resigned.A new head teacher and governors were appointed but - while inspectors found it had improved on a visit in March - it remains in special County Council said it had suffered "significant financial implications" after the school's former governing body did not "appropriately invest" in its Grade II* listed building and wider site. It also said the school previously lacked "robust financial management and other leadership", which had left its budget "significant overspent" to the tune of about £1.5m in a report to councillors that will be discussed at a meeting next Friday, the council's director of children's services Lisa Lyons said the school's site was "not fit for purpose".She added: "Despite significant investment from the county council, this site and building cannot be improved to deliver quality education and the long-term plan is to relocate the school into more appropriate premises."The school has about 80 pupils, all of whom have Education, Health and Care Plans (EHCPs). It previously offered residential placements but they were paused following Ofsted's inspection in 2023 and they have since been year, the council agreed to spend £900,000 on replacing fire doors as well as making other "fire safety improvements to meet the legislative standards".It said that money was also going to be spent on "suitable perimeter fencing" and new entrance gates. You can follow BBC Oxfordshire on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.
The Sun
31 minutes ago
- The Sun
Win a Westland plant food bundle worth £100
Its around this time of year that your garden could do with a good feed. And happily our friends at Westland are offering up two fantastic bundles of plant feed for pretty much every occasion. 2 2 The bundle includes tomato, hydrangea and rose feed. As well as a lawn liquid and bug feed. To enter fill in the form below. Or write to Sun Westland Boost competition, PO Box 3190, Colchester, Essex, CO2 8GP.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Why baby boomers are the backbone of middle-class Britain
Why do so many younger people feel they are disadvantaged relative to older generations? The narrative of intergenerational 'unfairness' – recently explored in a Telegraph piece on whether boomers are the 'victim generation' – pervades social discourse, and I find it really troubling. Pitting one section of society against another, on the basis of perceived 'fairness', damages the fabric of our country. In truth, there are vast differences in income and wealth throughout the population, both across and within age groups. Many young people are well-paid, and they certainly enjoy far more leisure time and holidays than previous generations, along with flexible working and much better employment protections than the baby-boomers could ever have imagined – which we have fought hard to achieve. Indeed, the post-war baby-boomers are the backbone of middle-class Britain, and have been the bastion of trying to safeguard British values while championing progress. Of course, there are vast differences among people in their 60s and early 70s, but in general, they tend to have a strong work ethic – want to support themselves and their families, avoid living on benefits – and will work even when feeling unwell, because they are loyal to their employer or their business. This is the generation that built the country we know and love today – they are disciplined, self-reliant and resourceful, unafraid of competition, and strive to improve themselves and help their families as much as they can. As Anthony New, a Telegraph reader, puts it: ''When we were growing up, many of us were very poor but we worked hard and balanced our budgets carefully.' The baby-boomers are also the heart of many of our charities and volunteering networks. They take responsibility for others, not just themselves, and want to 'give back' to society. They tend to be very community-minded and want to 'do the right thing' – which sometimes requires self-sacrifice, but baby-boomers have been brought up to believe this is how society works well. Their parents, who went through the war years, had real deprivations, while baby-boomers had very little when young but nevertheless worked hard to rebuild the country, taking advantage of post-war industrial and technological improvements. Despite all of this, too many commentators blame baby-boomers for selfishly gathering more than their 'fair share' of national resources, depriving them of their rightful dues. They accuse them of being 'lucky' to afford their own homes, enjoy free university education, and get big pensions. These accusations are much more perception than reality. Of course those at the end of their career will be better off than those just starting their working life. As Deborah Skinner, another Telegraph reader, puts it: 'We worked bloody hard throughout our life. Never had savings or a rich family to fall back on.' The baby-boomers scrimped and saved to afford sky-high mortgage interest. No holidays, spending cut to the bone, and working for years before they could buy a property. Less than ten per cent of baby-boomers went to university. The vast majority started work at 15, 16 or 18 – with many going into apprenticeships, bringing home an income straight from school. So by the time they reached their late twenties, they had already been earning money and saving for ten to fifteen years. Today's younger people, many of whom have higher education, do not reach this point until their early or mid-thirties. And as for pensions. Well, less than half of baby-boomers – and particularly women – were offered an employer pension. There was no auto-enrolment, no automatic right to a pension or any other workplace benefit. Women could be barred from pensions and generous maternity rights. Even basic employment protections against harassment and unfair dismissal were not the norm – we had to fight for women's working conditions to improve. So, it's time to stop this 'oldie bashing' and start to appreciate that each generation contributes to society, and the intergenerational envy that has crept into conventional thinking for too many younger people does not reflect reality. In fact it builds dangerous resentment. There are inequalities everywhere. Rather than trying to take money away from baby-boomers, who did so much to improve our country, let's work together as a society. It is the turn of younger generations now to carry us forward and build an even better future. Will they rise to the challenge?
