logo
Lawyers who steal: R1.4bn trust fund theft ignored

Lawyers who steal: R1.4bn trust fund theft ignored

The Citizen22-04-2025

Unscrupulous lawyers have plundered their clients' trust funds to the tune of R1.4 billion with more than 500 cases documented – but only 59 convictions were made in seven years and just 25 resulted in jail time.
More than 500 cases in which lawyers are accused of stealing more than R1.4 billion of their clients' money from trust funds have not been prosecuted.
This was revealed by statistics recently released by the Legal Practice Fidelity Fund.
The figures show that 561 trust fund theft cases, in which lawyers allegedly stole R1.4 billion from clients, remain unprosecuted. They also revealed that only 59 convictions were made in seven years and just 25 resulted in jail time.
Concern about integrity of legal profession
Wayne Duvenage, CEO of corruption fighting group Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (Outa), said lack of accountability in trust fund theft cases in South Africa, was not taken seriously by the National Prosecution Authority (NPA) or the Legal Practice Council (LPC), which raises serious concerns about the integrity of the legal profession and the effectiveness of regulatory oversight.
'A reason often given is that the NPA is stretched thin and lacks the forensic capacity to investigate these complex financial crimes, but this excuse must come to an end,' said Duvenage. 'A matter of more serious concern is that the LPC internal disciplinary actions are often opaque, and weak and complainants are rarely updated on outcomes.
ALSO READ: Barred KZN attorney who misappropriated R2m in trust funds to 'prop up lifestyle' loses case to be readmitted
'There appears to be a lack of leadership and political will to address this matter. Theft or misconduct in the legal profession appears to be far more lenient compared to lower-level financial crimes.
'It would appear that regulators may be reluctant to aggressively pursue cases that could further erode public confidence in the legal system.'
Trust fund theft: Corrupt lawyers protected?
Duvenage said before the establishment of the LPC in 2018, the provincial law societies failed to maintain proper oversight or respond robustly to growing reports of trust fund abuse. He said the entity's provincial offices were often accused of protecting corrupt lawyers.
'Even now, many former law society structures and personnel still influence current regulatory culture, slowing down the pace of reform.
'Until the LPC takes a more aggressive stance and works closely with the NPA, the SA Police Service and Treasury to criminally prosecute trust fund theft, and until parliament holds regulators accountable, this pattern will persist. A major overhaul of legal oversight and the urgent recapitalisation of the Fidelity Fund are long overdue.'
ALSO READ: Bar of South Africa refers sexual abuse allegations against advocate Jeremy Gauntlett for investigation
LPC defends itself
LPC spokesperson Kabelo Letebele defended his organisation, saying the delay of the cases was not their fault and that the LPC was doing its best to address reported complaints.
Letebele said on average, the LPC dealt with over 1 000 complaints per month and in the past two years, complaints had exceeded 14 000 each year. He said over 90% of the complaints were finalised each year and the serious cases of misconduct have resulted in suspensions or striking off of more than 150 legal practitioners in 2024 alone.
'The law restricts the role of the LPC in investigating complaints and initiating disciplinary processes.
'In other words, we investigate complaints of misconduct or subject a legal practitioner to an investigation and can subject them to a disciplinary hearing.
'Once our independent investigations committee and independent disciplinary committee have concluded their work, they recommend that the LPC should apply to court for a suspension or strike off.
'This recommendation, together with all the details on the matter, including evidence presented, is then considered by the council, which makes the final decision on the matter.'
ALSO READ: More than 100 legal practitioners struck off the roll
He said that once a lawyer has been struck off by the high court, the LPC's involvement ends. In the event criminal proceedings were initiated against lawyers by the South African Police Service or the NPA, the process is not under oversight of the LPC, although a number of times the LPC has been called in to testify or give information in support of the court process.
Dodgy lawyers 'disappointing'
President of the Law Society of South Africa Nkosana Mvundlela said the growing number of lawyers reported to the LPC was concerning.
'While the overwhelming majority of legal practitioners uphold the highest standards of ethics and professionalism, the conduct of a few continues to cast a shadow over the entire profession.
'As a voluntary association committed to promoting the integrity and excellence of the legal profession, the LSSA is deeply disappointed by these numbers.
'They represent not only a breach of legal ethics but a loss of trust by members of the public, who rely on attorneys to act with honour and accountability.'
ALSO READ: Mkhwebane says move to strike her from roll of advocates is 'politically motivated'
Mvundlela said with approximately 6 000 candidate attorneys entering the system each year and thousands more in active practice, the number of practitioners who face serious disciplinary action remains relatively small by proportion.
'However, even one instance of serious misconduct is one too many.'
Terrence Manase, spokesperson for Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development Mmamoloko Kubayi, said the department acknowledged the reported statistics and took the matter with the utmost seriousness.
'We want to assure the public that decisive steps are being taken to strengthen accountability and restore trust.'
NOW READ: Convicted man's 10-year jail sentence set aside due to lawyer's suspension

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Nafiz Modack convicted of corruption — trial for multiple murders continues
Nafiz Modack convicted of corruption — trial for multiple murders continues

Daily Maverick

time7 hours ago

  • Daily Maverick

Nafiz Modack convicted of corruption — trial for multiple murders continues

In 2011, alleged underworld figure Nafiz Modack paid a corrupt, high-ranking police official to recover his vehicles using state resources. Nearly 14 years later, the top cop's plea agreement was used to convict Modack of corruption charges. Alleged underworld figure Nafiz Modack has been acquitted on charges before, but for the first time on Friday, 6 June 2025, he was convicted by a court on corruption charges. The corruption occurred in 2011, and nearly 14 years later, thanks to a plea agreement by former Brigadier Kolindhren Govender, a court could convict Modack. Several cases, including the murder of late Anti-Gang Unit Lieutenant Colonel Charl Kinnear, remain to be resolved. Govender entered into a plea and sentencing agreement on 2 December 2019 and pleaded guilty to 51 counts of corruption and a count of contravening the South African Police Service Act. Among the reasons that this case took so long to resolve was that some of the final witnesses testified only last year. According to investigators, since Modack has been behind bars since April 2021, he no longer poses a threat to or can intimidate witnesses. The central point of this corrupt relationship was that Govender instructed police officers under his command to recover missing vehicles belonging to Modack. On Monday, 9 June, National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) Western Cape spokesperson Eric Ntabazalila said police recovered vehicles, including two exotic vehicles, which were handed over to Modack without following due process. The NPA did not comment on how many vehicles were recovered through the corrupt scheme. None of the recovered vehicles, he added, were processed through SAPS records, nor were any police dockets or inquiries opened and registered in any of the incidents. At the time of the offence, Modack was the sole owner of the businesses AMG Auto and Peuxon Properties. Court papers dating back to the time of the corruption said: 'In and during November 2011 Brigadier Govender commenced accepting gratification from Modack. Regular payments in a total of R146,600 were paid to Govender in return for special treatment and favours.' Govender pleaded guilty to 51 charges of corruption that relate to a corrupt relationship he had with Modack. He was handed five years' imprisonment, of which four-and-a-half years were suspended. The sentence was ordered to run concurrently with the six-year sentence that was handed down on a different matter. Payments for special treatment Senior State prosecutor advocate Louis van Niekerk successfully argued that Brigadier Govender received R146,000 from the two firms' accounts between November 2011 and August 2013. Van Niekerk also contended that the 51 payments Modack made had no legitimate purpose. He stated: 'Modack made regular payments to Brigadier Govender as a high-ranking South African Police Service (SAPS) member in return for special treatment and favours. Police were not allowed to do private work or preferential work for members of the public. 'Members of the public were not allowed to reward members of the SAPS. Modack never gave statements for any of the recovered vehicles. There were no statements by the arresting officer. There were no SAP13 recordings. No dockets were registered. His version was that they were his vehicles,' Van Niekerk explained. The court concluded that, given the evidence in totality, Modack was guilty of corruption relating to the recovery of motor vehicles. The case has been postponed until 8 July 2025 for Modack's sentencing. Murder charges In another case, Modack is on trial for a range of charges, including multiple murders and attempted murders. He was arrested in April 2021 in connection with the murder of Kinnear. Kinnear was assassinated outside his house in Bishop Lavis in September 2020. At the time of his demise, he was investigating Modack. Modack and former rugby player and debt collector Zane Kilian are the two main accused in Kinnear's assassination. The State contends that they also conspired in an attempt to murder lawyer William Booth in April 2020. In that case, Modack and Kilian, with the other accused, are collectively facing 124 charges, including murder, attempted murder, corruption, gangsterism, extortion, the illegal interception of communications, money laundering and contravention of the Prevention of Organised Crime Act. Modack and his co-accused pleaded not guilty to the charges in January 2024. In March 2024, a State witness, who can be referred to only as 'Mr A' to protect his identity, implicated Modack as the person who allegedly ordered a hit on Nicolaas Heerschap, the father of Hawks officer Nico Heerschap. He said Modack told him he was proud of the hit. In January 2025, Western Cape High Court Judge Robert Henney dismissed several charges against Modack and his 14 co-accused, but not the principal charges of murder and attempted murder. Another pending case against Modack, his wife Rehana, and police officers is firearm licence fraud, which will be heard in Gauteng. In addition, Modack also faces charges in a massive tax fraud case involving more than R46-million, and his mother is allegedly the criminal enterprise's manager. Investigators told Daily Maverick that once all these cases had been concluded, Modack would be apprehended in connection with a probe into R50-million vehicle and property asset finance corruption. Another cop in Modack's web Modack had an alleged corrupt association with other police officers before Govender. Former AGU Sergeant Ashley Tabisher lost his job as a result of this alleged corrupt relationship with Modack. Tabisher faces charges of corruption for allegedly warning Modack about Anti-Gang Unit operations. It is alleged Tabisher received R10,000 from co-accused Amaal Jantjies. He was eventually released in December last year. Tabisher intends to bring an application to be acquitted on all charges. Furthermore, evidence presented in the Kinnear murder trial heard in the Western Cape High Court in April suggested that Modack was allegedly deceived by a middleman while trying to bribe former top cops Major General Jeremy Vearey and the late Kinnear. Modack's bank statements reveal that he made R600,000 in payments that he allegedly thought would go to Vearey and Kinnear. The payments were made for the return of his firearms that had been confiscated by the Anti-Gang Unit in 2017. Modack did not receive the confiscated firearms and Vearey, who had no involvement in the bribery scheme, did not receive a cent as Modack had apparently been duped by a middleman. DM

Father of 3 handed 195 years behind bars for digital trafficking, rape of his children
Father of 3 handed 195 years behind bars for digital trafficking, rape of his children

Eyewitness News

time12 hours ago

  • Eyewitness News

Father of 3 handed 195 years behind bars for digital trafficking, rape of his children

CAPE TOWN - A father of three minor children has been sentenced to 195 years behind bars after he was found guilty of digital trafficking in persons and the rape of his children. The 27-year-old was sentenced in the Paarl Regional Court on Monday to serve 195 years behind bars, but because the sentences will run concurrently, the accused will spend an effective 35 years in prison. The accused cannot be named due to the nature of the crimes against his minor children, two girls aged six and four years old, and his one-year-old son. The National Prosecuting Authority says (NPA) the 27-year-old man was arrested in May 2023 after the Federal Bureau of Investigation sent information about the accused's activities to the South African Police Service. Following his arrest, the accused confessed to making pornographic content of his biological children that he shared online in exchange for a monetary reward. The court convicted the 27-year-old father on four counts of rape of two minor children and 629 counts of possession of child pornography - among other charges. His name will also be entered into the National Register for Sexual Offenders.

Father sentenced to 35 years for exploiting his children
Father sentenced to 35 years for exploiting his children

The South African

time14 hours ago

  • The South African

Father sentenced to 35 years for exploiting his children

A Cape Winelands father created child pornography using his minor daughters and infant son for financial gain. The court sentenced him to 35 years in prison. The court found the 27-year-old man guilty of multiple charges. These include trafficking in persons, rape, creating and benefiting from child pornography, possessing and distributing pornographic material, and child abuse. The state withheld the man's name to protect the identity of his daughters aged six and four and son aged one. The man married the mother of his children in March 2018. He stayed home and cared for them because he was unemployed. The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) spokesperson Eric Ntabazalila said 'He subscribed to a social media application with instant messaging where one can transmit and receive messages, photos, and videos. Users can communicate privately with other users or in groups. The social media platform users can send photographs taken within the application. Which indicates to other users a picture was taken in real time and not imported from a camera roll.' 'He decided to create child pornography for financial gain. As the conversion rate at the time was R18 to the dollar. He connected with the group after the administrative user approved his access to the group, and he started to communicate with the administrative user.' Ntabazalila said he made pornographic content of his biological children and admitted to selling an 'unknown amount of child pornography to unknown users for $5 (R88.9) to $10 (R177.8).' An undercover FBI task force officer from the Washington field office was part of the FBI child exploitation and human trafficking task force. The officer shared information about the man's activities with South African police. Police then arrested him on 30 May 2023 and confiscated his cellphone. Senior state advocate Evadne Kortje finalised the plea and sentencing agreement. She said the accused sexually exploited children whose innocence should have been protected and preserved at all costs. 'He communicated and joined the social media application to connect with individuals interested in child pornography. He downloaded child pornography from other unknown collectors and other hands-on child sexual abuse offenders. Then he abused his parental privilege and the trust relationship he had towards his three small children. Regional court magistrate Gangadu emphasised the inescapable reality of the increasing prevalence of the abuse of modern technology to exploit our children,' said Ntabazalila. The Paarl Regional Court sentenced the man to 35 years of direct imprisonment and ordered him to serve two-thirds of the sentence before he becomes eligible for parole. The court will enter his name into the national register for sexual offenders. The court declared him unfit to work with children or to possess a firearm. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store