Hearts CEO McKinlay says club ‘got it wrong' with Critchley appointment
Hearts chief executive Andrew McKinlay admits the club made a mistake with their managerial recruitment process and appointment last time out.
Hearts sacked Neil Critchley after six months in charge after they failed to qualify for the Premiership top six and then lost at home to Dundee to raise the prospect of a relegation fight.
They have since won their final four games under caretaker boss Liam Fox and appointed former Aberdeen and Kilmarnock manager Derek McInnes as their new head coach.
Regarding the previous appointment, McKinlay told Sky Sports: 'I'll admit that we got it wrong. If anyone can stand there and say they've not made mistakes then I challenge them on that. The main thing is you learn from those mistakes.
'We went for a certain type of manager and Neil was a very good coach, very nice guy, but I'm not sure he quite got the club and got the demands of the club.
'We spoke to a number of people but ultimately Neil was the one we ended up with and the only one that we actually entered into serious discussions with.
'We spoke to a good number of other individuals, some of whom were named at the time, some of whom weren't.
'The one thing I did learn from that process though – and it is much harder with foreign managers – was you've got to meet people face to face.
'We didn't actually meet anyone face to face last time round. Some of that was circumstances, (sporting director) Graeme (Jones) wasn't in the role, I was out in Azerbaijan.
'It wasn't straightforward, we were keen to do it as quickly as possible and therefore we did it all remotely and I would never do that again.
'I don't think there's anything wrong with doing some of the interviews remotely, maybe the first lot, but I don't think you should ever appoint anyone into a job like that that you haven't sat down with face to face and that's something that obviously we've done on several occasions with Derek.
'We need someone that understands the Scottish game, someone that's managed at the top end of Scottish football, understands the demands of the Hearts support and has had success in the past. Derek is the man and I'm really looking forward to working with him.'
McKinlay expressed sympathy for Critchley and claimed he was 'very unlucky in some ways'.
Hearts looked set to qualify for the knockout stages of the UEFA Conference League after a good start but a late penalty cost them victory at home to Petrocub in a final game they were expected to win.
They missed out on the top six on the final day and then had two men sent off in the Scottish Gas Scottish Cup semi-finals against Aberdeen before going down to a late extra-time winner.
'Every fine margin, everything went the wrong way for us,' McKinley said. 'So in some ways you've got to feel sorry for Neil.
'We just got to the stage where we felt we were concerned, I'll be honest, after that Dundee game that we were going to slip into a relegation situation.
'I understand some people might think we were hasty but we just felt, a difficult decision but we just had to make it. And I think hindsight shows it was probably the right decision.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
North Wales Chronicle
5 hours ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Scotland goalkeeper Cieran Slicker has debut to forget in home defeat to Iceland
Luckless home goalkeeper Angus Gunn sustained an injury in the third minute and eventually had to be replaced by the 22-year-old Ipswich stopper, minutes after which he conceded possession before Andri Gudjohnsen beat him with a terrific drive. John Souttar levelled in the 25th minute from a corner but Slicker and his defenders struggled collectively when the visitors regained the lead from a corner, just before the break, with Scotland midfielder Lewis Ferguson putting through his own goal. Slicker was again found wanting in the 52nd minute when he was beaten by a Victor Palsson header, which added the gloss for the visitors. Iceland had lost all six of their previous meetings with Scotland but they deserved their first win. Sturm Graz right-back Max Johnston and Ipswich forward George Hirst made their first starts in an otherwise experienced team with defender Kieran Tierney winning his 50th cap playing in a back five. After a minute's applause to remember former Scottish FA president Jack McGinn, midfielder John McGinn's grandfather, who died last month aged 92, play started then soon stopped when Gunn – starting as Craig Gordon was injured – stayed on the ground after landing awkwardly. After some treatment, the 29-year-old was replaced by Slicker, who endured a nightmare start. His clearance was immediately returned to Gudjohnsen – son of former Chelsea and Barcelona striker Eidur – and from 20 yards, he drove the ball high past Slicker. Two more poor kicks from the keeper did nothing for confidence. In the 21st minute, good pressing from McGinn won him possession inside the Iceland penalty area but from his pinpoint cross, Hirst headed over from six yards. Then after Slicker had gathered a drive from Jon Dagur Thorsteinsson at the second attempt, the Hirst then tested Iceland goalkeeper Elias Olafsson with a drive which was tipped over the crossbar but from Johnston's corner, Souttar stooped to head in from six yards. Scotland began to find some flow but when Albert Gundmundsson delivered a corner in the 44th minute, Slicker and his defenders failed to deal with it and the ball ricocheted off a couple of players before it came off Ferguson and over the line. Boos rang around the stadium at half-time and there was more consternation after 52 minutes when Palsson's header from a Gudmundsson free-kick went through the hands of Slicker, with VAR confirming the goal after a suspicion of offside. The Ipswich keeper was then sarcastically cheered by some of the Tartan Army after a comfortable collect. At the other end, Hirst's effort from close range – it looked like the ball came off his shoulder following a Johnston cross – was brilliantly saved by Olafsson. The Iceland keeper was beaten in the 63rd minute by Hirst after parrying a Scott McTominay shot, but the Napoli midfielder was ruled offside. Motherwell midfielder Lennon Miller came on to make his Scotland debut in the 68 minute, along with striker Che Adams and defender Scott McKenna, by which time the home side had gained the initiative. Olafsson tipped McGinn's clever chip over the crossbar in the 88th minute but there was no late Scotland siege.
Scotsman
7 hours ago
- Scotsman
Finn Russell inspires Bath comeback to keep treble dream alive but Scotland star sparks injury scare for final
Bath power into Premiership final with second-half show Sign up to our Rugby Union newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Scotland star Finn Russell inspired a second-half comeback for Bath against Bristol to reach the Gallagher Premiership final - although the west-country side will have some concerns over his fitness after he came off late on with a leg injury. Stand-off Russell and his teammates overcame a seven-point deficit at the break eventually prevail 34-20 victory over near-neighbours Bristol and set up a clash at Twickenham next weekend against either Leicester Tigers or Sale Sharks. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Russell bagged 14 points and was key to their second-half turnaround, ably assisted by fellow Scotland internationalists Cam Redpath and Josh Bayliss. It keeps Bath's hopes of a treble alive with the Premiership Cup and Challenge Cup already in the bag as Johan van Graan's team look to atone for losing last season's final to Northampton. Scotland star Finn Russell helped Bath defeat Bristol. | Getty Images They will hope that Russell's injury is nothing more than a dead leg after he was replaced in the closing stages. The 32-year-old has become a talisman for club as well as country and did his Lions starting credentials no harm at all with this performance. He was all smiles at the end but no doubt Bath will assess his condition. Bristol were 13-6 in front at the break and it could have been more. The try of the match was scored by their lock James Dun after Fiji wing Kalaveti Ravouvou set off from his own line, leaving four Bath defenders in his wake. Guy Pepper started in the Bath back row in the absence of the suspended Sam Underhill, while Redpath replaced Will Butt at centre. England prop Ellis Genge was recalled to the Bristol pack along with Dun and centurion Steven Luatua. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A fast and furious first half opened with a penalty to Bristol which was quickly reversed for some ill-advised verbals. When Bath then laid siege to the visitors' line, Genge was the man who held up the ball to earn a relieving drop-out. Tough start for Bath Both sides were probing for any advantage they could find and the first points went to Bristol as AJ MacGinty punished Pepper's infringement at a ruck with a straightforward penalty after 12 minutes. When hooker Gabriel Oghre broke clear, Bath had to defend desperately before Ben Spencer eased the anxiety with a long kick upfield. But Ravouvou, collecting the ball near his own line, somehow evaded a quartet of would-be tacklers and the home defence was soon spreadeagled at the other end. Lock Dun eventually cut a simple line to the posts and MacGinty added the conversion for a 10-0 lead. Ravouvou was soon sent to the sin bin for preventing a quick-tapped penalty by Spencer, allowing Russell to pull back three points for Bath but MacGinty immediately replied to make it 13-6 at the break. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Finn Russell celebrates with Bath owner Bruce Craig. | Getty Images Losing scrum-half Harry Randall to a shoulder injury just before half-time had not helped Bristol's cause and a Ted Hill try converted by Russell straight after the break brought Bath level. Joe Cokanasiga swooped on a teasing kick ahead by Tom de Glanville to score Bath's third try shortly after to put them ahead for the first time. When Will Muir finished off a prolonged period of pressure by touching down in the left corner and Max Ojomoh added a fifth on the hour, Bath were back in command. With Russell faultless from the tee, the score was suddenly 34-13.
Daily Record
7 hours ago
- Daily Record
Steve Clarke admits Cieran Slicker wasn't ready for Scotland debut as boss issues goalkeeping SOS for Liechtenstein
With Liam kelly injured, Clarke will take teenager Callan McKenna and try to find a more experienced option who isn't on holiday Steve Clarke admits Cieran Slicker wasn't ready for his Scotland debut as he sent out a goalkeeping SOS for any Scottish keepers still in the country. Slicker was thrown in at the deep after just a couple of minutes of the 3-1 friendly defeat at home to Iceland. Angus Gunn suffered an injury with his first involvement and after Rangers stopper Liam Kelly had pulled out of the warm up, Slicker was given the nod from the bench ahead of Kilmarnock's Robby McCrorie. Ipswich keeper Slicker has played just NINE minute of football over the course of the season and it showed, as he sclaffed a clearance for Iceland's first goal, fumbled a corner that saw Lewis Ferguson put past him for the second and let Victor Palsson's header go straight through him for the third. With veteran Craig Gordon injured along with Tyencastle understudy Zander Clark, the Scotland boss isn't sure where he's going to find another one at this stage before flying to Liechtenstein for Monday's game. He'll try and find one to take alongside kid gloves Callan McKenna, but did admit he had sympathy for Slicker after a debut to forget. "It's difficult for Cieran. I feel for him," said Clarke. "He got thrown into a situation where he maybe wasn't quite ready for it. But Craig's injured, Liam Kelly's injured, Zander Clark was injured. "I mentioned back in March that it was something I thought might come back to bite us. The only good thing is it came in a friendly match. "I don't know (about Gunn's injury). If he comes off in the first couple of minutes then I imagine he's not going to play the next game. For sure I'll try and call up another goalkeeper. I've had young Callan McKenna who's just turned 18-years of age, training with us and he'll travel. I'll see if I can find another one somewhere in Scotland that's not on holiday. "It was a disappointing night didn't get off to a great start , we lost our No2 goalie in the warm up and then we lost our No1 goalie after a couple of minutes. We then immediately compound that by conceding the first goal. That made it difficult. "We created some chances then got back in the game. But conceded another poor goal which makes it a difficult night."
