Motsoaledi dismisses suggestions PEPFAR withdrawal will collapse govt programmes
CAPE TOWN - Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi has moved to counter suggestions that the withdrawal of United States funding for HIV/AIDS treatment is threatening the collapse of government programmes.
US President Donald Trump withdrew the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, known as PEPFAR, in January this year, which in this year would have contributed around R7.9 billion to treatment programmes in eight provinces of the country.
Motsoaledi has come under fire in Parliament and from activists for not being proactive enough to plug the funding gap and to stop the closure of clinics.
READ: PEPFAR funding cut to only affect staffing, says Motsoaledi
At a media briefing in Pretoria on Thursday, Motsoaledi has, however, hit back at the media for what he said are false narratives linked to the withdrawal of funding.
The health minister said the files of patients who were receiving treatment at PEPFAR-funded clinics have been transferred to other sites.
"It is inconceivable that out of the R6.8 billion spent by the country on the HIV/AIDS programme, the withdrawal of R7.9 billion by President Trump will immediately lead to the collapse of the entire programme. We believe it's inconceivable."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
3 hours ago
- The Star
EFF's Julius Malema is ‘quietly' singing ‘Hallelujah hosanna' over Trump-Musk fallout
EFF leader Julius Malema is 'quietly enjoying' the dramatic fallout between US President Donald Trump and billionaire Elon Musk, the two figures who have long criticised him over his outspoken rhetoric, radical political views, including the controversial "Kill the Boer" chant. The two had previously accused Malema of inciting violence against white farmers. The red berets have denounced the claim. The latest split between the former allies who were once bound by political interests appears to align with Malema's long-standing opposition to both. Trump, in a televised Oval Office tirade, said he was "very disappointed" in Musk after the tech billionaire criticised his spending bill. Musk fired back on X (formerly Twitter), accusing Trump of ingratitude, claiming credit for his 2024 win, and even referencing unverified claims linking Trump to Jeffrey Epstein. The feud has political and economic fallout. Tesla shares dropped, Musk threatened to withdraw from a major US space programme, and Trump also hinted at pulling Musk's government contracts. The clash comes amid rising tensions between the US and South Africa. Tensions between the two countries have intensified since Trump's second term. Last month, during a high-level meeting with President Cyril Ramaphosa and the Trump administration in Washington, aimed at mending diplomatic relations between the two countries, Malema took centre stage. Trump played clips of Malema singing the 'Kill the boer' chant, which he argued incites violence against white farmers, but the red berets rubbished the claim. Trump called for Malema's arrest and denounced South Africa's land reform as 'land seizure.' IOL News previously reported that Malema has vowed to continue singing the controversial song despite strong criticism from Trump. The US also cut HIV/AIDS funding and granted refugee status to 49 white South Africans, claiming racial discrimination, which Pretoria has vehemently rejected. With Musk born in South Africa and now publicly clashing with Trump, Malema 'may' see this as more than political theatre, which is possibly a moment of vindication. Speaking with IOL News, Professor Theo Neethling, from the University of Free State's Department of Political Studies and Governance, said the fallout between Trump and Musk was 'long predictable.' 'The Trump-Musk fallout was long predictable, and even if the EFF delights in it, the fact remains that the United States conducts diplomatic relations with the South African government, not with the EFF…,' he said. 'The EFF is a relatively small party, as President Ramaphosa pointed out to Trump, and it is not relevant in South Africa's international relations.' Neethling emphasised that diplomatic relations are maintained between the US government and South African government, not with political outliers. 'The Trump administration also conducts its relations with the South African government, and what carries much more weight in the US than Elon Musk are the views and roles of top Republican voices like JD Vance, Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz. They will be decisive in the future US-South Africa relations.' Commenting on the developments of Trump and Musk clashing, Neethling said Malema will continue 'loudly in his rhetoric of African self-reliance,' but South Africa's Government of National Unity (GNU) understands the importance of maintaining relations with the US, which is the largest economy in the world. 'Around 600 American companies invest and do business here in South Africa and contribute to job creation,' he told IOL News. 'The Minister of Finance (Enoch Godongwana) also rightly pointed out recently that if the US does not want to do business with a country, it places that country on the periphery of international trade and investment.' According to Neethling, the Trump and Musk fallout will have no impact on future US and South Africa relations. 'Again, top Republican voices like JD Vance, Marco Rubio, and Ted Cruz are what matter, as well as those of senior officials in the White House.' Meanwhile, independent political analyst Goodenough Mashego also expressed his views on the Trump and Musk fallout, adding that Malema is probably 'enjoying' seeing the two clash. 'I think Julius Malema is really enjoying, is really reveling at what is happening because it absorbs him in a way to say, look, two liars are now fighting. You know, they say, do not disturb. Napoleon Bonaparte once said, don't disturb your enemy when he's making a mistake.' Mashego said he believes that Malema is currently not in any mood to disturb what he called 'enemies' as they make mistakes. 'I hope he doesn't tweet. I hope he just watches the show. He just enjoys reading Elon Musk and Donald Trump's Truth Social tweets. So that, you know, I think it's a marvel…' He added, 'think EFF, I think Julius Malema, he now knows that the person who's been whispering into Donald Trump's eye is no longer in the picture, which means the rhetoric from the part of the White House towards him is going to be limited because Trump doesn't have an original opinion.' 'All that he's saying is a megaphone. He's just saying what other people want him to say. So I think this is really the end of the Que de Bois charade that Donald Trump used to stage. And it's the end of that whole obsession by Donald Trump with Elon Musk, because going forward, with the Que de Bois, because going forward, whatever Elon Musk says relating to South Africa, I think one of the people is going to really try to ridicule it will be Donald Trump.' 'So they have two fools, two buffoons, really ridiculing each other,' Mashego added. He described the fallout between Trump and Trump as a Christmas for the EFF. 'Well, I don't think it really gives Malema a chance to push his message of self-reliance because self-reliance needs not be pushed through rhetoric. It needs to be pushed through doing.' IOL News has sent questions to the EFF, requesting their input on the latest development between Trump and Musk, and will be updated once received. [email protected] IOL Politics
Eyewitness News
6 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
'Resilient, and a man of unwavering principle' - President Cyril Ramaphosa pays tribute to anti-apartheid activist, Reverent Tshenuwani Farisani
JOHANNESBURG - Resilience - the word many used to describe the late reverend Tshenuwani Farisani - a respected anti-apartheid activist and former member of Parliament. Mourners, including senior government officials, gathered at the University of Venda in Thohoyandou, Limpopo on Saturday to honour the man who they say never wavered in his fight for liberation. ALSO READ: Dr Tshenuwani Farisani remembered as a dedicated public servant Farisani passed away on Thursday at the age of 76, following an undisclosed illness. President Cyril Ramaphosa, who delivered the eulogy, reflected on Farisani's courage, recalling how he was arrested three times during Apartheid for his activism. In 1987, Farisani went into exile in the United States, but later returned - a move Ramaphosa has described as a powerful symbol of his commitment to justice and freedom. "He was a man of unwavering principle, nothing could sway him from what was right, from his dedication to the cause, the people of South Africa and their total emancipation."
IOL News
9 hours ago
- IOL News
Phoenix's healthcare crisis: a community's plea for change
IN THE heart of Phoenix, Durban, a crisis is unfolding that demands immediate attention. The Mahatma Gandhi Memorial Hospital and the Phoenix Community Health Care Centre, once pillars of hope for the people of this community, have descended into a state of neglect so severe that it now threatens the dignity, health, and lives of those they are meant to serve. For thousands of residents, many of them elderly, frail, and economically vulnerable, these public healthcare facilities represent their only access to medical care. And yet, what awaits them behind these hospital doors is not healing, but hardship. It is no secret that the physical state of both the Mahatma Gandhi Memorial Hospital and the Phoenix Community Health Care Centre is deplorable. Walls are peeling, sanitation is questionable, and essential medical equipment is either outdated or completely absent. Many wards lack basic amenities, and waiting areas overflow with frustrated, tired patients forced to sit for hours - sometimes even an entire day - just to be seen by a healthcare provider. These scenes are not isolated incidents, they are the everyday norm in Phoenix. The tragedy lies in the fact that these facilities were built to uplift the community, not to compound its suffering. The current state of disrepair reflects more than just budgetary constraints - it is a glaring indictment of mismanagement, neglect, and a systemic failure to prioritise public health. One of the most distressing realities facing patients is the chronic shortage of medical supplies and life-saving medications. From insulin and hypertension drugs to basic antibiotics and sterile bandages, stockouts are frequent and prolonged. For individuals suffering from diabetes, high blood pressure, HIV/AIDS, and other chronic conditions, the consequences of such shortages can be deadly. Patients are often told to return in a week - or even a month - when the next batch of medication might arrive. This is not only unacceptable but unethical. The shortage of qualified medical personnel is another ticking time bomb. Doctors, nurses, and administrative staff are spread dangerously thin, leading to unmanageable workloads and exhaustion. The result? Appalling delays in patient care, rushed consultations, and a severe decline in the quality of service. Some patients report waiting for over six hours before even being triaged, only to be told to return another day. In the worst cases, patients are turned away altogether. The most heart-breaking aspect of this crisis is the treatment of the elderly and unemployed. Many are forced to make multiple costly trips to the health facilities, only to be dismissed without being seen by a doctor. For pensioners living on meagre state grants, and for those unemployed due to circumstances beyond their control, this adds an unnecessary layer of suffering to an already dire situation. The bed shortage at both facilities adds another dimension to this tragedy. Emergency cases are often left unattended on gurneys in hallways or even in waiting rooms. Women in labour, patients with broken bones, or individuals in need of urgent surgical attention are all crammed into overcrowded wards or makeshift recovery areas. In such conditions, patient dignity is routinely compromised. To compound the situation, there are growing concerns about the lack of empathy and compassion among some healthcare workers. While it is important to acknowledge the incredible strain placed on staff, it does not excuse the dismissive or even hostile attitudes patients often encounter. For people who are already vulnerable, being treated with indifference only adds psychological pain to physical ailments. A call for radical reform: It is evident that a mere increase in funding or supplies will not suffice. What the Phoenix's healthcare system needs is a complete and unapologetic overhaul - starting with its management. The leadership at both the Mahatma Gandhi Memorial Hospital and the Phoenix Community Health Care Centre must be held accountable. This is not the time for political appointments or bureaucratic tokenism. We urgently need a management board that is rooted in the community it serves - composed of local residents with a genuine understanding of the social, economic, and cultural context of Phoenix. These board members must have credible backgrounds in community healthcare, leadership, and organisational management. Additionally, skills in fundraising, marketing, communication, and community development should be prioritized. This type of leadership can help bridge the gap between state resources and community needs, while restoring trust and transparency in the system. The way forward: Public healthcare is a basic human right, not a privilege for the few. The situation in Phoenix is not just a local issue - it is a reflection of a broader national crisis that must be addressed with urgency and sincerity. Civil society, local businesses, religious institutions, and NGOs must come together to pressure government stakeholders into taking action. It is only through a united front that we can begin to restore dignity and health to the people of Phoenix. Moreover, health oversight mechanisms must be implemented to monitor progress, with public reporting channels to ensure accountability. Technology can also play a vital role in improving administration, tracking supplies, and ensuring better patient flow. However, none of this will work without dedicated and compassionate leadership. The suffering of Phoenix residents cannot be tolerated as an unfortunate norm any longer. The dilapidated state of these two facilities is a stain on our collective conscience. It is time for the community to demand better - not in whispers, but in a unified voice that echoes across municipal, provincial, and national platforms. The health of a nation begins in its most vulnerable communities. Phoenix is calling.
