NRL baffled by Sandon Smith's sin bin in Roosters' win over the Dragons
The NRL world has reacted with more confusion after the latest ruling on a high tackle in the Roosters' 46-18 thrashing of St George Illawarra on Anzac Day.
The inconsistencies from the referees and the NRL's Bunker are plaguing the sport and baffling those watching on, with vastly different calls being made on similar incidents on a weekly and even daily basis.
FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE in 4K with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer.
Part of the problem stems from the NRL head office issuing a 'crackdown' on high shots that only seemed to last for a week or two.
But it's deeper than that, with incident such as Bulldogs star Matt Burton's high shot on Brisbane's Billy Walters on Thursday night leading to plenty of confusion.
Burton was placed on report and handed a one-match ban by the judiciary for his high tackle, but allowed to stay on the field.
Fast forward to Anzac Day and just over four minutes into the second half at Allianz Stadium, Dragon Lachlan Ilias took off for a run on the fifth tackle and was brought down by Sandon Smith and Egan Butcher
No one picked up any issues with the play and the Dragons were handed a penalty for a separate infringement before referee Todd Smith appeared to receive a message in his ear about a swinging arm.
'OK earlier in this set, it's Sandon's contact on Lachlan Ilias, it's direct contact and moderate force,' Smith said.
'On report, in the bin.'
It left the Fox Footy commentators stunned before they saw a replay.
'Oh wow, let's go back and see this on Ilias,' Andrew Voss said.
Greg Alexander then commented: '(Ilias) just drops his head fractionally and that's enough. The arm swinging from Sandon Smith.
'Slow motion it looks terrible, but it happens in a split second.
'I've got no problem with it (the sin bin), there was force in it, contact was unintentional but there we go.'
It was the only low point on a stunning day for 22-year-old Smith, who scored a double and nailed a series of conversions and penalty goals.
But the lack of refereeing consistency left fans baffled as they took to X to comment.
After the sin bin ruling, Matt Baseley asked: 'Then why didn't Burton get sent to the bin retrospectively last night?
'This game is so hard to be a fan of.'
Account Eels Guru wrote: 'Last night they couldn't go back on the play to send Burto off tho.
'No rules in this sport, just all made up s**t by the ref.'
Brandon Ryan offered: 'Sandon Smith binned. I get that it's contact to the head but does any genuine rugby league fan want to see that being sin binned? I know it's the current standard but it is so s**t.'
The MRC on Friday morning announced Josh Curran, Burton and Sitili Tupouniua are facing suspensions after several ugly moments in the team's 42-18 loss to the Broncos at Suncorp Stadium on Thursday night.
Canterbury had a night to forget with three players sent to the sin bin — but they were lucky Tupouniua wasn't sent from the field for a second time.
Tupouniua has been hit hardest, receiving a three-match ban for his first half shoulder charge high tackle on Broncos defender Brendan Piakura.
He has been hit with an additional two match ban for a second foul act where he raised his knees while running at Piakura in the second half.
It is Tupouniua's dangerous knee lift that got most people talking on Thursday night.
Replays showed the Bulldogs' second-rower collected Piakura in the head with his knee and then followed up with another kicking motion that also collected Piakura again as he slumped in the tackle attempt.
Referee Gerard Sutton spotted Tupouniua's act and immediately awarded the Broncos a penalty and put Tupouniua on report. After reviewing the incident the video match official in the Bunker informed Sutton that the incident warranted no further action.
The NRL's much maligned video referee system is under fire again with the MRC's punishments showing just how wrong the call was that allowed Tupouniua to remain on the field.
Leading rugby league journalist Phil Rothfield posted on X: 'How the f*** is Tupouniua not in the sin bin. Kneed a bloke in the head.'
He went on to write: 'This actually could have been a send off. Sin bin at very least. The NRL has completely lost the plot with the bunker.'
Roosters legend Brad Fittler said on Nine: 'You can't have that.'
Bulldogs cult hero Michael Ennis also said Tupouniua was 'lucky to stay on the field'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
an hour ago
- 7NEWS
Run It Straight league holding a $200k competition despite health warnings
A Run It Straight competition is going ahead despite warnings from health bodies about the dangers of the sport. The Runit Championship League will award $200,000 to the winner of its RUNIT02 competition. In the sport, a runner and a tackler run at each other at top speed on a 'battlefield' that is 20m x 4m in dimensions. The loser is the one who is knocked out. The death of a New Zealand teenager last month shone a spotlight on the dangerous activity. Ryan Satterthwaite, 19, was rushed to hospital with serious head injuries and died on May 26 after playing the 'combat sport'. Police Manawatu area commander Inspector Ross Grantham said Satterthwaite, from Palmerston North on New Zealand's North Island, took part in an impromptu version of the game and his death is an 'absolute tragedy'. In response to Satterthwaite's death, Runit Championship League said the sport 'should only be held in highly controlled environments, which include professional medical supervision and support'. 'All RUNIT events follow established protocols including screening of participants for suitability, strict guidelines around where and how to tackle (between the shoulders and hips only), with qualified medical support and medical assessments conducted both during and after competition. 'We do not encourage any copying of the sport as it should only be done under the strict conditions outlined above in sanctioned RUNIT events.' 'Beer and head injuries don't mix' In May, two men were knocked unconscious and required medical attention during a game. Both men were knocked out, and one appeared to have a seizure, as they competed for an $18,500 cash prize. A leading concussion expert last month urged NRL fans to stop this activity after vision surfaced of a crowd engaging in Run It Straight at a Manly Sea Eagles game. Security reportedly stepped in when fans ran at each other on the hill at Brookvale Oval late in Manly's win over Brisbane on May 31. Sea Eagles chief executive Tony Mestrov said anyone found to have been involved will be banned. Dr Alan Pearce, who has worked with NRL players on concussions, said he is 'still speechless'. 'I'm pretty appalled by what we're seeing and I'm really concerned about the health of the people undertaking this activity,' he told Sunrise. 'There's no medical attention nearby if something happened.' Pearce said it was made worse by the apparent levels of intoxication. 'Beer and head injuries do not mix,' he said. 'This is what we're seeing now and this is something we've been concerned about surrounding the Run It events. 'Things like this will be happening everywhere now and they're not checked properly. That's the concern.' Do not try Run It at home While some of those filmed participating at the NRL game appeared to be grown men, Pearce said he fears for kids and even young adults involved in the trend. 'The damage to a young brain is potentially profound and catastrophic,' he said. 'With young people, kids up to the age of 20, there's a risk of what we call 'second impact syndrome'. 'Even though you might get a hit to the head and not necessarily think that there's anything going on, having a second hit to the head in a rapid time period after — it might be a few minutes, it could be 15 minutes — could be potentially life-threatening. 'This is something we are really worried about.' Other experts have also slammed the trend. Injury prevention expert Professor Patria Hume called the trend a 'reckless and dangerous spectacle' and 'a step backwards' in sport safety. 'We've spent years building evidence-based strategies to reduce head and neck injuries in rugby and contact sports,' she said. 'This event ignores all of that.' Following Satterthwaite's death, top sports neuroscientist Dr Alan Pearce said the loss of life was sadly inevitable. 'This was a matter of time, really, as sad as that is to say,' Pearce told News Corp. 'The concern is that this can happen at any level. Even in the sanctioned Run It events, someone will probably die in that at some point as well. 'It can't be done safely and when there's kids and teens that see it, they like to copy what they see online, and this is something that absolutely not should be copied. 'It is the biggest 'please do not try this at home' disclaimer, if I've ever seen one'.
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
Late pen sinks Tigers – Benji blows up!
NRL: Jarome Luai was penalised for a late shot on Blaize Talagi with the scores tied at 10-all, giving Penrith the lead with coach Benji Marshall not being happy about it.
News.com.au
4 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘Up yours to the fans': Slater, QRL boss under fire over controversial Mam Origin selection
Queensland's selection of Ezra Mam has created a stir given the Broncos five-eighth missed nine games of the season due to a serious off-field incident. Maroons coach Billy Slater dropped a couple of bombshells when naming his team for the must-win game two in Perth including naming Mam in the extended squad after playing just three games this season. Mam missed the first chunk of the season after he was handed a nine-game suspension and a total of $120,000 in fines from the Broncos and NRL combined following a car crash while he was driving with drugs in his system and without a current licence. FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer > Slater told reported on Monday that the 22-year-old is 'the right person for that position right now' and 'we feel the squad will benefit from him being there.' But not everyone is on board with the controversial selection with veteran journalist Phil Rothfield declaring the selection is an insult to NRL fans. 'Ben Ikin, the CEO of the Queensland Rugby League and Billy Slater have not read the room under these circumstances,'' Rothfield said on NRL 360. 'You saw Mam run onto Brookvale Oval and the entire crowd booed him. He is very, very lucky to be playing NRL football this year. I'm not going to go through the crime again. 'I think we've had to wear him coming back to play NRL this year. The NRL made the mistake there and so did the Broncos. 'But to put him on the highest stage of our game — extended bench or not — is going to the fans 'up yours'.' Proud Queenslander and Maroons legend Gorden Tallis defended the decision by saying Mam 'has served his punishment' and that it was the NRL's fault that he was back playing and free to be selected. 'Don't blame Queensland for picking him. He's playing the game, he should be allowed to be chosen,' he declared. But Rothfield went as far as suggesting Mam shouldn't have been allowed to play again this year. 'This was the most serious off-field indiscretion for a very long period of time, driving with drugs and drink in his system and putting a little girl into hospital,' he said. 'He does not deserve to be any part of Origin this year. 'In this situation I think he was entitled to a greater punishment. I would've been happy if he didn't play again this year. 'I'm just surprised Ben Ikin of all people, so smart, so clever, has not read the fans on this occasion.' Tallis continued to argue that it's not Mam's fault that he was selected, to which the panel agreed. But News Corp journalist Brent Read also backed up Tallis on his belief that it's also not the QRL's fault that Mam was free to be picked. 'Once the NRL gave him the sanction and he was cleared for Origin, I don't think you can blame the QRL,' he said. However Rothfield doubled down on saying the selection offends fans. 'Do you think the QRL understand the fan outrage that he's even playing footy this year? They've gone to the fans 'up yours',' he said.
