NRL baffled by Sandon Smith's sin bin in Roosters' win over the Dragons
The NRL world has reacted with more confusion after the latest ruling on a high tackle in the Roosters' 46-18 thrashing of St George Illawarra on Anzac Day.
The inconsistencies from the referees and the NRL's Bunker are plaguing the sport and baffling those watching on, with vastly different calls being made on similar incidents on a weekly and even daily basis.
FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE in 4K with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer.
Part of the problem stems from the NRL head office issuing a 'crackdown' on high shots that only seemed to last for a week or two.
But it's deeper than that, with incident such as Bulldogs star Matt Burton's high shot on Brisbane's Billy Walters on Thursday night leading to plenty of confusion.
Burton was placed on report and handed a one-match ban by the judiciary for his high tackle, but allowed to stay on the field.
Fast forward to Anzac Day and just over four minutes into the second half at Allianz Stadium, Dragon Lachlan Ilias took off for a run on the fifth tackle and was brought down by Sandon Smith and Egan Butcher
No one picked up any issues with the play and the Dragons were handed a penalty for a separate infringement before referee Todd Smith appeared to receive a message in his ear about a swinging arm.
'OK earlier in this set, it's Sandon's contact on Lachlan Ilias, it's direct contact and moderate force,' Smith said.
'On report, in the bin.'
It left the Fox Footy commentators stunned before they saw a replay.
'Oh wow, let's go back and see this on Ilias,' Andrew Voss said.
Greg Alexander then commented: '(Ilias) just drops his head fractionally and that's enough. The arm swinging from Sandon Smith.
'Slow motion it looks terrible, but it happens in a split second.
'I've got no problem with it (the sin bin), there was force in it, contact was unintentional but there we go.'
It was the only low point on a stunning day for 22-year-old Smith, who scored a double and nailed a series of conversions and penalty goals.
But the lack of refereeing consistency left fans baffled as they took to X to comment.
After the sin bin ruling, Matt Baseley asked: 'Then why didn't Burton get sent to the bin retrospectively last night?
'This game is so hard to be a fan of.'
Account Eels Guru wrote: 'Last night they couldn't go back on the play to send Burto off tho.
'No rules in this sport, just all made up s**t by the ref.'
Brandon Ryan offered: 'Sandon Smith binned. I get that it's contact to the head but does any genuine rugby league fan want to see that being sin binned? I know it's the current standard but it is so s**t.'
The MRC on Friday morning announced Josh Curran, Burton and Sitili Tupouniua are facing suspensions after several ugly moments in the team's 42-18 loss to the Broncos at Suncorp Stadium on Thursday night.
Canterbury had a night to forget with three players sent to the sin bin — but they were lucky Tupouniua wasn't sent from the field for a second time.
Tupouniua has been hit hardest, receiving a three-match ban for his first half shoulder charge high tackle on Broncos defender Brendan Piakura.
He has been hit with an additional two match ban for a second foul act where he raised his knees while running at Piakura in the second half.
It is Tupouniua's dangerous knee lift that got most people talking on Thursday night.
Replays showed the Bulldogs' second-rower collected Piakura in the head with his knee and then followed up with another kicking motion that also collected Piakura again as he slumped in the tackle attempt.
Referee Gerard Sutton spotted Tupouniua's act and immediately awarded the Broncos a penalty and put Tupouniua on report. After reviewing the incident the video match official in the Bunker informed Sutton that the incident warranted no further action.
The NRL's much maligned video referee system is under fire again with the MRC's punishments showing just how wrong the call was that allowed Tupouniua to remain on the field.
Leading rugby league journalist Phil Rothfield posted on X: 'How the f*** is Tupouniua not in the sin bin. Kneed a bloke in the head.'
He went on to write: 'This actually could have been a send off. Sin bin at very least. The NRL has completely lost the plot with the bunker.'
Roosters legend Brad Fittler said on Nine: 'You can't have that.'
Bulldogs cult hero Michael Ennis also said Tupouniua was 'lucky to stay on the field'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
38 minutes ago
- ABC News
State of Origin series could be making of New South Wales prop Max King
He might have made his State of Origin debut a few weeks back, but Max King still can't believe he's here. If he had his way, the idea of Max King, New South Wales player, would never really sink in. "Coming into camp the big thing for me is the gratitude of being here. The first one I'd go back to my room every day and think, 'Wow, I can't believe I'm here.' I'd look at my training gear and couldn't believe I was wearing a Blues shirt," King said. "I don't want to lose that. I don't want this to be normal. I want [at] every game to be able to reflect and think how cool it is that I'm selected." Right now, King is on the run of his life and there is no telling where it could end. After his successful Origin debut, when he ran more than 100 metres and made 21 tackles without a miss in a handy Blues win, he has not only been recalled for Game II but pitched into the starting side to replace the injured Mitch Barnett. "One thing Laurie [Daley] did say is, 'Just because you're selected doesn't mean you're an Origin player. What you do with that selection defines whether you're an Origin player,''" King said. It was a test for me, and it was to prove to a lot of people but it was to prove it to myself that I am an Origin player and I do belong there. "I'm close with my faith and I felt like God had pulled a lot of the strings to get me there and I knew that He wouldn't take me to this platform and leave me there to have a shocker and drop the ball six times and miss 10 tackles. "It's a big thing to get recalled, but to get recalled and promoted is even better. It just keeps going up and up for me. "It's not under great circumstances with Mitch Barnett [getting injured] — and he did a great job in Game I. "That's the goal: To play a Max King game but model it off what he did and set a platform for the boys." The Blues ruled Lang Park through muscle, strength and bone in Origin I, with Barnett, Payne Haas and Isaah Yeo dominating the early exchanges and King bringing more of the same once he came on. It wounded Queensland's pride and caused a reshuffle of their whole forward pack. As a result, King is expecting the Maroons' most ferocious effort of the series next week and he cannot wait for it. "Starting the game is fantastic and a great experience for me because we'll see the best Queensland side we've seen all series, especially in that first 20 minutes, and it's another chance to prove to myself that I belong here," King said. "[It is a] baptism by fire, I guess, going straight into the belly of the beast." Origin II marks the midpoint of what has already been a career year for King. He's the most important middle forward for Canterbury's premiership charge and, while he was already in the best form of his NRL tenure before he played for the Blues, the best could still be yet to come. In his sole NRL appearance between Origin I and II, King ran from 229 metres in the Bulldogs win over Parramatta — the second-highest total of his NRL career. It is proof that Origin can be two things at once: both a career highlight and a propulsive force that pushes a player to even greater heights. "Coming back to clubland and having that confidence that I do belong here, it elevates yourself," King said. "You want to lead more." "Growing up, if there was one thing I lacked a bit in my career it probably was confidence, believing that I'm that guy. "It's probably tied in with my humility, but coming back I could feel that confidence and I think it could only benefit my game." If the Blues were to wrap up the series it could only be the start of King's accolades for 2025. The Bulldogs are second favourites for the premiership and a successful Origin campaign would put King firmly in the frame for a spot on the Kangaroo tour at year's end. That would see him join his grandfather Johnny as an Australian Test player. Given King thought breaking his six-year NRL try-scoring drought a few weeks ago would be the highlight of his year, it's a heady possibility. But after what's happened recently, anything feels possible. "It started off with me scoring tries, which I couldn't believe, and then I was in Origin," King said. "The tour is far down the road and I don't want to think about it too much, but representing Australia would cap off the year. "I don't want to say it's a dream come true because my dreams are already coming true."
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
NSW settled, despite To�o concerns
NRL: The NSW Blues prepare for game two in Perth with a stacked and settled team, contrasting a QLD team full of shakeups.
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
Penrith and NSW playmaker Nathan Cleary makes it clear where he stands on possible swap to rugby union
Nathan Cleary has issued his strongest response to the rumours linking him with a shock move to rugby union, with the champion Penrith playmaker not wanting to 'waste' his prime years as he looks to squeeze everything out of his rugby league career. It's not the first time the rumour mill has run wild, with speculation during last year's finals series that Cleary could move to the Super League to be closer to his partner, Mary Fowler. A potential move to rugby has been mooted a few times, although it's never come from the Cleary camp who have had to politely shut down suggestions that the best player in the world wants to earn big bucks overseas or test himself with the Wallabies. Cleary, 27, still has two more years to run on his Panthers deal and could earn the biggest contract in rugby league history if and when he chooses to stay in the NRL. The lure of testing himself in another sport is a perfectly logical argument, but it's one that doesn't stack up for a guy who is constantly rewriting the record books and is facing a new challenge as the four-time defending premiers fight to stay in touch with the top eight after falling to the foot of the ladder a few weeks ago. 'I think I've got enough challenges in front of me playing rugby league,' Cleary told the NewsWire from Blues camp in Leura. 'I feel like I want to squeeze the most out of my rugby league potential as I can. 'I've put so much into it and it's been my passion for so long, so to then get to this stage where I feel like I'm probably playing my best footy and in the best position to play my best footy in the coming years, I don't want to waste that. 'Going back to Penrith and the way we started the year, that's a challenge in itself and I've found motivation in that. You can't take winning for granted.' Cleary is climbing up the leaderboard as one of the greatest scorers in competition history, with the superstar playmaker likely to move into top spot if he stays fit. That's if he decides to stay in rugby league, with his father and coach at the Panthers, Ivan Cleary, leaving the door ajar when asked last week about a possible stint in rugby later in Nathan's career. Cleary is the ultimate professional and would find a way to dominate the 15-man code if he ever wanted to make the switch, but the NSW halfback is content in rugby league and has no desire to leave. 'Growing up in New Zealand, it's so big over there, so I do watch a bit of the international game,' he said when asked if he actually enjoyed rugby. 'I have admiration for those guys and keep up with it, but I much prefer to watch rugby league any day of the week. 'That's part of the reason why I hear this talk about me going to rugby union – and I don't really know where that's coming from – I think that I love rugby league too much to even process that right now. 'I do have an open mind that later in life maybe (I consider it) but definitely not at the moment. 'I feel like I have so much more to tap into my potential as a rugby league player. I feel like I'm coming into those prime years and I don't necessarily want those to go to waste by learning a new sport.' While the lure of playing overseas is tempting for any young man, Cleary appreciates what he has in Penrith where he's the face of the NRL and on track to be the greatest player of all time. It's been a fascinating journey for the premiership star who has the chance to seal the State of Origin series in Perth next week nine years and two weeks after he made his NRL debut as a fresh-faced teenager. Cleary was only 18 and had played just one NSW Cup game following back-to-back 74-10 wins in the Holden Cup where he scored 56 points in what would be his final two matches in their stacked under-20 team. 'I didn't know it was ending at the time. I thought I'd be playing for another two years,' he said, explaining how he became so addicted to footy's daily grind. 'It's a bit different because you play 20s and it's a bit of a hobby in a way because you're not doing it full-time. Of course you love it because you're playing with all your mates and you put a lot of time and effort in it. 'But when you're in first grade and you're being scrutinised all the time, it feels a lot different. 'I was still doing a teacher's aide job when I was playing 20s, so you're juggling so many other things and the competition isn't as hard as the NRL. 'Then you get into first grade and you become addicted to your craft and you put so much into it.'
