Chad Warner stars as Swans down Giants in bitter derby
Chad Warner has starred as Sydney snapped their AFL losing streak with a 14-point win over GWS in a spiteful derby clash.
Beaten in their three previous games, the Swans rediscovered their form to lead at every change en route to a 12.15 (87) to 10.13 (73) victory in front of 39,260 fans at the SCG on Sunday.
But Sydney will face a nervous wait on the availability of Lewis Melican after the defender was cited for collecting GWS tagger Toby Bedford high in the second quarter.
Melican caught Bedford, who had already tapped the ball forward, with his swinging arm.
Bedford did not appear to suffer a concussion but was sent from the field under the blood rule for a cut to his right cheek.
He was later substituted out at half-time due to the swelling around his eye, replaced by Jake Stringer (three goals).
Toby Bedford left the field after this incident with Lewis Melican.#AFLSwansGiants pic.twitter.com/2lqKbtuJYz
— AFL (@AFL) May 4, 2025
A suspension to Melican would be a massive blow to an injury-ravaged Swans outfit, with captain Callum Mills (foot), Tom Papley (heel) and Errol Gulden (ankle) among 11 players sidelined.
Swans midfielder Warner won the Brett Kirk medal as best afield for his 24-disposal, seven-clearance effort.
Winning the rematch of last year's qualifying final, Sydney (3-5) have now beaten GWS in their past five meetings.
The Giants (4-4) extend their losing streak to three matches.
GWS midfielder Tom Green led the game with 34 disposals and six clearances, while teenager Josaia Delana - who arranged 80 tickets for family and friends to attend his debut - impressed with five tackles.
There were plenty of spotfires early as the Swans kicked five consecutive goals to set up a 21-point lead at quarter-time.
Giants defender Lachie Ash gave away a 50-metre penalty - and a goal - after a poorly timed attempt to punch the ball out of a marking James Rowbottom.
It took 20 minutes for the Giants to slot their first major, with Darcy Jones hitting the scoreboard before Aaron Cadman added another.
So dominant were the Swans in the first term that they took 20 inside-50 entries to eight.
GWS cut the deficit to six points in the second quarter, but Sydney held their nerve.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
'Hasn't worked': AFL world rallies around Ollie Wines amid difficult development
AFL fans are showering Ollie Wines with support after the Port Adelaide star revealed on Monday he'll likely need more heart surgery. The former Brownlow Medallist suffers from a heart irregularity which sometimes causes palpitations. The condition has seen him substituted out of three games in the past four seasons - most recently in Port's away win against Sydney on April 20. Wines had heart surgery last December in a bid to correct the issue, but revealed on Monday it hasn't worked. "I had a procedure back in December and there was one per cent likeliness that it wouldn't work," he told reporters. "And unfortunately, I'm in the one per cent that it hasn't worked. "So we've gone back to a bit of an intervention plan that we had the previous two years to manage it up to that operation and that is working well so far. We will reassess at the end of the season to see if we do it again and try a surgical operation." It comes after Wines and partner Olivia announced last month they're expecting their first child. Despite the difficult development, Wines is staying optimistic. "It was frustrating (to be subbed out against Sydney)," he said. "But, look, at the end of the day, luckily for me it's not life threatening. And it's something that cost me a game of footy, enough to get subbed out of a game of footy. "So I'm in a really fortunate position. I've got the best cardiologists and doctors around me at the footy club and they've talked me through everything. So at the moment, it's just this plan that has previously worked. I've never had an episode when we're using this intervention and once the season ends, we'll assess if I need a procedure again." Wines and partner Oliver announced in May they're expecting a baby boy. 'Soon to be three,' Olivia wrote alongside a photo of the ultrasound. The couple also shared a video of them cutting into a blue cake to reveal the gender. The official Port Adelaide account was among the many to congratulate the happy couple. 'Couldn't love this more,' they wrote. Maisie Rozee, the wife of Port captain Connor, wrote: "Congratulations!! Sooo exciting!!" Kellie Finlayson, the wife of Port player Jeremy, wrote: "Congratulations beautiful humans." While Charlotte Viney, the wife of Melbourne player Jack, commented: "So happy!" View this post on Instagram A post shared by Olivia May (@oliviamay666) View this post on Instagram A post shared by Olivia May (@oliviamay666) Port coach Ken Hinkley previously praised Wines for the way he's been handling his heart issue. "I think it's a managed situation which we know how to manage really well," Hinkley said. "Ollie, more importantly, understands it really, really well. "Even on the weekend (against Sydney), he's self-diagnosed himself, he knows himself what's going on. So what I'm comfortable is that Ollie understands everything and he's comfortable about it. He's more than OK to continue on and be playing the game." RELATED: James Hird calls out Sydney Swans over moment he's 'never seen' Collingwood fans 'salty' after rival club takes step-son of legend AFL fans rallied around Wines on social media on Monday after learning his procedure didn't work. "Wishing Ollie Wines the very best," one person wrote. Another commented: "All the best, hope everything works out."
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Galvin receives praise from former Tigers star
Former Wests Tigers playmaker Luke Brooks says it was the 'smart decision' for the club to part ways with Lachlan Galvin given the contract saga would have become a messy distraction for both parties if it was allowed to fester. The Bulldogs confirmed last week that Galvin had joined the club effective immediately until the end of the 2028 season after the young five-eighth informed the Tigers earlier this year that he wouldn't entertain the idea of re-signing beyond 2026. The contract mess led to Galvin being dropped to NSW Cup for a game before he returned to the NRL side the following week. Galvin is now in line to make his Bulldogs debut next Monday against the Eels who were also after his signature. Brooks spent 11 seasons at the Tigers but informed the club in 2023 that he would leave at the end of the year to take up a lucrative deal with Manly. He's seen the toll contract negotiations can have on young stars at the club, and he hopes both Galvin and the Tigers can move on swiftly now that it's all sorted. 'I think the smart decision was made for them to part ways,' he told the NewsWire. 'It would have been a distraction if it went for another year. It's good for both parties. 'I don't know too much about what's going on, but looking at it, I feel like he's handled it really well for a 19-year-old. 'Not many guys that age can go through that with all the media pressure and so much noise going on. 'He still came out and played some good footy. There'll still be some news going on around him, but after a few weeks playing for the Bulldogs, hopefully that goes away and he can focus on playing good footy. 'He's a great player and he's a good young kid as well. Hopefully, it works out for him.' While Galvin has been the talk of the town lately, a man at the opposite end of his career has also been in the headlines with chat around whether Queensland captain Daly Cherry-Evans should keep his spot in the team. The veteran halfback has been a loyal servant for the Maroons throughout his illustrious career, but there have been calls for Tom Dearden to replace him following the game one defeat. Cherry-Evans put the disappointment behind him to star with three try assists as Manly bounced back to thrash the Broncos on Saturday night, with the skipper showing he still has it just days after copping a tough loss in Brisbane. 'When you have a big game like that (the Origin opener) and end up losing, I feel like you want to go out there and play straight away. He really led from the front,' Brooks said. 'To be doing what he's doing at his age by backing up three days later and then putting on a clinic, it just shows that he's a great player. 'There's been a lot of noise, so to put that to the side and put on a performance was great. 'I don't think the halves were the problem (for Queensland). They lost to a good Blues side, so whatever way they go is up to them. 'Hopefully, for his sake, he gets another crack.'
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
'I've never seen that': James Hird takes blowtorch to Swans after shambolic scenes
Essendon great James Hird has taken a blowtorch to the Swans and says one shambolic play in Saturday night's huge loss to Adelaide sums up Sydney's struggles in the AFL this season. Crows star Wayne Milera probably echoed the thoughts of many fans when he described the Swans as a "rabble" after his side's thumping 90-point victory at the SCG. And Hird pointed to Sydney's lack of class up forward, their lacklustre ball movement and inadequate distribution of the footy as major issues for first-year head coach Dean Cox to try and fix. "I think their biggest issue is they haven't got a forward line," Hird said on Nine's Footy Furnace. "They haven't got a forward line that can take a contested mark and their ball movement has gone off which was their one-wood last year. Their congested side of things is not where it needs to be, they rely on too few around the middle of the ground." The Swans have been one of the most consistent sides in the AFL over the last decade and went down to Brisbane in last year's grand final after finishing the regular season on top of the ladder. But Sydney's lofty standards have slipped in 2025 as the injuries have racked up, with Cox admitting Saturday night's performance against Adelaide was "unacceptable and embarrassing". Hird agrees and says the Swans' effort areas and failure to execute the fundamentals is a major concern. "And I think the one thing I've loved about the Swans over the last 10 years is their standards. Everything was done - not perfectly - there were some mistakes but not too many," he added. The Essendon great singled out a second quarter goal for the Crows where two Sydney players just needed to scramble the ball through the posts and concede a behind. Instead, they were caught dawdling and allowed Adelaide forward Riley Thilthorpe to toe the ball through the sticks for a goal, in a moment Hird said was indicative of the Swans' struggles this year. "I've never seen a Swans backline let a goal like that go through and it might be unlucky... but I just can't believe that ball went through and I just think it's just symbolic of where the Swans are at," Hird added. "Yes, it's not a massive thing, it's not a game plan thing but I've never seen a Swans group of players in the last 10 years let that happen." Hird and three-time premiership winning Geelong great Jimmy Bartel were also shocked to hear that Milera and the Crows apologised for referring to the Swans as a "rabble". The AFL greats insisted that such criticism was fully warranted after the 90-point hiding. "So what's the cut-off point, 100? You got belted by 90 points," Bartel said. "You were a rabble. We've been a rabble before when we've been belted. Adelaide CEO Tim Silvers reportedly called Swans counterpart Tom Harley to apologise for Milera's comments and Crows teammates insist he meant no harm. RELATED: Pies' move set to force rivals into rethink as Ginnivan predicts change Calls for Kane Cornes to be sanctioned over Luke Beveridge incident AFL world gutted over heartbreaking news about West Coast hero But Hird agreed with Bartel that the criticism was warranted after Saturday night's game and took no issues with the situation. "It seems to me as if they were a rabble and you know when players are back-chatting each other and talking on the ground, you really love it when the opposition is doing it," Hird added. "But at the end of the day they were a mess, they really were a mess on Saturday night."
