Man jailed for at least 24 years over murder of Elgin woman
A man who went on a spending spree after beating a mother-of-two to death in Moray has been jailed for at least 24 years.
Owen Grant, 43, killed Lucretia Donaghy, 32, known as Kiesha, at her home in Elgin in November 2023.
Judge Lord Scott said Grant murdered the "unarmed and defenceless" woman by repeatedly striking her on the head and body with a claw hammer or similar implement.
Ms Donaghy died as a result of blunt force head injuries.
Lord Scott described the frenzied attack as "exceptionally savage" and "brutal".
He told Grant: "Whatever implement you used, whether a claw hammer or something similar, the murder weapon was never found, undoubtedly disposed of by you in calm and calculated efforts to conceal your crime and dispose of any evidence in its immediate aftermath."
The court heard there had been no evidence of provocation, with Grant accused of murdering Ms Donaghy for money.
Lord Scott stated: "On the evidence, you were struggling to pay your rent at the time. On your own evidence, you owed Lucretia Donaghy money for drugs.
"Almost immediately after her death, you embarked, once again calmly, on a spending spree involving attending to your own needs and drug habit.
"You went from having only £12.36 in the bank on 15 November 2023 to frittering away hundreds of pounds on cocaine in a matter of three or four days.
"Frittering away hundreds of pounds of the murdered Lucretia Donaghy's money entirely on your own selfish purposes. You started to do so before her body had even been discovered, within no more than two hours of her death."
Grant denied any wrongdoing but was on Thursday found guilty of murder following a trial at the High Court in Edinburgh.
Lord Scott handed him a life sentence with at least 24 years behind bars.
The judge highlighted a victim impact statement prepared by Ms Donaghy's mother, Amanda Gow.
Lord Scott said: "She mourns for her daughter and the life Kiesha would have had. Her mind returns constantly to Kiesha's final minutes, wondering if she was in pain."
In a statement released through Police Scotland, Ms Gow thanked all those who have shown support.
She added: "Life without Kiesha will never be the same. She was my only daughter and my first born. Her two daughters will have to live their lives without their mum.
"I still cannot get my head around the fact that she is gone and that her life was taken in such a brutal way."
Detective Superintendent Lorna Ferguson said it had been a "complex enquiry", but Grant was now facing the consequences of his actions.
She added: "My thoughts remain with Kiesha's family and friends as they continue to try to come to terms with what happened. I hope the verdict will bring them some form of justice."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
27 minutes ago
- The Sun
Love Island star Kyle Ashman breaks silence after being axed from show over machete attack arrest
LOVE Island star Kyle Ashman has broken his silence after being cut from the show over his arrest. He has since spoken out about being axed saying: 'I fully co-operated with this police investigation and made it very clear that I had no involvement in this incident. 'I am not a violent person and any suggestion otherwise is a mischaracterisation.' 1
BBC News
40 minutes ago
- BBC News
Bath boss Van Graan urges side to keep discipline
Bath director of rugby Johann van Graan has urged his side to keep their discipline in their Premiership semi-final against Bristol on Graan's side finished the regular season with 72 points, 11 points clear at the top of the Premiership standings, and 14 clear of fourth-placed the South African is wary of the threat Bath's local rivals pose, having lost twice to the Bears in the league this season already."This is our third semi-final we've played this season and I'll just say the usual - make sure you're disciplined, stick to what you do and make sure you perform on the day," Van Graan told BBC Radio has been a historic season in many ways already for Bath, having already completed a cup double by winning the Premiership Rugby Cup and European Challenge Cup - ending a drought of 17 years without a ahead of Friday's match, Van Graan has taken time to look back on his three years at the club having described Bath as "broken" when he took the helm in 2022."When we started, to get to Twickenham looked kind of impossible," he said. "We had a mountain to climb but step by step everyone at the club did it."I was very proud of the group that we passed another milestone. If you think back to the first year, our last game was to get ourselves into the Champions Cup." Bath lock Charlie Ewels has also been complimentary about Friday's opponents in the build-up to the match."They're a very good team, that's what I've taken from those matches," he said."Obviously there's an extra level as it's a derby around the fans. "We've played them a few times this season - in the cup, twice in the league. At Cardiff we played different teams against them."They will be very well prepped, we'll be very well prepped and we'll be really looking forward to it."Ewels has emphasised his side's need to "trust the process", a similar mantra coined by his coach last month, in order for Bath to go one step further and win the Premiership on 14 June to complete a historic he is not using last season's defeat in the final against Northampton Saints as extra incentive to inspire the club to what would be their first league title since 1996."I can honestly say the full-time whistle went and I was gutted for maybe a minute or two," the 29-year-old added."And then I thought, what more could any of us have done? I gave everything and I looked around me and everyone gave everything."If you do that, with anything in life, it was quite easy to get over."
The Sun
42 minutes ago
- The Sun
Thousands to be left without HOT WATER due to energy meter switch-off
THOUSANDS of households are at risk of being left without heating and hot water in weeks due to a shortage of smart meter appointments. Homes with electricity meters that use the Radio Teleswitch Service (RTS) need to upgrade to a smart meter before June 30 - when the service is being switched off. 1 Some RTS meters automatically turn the heating and hot water system on and off at different times during the day. This means that once the signal is switched off households could find that these systems do not work properly. They could also end up running their heating permanently during peak time, which could cause huge bill hikes. But a shortage of smart meter appointments means that thousands of households will not be able to make the switch before this deadline. None of the major energy suppliers or industry regulator Ofgem were able to tell us how long customers could expect to wait for a smart meter appointment. More than 100,000 RTS meters are still in use, according to Energy Action Scotland. But the meters are only being replaced at a rate of around 1,000 a day, according to industry regulator Ofgem. As a result, some customers are being offered meter replacement dates well after the deadline. An Ofgem spokesperson said: "Suppliers need to do more and ensure customers are protected from detriment, which is why industry is putting in place a phased area-by-area shutdown beginning from 30 June. "We have made clear that the signal serving a specific area should not be switched off until suppliers have demonstrated that they are ready and able to respond quickly to any issues customers experience. From TV to energy... tips to save you money on 7 bills that are going up in April 'While this carefully managed phaseout should reassure customers that they will be protected, it remains crucial that these meters are replaced so I would urge customers to engage with their supplier when offered an appointment – even if it is after the 30 June date.' Forums online are now inundated with energy customers complaining about being unable to secure an appointment. One Ovo customer said he had been trying to upgrade his two RTS meters since October 2024. An engineer visited his home that month and tried to install the meter but there was a signal issue. How do I know if I have an RTS electricity meter? YOU'LL be able to tell if you have a meter that relies on the RTS quite easily. The oldest RTS-powered meters have a switch box labelled "Radio Teleswitch" located next to the physical electricity meter. Others may have the RTS switch box included within the electricity meter as a single box on the wall. If you're unsure about the type of electricity meter in your home - call your supplier as they'll usually have this information on hand. RTS is also sometimes called dynamically teleswitched (DTS). A fortnight ago his appointment was cancelled due to a system issue. He added: 'I tried to re-book an appointment today but all the appointments had gone and there is nothing left before 30th June. 'I was told by the operator that because it is not my fault the meters have not been changed that I would not lose electricity supply - I have little faith in this happening and dread an electric bill after the 30th of June.' Another said their parents are in a similar position. They said: 'My parents are with Utility Warehouse but their electric supply is through Eon Next. Neither of them have contacted them about the RTS switch off.' They added that when they called Utility Warehouse customer services they were unable to speak to anyone. They tried to book an appointment online but every time were told: 'we're not able to provide you with a smart meter right now. Register interest and we'll get in touch when we can.' Another said: 'I am a British Gas 'customer' on a fixed price tariff. Last October BG advised that my electricity meter was one of the soon to be obsolete RTS type. 'I dutifully signed into my account and tried to request a smart meter … no appointments available. "Since then I have regularly tried to request an install … no appointments.' Andrew Bartlett, chief executive of Advice Direct Scotland, said customers are "in the dark" about the RTS switch. He added: "People are being given dates well after the June 30 deadline for the replacement of their RTS meters with a smart meter, even into August. 'Customers are doing the right thing by contacting suppliers to arrange their fitting, only to be given dates more than a month after the deadline. 'We are also aware anecdotally of people being wrongly told that they have nothing to fear as the cut off won't happen until 2028.' How long do I need to wait for an appointment? Ovo Energy Ovo Energy said it has appointments available to install a meter as soon as possible. However, the availability of these appointments may vary depending on where you live. If you are unsure of what to do or are vulnerable then you should contact Ovo as soon as possible so it can ensure you have an appointment booked in. Customers will be able to choose which tariff they switch to and its specialist team will be on hand to help find the most appropriate one. Octopus Energy Octopus Energy said it has contacted every customer it thinks has an RTS meter that may not work effectively after the switch off. It is installing nearly 20,000 meters a week and said it has the capacity to prioritise anyone who thinks they might lose their heating after the switch off. A spokesperson said: 'It's really important that customers with RTS meters get in touch with us - but we also want them not to worry. Our team is working 7 days a week, and we'll do our very best to make sure that no-one is left without power.' said it will prioritise RTS upgrade appointments and has reserved engineers to ensure it has the capacity to deliver these upgrades. It said all RTS customers should not delay. You should book your smart meter upgrade appointment as soon as possible to make sure your heating and hot water continues to run smoothly. How can I improve my chance of getting an appointment? You should regularly check your supplier's website to see if they have released any new slots. Most suppliers will only let you book an appointment in the next six weeks. You can also ask your supplier how often they release new slots and on which day of the week. For example, Octopus Energy releases new slots on a Monday but you will need to get online early to secure a space. Most suppliers will let you register your interest online so they can notify you when new slots become available. You can do this online through your account. A spokesperson for Energy UK said: "We would only suggest that anyone with an RTS meter contacts their supplier as soon as possible. "Booking a meter replacement appointment now will ensure a smooth change that enables your heating and hot water to continue operating in the same way. "If you are worried that you have an appointment booked after 30 June, this has been taken into account as part of the phase out plan.' Can I keep my RTS tariff? In most cases, RTS customers will be offered a smart meter. The smart meter operates in the same way as an RTS meter on a multi-rate tariff such as Economy 7 or Economy 10. If that is not possible then suppliers must take all reasonable steps to provide a similar tariff, so customers do not see their bills increase. Meanwhile, upgrading an RTS meter to a smart one should give customers access to a wide choice of smart meter only tariffs that should save them money. If your supplier has not contacted you already then you do not need to wait for a letter or email asking you to switch. Get in touch with your supplier directly as soon as you can. What energy bill help is available? There's a number of different ways to get help paying your energy bills if you're struggling to get by. If you fall into debt, you can always approach your supplier to see if they can put you on a repayment plan before putting you on a prepayment meter. This involves paying off what you owe in instalments over a set period. If your supplier offers you a repayment plan you don't think you can afford, speak to them again to see if you can negotiate a better deal. Several energy firms have schemes available to customers struggling to cover their bills. But eligibility criteria vary depending on the supplier and the amount you can get depends on your financial circumstances. For example, British Gas or Scottish Gas customers struggling to pay their energy bills can get grants worth up to £2,000. British Gas also offers help via its British Gas Energy Trust and Individuals Family Fund. You don't need to be a British Gas customer to apply for the second fund. EDF, Octopus Energy and Scottish Power all offer grants to struggling customers too. Thousands of vulnerable households are missing out on extra help and protections by not signing up to the Priority Services Register (PSR). The service helps support vulnerable households, such as those who are elderly or ill. Some of the perks include being given advance warning of blackouts, free gas safety checks and extra support if you're struggling. Get in touch with your energy firm to see if you can apply.
