Class action lawsuit over housing on First Nations in court this week
Social Sharing
A class action lawsuit against Canada for failing to provide adequate housing on First Nations land is being heard in Federal Court this week in Winnipeg.
St. Theresa Point First Nation in Manitoba and Sandy Lake First Nation in northwestern Ontario filed the lawsuit in 2023. Over 100 First Nations have opted in to the class action.
The statement of claim alleges Canada has "deliberately underfunded housing on reserves," while simultaneously isolating First Nations by imposing restrictions on their ability to provide housing for themselves.
The First Nations' legal team says this is the first case to consider the federal government's obligation to provide adequate housing for First Nations.
"The housing crisis on reserve is a national shame," said St. Theresa Point Chief Raymond Flett in a news release.
"Our children and future generations deserve to grow up in decent housing where they can survive and flourish."
The class action is seeking $5 billion in damages.
The 2023 statement of claim alleges that 25 per cent of the 646 houses in St. Theresa Point, 465 kilometres northeast of Winnipeg, should be condemned due to "severe decay and rotting," and that more than half of houses in Sandy Lake, 450 kilometres northeast of Winnipeg, are in need of major repairs.
The statement of claim refers to a 1977 federal government strategy that would provide homes with "physical infrastructure that meets commonly accepted health and safety standards" similar to neighbouring non-Indigenous communities.
The statement of claim also alleges the intensity of a 2009 outbreak of H1N1 flu in St. Theresa Point was attributable to the lack of running water and overcrowding housing. It says Canada's response was to the flu outbreak was t o send body bags rather than respond to the source of the crisis.
The news release said it's still common for 20 people to share a small home and living in housing structurally "falling apart," or without plumbing.
No legal obligations for housing, says Canada
Canada's statement of defence said "Canada does not build or maintain houses on reserves.
"First Nations are responsible for planning, procuring and managing their housing stock. Canada supports their housing projects through funding….
"Canada does not owe any legal obligations or duties to build and maintain houses on-reserve. The claim should be dismissed."
In its 2024 statement of defence, Canada said that 185 of the houses in St. Theresa Point require major repairs and 25 homes require replacement and that, of 432 houses in Sandy Lake, about 55 of them require major repairs and 55 require replacement.
The statement of defence also said that a lack of running water or overcrowded dwellings were identified by the Public Health Agency of Canada as likely contributing factors to St. Theresa Point's 2009 H1N1 outbreak.
It denied the remainder of the allegation, saying Canada responded meaningfully to the outbreak and that Health Canada nursing stations were advised to order supplemental pharmaceuticals, medical supplies, and equipment to provide four months of stock instead of the normal six weeks of stock.
The hearing is expected to wrap up on Thursday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Canada Standard
19 hours ago
- Canada Standard
The food affordability crisis is one reason governments need to step up for school food
Despite the hard work and dedication of hundreds of local grassroots organizations across the country to deliver student nutrition programs, there are, too often, not enough funds to purchase the food to meet student needs. As described in a study of elementary school parents' and teachers' perspectives on school food in southern Ontario, in the city of Hamilton and Peel Region, far too many school food programs cannot adequately meet existing nutritional needs of hungry students. Some teachers described how students, as young as four years old, come to school without enough nutritious food to fuel them through the day. As a researcher who examines biological and cultural determinants of human nutrition and food security, I conducted this study with academic colleagues in partnership with the Coalition for Healthy School Food. Fortunately, in 2024 the government of Canada announced a new National School Food Program and policy. As of March 10, 2025, the federal government has made school food agreements with all provinces and territories. This is an opportunity to reinvent school food across Canada and to catch up to other G7 countries that have long-running traditions of school food programs. In our study we asked parents through an online survey and focus group discussions in Hamilton and Peel Region to tell us what they envision for a future national school food program. Eighty-three per cent of the respondents were women; respondents self-identfied as South Asian (eight per cent), Black (five per cent), Indigenous (four per cent), Middle Eastern (four per cent), Southeast Asian (three per cent), Latino (three per cent), East Asian (three per cent) and white (70 per cent). Forty-three per cent of households were classified as experiencing some level of food insecurity, with 41 per cent having an annual household income of less than $69,999. Ninety-six per cent of survey respondents said they want their child to participate in a school food program, and 77 per cent said they would be willing to pay some amount for it. In parent focus groups, and teacher interviews, participants cited such benefits as: Participants saw affordability as one of the major barriers to an accessible program. Suggestions for funding models ranged from universal free programs to government-funded programs subsidized by optional parent contributions, and corporate donor funding. Read more: School gardens and kitchens could grow with Ontario's proposed food literacy act Most parents and teachers were adamant that programs be universally accessible with nutritious and diverse food options for all students regardless of ability to pay. Federal funding of $79 million flowed to the provinces and programs in the first year of the government's National School Food Program, but those funds were quickly used up. As noted by the Coalition for Healthy School Food, not all provinces are contributing in the same way towards school food programs to date. In Saskatchewan and Ontario, school food is severely underfunded relative to other provinces and territories. Saskatchewan and Ontario's per capita investments are four times lower than the national median of 63 cents per student per day: Nova Scotia contributes $3.30 whereas Saskatchewan and Ontario are at the bottom of the pack at three and nine cents per student per day respectively. That's based on an annual average of 190 school days per year across Canada. Without significant funding increases from those provincial governments, none of the hopes and dreams for a National School Food Program in Saskatchewan and Ontario will come to fruition. While the need for more funding is paramount, there are also logistical issues to tackle. Without commercial-grade kitchens in elementary schools, some survey respondents suggested centralized food preparation models by upgrading existing neighbourhood or high school infrastructure, from which meals could be distributed to local schools. Read more: What needs to happen next for Canada to have a successful school food program Others were in favour of contracting local food businesses as providers. A few parents raised the concern that school boards might contract large food conglomerates, resulting in a situation where corporate profit compromises food quality. Teachers voiced the need for adequate staffing and volunteer support so as not to unduly burden school staff. Some parents and teachers felt strongly about minimizing packaging waste. As one teacher stated: "I would be concerned about the environmental impact, going from trying to conserve and be mindful of what we use, like reusable containers, to a disposable model ... I think it would send a poor message to kids who we're asking to protect their environment." The topic of how much time students have to eat arose frequently in discussions. In Ontario, many schools at the elementary level adhere to a two-break or balanced day model, where students have a "nutrition break" in the morning with recess, and another in early afternoon (instead of two short recesses and a mid-day window for lunch/recess). This may be a reason why parents and some teachers say that kids don't have enough time to eat. In addition to logistical operations and accessibility, parents and teachers voiced the need to consider social and cultural diversity and inclusion. They noted the diversity of student dietary requirements and preferences - from food allergies/intolerances and cultural and religious foods to concerns about what respondents referred to as their "picky eaters." Teachers pointed out that halal and/or vegetarian foods must be made available. The oversight of food safety and offering a diversity of healthy food choices was mentioned repeatedly by parents. Meals and ingredients could be posted in weekly or monthly menus - like they are in in France, for example - to ensure students and their families are aware of what is being served. There was enthusiasm for exposing kids to culturally diverse menu options that would make students from all backgrounds feel included and welcome. While some parents were concerned that their kids might not eat foods they're unfamiliar with, others thought it would be great to expose them to new foods that they might eat at school even if they wouldn't at home. Some parents were excited about the prospect of community involvement, including volunteers but also students in food prep, distribution and cleanup. Beyond the school community, some proposed fostering partnerships with local farms, community gardens and local food providers. In sum, participants voiced the need for flexible programs that could be tailored to specific school, family and community needs - with clear communication with all families and school staff about the school food programs' goals and operations. We have a tremendous need and opportunity in Canada to strengthen our food system and food security with the National School Food Program. We have just begun this project with the commitment of some federal, provincial and municipal funding, but there is much more work to do in developing school food programs in each part of the country. The continued food affordability crisis and the threat of tariffs by the United States make it clear how important these programs are. No matter how these programs end up evolving, parents and teachers in Hamilton and Peel Region have clearly voiced their desire for equity - school food program accessibility, regardless of family income. They also want to see food offerings meeting students' diverse dietary requirements, and the inclusion of student, family, educator and local community partners.
CTV News
5 days ago
- CTV News
First Nations take steps to reduce wildfire risk
First Nations take steps to reduce wildfire risk Heading into peak wildfire season, several First Nations across B.C. have already taken steps to reduce the risk to their communities.
CBC
5 days ago
- CBC
Island Lake First Nations under partial evacuation due to wildfire smoke
Some Manitoba First Nations evacuating vulnerable residents amid worsening air quality say finding accommodations has been challenging, with thousands fleeing wildfires across the province. Four First Nations in the Island Lake region in northeastern Manitoba — Garden Hill, St. Theresa Point, Wasagamack and Red Sucker Lake — are under partial evacuations as of Thursday, said Anisininew Okimawin, a coalition of the four First Nations. About 250 residents had been flown out of the region — around 500 kilometres northeast of Winnipeg — as of Thursday afternoon, said Anisininew Okimawin Grand Chief Alex McDougall. "All of the four communities have focused their efforts around those that are most vulnerable," McDougall said. That includes "those that have respiratory issues and are being affected by the smoke, the heavy smoke that is being blown in by the fires … to the west of us here, primarily [in] Norway House [and] Cross Lake," about 200 kilometres west of Island Lake, he said. "There's a lot of fear and a lot of uncertainty from our community members." WATCH | Partial evacuation underway in Island Lake: Partial evacuation underway in all 4 Island Lake First Nations 3 hours ago Duration 1:51 Around 250 people have been flown out of the remote Island Lake region in northeastern Manitoba, as all four member First Nations have ordered partial evacuations due to wildfire smoke. Pimicikamak Cree Nation, also known as Cross Lake, and the incorporated community of Cross Lake are among the Manitoba communities under full evacuation orders due to a nearby wildfire. Norway House is under an evacuation notice, with people ordered to be ready to leave. An Environment Canada air quality warning is in effect for much of Manitoba, including Island Lake, with 27 active fires still burning in the province as of Thursday afternoon. Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs Grand Chief Kyra Wilson told CBC News earlier Thursday that Misipawistik Cree Nation in the Interlake region, nearly 400 kilometres northwest of Winnipeg, was also preparing to evacuate vulnerable residents. "Priority 1 individuals are going to be evacuated to southern Manitoba, but what the leadership wants is … actual hotel spaces before they send their community members to the south," Wilson said. A fire 2,500 hectares in size was about eight kilometres north of Misipawistik as of Thursday's provincial fire bulletin. There were also two active fires west across the bay around Easterville, according to the province's fire map — the largest about 35 hectares in size. Other evacuations taking up space The Island Lake communities have about 16,000 members combined, with roughly 2,000 being Priority 1 residents — those considered most vulnerable and the first to be evacuated, McDougall said. Dozens of dialysis patients have been taken to health facilities in places like Gimli and Powerview-Pine Falls. But McDougall added the First Nations are trying to select the most vulnerable even within that category, as evacuations elsewhere in the province limit the number of accommodations available for Island Lake residents. The Canadian Red Cross has registered about 18,000 wildfire evacuees in the province as of Thursday, the province said in its latest fire bulletin. "One of the challenges that we're seeing with the evacuations is knowing that Manitoba has already been facing evacuations from other communities," McDougall said. "All of those have been going to the larger urban centres in Manitoba and are obviously taking up all of the available accommodations." Premier Wab Kinew said during an interview with Information Radio Thursday morning the situation for Island Lake evacuees is something the province is looking at. "They're medical patients and people who are very vulnerable," he said. "And so it's a bit of a balancing act between getting people into shelter and making sure that we keep some rooms open when those really high-priority medical patients come into the city." First Nations have 'no real involvement': grand chief Wilson criticized the evacuation of other communities in recent days as disorganized and unco-ordinated, with some people, including vulnerable residents with medical conditions, left waiting in line for accommodation or meals. "Unfortunately, we have no real involvement," Wilson said, with the Red Cross providing evacuation services to First Nations under an agreement with Indigenous Services Canada. Watch as the northern Manitoba wildfires grow 9 hours ago Duration 1:11 Wildfires have been burning in northern Manitoba since late May, when a province-wide emergency was declared. Watch as CBC Weather Specialist Riley Laychuk tracks the fires threatening the communities of Flin Flon, Sherridon and Pukatawagan. The AMC grand chief is calling for a regional emergency management strategy in which Indigenous communities have more participation than they do now. "We need First Nations leadership to be involved in the decision-making, and the response time needs to be quick," she said. Meanwhile, McDougall said there would be no need for Island Lake to be partially evacuated if the region had a hospital of its own. "Service would be available locally, and that's been the argument of our leadership," he said. "You compare the size of the population of any other non-First Nation population — they have hospitals." Are you an evacuee who needs assistance? Contact Manitoba 211 by calling 211 from anywhere in Manitoba or email 211mb@
