Now it's the DIMBYs! Villages at war over 2,000 house housing estate they DO want to be built in their back yards
Two small communities are locked in an extraordinary dispute about who should have a massive housing development in their area – with both insisting it should be them.
Discussions are underway about 2,000 homes being built at Robertson Barracks in Norfolk - a historic 400-acre military base where Churchill and Eisenhower once met during the Second World War.
But this has sparked a feud as the land lies on the boundary between Swanton Morley and neighbouring Hoe and Worthing – both of which are laying claim to the development as it will generate significant council tax revenue.
Much of the base, including where the barracks are located, is in Swanton Morley.
But the area which once formed an RAF airfield – and where most of the new homes would go up – is in Hoe and Worthing.
Swanton Morley, which has a population of 2,300, is now arguing it would make sense for the entire site to be administered by one parish, triggering accusations by its smaller neighbour, which has 300 residents, of a 'land grab'.
The issue exploded at a recent general purposes meeting hosted by Breckland District Council, the planning authority for the area, where Roger Atterwill, the chairman of Swanton Morley Parish Council, put forward the proposal.
But Celia Daniel, the chairman of Hoe and Worthing Parish Meeting, complained there had been 'no engagement' between the two areas about it.
She said: 'This is deeply concerning. The proposal to enlarge Swanton Morley means reducing the Hoe and Worthing parish area. What they are asking for is morally wrong.'
Michael Goff, who farms land by the airfield, added: 'Fundamentally, this is a land grab.
'This will reduce Hoe and Worthing to an utterly irrelevant, moon-shaped sliver of a parish. It might as well disappear at that point.'
Ms Daniel declined to comment further when contacted by the Mail today, saying only that there had been 'various meetings since last year' about the proposed sustainable development.
But Mr Atterwill, who is also leader of the Independent and Green group at the district council, insisted there was no 'land grab' - and claimed his parish was better suited to take on the responsibility of the new dwellings and more deserving of the funds.
'Between the two villages, Swanton Morley would have all the traffic and all the construction vehicles and everything that goes with that but the houses would be in Hoe and Worthing,' he said.
'Every local authority has to have a local development plan which is made up of the district council's local plan and a selection of parish councils that have done their own neighbourhood plans, so that they can have their own development policies.
'Hoe and Worthing is quite a small hamlet. They don't have a local development plan and they've got no intention of doing one.
'Hoe and Worthing is not a parish council. They're a parish meeting. They are only meeting once or twice a year. They get a total precept of around £1,800 and ours is £98,000, so there is a difference in resources…
'This is very important to Swanton Morley because we're one of the largest villages in the district of Breckland.
'We have a medical practice here, road infrastructure that needs to be improved and the village school grounds could be expanded.
'Hoe and Worthing doesn't really have assets. It's got a couple of dog bins and notice boards but no other assets. They don't have a village hall.'
Mr Atterwill added having a local development plan meant his parish council would be able to lock in Section 106 agreements, under which developers must pay for local facilities in return for planning approval of lucrative sites.
And he said Swanton Morley had ambitions to turn the Grade II listed air traffic control tower at the base into a museum due to its significance.
On July 4, 1942, British prime minster Winston Churchill and General Dwight D Eisenhower, the Supreme Commander of the Allied Expeditionary Force in Europe, watched American and British airmen take off from what was then RAF Swanton Morley on the first combined bombing raid of the war.
The operation targeted German airfields in occupied Holland and involved six US crews from 15th Bombardment Squadron and six RAF crews from 226 Squadron, using Boston light bombers.
Mr Atterwill added: 'There is no intention to land grab because we are not grabbing any land. We're not looking to grab any buildings.
'It's simply moving the boundary around the field. There's no homes or base within that field [at present].'
Locals were bemused by the feud between the modestly-sized communities, noting they might normally be expected to fight expansion to preserve their way of life.
One said: 'I wouldn't call it a David and Goliath situation, more David and David.'
A Swanton Morley resident added: 'This is Dimbyism – definitely in my back yard.'
The RAF handed the base over to the Army in 1995 and it was renamed after Sir William Robertson, head of the British Army during the First World War.
It is currently home to 400 personnel of 1st The Queen's Dragoon Guards, with family accommodation and a pre-school on-site, but is scheduled to close in 2031.
Troops will relocate to Wales and the site has been earmarked for development under the district council's local plan for the next 20 years as part of efforts to build 16,500 homes in total.
Breckland District Council were contacted by the Mail for a comment.
But speaking at the May 15 general purposes meeting, district councillors said Swanton Morley's proposal had been put forward 'prematurely'.
Conservative member Mark Kiddle-Morris commented: 'Once there is a planning application, then it would be appropriate to consider this. But we are not quite there yet.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
35 minutes ago
- Times
Business live: UK economy shrinks 0.3% in April
Pepco has sold Poundland to the investment firm Gordon Brothers for a 'nominal' sum. The discount chain was put up for sale in March by Pepco, the Warsaw-listed company behind the Poundland and Dealz brands, after sales slowed in what Pepco said was an 'increasingly challenging UK retail landscape'. Gordon Brothers, the former owner of Laura Ashley, had been frontrunners to take control of the retailer. Poundland currently employs around 16,000 staff across over 800 stores across the UK, Isle of Man and Ireland. All stores, colleagues, assets and liabilities of the Poundland business will to Gordon Brothers. Pepco expects to obtain a minority investment interest in the chain, 'subject to the proposed restructuring of Poundland being sanctioned by the High Court in England'. The economy still grew by 0.7 per cent on a rolling three-month measure despite the contraction in April, Mehreen Khan, Economics Editor, writes. This was in line with projections. The ONS said the dominant services sector, which accounted for around three quarters of total GDP, fell by 0.4 per cent on the month, driving the underperformance. Output in production, which included manufacturing, contracted by 0.6 per cent, while the smaller construction industry was the best-performing part of the economy, recording growth of 0.9 per cent. Companies cited the economic uncertainty generated by US tariffs, announced on April 2, and the impact of the rise in payroll taxes at the beginning of the month, the ONS said. Please enable cookies and other technologies to view this content. You can update your cookies preferences any time using privacy manager. The chancellor has started a 'war on the private sector', Kemi Badenoch has said. The Conservative leader said that businesses are having to downsize because of Rachel Reeves's policies, such as the national insurance increase. Badenoch refused to commit to reversing the hike, saying that she 'would not have made the mistake in the first place'. 'Uncertainty about tariffs' had contributed to a fall in GDP in April, the month President Trump announced sweeping levies on imports to the United States, Rachel Reeves has said. 'We know that April was a challenging month', the chancellor said. 'There was a huge uncertainty about tariffs, and one of the things if you dig into those GDP numbers today is exports weakening and also production weakening because of that uncertainty in the world around tariffs.' She added that the figures for April were 'disappointing but also perhaps not entirely unexpected, given the uncertainty that is out there in the world at the moment'. A senior adviser at Oxford Economics has said the economy is likely to stay 'sluggish' for the rest of the year. Michael Saunders, a former member of the Bank of England's monetary policy committee, told the Radio 4 Today programme: 'The level of interest rates is still quite high, monetary policy is still quite tight, global trade uncertainty is high and that's hitting exports from many countries around the world and the government is tightening fiscal policy. 'Public spending is going up but taxes are going up even more, so the net effect is to reduce demand, and you can see that reflected — that vacancies are falling, job growth is slowing and unemployment is rising. 'The chancellor said the UK was the fastest growing economy in the quarter among the G7 but I don't think that's going to be the case for the year as a whole.' Yael Selfin, chief economist at KPMG: 'The UK economy lost steam in April amidst global trade disruptions. While the recently announced trade deals offer businesses a degree of policy certainty, tariffs on UK exports to the US are higher than their pre-April levels. This is expected to act as a headwind for UK trade in the medium term.' Paul Dales, chief UK economist at Capital Economics: 'This won't prompt the Bank of England to cut interest rates next Thursday. But it is one more piece of news pointing to another cut in August.' Rachel Reeves did not rule out further tax rises, despite previously saying there would be no more increases to income tax, VAT or national insurance during this parliament. 'We've drawn a line under the mismanagement from the previous governments,' the chancellor said. She said her actions in the budget were 'necessary' and all the additional spending set out in the review had been costed. 'This government is not increasing taxes on working people,' Reeves said. The chancellor conceded that 'not everybody in all parts of the country is feeling' the effects of growth, but said her budget measures were beginning to have an impact. Referring to the increase in the minimum wage, Rachel Reeves told Sky News: 'Putting more money in the pockets of the poorest is beginning to be felt.' Rachel Reeves admitted the GDP figures were 'clearly disappointing' but insisted her spending review would help deliver growth. 'Our number one mission is delivering growth to put more money in people's pockets through our Plan for Change and while these numbers are clearly disappointing, I'm determined to deliver on that mission,' she said. 'In yesterday's spending review we set out how we'll deliver jobs and growth, whether that's improving city region transport, a record investment in affordable homes or funding Sizewell C nuclear power station. We're investing in Britain's renewal to make working people better off.' The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has fined the firm £1.25 million following an investigation of its audit of Carr's Group 2021 accounts. KPMG partner Nick Plumb has been fined £70,000, discounted for admissions, early disposal and exceptional cooperation to £38,675. The FRC said that KPMG and Plumb breached ethical standards when it relied on the work of 'Firm X', which audited one of Carr's subsidiaries, despite 'Firm X' providing tax and accountancy services to the subsidiary and having held the audit role for more than five years. Sales at Tesco beat quarterly sales expectations in the UK despite operating in what it called an 'intensely competitive' market, Isabella Fish, Retail Editor, writes. Like-for-like sales at the UK's largest supermarket rose 5.1 per cent to £12.3 billion in the first quarter, driven by its Aldi price match scheme and Clubcard deals. Analysts had forecast sales growth of around 4.6 per cent in its UK division. The grocer maintained its profit guidance. Ken Murphy, chief executive, said the company continued to see market share gains in UK, adding that the market 'remains intensely competitive'. In April, he warned of a mounting price war among UK supermarkets, forcing the country's largest grocer to double down on cost cuts and lower its profit forecast for the year. UK economic growth slowed sharply at the start of the second quarter. Month-on-month gross domestic product (GDP) shrank 0.3 per cent in April, data from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) showed. City economists had expected the economy to contract by 0.1 per cent. Liz McKeown, ONS director of economic statistics, said: 'The economy contracted in April, with services and manufacturing both falling. However, over the last three months as a whole, GDP still grew, with signs that some activity may have been brought forward from April to earlier in the year.' The loss of momentum was expected after the economy was boosted in the first three months of the year by front-running of exports to the US ahead of President Trump's 'Liberation day' trade tariffs on April 2. The FTSE 100 is set to open down more than 35 points after a fresh tariff salvo from President Trump and rising tensions in the Middle East offset hopes of a US-China trade truce. Ahead of his July 8 deadline on tariffs, Trump said he would send out letters outlining the terms of trade to dozens of countries, which they could embrace or reject. Trump also said the US was moving staff out of the Middle East, which could be a 'dangerous place', ahead of talks with Iran over its nuclear activity. Tokyo's Nikkei 225 was down 0.6 per cent, Hong Kong's Hang Seng fell 0.7 per cent and China's SSE Composite was flat. The dollar weakened, and the gold price rose. • Wall Street cautiously welcomed President Trump's declaration of a 'done' deal between the United States and China over raw materials exports after two days of negotiations in London.• Gold overtook the euro to become the second-largest global reserve asset after the dollar last year, according to the European Central Bank, amid rising geopolitical risks and concerns around sanctions.• US private equity group KKR has moved ahead again in the race to own hundreds of doctors' surgeries after increasing its offer for Assura, the NHS landlord, to £1.7 billion.• WSP Global, one of the world's largest consultancy firms, has agreed to buy Ricardo, a smaller London-listed engineering consultancy, for £281 million, delivering a windfall for an activist shareholder that had been seeking to oust the chairman.• Hybrid working has become a 'new normal' for white-collar professionals, but the ability to split time between work and the office is not being enjoyed equally. Younger and older workers and those who live in deprived areas are less likely to do so, the Office for National Statistics has found.• WPP, the UK's largest advertising group, has suffered a new blow after losing a $1.7 billion global media planning and buying contract for Mars to Publicis, its French rival.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Economy shrinks by more than expected amid record fall in exports to the US
The economy saw the biggest monthly contraction for a year-and-a-half in April as manufacturing activity pulled back sharply amid a record drop in exports to the US following President Donald Trump's tariff hikes. Official figures showed gross domestic product (GDP) fell by 0.3% in April, compared with growth of 0.2% the previous month, and marking the biggest contraction since October 2023. It was also worse than the 0.1% contraction expected by most economists. The Office for National Statistics (ONS) said output in Britain's manufacturing sector dropped by 0.6% in April, having surged earlier in the year as US importers stocked up ahead of Mr Trump's tariff rises, which came into effect at the start of April. Exports to America fell at the fastest pace on record, down £2 billion in April – led by machinery and transport, including cars, according to separate trade figures from the ONS on Thursday. ONS director of economic statistics Liz McKeown said: 'After increasing for each of the four preceding months, April saw the largest monthly fall on record in goods exports to the US with decreases seen across most types of goods, following the recent introduction of tariffs.' The wider economy also shrank as the all-important services sector saw activity fall by by 0.4% in April. The ONS said this was largely pulled lower by a drop off in demand in the housing market following the rush to complete property deals ahead of the stamp duty change from April 1. Chancellor Rachel Reeves acknowledged that the latest GDP figures were 'clearly disappointing', but insisted her spending review would help deliver growth. She said: 'Our number one mission is delivering growth to put more money in people's pockets through our plan for change, and while these numbers are clearly disappointing, I'm determined to deliver on that mission.' The fall in GDP also comes after soaring wage cost pressures from April, with the increase in national insurance contributions (NICs) and the minimum wage both taking effect at the start of the month, which has hit the service sector particularly hard. Ms McKeown said declining output in services and manufacturing sectors both dragged on overall GDP in April. 'However, over the last three months as a whole GDP still grew, with signs that some activity may have been brought forward from April to earlier in the year,' she said. She added: 'Both legal and real estate firms fared badly in April, following a sharp increase in house sales in March when buyers rushed to complete purchases ahead of changes to stamp duty. 'Car manufacturing also performed poorly after growing in the first quarter of the year.'
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Rachel Reeves defends spending review as she admits latest growth figures ‘disappointing'
Update: Date: 2025-06-12T07:09:40.000Z Title: Rachel Reeves gives interviews after delivering spending review on Wednesday Content: Good morning. Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, got a good reception from MPs when she addressed them yesterday after delivering her spending review. But she cannot avoid questions about whether taxes might have to rise in the autumn, and growth figures for April out this morning undermine the claim that the economy is turning round. Reeves is giving interviews this morning. Commenting on the growth figures, she said they were 'clearly disappointing'. Our number one mission is delivering growth to put more money in people's pockets through our Plan for Change, and while these numbers are clearly disappointing, I'm determined to deliver on that mission. In yesterday's spending review we set out how we'll deliver jobs and growth – whether that's improving city region transport, a record investment in affordable homes or funding Sizewell C nuclear power station. We're investing in Britain's renewal to make working people better off. Here is the agenda for the day. Morning: Rachel Reeves, the chancellor, is doing a morning interview round. She is on the Today programme at 8.10am. 9am: The Resolution Foundation publishes its spending review analaysis. 10.30am: The Institute for Fiscal Studies publishes its spending review analysis. 10.50am: Kemi Badenoch gives a speech at the Peel Hunt FTSE250 conference in London. 11.30am: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing. Noon: John Swinney, Scotland's first minister, takes questions from MSPs. 1pm: Wes Streeting, the health secretary, gives a speech at the NHS Confederation conference in Manchester. If you want to contact me, please post a message below the line when comments are open (normally between 10am and 3pm at the moment), or message me on social media. I can't read all the messages BTL, but if you put 'Andrew' in a message aimed at me, I am more likely to see it because I search for posts containing that word. If you want to flag something up urgently, it is best to use social media. You can reach me on Bluesky at @ The Guardian has given up posting from its official accounts on X, but individual Guardian journalists are there, I still have my account, and if you message me there at @AndrewSparrow, I will see it and respond if necessary. I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos. No error is too small to correct. And I find your questions very interesting too. I can't promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog.
