‘Heightened Scrutiny' Review: A Transgender Attorney Heads to the Supreme Court in an Emotional and Informative Doc
The visual approach in 'Heightened Scrutiny' — Sam Feder's documentary following a transgender lawyer prepping for a U.S. Supreme Court case — seems familiar at the outset. Its straightforward approach to locked-off sit-down interviews, interspersed with graphics and other B-roll footage, is hardly novel. However, an immense amount of care and detail goes into its construction, deepening its use of traditional form and packing a powerful punch.
'Heightened Scrutiny' follows ACLU attorney Chase Strangio, as he prepares to become the first transgender person to make arguments before the Supreme Court. However, this superlative — while it's certainly compared to other civil rights landmarks — is but a fleeting detail in the face of how vital the case in question might be. United States v. Skrmetti is, at the time of the film's Sundance premiere, still ongoing, and is set to determine whether Tennessee banning hormone therapy and puberty blockers for transgender youth violates the Fourteenth Amendment's Equal Protection Clause.
More from Variety
Marlee Matlin Says Hollywood Hasn't Changed Since 'CODA,' but That Won't Stop Her From Creating Her Own Projects: 'I'm Still Knocking on Doors'
'Wedding Banquet' Trailer: Bowen Yang, Lily Gladstone Plan a Sham Wedding in Remake of Ang Lee's Queer Rom-Com Classic
Why Isaac Mizrahi Both Cringes and Feels 'Weirdly Empowered' by the Re-Release of 'Unzipped' for Its 30th Anniversary at Sundance
For those unaware of the particulars, Strangio makes persuasive arguments to the camera. But 'Heightened Scrutiny' isn't just concerned with specific legalese. Feder seems aware that what determines such a ruling is much larger than constitutional language, and he therefore takes aim at the media building blocks of anti-transgender prejudice — the way Feder's previous work, 'Disclosure,' examined trans films in Hollywood — and the way news stories inform lawmaking. The film, in this way, takes on an occasionally essayistic form, as it holds major news organizations like The New York Times and The Atlantic accountable in jaw-dropping, thorough detail.
Its arguments are as academic as they are emotional. Strangio is joined by a number of trans activists — including famous faces like Elliot Page, and an outspoken 12-year-old named Mila — in not only expounding upon daily prejudices and hypocrisies of anti-trans alarmism, but also daily mundanities. In capturing Mila's family dinners, and in following Strangio home, watching him pick out outfits, and fawn over his cat, the movie's key persuasion becomes the everyday relatability of its subjects.
What separates 'Heightened Scrutiny' from similarly straightforward works is that it takes its time. Despite its slim 89-minute runtime, it feels entirely rigorous in its unraveling of personal and practical information. You could throw a penny blindfolded and have it land on a documentary that employs fleeting expert testimonials; where Feder's movie stands apart is that none of its interviewees are mere talking heads — whether lawyers, journalists, parents of trans children, or celebrities like Peppermint and Laverne Cox. No single subject is used merely to add color. Rather, they become full-fledged, fully-formed characters in and of themselves, whose inner lives are the focus as much as their expertise.
Furthermore, the film never separates these facets of their experience; their emotional connection to the case is paramount. As if in stern rebuke to the 'just asking questions' crowd, who reduce people's real lives to intellectual exercises, 'Heightened Scrutiny' interweaves thought and feeling simultaneously. Strangio may be the movie's anchor, but as much as he builds legal arguments, his sense of camaraderie with the film's other trans subjects widens the scope of what's at stake for trans lives, and for America as a whole, in the years to come. Beyond all the legal and even medical specifics resides a sense of communal understanding, and — at the risk of sounding mawkish — a deep and abiding love for one's fellow human beings, which Feder taps into with aplomb.
Best of Variety
The Best Albums of the Decade
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Tense scene at Weinstein trial as alleged perv appears to have medical episode after accuser's defiant gesture
Harvey Weinstein's Manhattan sex crimes retrial took a dramatic turn Tuesday when the accused serial perv apparently suffered a medical episode — sparking a frenzy of court officers to tend to him. The bizarre moment came after a former actress who accused Weinstein, 73, of raping her defiantly stared down the disgraced Hollywood producer after leaving the witness stand and pointed a finger at her eye, demanding that he look at her. The startling 'look at me' gesture by Jessica Mann, 38, prompted Weinstein's high-powered defense attorney Arthur Aidala to argue for a mistrial to Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Curtis Farber. As Aidala contended that the trial should be tossed, Weinstein bizarrely made gurgling sounds — and two court officers quickly surrounded him. The wheelchair-bound Weinstein took a sip of water, bringing the brief episode to an end. Asked later if Weinstein had a medical episode, Aidala told The Post that the Miramax founder's already-poor health has been getting worse. 'The short answer is yes, but it was alleviated,' the attorney said. 'He's not doing well. The last two weeks there has been a marked difference in his physical appearance and his stamina. I don't know if its the cancer kicking in, but he's definitely suffering.' Mann's daring gesture came after she wrenchingly detailed to jurors, between sobs, an alleged rape by Weinstein at a Beverly Hills hotel. But the convicted sex pest could only shake his head in response, before he descended into gurgling. 'That's absolutely inappropriate behavior by her,' Aidala wailed to the judge. Prosecutors argued Mann's reaction didn't even come close to grounds for a mistrial — and Farber agreed, denying Aidala's bid. Mann later returned to the stand and continued to recount the alleged California hotel rape, which took place around the beginning of 2014, recounting for jurors how she had taken an hours-long shower afterward. 'I'm going to bury this so deep and I'm going to forget about this and move on with my life,' she said she told herself. Mann testified that she decided to 'keep going' to pursue her Hollywood dreams – and continued to have contact with the powerful Weinstein, which led to a consensual sexual relationship. She recounted that she faked orgasms to end uncomfortable sexual encounters with Weinstein. 'I'm not saying I performed her performance but I made noises,' she said, comparing her fake orgasms to that of Meg Ryan's character in an infamous scene from the 1989 romantic comedy 'When Harry Met Sally.' 'It was definitely not the best I ever had,' she added when Aidala asked if it was a lie. Mann's first day of testimony Monday saw her tearfully detail another alleged rape by Weinstein in a Midtown hotel. She testified that after the attack, she found an erection-inducing drug needle apparently used by Weinstein in a hotel room's garbage can with a puzzling label. 'I found on Google that it basically meant 'dead penis,' and you inject it and it can only be used a certain amount of times back to back over a certain time,' she told jurors. Weinstein is only charged in the Midtown alleged rape. He has pleaded not guilty to charges in his sex crimes retrial. Weinstein in 2022 was found guilty of one count of rape and two counts of sexual assault at a Los Angeles trial. He has appealed the conviction.
San Francisco Chronicle
15 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Today in History: June 20, Muhammad Ali convicted of draft evasion
Today is Friday, June 20, the 171st day of 2025. There are 194 days left in the year. Summer begins today. Today in history: On June 20, 1967, boxer Muhammad Ali was convicted in Houston of violating Selective Service laws by refusing to be drafted and was sentenced to five years in prison. (Ali's conviction would ultimately be overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court). Also on this date: In 1782, the Continental Congress approved the Great Seal of the United States, featuring the emblem of the bald eagle. In 1837, Queen Victoria acceded to the British throne following the death of her uncle, King William IV. In 1893, a jury in New Bedford, Massachusetts, found Lizzie Borden not guilty of the ax murders of her father and stepmother. In 1943, race-related rioting erupted in Detroit; federal troops were sent in by President Franklin D. Roosevelt to quell the violence that resulted in more than 30 deaths. In 1947, gangster Benjamin 'Bugsy' Siegel was shot dead at the Beverly Hills, California, home of his girlfriend, Virginia Hill, likely at the order of mob associates. In 1972, three days after the arrest of the Watergate burglars, President Richard Nixon met at the White House with his chief of staff, H.R. Haldeman; the secretly made tape recording of this meeting ended up with a notorious 18 1/2-minute gap. In 2002, in the case Atkins v. Virginia, the Supreme Court ruled in a 6-3 decision that executing people with intellectual disabilities qualified as cruel and unusual punishment and was therefore in violation of the Eight Amendment. Today's Birthdays: Filmmaker Stephen Frears is 84. Musician-songwriter Brian Wilson is 83. Singer Anne Murray is 80. TV personality Bob Vila is 79. Musician Lionel Richie is 76. Actor John Goodman is 73. Rock bassist Michael Anthony (Van Halen) is 71. Rock bassist John Taylor (Duran Duran) is 65. Actor Nicole Kidman is 58. Filmmaker Robert Rodriguez is 57. Actor Josh Lucas is 54. Sen. Eric Schmitt, R-Mo., is 50. Actor Christopher Mintz-Plasse is 36.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Jane Rosenthal Champions Female and Nonbinary Filmmakers When the 'Very Act of Us Speaking Up Feels Risky' at Chanel Tribeca Festival Luncheon
When actress Mira Sorvino thinks about what and who helped her launch her career, she credits Tribeca Festival co-founder Jane Rosenthal for giving her that break. 'Jane Rosenthal actually gave me my first job in the industry. It started off being a volunteer position — I was an intern at Tribeca Productions, reading scripts. Then it turned into a paid position as a reader after they ended up liking my coverage. I did that for two years, and during that time I actually read the script Amongst Friends that ended up being the first feature that I ever starred in. We went to Sundance and that launched my career,' the actress recalled. 'Tribeca helped me start my career, and it's always given a hand up to young artists and people who had the gumption to just go for it.' More from The Hollywood Reporter Miley Cyrus Talks Growing Past 'Hannah Montana' and Hiding Her Drug Purchases From Accountant 'American Psycho' Director Mary Harron Is Surprised by Movie's Lingering Relevance What Sold Gerard Butler on Reprising His Role in the Live-Action 'How to Train Your Dragon' So supporting the 10th anniversary of the Through Her Lens — a women and nonbinary filmmaker-focused program — as part of the exclusive Chanel Tribeca Festival Women's Luncheon at The Greenwich Hotel Courtyard on Friday was an easy yes. Particularly, says Sorvino, in a moment where artists' freedom of speech and expression are under attack. 'They are creating a circle here where people are very focused on humanity and intersectionality and opposing opinions, but like a dialectic where truth can arise that's greater than the sum of its parts, with connection and recognition of one and the other,' she told The Hollywood Reporter on the carpet ahead of the event. 'It's standing here as a beacon of honesty and artistic expression in a time where all of those things are under attack.' Inside the hotel in a packed room, Rosenthal acknowledged the importance of being vocal and openly supportive of artists and the communities' work in the current cultural moment. 'The very act of us speaking up feels risky,' the Tribeca co-founder told the group. 'This program reminds us that our voices matter, that storytelling is activism, and that art is a form of existence. A person whose words comfort me in these times are Toni Morrison, and she writes about how she would guide us into this objective and this chaos. She says this is precisely the time when art is going to work — not when everything is fine, but in times of dread.' 'There is no time to despair. No place for self-pity. We speak, we write, we do language. That is how civilizations heal,' she continued. 'So, thank you for what you're doing, for every script that you write, every scene, every story. Thank you for your work, your fire, your voices. And thank you for refusing to wait for permission. Thank you for continuing to lift one another up.' Using your voice and continuing to do the creative work despite timely challenges was a theme of the event conversation. In terms of directly navigating the industry, Wonder Woman and Monster director Patty Jenkins told THR on the luncheon's carpet that 'the struggle is real and it's very alive right now' for women and nonbinary filmmakers. However, evidence is still there that diverse storytelling matters. 'The truth is there's already all the evidence showing that the world is craving diverse stories and that everybody's universal. But the old system of Hollywood, which is crumbling, has still not moved on, so there's a collision,' she explained. 'The thing I want to say to inspire people is that the indie film world is really starting to explode right now, and with the studio system really falling apart, it's an opportunity. But we do all have to fight to get our stories told, to prove that they can make money and to prove that there's an audience for them. But it's an exciting moment as much as it's been so frustrating.' While speaking to luncheon guests, Jenkins later added that creatives should consider this opportunity and bring in their community to do it. 'We have our own money. We have our own producers. We have our own skills. We actually also need to really embrace coming together and not asking for permission or partnership under the old system,' she said. 'It's why I love coming in this room. So grateful to Chanel and Tribeca for doing it. It gives a forum for having these conversations.' Rosenthal, Sorvino and Jenkins were in attendance at the Tribeca and Chanel event alongside Chanel ambassadors Riley Keogh and Whitney Peak, as well as guests Lucy Liu, Olivia Munn, Parker Posey, Miley Cyrus, Carrie Coon, Beanie Feldstein, Nia DaCosta, Mariska Hargitay, Zosia Mamet, Annie Murphy, Ilana Glazer, Jurnee Smollett, Francesca Scorsese and Rachel Hilson. In addition to discussing how women and nonbinary artists can navigate the current moment, they all eagerly celebrated the mentorship program, which offers emerging U.S.-based creatives industry support, artistic development and funding. 'It's really a special one, this event, because it's women and nonbinary people coming together looking gorgeous, obviously, in Chanel, but having really profound, meaningful conversations. It's rare for everyone to be in one room. It's rare to all gather in such a specific way,' Feldstein said. 'I was so lucky to be on the jury last time they did it in the fall, and to hear all of these people pour their creativity into the room and present to us with open hearts, open minds — so receptive to questions and feedback — the artistry was on another level and inspired all of us.' 'This is such a resonant lunch to me because it's about nurturing other people, and just by doing that and following our truth, we can inspire people,' said Hargitay, whose new doc My Mom Jayne premieres on HBO Max on June 27 and is screening at Tribeca. 'What we all want personally and professionally is community. That is where our power goes. So, however, we do that on a scale from one person, if you're supporting one person or a million, it's the same.' While the program itself focuses on providing mentorship of emerging talent, many of the attendees acknowledged the myriad of ways it can be meaningful, even as women and nonbinary creatives advance in their careers. 'It's super important and it's not just mentorship from people who are way above you in their careers, it's also your peers. I've had so much support from my peer female filmmakers,' DaCosta told THR. 'Being able to call people and ask for advice and just commiserate or just be joyful together — all of that's as important as talking about the craft and business.' 'To me, mentorship doesn't even have to be someone on your same level. It can be someone who's maybe not even at your level yet but thinks in a way that helps crack you open and guide you further on your path,' Mamet said. 'I think when you choose an artistic lifestyle, it can be incredibly difficult and there are many dark nights of the soul. It's not a linear path. So, I think community and support are just so important, and I think that is the essence of mentorship. Wherever you can find that, I don't think it has to look like someone who's older or necessarily more experienced. I think it's just actually finding those people to help and, of course, and keep you going.' The luncheon was the first of a two-part event spotlighting and connecting visionary creatives. Later in the day, 'Through Her Lens Conversation: In Process with Riley Keough & Gina Gammell' saw Keough debut her latest project. 'I was actually inspired by this event, Through Her Lens and Tribeca. We made three little short clips that are exploring different women's creative process,' Keough explained. 'We did one talk with myself and then with an actor and one with a director and an actor. Selfishly, I wanted to watch other females work.' For White Lotus star Coon, connecting to other women and engaging about and beyond their creative process is one of the reasons she attended the event. 'Anytime I meet these women, I am putting them in my phone and I'm ready to make that phone call now,' the actress said. 'I think anytime you have women in a room, it's possible that something very powerful will happen, but history has separated us. So the more events like this we have, the more probability there is that we will save not only creative industries but maybe the whole world.' Best of The Hollywood Reporter Seeing Double? 25 Pairs of Celebrities Who Look Nearly Identical From 'Lady in the Lake' to 'It Ends With Us': 29 New and Upcoming Book Adaptations in 2024 Meet the Superstars Who Glam Up Hollywood's A-List
