Architect of So-called Generals' Plan: 'Israel Failed Miserably in Gaza War'
The architect of the Israeli so-called Generals' Plan retired General Giora Eiland said the Zionist entity 'failed miserably in the Gaza war.'
The Israeli newspaper Maariv has quoted the retired general and the former head of the so-called Israeli National Security Council as saying that 'Israel' failed in Gaza.
Eiland, who masterminded the controversial plan for displacing Palestinians from northern Gaza, argued that the Israeli defeat can be assessed by examining which side achieved its objectives and imposed its will.
He pointed to the recent developments in Gaza, stating, 'Look at the agreement—Israel opened the Rafah crossing and withdrew from the Netzarim axis, while thousands of Palestinians returned to the north.'
Eiland noted that 'Hamas can dictate to us in phase two an agreement.' Although admitting the importance of recovering Israeli detainees currently held in Gaza, he said that Israel 'will also pay with the mass release of hundreds of prisoners.'
In his remarks, Eiland advocated for the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians, stating that 'if you occupy the Strip and the civilians remain, Hamas will remain too. Apart from receiving terrible attacks against the occupying force, you will not gain anything.'
Earlier in a comment piece for Ynet, described the Israeli war on Gaza as an 'absolute failure'.
'Israel has failed in three-and-a-half out of the four goals of the war: we have not demolished Hamas' military power; we have not overthrown Hamas' rule; we are not managing to return the residents… safely to their homes [in settlements], and as for the return of the abductees, the fourth goal – we have partially succeeded,' he wrote.
He said Hamas had, conversely, 'achieved all of its goals, chief among them: continuing its rule in Gaza.'
Former Israeli national security adviser Giora Eiland describes the recent war in Gaza as 'a resounding failure' for Israel, acknowledging that Hamas has not only prevented Israel from achieving its goals but has also secured its own pic.twitter.com/e3He19U4bc
— Middle East Eye (@MiddleEastEye) January 19, 2025
The Generals' Plan was published in late September 2024 by the Forum of Commanders and Soldiers in the Reserves, an Israeli NGO that defines itself as a professional body comprising more than 1,500 army officers.
At its simplest, this plan involves ethnically cleansing the northern Gaza Strip of people; and then besieging the region, including stopping the entry of humanitarian supplies, to starve out anyone left, including Palestinian fighters.
The original plan, also known as the Eiland Plan after its creator, was seen by Palestinians and rights groups as part of a long-term project of ethnic cleansing that would result in the reestablishment of Zionist settlements in Gaza.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
MTV Lebanon
6 hours ago
- MTV Lebanon
03 Jun 2025 14:12 PM At least 27 Palestinians killed while waiting for aid distribution
Local health authorities in Gaza said on Tuesday that at least 27 Palestinians were killed by Israeli fire while waiting for aid distribution near Rafah. The Israeli military said on Tuesday it fired shots at individuals about half a kilometre from the aid distribution site of US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation in the Gaza Strip. The individuals were moving towards forces in a way that "posed a threat to them", the military said. It said its forces do not prevent Gaza residents from reaching aid despite multiple reports of deadly attacks by Israeli forces near the US centre in recent days. The United Nations human rights office said on Tuesday the impediment of access to food and relief for civilians in Gaza may constitute a war crime. "Attacks directed against civilians constitute a grave breach of international law, and a war crime," The head of the UN agency, Volker Turk, said in a statement. The UN has called for an independent investigation into killings of Palestinians near the US-backed aid centre in south Gaza. In northern Gaza, three Israeli soldiers were killed the Israeli military said Tuesday, in what appears to be the deadliest attack on Israel's forces since it ended a ceasefire with Hamas in March. The military said the three soldiers, all in their early 20s, fell during combat in northern Gaza on Monday, without providing details. Israeli media reported that they were killed in an explosion in the Jabaliya area. The soldiers' deaths were announced hours after Hamas' armed wing said on Monday its fighters were engaging in "fierce clashes" with Israeli forces in the north of the territory. Israel ended the ceasefire in March after Hamas refused to change the agreement to release more hostages sooner. Israeli strikes have killed thousands of Palestinians since then, according to Gaza's health ministry. Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and took 251 people hostage in the October 7, 2023, attack into Israel that ignited the war. They are still holding 58 hostages, a third of them believed to be alive, after most of the rest were released in ceasefire agreements or other deals. Israel's military campaign has killed over 54,000 Palestinians, mostly women and children, according to the Gaza health ministry, which does not say how many of the dead were civilians or combatants. Israel says it has killed around 20,000 militants, without providing evidence. Around 860 Israeli soldiers have been killed since the October 7 attack, including more than 400 during the fighting inside Gaza.
Al Manar
8 hours ago
- Al Manar
Iranian FM Visits Martyr Sayyed Nasrallah Shrine: Resistance in Lebanon Will Become Stronger
The Iranian foreign minister Abbas Araghchi, who is on an official visit to Lebanon, affirmed that the Resistance in Lebanon will become stronger, adding that the martyrdom of the leader Sayyed Hasan Nasrallah crowns his heroic journey of Arab and Islamic struggle against the Zionist enemy. Visiting Sayyed Nasrallah Shrine, Araghchi highlighted the influence of the martyr's character and underlined that the Lebanese people and resistance will certainly reach the ultimate victory against the Israeli occupation. Signing his new book 'The Power of Negotiation' in Beirut, Araqchi made several remarks pertaining to the nuclear file. Araqchi indicated that the US-Iranian talks may reach an agreement on the nuclear file, adding that the uranium enrichment is a red line. The Iranian foreign minister also responded to Trump's remarks, stressing that Iran does not take the permission from anyone to enrich uranium. Were the US capable of striking the nuclear facilities in Iran, it would not engage in a negotiation process, Araqchi maintained, highlighting the Iranian military power in this regard.
Nahar Net
8 hours ago
- Nahar Net
Lebanon wants 'state-to-state' relation with Iran, Aoun tells Araghchi
by Naharnet Newsdesk 5 hours President Joseph Aoun on Tuesday told visiting Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi that 'Lebanon is looking forward to enhancing state-to-state relations with Iran.' 'Domestic dialogue is the gateway for resolving all the disputed issues, as well as dialogue between nations, away from violence,' Aoun added. 'Reconstructing what was destroyed by the Israeli war on Lebanon is among the priorities we're working on with the government, in cooperation with the brotherly and friendly countries and according to the applicable laws,' the president said. Araghchi for his part expressed his country's support for 'Lebanon's independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity, as well as for the efforts it is exerting to end Israeli occupation.' 'Iran's support for Lebanon falls under the good ties between the two countries and the principle of noninterference in domestic affairs,' Araghchi added. He also voiced Iran's support for 'national dialogue in Lebanon between the various sects, groups and orientations.' Araghchi's visit comes after Iran's main Lebanese ally, Hezbollah, was weakened by a 14-month war with Israel that left much of the Iran-backed group's political and military leadership dead. Araghchi's visit is his first since October, which came at the height of the Israel-Hezbollah war that ended a month later with a U.S.-brokered ceasefire. The war killed more than 4,000 in Lebanon, displaced over 1 million people and caused destruction that the World Bank said will coast $11 billion in reconstruction. Since the war ended, army commander Joseph Aoun was elected president and prominent jurist and diplomat Nawaf Salam became the country's prime minister. Both Aoun and Salam have repeatedly said that only the state will monopolize the use of weapons in Lebanon. The visit also comes after the government of Syrian President Bashar Assad was removed from power in December by insurgent groups opposed to Iran's influence in the region. Assad was one of Tehran's closest allies in the Arab world and his country was a main link for the flow of weapons from Iran to Hezbollah. Over the past decades, Iran funded Hezbollah with billions of dollars and sent all types of weapons to the Lebanese group enjoying wide influence in the small nation through. Since the Israel-Hezbollah war ended, Lebanese authorities have taken tight measures at Beirut's airport to prevent the flow of funds from Iran to Hezbollah and flights by Iranian companies have been suspended to Beirut.
