
The road too often travelled
Opinion
You have twenty minutes or less. Pack a small bag, but hurry! You (and your family) must run, in order to live. Go! Now!
Whether it is wildfire or war, a natural disaster or one created and fuelled by people, this is the reality for millions of people every year. The lucky ones escape, but with little (or nothing) more than their lives.
June 20 is World Refugee Day. Given the thousands of people evacuated from the north already this year, more Manitobans than ever will understand what it feels like to be a refugee.
The Canadian Press
Sudanese refugees arrive in Acre, Chad on Oct 6, 2024. Canadians can count themselves lucky that they're rarely thrown from their homes, and even then, not often for long.
People become refugees by circumstance, rarely (if ever) by choice. They want to stay in their homes, in their communities, with their families and friends. But something happens, often suddenly, and they have to flee from wherever they live to somewhere less dangerous.
Notice that I did not say 'safe.' Too many refugees flee from one disaster to another, until finally they literally have nowhere else to go, and are trapped there.
Our own refugees are considered 'internally displaced,' unlike those who are forced to flee from their country. Once you cross that international border, you are totally dependent on the charity of others, however — and in a foreign land.
Notice that I said charity, not generosity. Our own climate refugees (which is what they are) were cared for by the government, the Red Cross, by the communities that welcomed them and the volunteers who showed up with donations and offered to help. But that is rarely the situation elsewhere; here, we are wealthier, have fewer refugees, and many of our 21,000 refugees will soon be able to go home. Literally, we can afford to give more, but those in Manitoba trying to survive on (eventually) $34 a day might challenge whether this amounts to 'generosity.'
It seems impossible, however, to scale up even this level of support to meet the current need in other places. Uganda hosts 1.8 million refugees; though Kenya hosts less than a million, camps like the Dadaab complex have become commercial hubs, not just temporary homes, with some families living there for three or four generations. In total numbers, Turkey leads the global list, with 3.6 million refugees.
Or consider Sudan, where 16 million people are internally displaced, and 4.1 million more have fled abroad. There is civil war in Sudan, making the government half the problem, and none of the solution. There are few resources, and those bringing aid in from outside have become targets. Neighbouring countries (like South Sudan) are so desperately poor themselves they have little to offer the refugees who arrive. Worse, crucial food and medical aid are vulnerable to politics elsewhere, like the cuts to USAID driven by MAGA ideology. Can there be a worse situation than famine in the midst of genocide? Where the UN is powerless and the African Union is hopeless?
The theme for this year's World Refugee Day is 'community as a superpower.' But when your own community is scattered to the four winds, when you flee with little and have nowhere to go, you must depend on the charity of strangers to survive.
From this grim and increasingly common scenario, I want to go back to that moment people find out they have to flee, transformed in a few minutes from citizens into refugees.
Only someone who has gone through the same experience themselves can really understand how it feels. If you can take anything with you at all, what will it be?
That moment offers terrifying clarity about what, in your life and the lives of your family, matters most. It might be documents, to cross borders; necessary medications; whatever money or valuables you can carry. Perhaps a change of clothes. Pets are left behind.
In other words, all those important things in your life, that you couldn't possibly even consider giving up for any reason, are suddenly abandoned, as you flee for your life.
Unless you started the fire (or the war), it is not your fault that you are a refugee. You want no more for yourself and your family than what you had before — what other people in this new place still enjoy.
Wednesdays
Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture.
The future you thought you knew has vanished, perhaps forever. Starting now with nothing, in a strange place where you wonder if these strangers will help or care, is overwhelming.
In the news, or on the streets, you witness angry voices talking about 'closing the borders,' about sending 'those' people 'back where they came from,' about regarding refugees as a threat. Shamefully, these may even be your own words from your life before.
The real superpower of community is compassion, love that emerges from understanding our shared humanity.
If you need a further reason to be generous with your compassion and support, consider that — somewhere, some day — you and your own family might yourselves suddenly need to depend on the generosity of a community of strangers.
Peter Denton writes from his home in rural Manitoba.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Toronto Star
an hour ago
- Toronto Star
Why your crass bumper sticker can snowball into something darker
Over the weekend, I was travelling around doing my normal errands when someone in a pickup truck turned in front of me. On the bumper was a sticker that read 'F*ck Carney.' Really? Mark Carney was just elected prime minister not even two months ago and we already have nasty bumper stickers? I was used to the F*ck Trudeau paraphernalia. I didn't like it — I think there are other ways to let my community know I'm unhappy with our politicians — but I understood people were angry with former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. We had been through a lot with his government and many were ready for him to go. ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Trudeau had been in office for almost a decade. The Carney government is still fresh and hasn't had a chance to really upset us. So, what's the issue? Why are you so vexed that you'd spend your hard-earned money to buy a bumper sticker denigrating the new prime minister who hasn't had time to govern? Could it be that you're just salty that your guy didn't win? We learned back in kindergarten not to be a sore loser. In life, there are always winners and losers and what were we taught? Dust yourself off and try again. You don't curse out the winner and pray for their demise. Because if Carney fails in this political climate, we all lose. Political disagreement isn't new in Canada, but recently, something has changed. It's sharper and more personal. It's not just about policies anymore — it's about identity, tribalism and control. We're not just debating carbon tax or health care; we're questioning the legitimacy of the people who dare to lead, especially if they on the other side. And we're doing it before people have a chance to prove themselves. Trust me, I have my issues with many politicians in this country. When I criticize politicians, I try to focus on policies, not the people. I assume that most politicians, as human beings, are decent people — we just disagree politically. The problem is when political anger turns deadly. This past weekend, in the U.S., a masked gunman disguised as a police officer shot and killed a Minnesota Democratic State Rep. Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark. Democratic State Sen. John Hoffman and his wife, Yvette, were also shot multiple times but are expected to survive. Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz called an 'act of targeted political violence.' ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW Sometimes, as Canadians, we arrogantly say, 'That's an American problem.' Sure, we don't have the history of political violence that the U.S. has, but Canada isn't immune. In 2020, a man carrying multiple firearms drove through the gates of Rideau Hall, reportedly looking to confront then Prime Minister Trudeau. In 2021, a Muslim family in London, Ont., was run down by a man police say was motivated by Islamophobia. In both cases, political rhetoric, online echo chambers and unchecked bigotry helped lay the groundwork. What starts as a crass bumper sticker can snowball into something darker — a culture that believes it's OK to dehumanize the people we disagree with. We are a country of amazing, smart and talented people. Tell me, who's going to volunteer to run for elected office if they are worried about if they'll make it home to their families? I'm all for criticizing politicians with our entire chests. Political dissent is healthy — protest is necessary. But this hatred of 'the other' is not. If you're angry about the direction of the country, stay engaged. Write letters. Organize. Run for office. But don't slap hate on your bumper and pretend that will create the change you want. It's not. It's just ginning up hatred and making your community feel unsafe. Because the moment we start treating the people we disagree with as enemies, the road ahead gets a whole lot darker — and we've already seen where that can lead.


Ottawa Citizen
5 hours ago
- Ottawa Citizen
Gearey: In the federal public service, simple gender parity isn't enough
Recently, I took part in a public service workshop examining hypothetical risks to Canada. Each table of participants was provided a dozen risks that we were asked to rank in order of perceived importance. Article content One potential risk card read something akin to: 'Diminished Male Relevance.' Article content I blinked twice, unsure if I'd read it correctly. Women are still crawling out of the long shadows of exclusion in Canada, still pressing for equity, and we're already anticipating a crisis of male relevance? Article content Article content That moment stayed with me. Perhaps it offered a glimpse into how some people perceive change: as erosion, not evolution. As someone losing versus the creation of a new partnership. Article content What was really on my mind was what's happening south of the border. In the United States, Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) programs in government and elsewhere are being dismantled. Furthermore, a man found liable for sexual assault, ordered to pay more than $83 million in damages, is president. That kind of backslide doesn't stay confined to politics; it seeps into culture, rewiring progress. Article content Canada leads other countries Article content In contrast, Canada's federal public service has something to be proud of. It has surpassed gender parity: women now represent 56.8 per cent of its workforce and 52.5 per cent of its executive roles. We've seen women serve as Clerk of the Privy Council, and also in top defence, foreign affairs and finance roles. The government also mandates Gender-Based Analysis-Plus across all departments. Furthermore, the OECD's Government at a Glance 2023 report places Canada among the top tier for women in public leadership, outpacing most G20 peers. Article content Article content Canada's public service didn't evolve this way by accident; it arrived here through litigation, legislation, years of sustained pressure and conscious strategy. Article content Article content In March, the federal government eliminated the position of minister for Women and Gender Equality, sparking intense criticism. Within weeks, the role was reinstated. The public response made it clear that gender equity is still a priority for Canadians. Article content Culture is the operating system that's unseen but runs everything. I've known women in the public service being told they were 'too assertive' or 'not collaborative enough.' Their leadership styles are questioned. Their confidence mistaken for abrasiveness. This is feedback that men are far less likely to receive. These aren't isolated events, they're patterns.


Winnipeg Free Press
5 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Carney to return to Ottawa after fruitful summit with G7 leaders in Alberta
KANANASKIS – Prime Minister Mark Carney is heading home to Ottawa today after hosting the G7 summit in Kananaskis, Alta. He had been meeting with world leaders since Sunday to discuss topics such as U.S. tariffs, human trafficking and artificial intelligence. Carney also had his first meeting as prime minister with numerous leaders, including German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Modi's presence at the summit drew protests from Sikh groups, who said it's not appropriate to seek closer ties when the RCMP has accused Indian diplomats of extortion, coercion and homicide. Carney says the G7 summit helped broker a looming trade deal with the U.S., co-launch a stockpile for critical minerals and boost co-ordination in fighting wildfires. He will be returning to Ottawa amid pushback to his government's legislation aimed at speeding up federal project approvals, with the Liberals limiting debate amid criticism the bill would let the government bypass existing laws. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 18, 2025.