‘Clearly Unhinged': Critics Sink Trump's 'Asinine' Plan To Reopen Alcatraz Prison
President Donald Trump's plan to expand and reopen Alcatraz as a prison 'to house America's most ruthless and violent Offenders' caused the island to trend on X and other social media sites on Sunday.
And not many people were on board with the idea.
Alcatraz is currently a national park which receives some 1.2 million visitors per year. Those who tour the island in San Francisco Bay see facilities in various states of decay. The prison was crumbling even as it was still in operation, and the high cost of maintaining it was a key reason it shuttered in 1963.
Given those realities, restoring Alcatraz and then expanding it, as Trump called for on his Truth Social website, would likely cost a fortune ― and then another pile of cash would be needed to maintain it.
Reopening it as a prison would also mean the loss of the tourism revenue the island currently generates as well as a loss of habitat for its thriving bird population.
The president, however, said Alcatraz's return to use as a prison would 'serve as a symbol of Law, Order, and JUSTICE.'
His critics fired back that the idea would be an expensive boondoggle:
Who has been to Alcatraz tour? 🙋🏼♂️It's absolutely asinine after it's been closed longer than I've been alive to get it up to speed the sheer amount of money and resources. Absolutely insane. Truly. pic.twitter.com/GIsBglJI3B
— Sarasota Freedom (@dontdemdownsrq) May 4, 2025
Was Donald Trump watching a movie about Alcatraz when he came up with the idea of reopening it and putting tariffs on movies?This guy is clearly unhinged.
— Art Candee 🍿🥤 (@ArtCandee) May 5, 2025
Alcatraz closed as a federal penitentiary more than sixty years ago. It is now a very popular national park and major tourist attraction. The President's proposal is not a serious one. https://t.co/ALKXZLWlzO
— Nancy Pelosi (@SpeakerPelosi) May 5, 2025
100% tariffs on foreign films (maybe shutting off China market for US films?) Re-open Alcatraz (closed for 60+ years)? I really do not think it is a good idea to leave President Trump alone on Sunday nights.
— Jeff Greenfield (@greenfield64) May 5, 2025
Wanting to reopen Alcatraz, check if the gold is still in Fort Knox, and release the JFK files are exactly the sort of actions that someone who hasn't read anything since high school would want to do. Surprised that he hasn't demanded that the Pony Express be reinstated.
— Luke Epplin (@LukeEpplin) May 5, 2025
Trump is an incredibly surrealist, postmodern figure. His whole worldview seems to be informed by urban legends and mid-20th century movie references that he then tries to turn into actual policy. There are too many examples to count. His fixation on the Fort Knox gold is another… https://t.co/Bmxu0krXj8
— Bobby Miller (@realBobbyMil) May 5, 2025
Wanna bet he watched The Rock this weekend? 😂 https://t.co/eCRuVqjKXw
— Amy Smith (@watchkeep) May 4, 2025
Great movie. Dumb place to reopen a prison. https://t.co/VeeKOt7eGWpic.twitter.com/3FUmo3JHvo
— Mehdi Hasan (@mehdirhasan) May 5, 2025
Rebuilding Alcatraz to imprison more Americans seems like a great use of tax dollars, doesn't it? 🙄If you've been on a tour there then you know this is a terrible idea.It's likely just red meat for the base that won't happen, but it's hard to tell these days. Pete Hegseth… pic.twitter.com/GKpHUn69ua
— Ryan Shead (@RyanShead) May 5, 2025
Watches The Rock once https://t.co/qcP0r1Ho1l
— Liam Donovan (@LPDonovan) May 5, 2025
Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy ordered Alcatraz to close in 1962: It "was much more expensive to operate than other facilities; it housed a startlingly small number of prisoners; it was deemed vulnerable to future escape attempts." https://t.co/OE4y5PFXSn via @sfchronicle
— Carla 'Bluechecked' Marinucci (@cmarinucci) May 5, 2025
I toured Alcatraz not too long ago. The place is a full on museum, on the top of a really steep hill. Rebuilt? Enlarged? Does this mean he's scrapping the El Salvador gulag plans? What is this potato even talking about? pic.twitter.com/f8FLQGxdQG
— Sara McGee for Texas HD 132 (@SaraForTexLege) May 5, 2025
Wait until they figure out how expensive it will be to remodel, modernize and operate Alcatraz. The plumbing alone would take years to upgrade and I'm not even sure if it's possible. It will never happen. pic.twitter.com/LGqQyRa4uf
— Turnbull (@cturnbull1968) May 4, 2025
Alcatraz Island contributes significantly to the economy, generating about $60 million in annual revenue for park partners. This revenue comes from the 1.6 million visitors who tour the island each year. This revenue helps fund park projects and supports local businesses.It's…
— Artem Russakovskii (@ArtemR) May 4, 2025
Reopening and rebuilding Alcatraz as a prison would cost approximately $235–370 million upfront and $40–60 million annually to operate. Where you at @DOGE? pic.twitter.com/Af9WzhYT2x
— Maine (@TheMaineWonk) May 4, 2025
I had the honor of visiting Alcatraz last year. It was eye-opening.One of the most haunting exhibits was a map of the world with black balls to help you visualize the prison populations of each countryPerhaps President Trump should visit. He might learn something https://t.co/vVnGxhcQ67pic.twitter.com/QTQhSEp6ip
— Rachel Coyle (@RachelCoyleOhio) May 5, 2025
Where's DOGE at? https://t.co/A66Ra9O2j9
— Ryan Jones (@RyanJones_23) May 5, 2025
Listen we all want to see a sequel to The Rock but this is too much https://t.co/qCUkugKc2X
— Tim Lim (@TimLimDC) May 4, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
12 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Elon and Trump's Breakup Results In Hilarious Consequences For Dogecoin
Elon Musk and Donald Trump's nasty feud has had some unintended consequences for the meme coin that inspired the Department of Government Efficiency. As CNBC reports, Dogecoin fell 10 percent on Thursday, the day that the Musk and Trump spat spilled over onto social media, and was down 22 percent week-over-week at its lowest point last night, when it was worth less than 17 cents per token (don't gasp too hard, but it's now soared back up to 18 cents.) Given that it's a meme coin, Doge has never been worth all that much to begin with. At its absolute peak in 2021, the coin traded just under 75 cents thanks to Musk's endorsement — and despite regular peaks and valleys, it's never again surpassed that all-time high. Despite its near-worthlessness, Dogecoin has been a useful metric for tracking the way Musk affects market. As CNBC notes, the meme coin spiked 15 percent in a day when Tesla began accepting it for merchandise in 2022, and jumped 35 percent later that same year when Musk bought Twitter. Just as Doge giveth, Doge seems to taketh away. The unelected billionaire has entirely squandered the gains he garnered for the meme coin when riding on Trump's coattails, first with the announcement of the agency's creation and again when its official website was launched just after the president's inauguration. As Cointelegraph reports, the coin could be poised to slip even further. Dogecoin's three-week Trump slump suggests, per the site's analysis, that it could fall to as little as six cents per coin if its bearish streak continues. Should it continue to fall, a massive selloff event may occur as itchy investors seek to rid themselves of the tarnished token. Over on the everything app, Doge bros are, as usual, acting absolutely bonkers about the coin's chances of survival. "Looks like yesterday was just another bear trap for Dogecoin," one such investor tweeted alongside a chart showing projected "euphoric" highs that almost certainly will not be attained. "Let's go!" In another unrealistic prognostication that borders on tragic, one account shared a graphic explaining that if investors "hold together, nobody will fall." "I'll keep reposting till we hit the Dollar," the delulu poster exclaimed. In Washington, the fiery feud between Musk and Trump has shaken the status quo — but for crypto types, it's just another weekend. More on meme coins: You'll Never Guess What Happened to Trump's Meme Coin After He Announced His Tariffs
Yahoo
12 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump says Elon Musk will face 'very serious consequences' if he funds Democratic candidates
President Donald Trump on Saturday said there would be 'serious consequences' if tech mogul Elon Musk funds Democratic candidates to run against Republicans who vote in favor of the GOP's sweeping budget bill. 'If he does, he'll have to pay the consequences for that,' Trump told NBC News in a phone interview, but declined to share what those consequences would be. 'He'll have to pay very serious consequences if he does that,' he added. The president also said he has no desire to repair his relationship with Musk after a feud between the two men erupted into public view earlier this week. 'No,' Trump said when asked if he had any wish to do so. Asked if he thought his relationship with the Tesla and SpaceX CEO was over, Trump said, 'I would assume so, yeah.' Trump's comments were the most extensive since he and Musk exchanged threats and attacks on X and Truth Social earlier this week. He added that he thought the Republican Party was more unified than ever after the two men fell out in front of the world. Trump said he has no plans to speak with Musk anytime soon. 'I'm too busy doing other things,' he said, adding, 'I have no intention of speaking to him.' Trump also accused Musk of being 'disrespectful to the office of the President.' 'I think it's a very bad thing, because he's very disrespectful. You could not disrespect the office of the President,' he added. Musk on Thursday launched a barrage of posts on X against the president, including a now-deleted post highlighting the onetime links between the president and the late sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. 'That's called 'old news,' that's been old news, that has been talked about for years,' Trump said on Saturday. 'Even Epstein's lawyer said I had nothing to do with it. It's old news.' In the days leading up to their public falling out, Musk had been critical of a GOP-led spending bill that the House passed last month. In the Oval Office on Thursday, Trump responded to Musk's criticisms, telling reporters, 'I'm very disappointed because Elon knew the inner workings of this bill. I'm very disappointed in Elon. I've helped Elon a lot.' Shortly after those comments, Musk launched his flurry of posts, including a now-deleted post promoting a call for Trump to be impeached and another where he said the president's tariff agenda would cause a recession later this year. Trump on Thursday also responded with his own posts on Truth Social. In one post, he wrote, 'I don't mind Elon turning against me, but he should have done so months ago,' suggesting that Musk knew what was in the bill before it was passed. He also wrote on Thursday, 'The easiest way to save money in our Budget, Billions and Billions of Dollars, is to terminate Elon's Governmental Subsidies and Contracts,' referring to federal contracts with SpaceX. 'I was always surprised that Biden didn't do it!' On Saturday, Trump said he hadn't given his suggestion about canceling Musk's companies' federal contracts any more thought. 'I'd be allowed to do that,' he said, 'but I have, I haven't given it any thought.' Trump also responded to calls from outside allies, like conservative activist Steve Bannon, who have said that Musk's business dealings and immigration record should be investigated by the federal government. The president told NBC News that he hasn't had those conversations. 'I mean it's not something that's on top of my mind right now," Trump said. He also cast doubt on the notion that Musk's opposition to the 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' is jeopardizing the bill's chances of success, saying he's 'very confident' that the bill will pass the Senate before July 4. 'The Republican Party has never been united like this before. It's never been. It's actually more so than it was three days ago,' Trump said. Musk contributed major financial support to Trump's presidential bid in 2024, spending over a quarter of a billion dollars to boost him in swing states last year. In the first months of the administration, Trump put Musk in charge of the Department of Government Efficiency, where he oversaw mass layoffs of federal workers and the shuttering or partial closing of several agencies. The feud, Trump said, has made lawmakers see the benefits of the bill. 'I think, actually, Elon brought out the strengths of the bill because people that weren't as focused started focusing on it, and they see how good it is,' Trump said. 'So in that sense, there was a big favor. But I think Elon, really, I think it's a shame that he's so depressed and so heartbroken.' This article was originally published on
Yahoo
12 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Measles resurgence highlights the toll of RFK Jr.'s anti-vaccine policies
After the U.S. surpassed 1,000 reported measles cases nationwide, it's clear the Trump administration is failing to protect our health and well-being. The measles outbreak in Texas is now the largest since 2000, when the country eliminated measles. And it's not yet over, threatening to make measles endemic in America again, where the risk of infection comes from within our country. Furthermore, two unvaccinated school-aged children in Texas died from measles, the first American children to die from the viral infection since 2003. Normally, a preventable infection causing avoidable deaths of children would lead to prompt government action. In 1991, I was a medical student with the U.S. Public Health Service in Philadelphia during a large measles outbreak. Over 1,000 people were infected, and nine children died. Government and public health leaders required home visits of infected children, mass immunization, education efforts and even court-mandated vaccinations. The outbreak was stopped. In Dec. 2014, a measles outbreak began at Disneyland and spread in communities with low vaccination rates. Public health action stopped this large outbreak at 125 cases. To prevent further outbreaks in California, I authored Senate Bill 277, which eliminated non-medical exemptions for school vaccines. And with further U.S. measles outbreaks in 2019, I authored Senate Bill 276 to crack down on fraudulent medical exemptions. These laws — championed by California parents demanding safe schools for children — raised statewide vaccination rates and shielded our communities. As Congress waits, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is dismantling decades of public health achievement that will make America sicker. Kennedy reduced vaccine outreach, removed key public health officials, spread disinformation from his official post and suppressed data while elevating conspiracy theorists to top positions. Kennedy and the Department of Government Efficiency fired a quarter of Health and Human Services staff, gutting the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and National Institutes of Health teams vital to outbreak response. He installed anti-vaccine extremists as advisors, including David Grier, a discredited researcher disciplined for unethical experiments on children with autism, to 'research' if vaccines cause autism, despite decades of research debunking this myth. The CDC has been muzzled: An analysis showing high rates of measles in low vaccination areas was suppressed, and dozens of Texas vaccination clinics were forced to close. When Kennedy dismantled the CDC's communication team, his former anti-vaccine organization, Children's Health Defense, filled the void with disinformation by publishing a fake CDC-branded vaccine 'safety' website that falsely linked vaccines to autism. The site mimicked official CDC design and branding, deliberately misleading the public. After news reports exposed the deception and forced the site's removal, no federal action has been taken to investigate or prosecute this unlawful impersonation of a federal agency. Furthermore, Dr. Peter Marks, the nation's top vaccine regulator who led President Donald Trump's Operation Warp Speed, refused a demand for false data on brain swelling and death caused by the Measles-Mumps-Rubella vaccine, of which there are no credible cases. Kennedy forced him to resign. In his resignation letter, Marks wrote, 'it has become clear that truth and transparency are not desired by the secretary, but rather he wishes subservient confirmation of his misinformation and lies.' And what of the dead children from measles? Kennedy dismissed the first measles death, saying 'it's not unusual.' He blamed measles on poor nutrition, called vaccines a 'personal choice' that could cause 'adverse events' and claimed Vitamin A and cod liver oil treated measles. Subsequently, many Texas children hospitalized with measles also had Vitamin A toxicity. At his first Congressional hearing, Kennedy testified, 'I don't think people should be taking medical advice from me.' He then refused to answer whether he would vaccinate a child against polio. As Health and Human Services secretary, he cravenly refuses to save Americans in a public health crisis. How many children must get sick — and even die — before Congress demands that Kennedy and the Trump administration answer for these preventable deaths and the continued spread of a preventable disease? This flu season, as flu vaccination declined, 226 children died from influenza — the highest since the 2009-10 pandemic. Other preventable and deadly diseases, including polio and whooping cough, will also return when vaccination is hampered and discouraged. Our state has made progress in raising vaccination rates, but we are not immune to Kennedy's dangerous vaccine disinformation; California has communities with enough unvaccinated people to fuel a serious outbreak. Measles outbreaks in other states makes it imperative that California strengthen our public health defenses against sparks of infection. And California needs Congress to hold President Donald Trump and Kennedy accountable for not stopping preventable disease in America. Dr. Richard Pan is a pediatrician and former California state senator who authored landmark legislation to eliminate non-medical exemptions to school vaccination requirements in response to major measles outbreaks.
