HMRC boss ‘regrets' frustrations over £49m phishing scam disclosure
The revenue body has faced criticism and questions over why MPs were not informed earlier about the incident.
On June 4, it was disclosed that HMRC had lost £47 million after a phishing scam breached tens of thousands of tax accounts.
Following updated information published by HMRC on Tuesday, that figure was revised upwards, to £49 million.
Senior civil servants at HMRC told the Treasury Committee that 100,000 people had been contacted, or were in the process of being contacted, after their accounts were locked down in what they said was an 'organised crime' incident which started last year.
The Treasury Committee, which held a live session on June 4, wrote to Mr Marks earlier this week, telling him that: 'To discover this information during a session from press reports and without adequate time for the committee to review the information in detail is unacceptable.'
During a Public Accounts Committee hearing on Thursday, Mr Marks told MPs: 'We welcome your scrutiny.'
Mr Marks described the incident as a 'serious, and (an) unacceptable loss of £49 million to the Exchequer, affecting 100,000 of our customers, which is about 0.2% of the PAYE caseload'.
He added: 'Given we collect over £840 billion a year, the judgment on materiality is different for HMRC perhaps than other government departments.
'But nonetheless, I agree with the point with regards (to) disclosure, and I will do that in my annual report, which I will publish next month for the first time, so that is, again, properly done according to the rules under public money.
'The final thing really to say, I do regret if there's been any frustration in terms of our handling of this, that was not our intent at all.'
He said he would respond to correspondence he had received this week with more detail.
Mr Marks continued: 'I welcome your point, with regards (to) the opportunity to have in-private briefings, the level of security threats is significant and constant.
'The team detected and disrupted this one well. There was a criminal investigation. And in (a) private hearing, I'm happy to bring the head of the fraud investigation service, my chief security officer, to explain more about some of that detail but also the threat environment and the way in which we are ensuring HMRC is secure now and secure for the future as well.'
Earlier this week, an HMRC spokesperson said: 'We faced a series of evolving and complex criminal attempts to access online tax accounts and our priority has been to protect customers and their accounts.
'Our customers suffered no financial loss as a result.
'Thorough investigation has been necessary to understand the extent of this activity and pursue the criminals responsible.
'We've worked closely with the Information Commissioner's Office throughout to ensure we met our obligations.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Two groups of people 'need to apply' for £300 DWP winter fuel payment
Certain groups of people may have to apply for the newly reinstated £300 winter fuel payment - which is set to be paid in November and December A BBC specialist has shed light on how certain people may need to apply for the reinstated £300 winter fuel payment. On BBC Morning Live, Coletta Smith clarified the eligibility criteria following Chancellor Rachel Reeves ' announcement that an additional nine million state pensioners who were overlooked last year will receive the payment in 2025. The funds are due to be distributed in November and December of this year, with most qualifying recipients receiving either £200 or £300 automatically. However, Smith noted that some people might not receive it automatically and should verify their eligibility with the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). BBC's cost of living correspondent Colletta Smith said: "Those eligible are people who earn now £35,000 or less, so it's a much higher threshold as a pensioner. So if you are getting some form of private pension, workplace pension, as long as you're below that threshold of £35,000, you'll still get the winter fuel payments. "And crucially, it will come automatically. So like it used to. Previously, you didn't have to apply for it. It just pops into your bank accounts come the beginning of November onwards, so you don't have to worry about any complicated forms to fill in." The correspondent advised that certain people will need to update their information in order to receive the funds, despite being entitled, reports Cambridgeshire Live. She said: "There will be a small number of people who might need to update their details. "So if you have deferred your state pension, if you've lived abroad recently and have moved back, it's probably worth contacting the government to make sure that you do get that payment. For everybody else, you won't have to apply for it." Upon announcing the measure, the DWP has since revised its guidelines, clearly indicating for the first time who will be beneficiaries of the financial boost. DWP representatives clarified the eligibility criteria based on date of birth: "The Winter Fuel Payment for 2025 to 2026 will be made to everyone in England and Wales born before 22 September 1959, unless you choose not to get it. "You could get either £200 or £300 to help you pay your heating bills for winter." They further assured: "You do not need to do anything - payments will be made automatically." However, they cautioned high earners that the amount distributed would be reclaimed through HMRC, although specific recovery mechanisms were not disclosed. According to the information provided, it said: "If your income is over £35,000, your Winter Fuel Payment will be recovered later through HMRC. Details of the 2025 to 2026 payment will be available by the end of June 2025." Ms Smith explained that individuals with earnings above the threshold may opt out of receiving the payment to avoid repayment. She clarified: "If you earn £35,000 or above, there is a way of ticking a box to say that you don't want to receive the payment in the first place, but otherwise, the payment will come through automatically, and then it will be clawed back through the tax system. So you will be taxed a bit more on your pensions to get that £200 taken back off you effectively." Ms Smith also highlighted a critical period for eligibility: "The crucial week we all need to remember is between the 15th and the 25th of September. So if you have had your birthday by the 21st of September and you've become a state pensioner, then at that point you qualify for the winter fuel payment this coming winter. So it's that week that's the what they call the qualifying week. 15th to 21st, September."
North Wales Live
4 hours ago
- North Wales Live
DWP confirm exact date people born by to get 2025 winter fuel payment
The Department for Work and Pensions has confirmed that all individuals born before a specific date will be eligible for the winter fuel payment this year. The website has been updated with preliminary details following Chancellor Rachel Reeves' announcement earlier this week that nine million people who lost the £200-300 benefit last winter will receive it this year. Those earning over £35,000 will also receive the payment, but it will subsequently be reclaimed through the tax system. Sir Keir Starmer has maintained that the decision to restore most winter fuel payments was not a reaction to political backlash against the policy. Following the announcement, the DWP has updated its information and for the first time revealed who will be eligible for the payment. DWP officials stated that only those born before a certain date would receive the money. They said: "The Winter Fuel Payment for 2025 to 2026 will be made to everyone in England and Wales born before 22 September 1959, unless you choose not to get it. You could get either £200 or £300 to help you pay your heating bills for winter. "You do not need to do anything - payments will be made automatically.", reports Teesside Live. Officials confirmed that everyone will receive the money, but cautioned those earning above a certain threshold that it would be recouped through HMRC, although they did not provide specifics on how this would occur. The statement read: " If your income is over £35,000, your Winter Fuel Payment will be recovered later through HMRC. Details of the 2025 to 2026 payment will be available by the end of June 2025." This week, warnings were issued that the 'fiscal drag' caused by the £35,000 earnings limit will result in hundreds of thousands of individuals losing their winter fuel payment during this parliament. This is due to Ms Reeves confirming that the £35,000 limit will not increase with inflation, leading to an estimated additional 500,000 people being affected before the end of this parliament. BBC Moneybox expert Paul Lewis stated: "The £35,000 income limit for keeping the winter fuel payment will be frozen Ministers confirm, leading to more pensioners repaying the money year by year it will join frozen bereavement payments, capital limits, child benefit limits, and tax thresholds." The Prime Minister highlighted recent growth figures and decreasing interest rates as evidence that "the economy has stabilised". Ms Reeves admitted that working individuals were not experiencing signs of progress as she attempted to move past the winter fuel controversy by asserting her spending review tomorrow would stimulate growth. "This government is going for growth because that is the best way to create jobs, boost wages, lift people out of poverty and sustainably fund our schools and our hospitals and all the public services we rely on," she addressed the GMB Union Congress conference. While expressing confidence in the government's direction, Ms Reeves commented: "I know that not enough working people are yet feeling that progress, and that's what tomorrow's spending review is all about - making working people better off, investing in our security, investing in our health, investing in our economy." Today, Rachel Reeves did not dismiss the possibility of further tax increases come autumn, following reports that the economy contracted more than anticipated in April. The Chancellor has consistently maintained that the forthcoming spending review's costs are offset by last year's tax hikes, emphasising that departments must now "live within their means". However, with a faltering economy and new obligations such as partially reversing cuts to winter fuel payments, experts caution that taxes might rise again in the autumn. When questioned on LBC about ruling out additional tax hikes, Ms Reeves said: "I think it would be very risky for a Chancellor to try and write future budgets in a world as uncertain as ours." Yet, she reiterated her commitment to avoiding tax increases on the scale seen last year, when they rose by £40 billion.
North Wales Live
12 hours ago
- North Wales Live
Winter Fuel Payment decision by DWP on pensioners living as a couple
The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has explained the regulations over the Winter Fuel Payment for pensioners who are living together as a couple. Following a government U-turn, it was announced on June 11 that nine million pensioners in England and Wales will receive the benefit from this winter. This adjustment means that eligible pensioners – those with an income of £35,000 or less – will receive either £200 or £300 this winter. It follows last year's reduction in payments when they were means tested for the first time, with only those on certain benefits receiving the payment. This effectively lowered the income threshold to just £11,600, according to Money Saving Expert. Under the new amendments, all pensioners earning less than £35,000 per year will automatically receive the payment this year, reports the Manchester Evening News. Rules on households Pensioners earning above this threshold will also receive the payment, but it will subsequently be reclaimed through tax. This implies that if someone earns over £35,000, their portion of the household payment will be recouped either via the PAYE or self-assessment tax system. Payments will be made per household, meaning a household with more than one pensioner will only receive one payment of up to £300. Therefore, for instance, two pensioners over the age of 80 living in the same house will each receive £150. Income is assessed individually rather than based on household income when it comes to certain payments for pensioners. This means that if one partner in a pensioner couple earns above the income threshold, they will have their portion of the payment reclaimed via the tax system, while their partner will still receive their share if their own income is below the threshold. 'Good system' Martin Lewis, the founder of the Money Saving Expert website, praised this approach as a "good system compared to what we thought was going to happen", having initially expected the threshold to be determined by the higher earner's income within a household. For most pensioner couples, the payment is usually shared, but MoneySavingExpert highlights an important exception. The website clarified: "If you're a couple claiming Pension Credit, there's no split. You'll get £200 or £300 (if one of you is 80+) in one lump sum.
