Independent 'draft assessment' of the Manawanui wreck circulates govt agencies' for feedback
UAS footage of RNZN Divers surveying the area around HMNZS Manawanui on the Southern Coast of Upulo as part of Op Resolution. 25 October 2024
Photo:
New Zealand Defence Force
The New Zealand Defence Force is circulating a draft assessment of the wreck of the HMNZS Manawanui to New Zealand government agencies but there's no date for public release.
"I'm getting their advice and providing advice on the initial draft ... They're other agencies such as Maritime New Zealand, MFAT - you know all key agencies that are part of the sort of multi-agency response that is responding to the Manawanui," Commodore Andrew Brown, from the Royal New Zealand Navy, said.
Commodore Brown has led the recovery operation of the wreck of the Manawanui for the New Zealand Defence Force since it hit the Tafitoala Reef, set on fire and sank off the south coast of Upolu Samoa on 6 October, 2024.
Diesel fuel slicks from HMNZS Manawanui observed from aerial shots.
Photo:
Ministry of Works Transport and Infrastructure Samoa
NZDF conducted more than 284 dives of the wreck, including checking its 55 tanks and compartments.
"We are as confident as we can be that we have removed as much of the diesel fuel and other pollutants from the vessel. If there is anything remaining from the vessel it would be very small amounts... Only traces I would expect of any fuel," Brown said.
"We've also completed work to recover important equipment and weapons and ammunition, and debris from in and around the ship. We've left the ship as secure as possible until a decision is reached on the next steps for the ship and the work required for that."
The salvors have returned to New Zealand bringing back diesel fuel, pollutants, debris and equipment including the azipod and the Manawanui's anchors and chains.
What happens next to the Manawanui will be informed by the independent wreck, reef and environmental impact assessments.
"We're pushing that as hard as we can, but as you could imagine these types of assessments need to be very carefully progressed. They're being carried out by independent experts. One of them is a Singaporean based," Commodore Brown said.
"They're providing the technical advice on the wreck and the wreck assessment and alongside them are independent experts on the reef, and environment experts. They've also subcontracted some work to New Zealand agencies in progressing that."
Commodore Brown said the initial draft of the wreck assessment is being circulated for advice but there is no timing for when the assessments will be completed, nor the names of the assessors.
"There is some commercial sensitivities related to the contracting of those experts" and they are "being tasked in association with our insurers," he said.
NZ Navy Commodore Andrew Brown.
Photo:
RNZ/ Susana Lei'ataua
A 2km prohibitive area around the Manawanui has been legislated by the Government of Samoa "for safety reasons".
"We've worked hand in glove with the Samoan government officials who you know have the lead on the response, and certainly have the lead on monitoring the environment. It's been very pleasing as we've worked alongside the likes of the Samoan science and research organisation who have been conducting seawater environmental testing," Commodore Brown said.
Water testing has gone from twice a week after the HMNZS Manawanui sank, to once a week and now monthly and "all of the results are coming back with the area clear and uncontaminated from elevated hydrocarbons".
NZDF continues to assist Samoan officials with monitoring the environment and testing the seawater but will not release these results.
"Not at this stage. They're owned by the Samoans. And if those results are to be made public I would expect that would be something that the Samoan authorities would release," Commodore Brown said.
He cannot say for sure if the independent wreck, reef and environmental impact assessments will be made public either "but certainly we have got an absolute focus on being as transparent as we can with respect to this response", he said.
This is Commodore Brown's 46th year with the Royal New Zealand Navy.
"I personally feel the loss of a ship like the Manawanui as if I have lost a colleague or a family member almost, and I know many of my sailor colleagues that have been involved in the response feel the same," he said.
"We also feel, I also feel that bond around the Manawanui and the loss of Manawanui from the Samoans as well. And the wonderful relationship that I've been exposed to through the work I've done with Manawanui working with the Samoan government and the people of Samoa has been an incredible privilege.
"No one ever, ever, ever wants this to occur again and never wanted it to occur in the first place, but it has occurred and we're doing our very, very, very best and I'm very proud to be part of the team that is responding to the Manawanui loss."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Students hope new prisoners' newsletter 'removes some stigma'
Photo: 123RF A group of journalism students at University of Canterbury has launched a newsletter for the region's prison population. The publication Prison News will be delivered to Christchurch Men's, Christchurch Women's and Rolleston Prison every two months, featuring stories about issues relevant to inmates. The project is being run in collaboration with prison reform organisation Howard League Canterbury. Student Aimee Muller, who is also the chief editor, said Howard League previously approached students about the opportunity to do a newsletter and the project took off this year. "Our first edition just came out and we've been working really hard to write stories that are interesting for inmates together. It's quite a collaborative project which has been super exciting," she said. "In the most recent addition we had a feature on a previous inmate who now has turned his life around and is working on documentaries. "We've done pieces on current legislation that is relevant to inmates, and we've also done a couple of pieces about services that are available as well, because we think it's really important to highlight services and opportunities for people who may be not be aware of these." Muller believed it was important for people not in prison to be informed as well. "People who can pick up our newsletter I think it's interesting for them to hear more about what goes on inside prison, stories from people who have been in prison and kind of what they're doing with their life now," she said. "We hope that it removes some stigma around what inmates are perceived as through the media sometimes." Muller said about 400 copies of the newsletter's first edition were printed and distributed to the libraries of the three prisons." A PO box number has been included also so that readers could send feedback on the kind of issues they would like to see covered. "Our overall dream would be to send copies to as many prisons across New Zealand as possible."

RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Bodies of four weasels found inside Zealandia eco-sanctuary
Zealandia rangers don't think the weasels were inside the fence for long. File photo. Photo: 123rf Four unwanted visitors have weaselled their way into Wellington eco-sanctuary Zealandia in the past week. The first dead weasel was found on Saturday afternoon, when a member of the public alerted the team to a fresh body in a DOC200 trap within the fence. Rangers cleared and reset the trap, and another weasel was found in the same trap the next day. A third weasel was discovered in another trap on Monday, and a fourth on Tuesday. These traps had been set after a tree fell onto the fence in May, and it was possible the weasels had got in during the storm, with these animals able to get through tiny holes only a thumb-width in diameter. General manager for conservation and restoration Jo Ledington said: "We don't know exactly how these weasels entered the valley but as they have not shown up on any of the detection devices deployed for the fence damage, the bodies were fresh and the traps had recently been checked and rebaited, we don't think they have been inside the fence for long." She said there was a "complex and layered biosecurity system in place, including motion-activated cameras, tracking tunnels, detection dogs, and a comprehensive trapping network". There was no evidence these weasels had killed any of the sanctuary's wildlife. "This is exactly what our conservation team is trained for. We're prepared for events like this, and our systems are doing their job. We will be continuing with our response until we are confident there are no further weasels in the sanctuary." Before this, the last time a weasel was found dead in a trap was August 2024, and before that was October 2023, and then back as far as 2019. Staff had since re-checked the fence to make sure it was secure, rebaited set traps to ensure the bait was fresh and attractive, and were regularly checking them. Work as ongoing to put in more trail cameras, and a mustelid dog was booked to do a search of the sanctuary as part of standard biosecurity measures. Zealandia was also in the process of fundraising for a new fence , with the old one nearing 25 years of age. But it said responding to events like this was expensive, and it could take months to be totally sure the sanctuary was safe. People could support the work by becoming a member or making a donation to the fence refurbishment project. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

RNZ News
17 hours ago
- RNZ News
Survey finds support for Queenstown Lakes mayor, councillors drops to 17%
Just 17 percent of respondents felt the council made decisions in the district's best interest. Photo: RNZ / Katie Todd Support for the Queenstown Lakes mayor and councillors dropped to just 17 percent, down from 44 percent a year ago, according to a survey commissioned by the council. The district council's community insights survey results released on Wednesday revealed growing frustration among residents about traffic congestion, increasing tourism and infrastructure pressure. Key Research surveyed 405 people in February and March about the council's leadership, core services and communication. The lowest scoring question in the survey saw just 16 percent of respondents agree the council created long-term solutions and improvements that worked well for them. Just 17 percent of respondents felt the council made decisions in the district's best interest and just 23 percent were satisfied with core services like roading, water and waste. In a statement, the council's acting chief executive Dave Wallace said the feedback reinforced their understanding of community frustration. He said the council was trying to manage unprecedented growth. "QLDC does not hold all the levers, but we must influence and continue to plan for change. How we move forward will be key to a sustainable future," he said. The survey was carried out after the overturning of freedom camping restrictions and around a controversial decision to discharge treated wastewater into the Shotover River. Queenstown Lakes District mayor Glyn Lewers. Photo: RNZ / Marika Khabazi In February councillors were warned that increasing tourist pressures could trigger protests and local hostility if there was not urgent intervention and investment. Residents also expressed dissatisfaction with the council's environmental efforts, with only 29 percent satisfied with efforts to reduce waste to landfill and 19 percent with preparations for climate change. Wallace said the council was trying to understand how to rebuild trust and engagement. "We have been working hard to build on these perceptions and have built our engagement through multiple forums, district-wide, including moving our workshops into the public domain," he said. The council scored well on community facilities, with 79 percent of respondents satisfied with local parks, reserves and gardens, and 85 percent happy with trails, walkways and cycleways. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.