Court backs DeSantis on migrant flight records
An appeals court Wednesday overturned a circuit judge's ruling that Gov. Ron DeSantis' administration took too long in providing public records about a controversial 2022 decision to fly migrants from Texas to Massachusetts.
A three-judge panel of the 1st District Court of Appeal backed DeSantis' administration in the dispute with the non-profit Florida Center for Government Accountability, which made two public-records requests in September 2022 and filed a lawsuit in October 2022 after it did not receive all of the documents.
Leon County Circuit Judge J. Lee Marsh in late October 2022 said the administration did not properly comply with the state's public-records law and gave it 20 days to provide records. But the appeals-court panel ruled Wednesday that Marsh erred in concluding that the administration's 'response was unreasonable and in violation of Florida's public records.'
'Here, the final hearing (not initiation of the lawsuit) occurred only 35 days after the first public records request,' appeals-court Judge Rachel Nordby wrote in an opinion joined by Judges Brad Thomas and Thomas Winokur. 'The public records sought were not singular documents or already composed files (like a court file where the records custodian merely accesses it electronically or pulls it off the shelf). This was a comprehensive request that, due to its scope, was going to take some time.'
The opinion also pointed to issues such as Hurricane Ian hitting the state in September 2022 after the Florida Center for Government Accountability, an open-government group, made the public-records request.
'The (governor's) office has a duty to timely fulfill all public records requests, but considering the magnitude and scope of the center's request — which coincided with the ongoing statewide emergency of a major hurricane — the office's response time cannot be considered unreasonable,' Nordby wrote. 'The center's demand that its two robust records requests be completed within a week was unfeasible and impractical given the breadth of the requests and the circumstances surrounding it. Given the record before us, the center has failed to demonstrate that the office's response constituted an unreasonable delay that violated the Public Records Act.'
The case focused, at least in part, on requests by the center for phone or text logs that could provide information about communications by DeSantis' then-chief of staff, James Uthmeier, related to the flights. Uthmeier was sworn in Monday as attorney general, after DeSantis appointed him to replace former Attorney General Ashley Moody.
The center filed records requests Sept. 20, 2022, and Sept. 21, 2022, and alleged in the Oct. 10, 2022, lawsuit that the administration had not provided all of the records sought. The flights, which involved 49 migrants going from San Antonio, Texas, to Martha's Vineyard, occurred Sept. 14, 2022.
In his Oct. 27, 2022, order, Marsh wrote that the governor's office 'has presented no evidence to the court of what direct steps it took to identify or produce records responsive to the public records request dated September 20, 2022, some of which have yet to be produced to the plaintiff.'
'The court finds that the EOG (the Executive Office of the Governor) is not in compliance with (the public records law),' Marsh wrote. 'EOG's partial production and response to the record requests were unreasonable. Specifically, the EOG has not made any production of a text or phone log of James Uthmeier as requested in the records request dated September 20, 2022.'
But in Wednesday's opinion, the appeals court said the request for Uthmeier's phone and text logs appeared to include his personal communications devices and that presumably, 'not all phone calls or text messages from any personal devices would be public records.'
'Sorting the public from the private in two weeks' worth of text messages and phone calls would not be quick,' Nordby wrote.
The appeals court said the governor's office did not challenge another part of Marsh's ruling that the administration made unnecessary redactions to records.
Marsh also ruled that the center was entitled to recoup its attorney fees and costs. Wednesday's opinion sent the case back to circuit court.
Click here to download our free news, weather and smart TV apps. And click here to stream Channel 9 Eyewitness News live.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
12 hours ago
- Axios
Hurricane season begins with no tax breaks for Floridians to stock up
Thanks to Republican infighting in Tallahassee, Floridians are on their own when it comes to stocking up as hurricane season gets underway, with no immediate sales tax holidays for supplies. Why it matters: In past years, sales tax holidays have saved families over $70 million, money that could've helped offset rising costs and motivated more people to purchase essentials. With consumers pulling back on spending nationwide, scrapping the incentive could mean fewer homes are prepared for the storms ahead. Catch up quick: The legislative session dragged into overtime because of disagreements over the state budget, with GOP lawmakers in a standoff over which tax cuts to push through. The House's recommendation didn't include sales tax holidays; the Senate's included one, which would've run from May 15 to May 31. DeSantis pitched two, each of which would've lasted two weeks. In 2024, Floridians got two 14-day tax holidays on supplies: one at the start of hurricane season and the other between August and September, its most active stretch. Yes, but: You don't need to go in unprepared. The Florida Division of Emergency Management created a disaster supplies kit checklist that includes food and water, first aid supplies, insurance documents, flashlights, batteries and medicine. State of preparedness: You can find almost everything (sans insurance documents, car keys, etc.) at your local Walmart. This year, Yacob found 30 items on the list for $226.37. (That's more than last year.) Pro tips: These items aren't all located in the same aisle or even the same general area of the store. Use the Walmart app to see the most cost-effective options and where to find them. You won't find the suggested "sturdy boots" for less than $30 at Walmart, and expect to spend a good amount on quality phone chargers, batteries and flashlights. You can purchase a first aid kit for $10.98, but buying supplies separately provides a better cost-to-quantity ratio.
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Fact Check: Gov. Ron DeSantis said Florida drivers can hit protesters if they fear for their lives
Claim: Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis said drivers in his state are allowed to hit protesters if they feel as though their life is being threatened. Rating: Context: DeSantis did not directly say Floridians can "drive over" or "run over" protesters as some claims alleged, but taking the full context of his quote into consideration, it is accurate to summarize his comments as such. A rumor that Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis said drivers are allowed to run over protesters with their cars if they feel threatened spread in June 2025 as debate raged over nationwide protests against U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids at the behest of President Donald Trump's administration. Some users on social media platforms such as Facebook (archived), Instagram (archived) and X (archived) alleged DeSantis declared that "Floridians are ALLOWED to drive over protesters in the street, if they feel like their life is in danger." It is true DeSantis said Florida drivers are allowed to hit protesters if the they feel their life is threatened, though it's important to note he did not directly say "drive over" or "run over," as some social media posts claim. However, based on the full quote, it is accurate to summarize his comment as such. DeSantis made the remarks during an appearance on "The Rubin Report," a conservative talk show on Rumble, a YouTube alternative favored by many on the political right (including a 2021 investment in the platform from Vice President JD Vance). There is no evidence the video featuring DeSantis was falsified or generated using artificial intelligence. The full quote in question occurred around 8 minutes and 50 seconds into the interview (archived). DeSantis said: And we also have a policy that if you're driving on one of those streets and a mob comes and surrounds your vehicle and threatens you, you have a right to flee for your safety. And so you drive off and you hit one of these people, that's their fault for impinging on you. You don't have to sit there and just be a sitting duck and let the mob grab you out of your car and drag you through the streets. You have a right to defend yourself in Florida. DeSantis' appearance was an an episode titled "Exposing the Real Origin of Gavin Newsom's ICE Riot Problem," and the Florida governor weighed in on the protests against ICE and the resulting actions by law enforcement in Los Angeles during June 2025. DeSantis and host Dave Rubin discussed a variety of topics, according to the episode's description, including "Florida's zero tolerance for riots and looting; the contrast between Florida and California on law enforcement and immigration" and "support for ICE and strong border policies." The statement came following days of escalating tensions across the United States after Trump deployed the National Guard to Los Angeles despite on-the-ground reports of the protests being primarily peaceful until escalated by law enforcement, causing further discontent across the nation. Snopes reached out to DeSantis' press office for comment about his statement, who referred us back to the full interview on "The Rubin Report" and cited a news release from 2021 announcing the governor's signing of "hallmark anti-rioting legislation" called the "Combating Public Disorder Act." According to the release, the act "takes a robust approach to uphold the rule of law" including the addition of "new criminal offenses and increased penalties for individuals who are participants in violent or disorderly assemblies." "We are holding those who incite violence in our communities accountable, supporting our law enforcement officers who risk their lives every day to keep us safe and protecting Floridians from the chaos of mob violence," DeSantis said at the time. Ebrahimji, Jessie Yeung, Rhea Mogul, Rebekah Reiss, Alisha. "Live Updates: Protests against Trump ICE Raids Flare across US." CNN, 12 June 2025, Exposing the Real Origin of Gavin Newsom's ICE Riot Problem | Ron DeSantis. 2025. "Immigration Protests: LA Appears Relatively Calm after Police Moved in before Curfew." AP News, Accessed 12 June 2025. "Protests Intensify in Los Angeles after Trump Deploys Hundreds of National Guard Troops." AP News, 8 June 2025, "Rumble, a YouTube Rival Popular with Conservatives, Will Pay Creators Who 'Challenge the Status Quo.'" The Seattle Times, 16 Aug. 2021, WHAT THEY ARE SAYING: Governor Ron DeSantis Signs Hallmark Anti-Rioting Legislation Taking Unapologetic Stand for Public Safety | Executive Office of the Governor. Accessed 12 June 2025.
The Hill
14 hours ago
- The Hill
DeSantis omits references to LGBTQ, Hispanic communities in latest Pulse remembrance
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) didn't directly reference LGBTQ or Hispanic people in an annual order issued Thursday to honor the victims of the 2016 mass shooting at Pulse, a gay nightclub in Orlando, a substantial omission that echoes recent actions by President Trump's administration against diversity and inclusion. DeSantis, who has led the state since 2019 and sought the 2024 Republican nomination for president, has mentioned the LGBTQ and Hispanic communities — the groups most devastated by the attack that killed 49 and injured dozens more — in near identical orders issued during each of his last five years in office. In those statements, DeSantis called the massacre 'a horrific act of terrorism against the LGBTQ and Hispanic communities.' Thursday's order says the attack was 'a horrific act of terrorism' without mentioning any specific groups. In 2019, his first year as governor, DeSantis was forced to issue an amended proclamation after an initial statement that also omitted references to LGBTQ people attracted widespread backlash. He said at the time that he was 'not involved' in drafting the first proclamation and requested his office issue a new one once he became aware of the exclusion. 'Sometimes these things happen, and you've got to correct them,' DeSantis said during a 2019 news conference on an unrelated matter. Multiple spokespersons for the governor did not return a request for comment on this year's omission or say whether the office would issue a new statement. Florida has recognized 'Pulse Remembrance Day' each year on June 12, the date on which the 2016 attack occurred, since its creation in 2018 by former Gov. Rick Scott (R). Now a U.S. senator, Scott said in his original proclamation that the state 'continues to mourn the tragic loss of life and recognize the lasting impact it has on our state and communities, including Florida's LGBTQ community.' In a statement on Thursday, Scott called the shooting, one of the deadliest in U.S. history, 'an act of terror targeting Orlando's LGBTQ and Hispanic communities.' A statement from Sen. Ashley Moody (R-Fla.), Florida's former attorney general who DeSantis appointed to replace Secretary of State Marco Rubio in the Senate in January, makes no mention of LGBTQ or Latino people. DeSantis's decision to delete references to the LGBTQ and Hispanic communities from his annual order mirrors Trump administration efforts targeting diversity and inclusion and LGBTQ rights. References to diverse historical figures, including Jackie Robinson, were removed from government websites in an initial purge related to Trump's executive orders against DEI and 'gender ideology.' Last week, reported that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth plans to rename an oil tanker named for the assassinated gay rights activist Harvey Milk. The Navy is also considering renaming other ships named after prominent civil rights leaders, including Harriet Tubman, Thurgood Marshall and Lucy Stone, according to a CBS News report. DeSantis has also campaigned against diversity efforts, frequently saying that DEI, which stands for 'diversity, equity and inclusion,' actually means 'discrimination, exclusion and indoctrination.' Laws signed during his tenure, including one forbidding classroom instruction on sexuality and gender, have been criticized for targeting the LGBTQ community. 'Governor DeSantis's erasure of the LGBTQ+ and Latino communities today may say a lot about what kind of person he is, but it doesn't change the fact that those were the communities most directly impacted at Pulse,' said Brandon Wolf, a Pulse survivor who serves as spokesperson for the Human Rights Campaign, a national LGBTQ advocacy organization. 'His erasure doesn't change the fact that families have empty seats at dinner tables, friends have missing faces at birthday parties, and our communities still bear the scars.' 'Today, rather than letting the governor's petty political cowardice write our story, I hope people choose to remember those stolen and impacted, reflect on the costs of violent hate, and recommit to honoring those we loved and lost with action,' Wolf, who lost two friends, Drew Leinonen and Juan Guerrero, in the shooting at Pulse, said in a text message. Florida state Sen. Carlos Guillermo Smith, a Democrat and the first openly gay Latino person elected to the Legislature in 2016, called DeSantis's omission 'a petty slight.' 'The Governor's on again, off again acknowledgment of those impacted by the Pulse shooting shows he cares more about scoring political points in the moment rather than showing authentic solidarity with his own constituents,' Smith said in an emailed statement, speaking on behalf of the LGBTQ rights group Equality Florida, for whom he is a senior adviser. 'Either way it would be a mistake to focus on the Governor's bigotry and exclusion. That's already well-known,' Smith added. 'Today is about remembering the 49 taken by gun violence, as well as remembering the strength and courage of those who survived and the families impacted. They will not be erased.'
