
Accountant forced to rip out central heating after neighbour row backfires
An accountant was forced to rip out the central heating from her Oxfordshire cottage after a row with her neighbour backfired, a court has heard.
Helen Faber sued her neighbour over a 'nuisance' fence which she claimed had encroached on a shared path by 40cm.
But the legal action had a counterproductive result when a judge threw out her claim and instead found she had herself encroached on the path with a patio and oil central heating pipe.
Ms Faber and her husband, Dominic Miles, were ordered to rip up the patio and the pipe – rendering their central heating useless – at Oxford County Court.
The couple are now challenging the ruling at the High Court.
Mr Justice Richard Smith heard last week that Ms Faber and Mr Miles own the £375k Pear Tree Cottage in Wardington, Oxfordshire, which has right of way on a footpath owned by Richard and Katherine Reid, who live next door at Forge Cottage.
In 2021, the couple returned to the countryside cottage from France to find a fence put in by Mr and Mrs Reid had 'narrowed' the 4ft-wide path by 40cm.
They said the fence was a 'nuisance' because it would make it more difficult to carry a 'large picnic tray laden with food and drinks...without spilling the drinks' to a patio at the rear of their garden.
Ms Faber and Mr Miles brought a claim at Oxford County Court claiming that the new fence was a 'substantial interference' with their use of the shared right of way.
But the move backfired when judge Melissa Clarke ruled there was no 'nuisance' and also found they had installed a patio and oil pipe that constituted 'trespasses' on the footpath.
'An oil line running from an oil tank in the Pear Tree Cottage second garden is on, over and under parts of the right of way,' judge Clarke told the hearing.
'The claimants now accept that the right of way is owned by Forge Cottage. The installation by the claimants of an oil line over the right of way is a trespass on the land of Forge Cottage and the defendants are entitled to an injunction requiring the claimants to remove it.'
She said the pipeline is 'susceptible to damage' and that, if damaged, any oil leaks would contaminate Mr and Mrs Reid's land, which is a risk they 'should not have to tolerate from trespass'.
Last week, Stephen Taylor, for Ms Faber and Mr Miles, argued that Judge Clarke made the wrong decision. He said that the couple had informed their previous neighbours at Forge Cottage before installing the heating system and they had not objected.
He insisted that means their current neighbours cannot now demand its removal.
The court heard that there is no gas supply in the village and that Mr Miles and Ms Faber claim 'modern' heating systems such as heat pumps are 'not suitable for use in a stone-built property more than three centuries old.'
He also claimed the judge was wrong in defining the boundary so that part of Ms Faber and Mr Miles' patio was on their neighbours' land and deemed a 'trespass' which would have to be removed.
However, Anya Newman, representing Mr and Mrs Reid, argued that Judge Clarke was right in her ruling at the county court and that the fence should stay and the patio and pipe should be removed.
'The dispute arose after the respondents (Mr and Mrs Reid) replaced an old fence at the rear of their garden,' she said.
'It was agreed that the route of the fence was somewhat different to the previous fence, it is now dog-legged instead of running at one angle.
'After initially being happy with the replacement fence, the appellants raised issue about its positioning.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Sky News
38 minutes ago
- Sky News
Ballymena riots: Families flee 'locals' venting their feelings
Here we go again. It was not long after 8pm when a police announcement over a tannoy mounted on their armoured vehicles reverberated around for all to hear. "Force is about to be used against violent individuals," blasted from the speakers as locals, some masked, stood waiting for action. "You better be filming this," one man said as we captured the scenes for Sky News amid a growing sense from locals that the police were being heavy handed in their tactics. And then officers, holding their shields, surged forward as people edged back. The move seemed to further anger the residents who had gathered, almost goading them as tensions ran high. The pace of clashes was slower on this, the third night of conflict. But it was nevertheless just as ugly and messy. Eyewitness: It is hard to see where the violence will end Soon came the baton rounds, the firebombs, the water cannon. Those pelting the police seemed unfazed as they were battered with plastic bullets in return. The watching crowd cheered the rioters on. Police chiefs earlier defended their operation. A senior officer insisted he did have "a grip" on the unravelling situation when questioned by Sky News. The increased presence of officers was felt on the ground and was clear to see. The soundtrack of sirens swirled around this town once again as police lurched from incident to incident as pockets of violence flared up. Officers are on their way from Scotland, England and Wales to help bolster resources. And they won't be short of work. A leisure centre 25 minutes away in Larne came under attack on Wednesday evening after it emerged some of the foreign families fleeing the Ballymena chaos were being temporarily held there. A short drive around Ballymena's one way road system takes you on a journey through housing estates where people have flooded the streets with union jack flags and stuck yellow A4 sheets to their windows with the words, "LOCALS LIVE HERE". These colourful displays are being seen as a public noticeboard of the nationality of the occupants inside each home. A deterrent to make the angry mob to look elsewhere. And those failing to advertise whether they are a 'native' or not seem to be paying a price. I witnessed an upper floor flat with a window smashed, the guttering on fire and the ground outside ablaze. An older neighbour fled her home downstairs in her dressing gown. Earlier in the day two Romanian women were frantically examining their phones down an alleyway as their kids played on the trampoline in the garden. They were terrified and were bundling their belongings in the car and leaving for good. A sizeable chunk of people born in Ballymena are angry. They do not like the talk from police and politicians that taking to the streets following an alleged sex attack on a teenage girl equates to them being "racist thugs". They see this as an act of venting their feelings. And they are hellbent on continuing this campaign of carnage across Northern Ireland to ensure they prove their point.


BBC News
3 hours ago
- BBC News
The Documentary Podcast The tyre scandal
Every year the UK produces around 50 million tyres for disposal. They are supposed to be sent for recycling. Instead, big money is being made by diverting tyres to illegal and dangerous 'pyrolysis' plants where they are melted down to extract oil and steel. Together with a team of journalists from Source Material, a not-for-profit group specialising in climate and corruption, we follow the tyres from the UK to India using tracking devices. The team discovers just how large scale this largely illicit business has become. Earlier this year, a makeshift pyrolysis plant exploded near Mumbai, killing four people. It had been processing tyres from abroad. Reporter Paul Kenyon confronts a tyre trader in the north of England who admits to shipping his waste tyres to India for pyrolysis.


BBC News
3 hours ago
- BBC News
Diddy On Trial ‘Jane' questioned about sex drugs and underwear she ordered for ‘hotel nights'
Defence lawyer Teny Geragos continued her cross-examination of 'Jane' with more focus the messages between her and Sean 'Diddy' Combs. 'Jane' is the pseudonym being used to protect the identity of Diddy's ex-partner. She was asked about messages which suggest she was planning 'hotel nights' for her and Diddy, along with other men. Photos were also shown to the jury of 'Jane' and Diddy spending time together. Meanwhile the prosecution has asked for one of the jury members to be dismissed. Anoushka Mutanda-Dougherty speaks to NPR music reporter Isabella Gomez-Sarmiento about the day in court. Sean 'Diddy' Combs is on trial in New York, facing federal charges of sex trafficking, racketeering with conspiracy and transportation for prostitution. He denies all the charges. The Diddy on Trial podcast is here to investigate the rumours, confront the theories, and give you the answers that you need. We also want YOU to be part of the conversation. Have you any questions about the case? Heard a theory that doesn't sit right with you? Get in touch now via WhatsApp: 0330 123 555 1. Details of organisations in the UK offering information and support with some of the issues raised are available at Presenter: Anoushka Mutanda-Dougherty Series Producer: Laura Jones Sound Design: Mark Burrows Senior Digital Producer: Matthew Pintus Production Coordinator: Hattie Valentine Editor: Clare Fordham Commissioning Editor: Rhian Roberts Assistant Commissioner: Will Drysdale Commissioning Producer: Adam Eland Commissioning Assistant Producer: Rechmial Miller