Judge Nathan Erasmus denies defence counsel request to drop charges in Joshlin Smith trial
Jacquen Appollis, Steveno van Rhyn and Kelly Smith face charges of human trafficking and kidnapping.
Image: Robin-Lee Francke/IOL
As the State closed its case in the Joshlin Smith matter on Wednesday morning, it is now time for the defence to bring forth its case.
Earlier, the State called Colonel Riaan Morris from the provincial Commercial Crimes Unit, who played six videos for the court.
The videos include Kelly Smith being filmed on Sunday, March 3, 2024, at an open prayer service being held for Joshlin.
The other videos also show Kelly having a meeting at the Spur with now Minister Gayton McKenzie.
Judge Nathan Erasmus dismissed the applications.
Image: Ayanda Ndamane/Independent Newspapers
A few videos of the meeting with McKenzie are shown.
He was also provided with two links, which led to two videos of McKenzie, seated in the back of a vehicle, where he questions Steveno van Rhyn about his whereabouts and what happened to Joshlin.
As the State closed its case in the matter, Judge Nathan Erasmus was told that the defence counsel would bring forth Section 174 applications.
A Section 174 application, under South Africa's Criminal Procedure Act, allows an accused person to be discharged if the court believes there is no evidence to support a conviction at the close of the State's case.
Fanie Harmse, the legal representative for Jacquen 'Boeta' Appollis, chose not to bring forth an application.
Van Rhyn's lawyer, Nobuhle Mkabayi, brought forth an application.
'The defence will argue accused two has no case to answer. All state witnesses who testified didn't bring any evidence that this court can come to the conclusion that accused two has committed an offence. It will be unfair if the accused is only brought into the dock to supplement the State's case,' she submitted.
When Judge Erasmus mentions that State witness Laurentia Lombaard implicated van Rhyn, Mkabayi shot back, stating she was 'not credible'.
'Your client made a statement which I found admissible, that he admitted to being with when Joshlin was taken away, and he had gone back to find out what he's cut was,' Judge Erasmus said.
'I strongly submit there is no evidence,' Mkabayi submitted.
Kelly's lawyer, Rinesh Sivnarain, also brought forth an application to have charges discharged against his client.
'My submission case has not brought enough prima facie evidence against my client. In regards to human trafficking, only one witness, Laurentia Lombaard, and I submit that her evidence was of such poor quality that it should be rejected in its entirety,' he submitted.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
Legal implications for a 12-year-old driver in a fatal crash? Understanding the consequences
A 14-year-old pedestrian tragically lost his life in Brakpan after being struck by a Mazda allegedly driven by a 12-year-old boy. Image: Supplied As South Africans express shock over the incident where a 12-year-old Gauteng boy allegedly fatally struck a 14-year-old boy while the 12-year-old was driving his parents' car, crime analyst says the law will probe into the circumstances of how the 12-year-old ended up with the vehicle. In an interview with IOL, crime researcher Thabang Bogopa said after the horrific incident, the child is carefully assessed and recommendations are made to the presiding officer. 'Once a minor is involved in the commission of an offence, the statute that will come into play is called the Children in Conflict with the Law Act (Child Justice Act). What will normally happen is that an inquiry will be held involving social workers who will interview the child, potential witnesses and make recommendation to the magistrate as to whether the child should be prosecuted, or whether the child should be given a hearing in camera which means in private, and be referred for a programme, normally at the child welfare," he said. "Children in conflict with the law are young individuals aged 12 to 17 who are suspected of committing crimes. The Child Justice Act (CJA) in South Africa provides a separate system for dealing with these children, focusing on their best interests and rights, and aims to prevent them from obtaining criminal records in appropriate cases." Bogopa said the CJA emphasizes restorative justice, diversions, and alternative sentencing options to help children turn their lives around. He said in instances where other people are affected by the minor's crime, mediation will also be recommended. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ Crime researcher Thabang Bogopa spoke to IOL Image: Supplied Bogopa however, said the law will carefully probe into circumstances on how the 12-year-old ended up with the vehicle, and there would be repercussions for anyone who gave the minor a vehicle. Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel. 'The person who gave the child the vehicle would be charged in terms of the National Road Traffic Act, there is a scheduled offence there which involves giving someone who does not have a driver's licence a vehicle to operate. So they would be charged under that Act," he said. "In this case, they would be charged for giving a child who is underage a vehicle, but also someone who does not have a valid driver's licence." The criminologist said it is imperative for parents to conscientise their children strongly against driving without a licence, which is a serious offence. "The advice would be for parents to desist from allowing their children to drive, especially if they are below 16, because if they are above 16, they can have a learner's licence and drive under the supervision of an adult. When they are 18 then they get a driver's licences to operate a motor vehicle on a public road," said Bogopa. He said the massive infrastructural damages caused by the vehicle may become the subject of a civil dispute. "Normally, a full comprehensive vehicle insurance cover would cover up to R5 million of the third party. So, it means the parents' insurance will pay off the damage. It will be between the parents and their insurance as to how they fix it going forward," he said. IOL reported on Monday that the 12-year-old boy appeared before the Brakpan Magistrate's Court in Gauteng after he allegedly fatally struck a 14-year-old boy while driving his parents' car. The boy appeared in court on Monday in the presence of his guardian. He is facing a charge of culpable homicide and driving a motor vehicle without a licence. National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) spokesperson, Lumka Mahanjana, said on Saturday, June 7, 2025, the 12-year-old was allegedly driving his parents' car at the corner of Madeley and Northdeene Street when he drove over a 14-year-old boy and subsequently bumped into a wall. "The 14-year-old boy sustained injuries and was declared dead on the scene. The 12-year-old was then taken to the Brakpan charge office and later released into the care of his parents by police on June 8, 2025," said Mahanjana. Mahanjana added that matter was postponed to August 28, 2025, to determine the 12-year-old boy's criminal capacity. According to City of Ekurhuleni spokesperson Zweli Dlamini, officers from the Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department's (EMPD) Accident Bureau responded to the scene, where paramedics had already declared the teenage pedestrian deceased. "At the scene, officers found a Mazda that allegedly bumped the pedestrian driven by a 12-year-old driver," said Dlamini. IOL News
Eyewitness News
16 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Drawn out bail application of man (29) accused of raping a minor close to conclusion
BOKSBURG - The protracted bail application by a 29-year-old man accused of raping a minor is close to finality. This comes as both the State and defence prepare to deliver their closing arguments before the Boksburg Magistrates Court. The Ugandan national faces two counts of rape after he allegedly raped the minor in December 2019 and in December last year. The Grade 6 learner fell pregnant allegedly from last year's incident. ALSO READ: Opposition to release of Boksburg man accused of raping, impregnating minor submitted in court However, the accused, who is also the victim's family friend, has denied this. The hearing of closing arguments is the final step before the magistrate considers the submissions of the state and the defence before handing down his judgment. The 29-year-old man is accused of a schedule six offence, which requires him to show the court that exceptional circumstances exist for his release on bail. The court will assess, among others, whether the Ugandan national is a flight risk, has a past criminal record or whether there's a risk that the accused may reoffend or interfere with evidence. The defence will attempt to discredit the witness presented during proceedings and argue that it is in the interests of justice that the man be released. The proceedings are expected to commence shortly before the accused is transported back to the Boksburg prison.
IOL News
16 hours ago
- IOL News
Nedbank responds to R40 billion lawsuit over fraud listing of Durban businessman
One of South Africa's biggest banks Nedbank is facing a R39.8 billion civil claim brought by Durban business Shaun Naidu Image: Supplied Nedbank says it is defending a R39.8 billion civil claim brought by Durban businessman Shaun Naidu, who alleges the bank wrongly listed him as a suspected fraudster for eight years. The bank told IOL that it follows a 'meticulous and thorough process' before listing anyone on the Southern African Fraud Prevention Service (SAFPS) database, but declined further comment as the matter is before the courts. 'As the matter is before the court, Nedbank cannot comment at this time. We can however confirm that we are defending the matter,' the bank told IOL. 'Nedbank would like to assure our clients that we adhere to a meticulous and thorough process before listing anyone on the Southern African Fraud Prevention Services (SAFPS) database. Please be assured that we are committed to resolving this matter in accordance with the principles of fairness and justice.' According to a Sunday Times report, Naidu alleges that Nedbank wrongly classified him as a suspected fraudster, leading to an eight-year listing on the SAFPS that he claims severely harmed his business and reputation. 'I was told I was tagged by Nedbank on the Shamwari database which was created and is maintained by SAFPS. Due to this listing, I couldn't open a bank account at any banking institution. I was very confused at this stage," Naidu told the Sunday Times. Naidu revealed that he became aware of his listing on the SAFPS in 2015 when he attempted to open a bank account. The Durban businessman said despite obtaining a police clearance and seeking assistance from both SAFPS and the National Credit Regulator, his name remained on the fraud database until 2021. It was only after his lawyers intervened through a formal dispute process that the listing was removed. "Besides losing lucrative business deals, I was not able to travel to international trade fairs that I was invited to for more possible business deals". The SAFPS is a non-profit organisation which aims to "improve vigilance with regards to fraud, financial crime and identity theft by educating businesses and consumers about fraud, and assisting them to protect themselves". The organisation also strives "to combat fraud through delivering a centralised fraud-prevention function." [email protected] IOL Business
