Government's smoking ban ‘risks breaching post-Brexit deal'
A proposed UK smoking ban, supported by Keir Starmer, risks breaching the post-Brexit Windsor Framework, according to former Tory justice secretary Robert Buckland.
The ban, which would make it illegal for anyone born after 2008 to buy tobacco, conflicts with EU law requiring tobacco to remain legal for adults over 18 in Northern Ireland under the Framework.
Buckland warns that applying the ban to Northern Ireland would breach EU law, while excluding it would fracture the UK's internal market, leading to a breach of the signed treaty.
He urges the Government to pause the Bill and either negotiate an exemption for Northern Ireland or remove it from the Bill's scope to avoid a legal and constitutional crisis.
Despite these warnings, the Government believes the measures drafted in the Bill are consistent with its obligations under the Windsor Framework.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Belfast Telegraph
25 minutes ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Equality Commission: ‘Supreme court ruling on gender has legal uncertainties for NI'
A paper released by the Commission today claims that the judgement will be 'highly persuasive' in certain aspects of Northern Ireland's courts, but there are still uncertainties of what effects it will have on NI law. In April the country's highest court unanimously ruled that the terms 'woman' and 'sex' in the Equality Act "refer to a biological woman and biological sex" following a dispute centred on whether someone with a gender recognition certificate (GRC) recognising their gender as female should be treated as a woman under the UK 2010 Equality Act – which does not apply in Northern Ireland. The judgement was made by the Supreme Court after campaigning group For Women Scotland, who wanted to overturn Scottish legislation which said 50% of members on public boards should be female, with the definition of female including transgender women. The decision made headlines across the UK, however questions remained over what the ruling meant for transgender people in Northern Ireland. The DUP's Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart welcomed the judgment calling it 'clear and a victory for common sense', while the Ulster Unionist Party's Justice spokesperson Doug Beattie said the ruling 'has major implications for the application of the Equality legislation in Northern Ireland' which he said affirmed that 'transgender women are not women.' NI based organisation The Rainbow Project acknowledged the decision at the time. saying on a social media statement that the 'ruling is not good news' and that they watched the ruling with 'significant concern'. The paper also states that the Supreme Court Judgement didn't consider article 2 of the Windsor Framework. Article 2 of the Framework concerns the rights that are written in the Good Friday Agreement, including protections against discrimination. Geraldine McGahey, Chief Commissioner of the Equality Commission for Northern Ireland says the Commission will be seeking a Declaration from the courts to address questions regarding legal uncertainties, adding that the commission's approach towards the issues will be in the 'best interests of everyone in Northern Ireland' 'To achieve greater long-term certainty and clarity for all involved, the Commission will be seeking a Declaration from the courts to address several questions regarding the significant legal uncertainties.' 'Our equality laws do not sit in isolation; they interact with other laws and regulations for which the Commission does not have a remit. We believe other bodies and organisations will also require clarification on the legal position in relation to their own areas of work and may join the Commission in its legal proceedings.' McGahey also said that the commission hopes to avoid 'toxicity' around the debate around biological sex. The paper also contains interim information for employers and service providers. In a poll by the Belfast Telegraph in May, almost three-quarters of people in Northern Ireland agree with the Supreme Court's ruling. The LucidTalk poll found that 72 per cent of people here agreed with the Supreme Court's ruling, with 20 per cent disagreeing and 8 per cent unsure.
South Wales Guardian
27 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
UK and France to agree migrant return deal to tackle Channel crossings
Plans for a pilot could be revealed next week, which marks one year since Sir Keir Starmer's Government came to power, or later in the summer, according to the Times. The deal could see migrants who arrive in the UK by crossing the English Channel in small boats returned to France, while the UK would accept those with legitimate claims to join family already in the country. It comes as the Government has vowed to crack down on people smuggling gangs across the Channel, while crossings are at a record high for this point in the year, totalling 18,518. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper has been leading the talks, the paper added, who is credited with strengthening relationships with French counterparts. French officials have also agreed to changes that would allow police patrolling the coast to take action in the sea when migrants climb into boats from the water. Under the new returns deal, a joint processing system between the UK and France would be set up to identify migrants who have a valid claim for family reunification in the UK, the Times reported. For each person accepted to come to the UK, a migrant would be returned to France and relocated across the country away from its northern coastline where crossings take place. But reacting to the reports, shadow home secretary Chris Philp said: 'We pay the French half a billion pounds to wave the boats off from Calais, and in return we get a migrant merry-go-round where the same number still come here. 'The French are failing to stop the boats at sea, failing to return them like the Belgians do, and now instead of demanding real enforcement, Labour are trying a 'one in, one out' gimmick.'
Glasgow Times
27 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Government climbdown on welfare Bill marks third U-turn this month
Here, the PA news agency looks at three major policy changes this month. – Welfare reforms The Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill was put in motion to change who could qualify for certain disability and sickness benefits. The package restricted eligibility for Pip, the main disability payment in England, and cut the health-related element of Universal Credit, in a bid to save £5 billion a year by 2030. But a backbench rebellion of more than 120 Labour MPs forced Sir Keir into a U-turn. In an attempt to appease those MPs, planned cuts will now only affect future applications for benefits, rather than existing claimants. (PA Graphics) – Winter fuel payment The Government scrapped winter fuel payments for pensioners who do not receive pension credits or other means-tested benefits just weeks after it came to power in July. It was described as a 'necessary and responsible' move by Chancellor Rachel Reeves, who argued it would help fill the £22 billion fiscal black hole. The Government said that changing the threshold for the payment would save £1.5 billion each year. But at the start of this month, the Prime Minister announced that the Government would reinstate winter fuel payments for millions of pensioners. The payment, worth up to £300, will be restored to the vast majority of pensioners who previously received it because anyone with an income of under £35,000 a year will now get the payment automatically. The Government said the change will cost £1.25 billion. The move followed the report by Baroness Louise Casey (James Manning/PA) – Grooming gangs Sir Keir has also U-turned on holding a national inquiry into grooming gangs. In January, the Prime Minister accused those calling for an inquiry of 'jumping on a far-right bandwagon' after tech entrepreneur Elon Musk criticised the UK for its lack of action on the issue. But following the recommendations of a report by Baroness Louise Casey into the scale of group-based child sexual abuse, Sir Keir announced in June that there would be a full national statutory inquiry. The Prime Minister had initially only promised five local inquiries in the most prevalent areas for grooming gangs. Asked about the change, Sir Keir said: 'I've never said we should not look again at any issue.'
